How Do We Make Attribution Work In A World Of Data Privacy?
How we track, measure and attribute the success of marketing activity puts many marketers in a cold sweat—whether we're talking about top-level marketing mix models dating back to the 1950s or the complex, hyperpersonalized multichannel attribution models of today.
The shift to digital has, of course, helped. With tools that can track customers throughout their journey, the process looks easier on the surface. But the truth is that the landscape has become even more complex. There's a skill shortage in attribution, and data privacy poses even more complex challenges. Data privacy laws already make handling consumer data a minefield, and there is little optimism that it will become easier. A 2025 Supermetrics survey of 200 marketers from around the globe revealed that 57% predict more difficulty in marketing attribution in the future.
Why Attribution Is So Important Today
It's worth emphasizing why attribution is more vital today than ever. Perceived wisdom, guided by the marketing rule of seven, has taught us that customers typically need to interact with a brand at least seven times before they decide to make a purchase. Today, however, the digital advertising landscape means customers interact with your brand much more often. Data compiled earlier this year shows that customers interact with a brand 28.87 times on average before a conversion.
With that many touchpoints, it's impossible to understand your successes and failures without an effective attribution model. Attribution helps us understand how customers interact at each touchpoint and enables us to determine the effectiveness of each marketing method. With analysis, we can see which aid conversion and then decide how to spend money and resources more effectively in the future.
The Challenges Of Attribution
Historically, access to data has been a stumbling block for many marketers. You may be unable to access data because you're on a small budget, which prevents you from accessing the right measurement software, or you may have a team that lacks the knowledge to implement what you have. Or there may be a disconnect between sales and marketing—creating data silos that prevent useful data from being used to make smarter marketing decisions.
Access to data is also changing due to user behavior. Nearly 33% of internet users now use ad blockers, which, along with blocking ads, also block cookies that allow us to collect and analyze user data.
Data quality is holding many marketers back as well. Research by the Chief Marketing Officer (CMO) Council and GfK in 2022 found that 62% of global marketers are only moderately confident—or worse—about their data.
How Data Privacy Has Affected Attribution
Since its implementation in 2018, the General Data Protection Regulation has radically changed how European marketers use customer data. There are currently no federal laws in the U.S. that are as comprehensive as the GDPR. However, laws like the California Consumer Privacy Act have started an inevitable shift toward increased data privacy. Legislation like this makes businesses legally obligated to process data securely and limit how they share or use it with other organizations. That means considering things like data processing agreements, which establish your roles and obligations as well as those of any organizations you share data with. It also means implementing robust data governance—ensuring all of your consumer data is clean, reliable and consistent. While essential for consumers, these are all things that take extra time and resources for businesses to implement.
There are also other areas of GDPR legislation that companies risk violating. One of the key tenets of GDPR is that data requests from users should be explicit and specific. Bundling together your requests with one checkbox is not considered compliant data collection. And the challenge of data collection post-GDPR doesn't just come from the legislation itself; it comes from users, too. According to GWI data from 2024, 34.5% of adult internet users globally now reject cookies at least some of the time.
Attribution In A Privacy-Focused World
The key to accurate attribution is still first-party data. Collecting your own customer data gives you control over compliance and privacy. While there are still gray areas with uncertainty about how GDPR legislation should be interpreted, this will improve as regulators provide more specific guidelines and enforcement increases. Businesses can ensure compliance in the meantime by implementing robust consent mechanisms, providing clear privacy policies and offering easy opt-out options for users.
Once you have that data, the next challenge is using it. Like attribution, data aggregation has always been complex for businesses with smaller marketing budgets. But technology could hold the answer. Data lakes, for example, can make it easier for organizations to store, manage and analyze large, unstructured datasets. They can also ease privacy concerns by anonymizing data for analysis. While this advanced technology still requires time, money and expertise to use effectively today, artificial intelligence is making it more accessible for companies now and in the future.
Machine learning algorithms can also help evaluate converting and nonconverting paths, giving relative value to each and making it easier for marketers to make decisions based on their data. AI can make working with different attribution models easier by combining deterministic data (e.g., logged-in user behavior) with probabilistic models to create a hybrid approach that better estimates cross-device behavior. It can spot patterns that may not have been visible to you before, and with the introduction of agentic models, it can apply insights to adjust budgets in real time and even make decisions on your behalf.
So, while data privacy makes attribution more challenging than ever, it's a welcome challenge for those who value its intentions. Compliant data collection gives users greater control over their data and helps build trust that is sorely lacking in the modern consumer. Combine that with first-party data and new technology, and we can spend marketing budgets more effectively and deliver experiences to consumers that are truly personalized to their behavior, not just based on assumptions.
Forbes Agency Council is an invitation-only community for executives in successful public relations, media strategy, creative and advertising agencies. Do I qualify?
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
13 minutes ago
- Yahoo
3 Ways Trump's ‘Big Beautiful Bill' Could Hit Tesla Investors
Tesla investors have had a rough go in 2025, with a stock price that's down by more than one-fifth year-to-date and a major slump in global electric vehicle sales. I'm a Self-Made Millionaire: Learn More: Now, the Elon Musk-led company faces more grim news in the form of President Donald Trump's 'Big Beautiful' spending bill, which was signed into law on July 4th. Among other things, the bill will bring an end to federal tax credits on certain EVs. Here are three ways the bill could hit Tesla investors. Tax Credits Will End Federal tax incentives played a big role in boosting Tesla's EV sales in recent years, but those incentives will soon come to an end. Because of Trump's bill, buyers have until Sept. 30 to qualify for the federal tax credits on Tesla EVs before they're terminated, CBS News reported. Before the bill passed, new EVs came with a $7,500 federal tax credit, while used EVs came with credits of up to $4,000. The idea behind the credits was to make EVs more affordable. That's important, because the average purchase price of a new EV is about $9,000 higher in the U.S. than the average new gas-powered car, according to Kelley Blue Book data cited by CBS News. Used EVs cost roughly $2,000 more than comparable gas cars, on average. An end to the tax credit will hurt Tesla — and Tesla shareholders — because it narrows the number of potential EV buyers. I Sold My Tesla: Rival EV Companies Will Get a Boost As Business Insider reported, one key provision in the new bill is that cars made by companies that sold more than 200,000 'accepted' EVs between December 31, 2009 and December 31, 2025 do not qualify for the tax credit. This provision will mainly impact Tesla, which sells a lot more cars than that in a single quarter. In contrast, rivals Rivian and Lucid have not reached the 200,000 milestone, meaning their customers can still get tax credits. This could give them an edge against Tesla, at least over the short term. Sales Could Decline Further Tesla's EV sales have already slumped badly this year. The company recently posted second-quarter car sales of 384,122 — down 13.5% from the previous year, CNN reported. It was the biggest year-over-year decline in Tesla history, and followed a similarly dismal first quarter. Trump's spending bill will likely hurt sales even further because buyers will no longer have the same tax incentives. This means they'll have to dish out more money to buy a Tesla than in the past. 'It's on Tesla to make the case for consumers to even slightly pay up today versus some other EVs,' Seth Goldstein, an equity strategist at Morningstar, told Business Insider. More From GOBankingRates 4 Housing Markets That Have Plummeted in Value Over the Past 5 Years This article originally appeared on 3 Ways Trump's 'Big Beautiful Bill' Could Hit Tesla Investors
Forbes
15 minutes ago
- Forbes
Slow Down To Speed Up: Leadership Practice That Accelerates Execution'
Slowing down for planning allows us to speed up our execution In a results-driven world that prizes speed and early wins, leaders often feel pressure to move quickly. But ironically, the key to accelerating execution is slowing down at the start. Going slow isn't hesitation—it's strategy. It builds clarity, commitment, and momentum that far outpace the delays caused by rushing in prematurely. This principle rests on a foundational truth: if you want your team to move fast later, you must first align hearts, minds, and agendas. Why Rushing To Execution Undermines Team Performance Many initiatives fail not because the idea is wrong or resources are lacking, but because alignment is missing. When leaders skip early-stage dialogue, surfacing disagreement, and co-creating a shared vision, they often face confusion, resistance, and costly rework later. Common warning signs include: These are symptoms of rushed alignment—and they're Early Buy-In Accelerates Team Execution True buy-in is more than agreement; it's emotional and intellectual commitment. It often follows conflict, not silence. As Patrick Lencioni writes in 'The Five Dysfunctions of a Team', 'The only way for a team to develop trust and commitment is to engage in unfiltered conflict.' This is supported by research. A meta-analysis by DeChurch & Marks in the Journal of Organizational Behavior found that early-stage team conflict, when managed constructively, improves decision quality and execution speed (DeChurch & Marks, 2001). Similarly, a study by O'Reilly, Caldwell, and Barnett in Group & Organization Management showed that teams with aligned values and early participation in decision-making perform significantly better (O'Reilly et al., 2014).5 Steps Leaders Take to Align Teams and Move Faster Here's what 'great preparation' looks like in practice: Why Team Harmony Fuels Agility and Innovation This process also nurtures better teamwork. Teams that take the time to align tend to experience more harmony—not due to constant agreement, but through shared direction and mutual respect. This harmony increases emotional engagement, which research shows improves innovation, productivity, and retention (HBR, 2023). Remember - alignment isn't a delay; it's the Examples: How Amazon and Agile Teams 'Slow Down to Speed Up' Amazon famously uses the principle 'disagree and commit' to ensure alignment before action. Agile teams invest heavily in backlog grooming and sprint planning—slower upfront processes that enable faster iteration and course correction. Similarly, successful executive transitions often involve a deliberate 'listen and learn' phase before major decisions are made, building trust and insight. The Leader's Role in Aligning Strategy and Execution Leaders set the tempo. If you rush, others will follow. If you normalize alignment and early debate, your team will see it as strength. Model patience with ambiguity, encourage thoughtful questioning, and affirm that this 'slower' phase is not wasted time—it's the accelerator. This key theme of 'leaders who create space for dialogue, build buy-in through co-creation' is emphasized in my previous Forbes article 'Why Great Leaders Learn to sit with Uncertainty' Key Takeaway Leadership isn't about fast starts—it's about effective finishes. When you pause to align and engage others early, you lay the groundwork for agile, confident execution. The small upfront investment in time creates outsized returns in speed, teamwork, and impact. 'Slowing down to speed up' isn't a contradiction. It's one of the most powerful leadership disciplines of our time.
Fox News
15 minutes ago
- Fox News
Bluetooth flaw exposes millions of premium headphones to spying
Bluetooth headphones are supposed to make life easier. You put them on, press play and forget they exist. But researchers have found that some of the most popular audio products on the market might be doing more than streaming your playlist. Cybersecurity firm ERNW has revealed that 29 devices using Airoha Bluetooth chips are vulnerable to attacks that could expose your personal data or let someone snoop on your conversations. The affected devices come from well-known brands, including Bose, Sony, JBL, Jabra and Marshall. They include headphones, earbuds, speakers and wireless microphones. Sign up for my FREE CyberGuy ReportGet my best tech tips, urgent security alerts and exclusive deals delivered straight to your inbox. Plus, you'll get instant access to my Ultimate Scam Survival Guide —c free when you join my The Bluetooth flaws in question are built into Airoha chips commonly used in true wireless audio devices, as reported by BleepingComputer. Three flaws were disclosed, each allowing an attacker to gain some level of unauthorized access. The most serious flaw lets an attacker read or manipulate data by exploiting a custom protocol used by the chip. All three flaws have been assigned official CVE numbers and scored between medium and high severity. To be clear, these are not casual attacks. They require close proximity and technical expertise. But when successful, the results are concerning. Researchers showed that they could extract call logs, contact lists and media being played. They could even force a phone to place a call without the user's knowledge. Once connected, they could listen in on any sound the phone picked up. In one proof-of-concept, the researchers retrieved Bluetooth link keys from a headphone's memory. This allowed them to impersonate the device and hijack the connection to the phone. With that access, they could issue commands using the Bluetooth Hands-Free Profile, a feature available across most modern phones. ERNW researchers have identified the following devices as vulnerable: Keep in mind that this list may not include every product affected by these vulnerabilities. As more research emerges, the list could change. Furthermore, not every device faces all the same risks. For instance, at least one manufacturer seems to have already addressed CVE-2025-20700 and CVE-2025-20701. However, we do not know if this fix was intentional or accidental. Because of these factors, getting a complete and accurate picture of which devices are truly secure remains a challenge. As a consumer, you should stay alert for updates and check with your device's manufacturer for the latest information. Airoha has addressed the vulnerabilities in its software development kit (SDK) and released an updated version to device manufacturers in early June. These manufacturers are now responsible for building and distributing firmware updates to affected products. If you haven't seen an update yet, it should be arriving soon, though some may already be available. However, there's a catch. According to a report by German outlet Heise, many of the most recent firmware updates for affected devices were released before Airoha provided its official fix. This means some products may still be running vulnerable code, despite appearing up to date. To make matters more complicated, consumers typically aren't notified directly about these updates. Firmware patches for headphones and similar devices often install silently, or in some cases, may not be delivered at all. As a result, most users have no way of knowing whether their devices are secure or still exposed to risk. We reached out to all 10 companies for a comment, but did not hear back before our deadline. 1. Regularly check for firmware updates: Visit the manufacturer's app or website to manually check for firmware updates, even if you haven't received a notification. Automatic updates aren't always reliable, especially for headphones and earbuds. 2. Turn off Bluetooth when not in use: Disabling Bluetooth when you're not actively using it reduces your exposure window and makes it harder for attackers to target your device. 3. Use devices in low-risk areas: Since these attacks require close proximity, avoid using Bluetooth audio devices in crowded or unfamiliar public places where someone nearby could exploit vulnerabilities. 4. Pair devices with trusted sources only: Avoid pairing your Bluetooth headphones with unfamiliar phones, computers or public terminals. Once paired, those devices can sometimes maintain a connection or reestablish one without your knowledge, increasing the risk of abuse if they're compromised. 5. Remove unused paired devices: Go into your Bluetooth settings and delete old or unfamiliar pairings. This helps prevent unauthorized reconnections from previously trusted devices that may now be compromised. The real concern here isn't the Bluetooth flaw itself, but what happens when the software inside everyday devices fails quietly. Vulnerabilities like this aren't unusual, but the way they are handled often leaves users in the dark. As long as consumers can't see or control the software running inside their own headphones, problems like this will keep happening. Should manufacturers be required to notify users directly when security flaws are discovered in their products? Let us know by writing us at Sign up for my FREE CyberGuy ReportGet my best tech tips, urgent security alerts and exclusive deals delivered straight to your inbox. Plus, you'll get instant access to my Ultimate Scam Survival Guide — free when you join my Copyright 2025 All rights reserved.
