Committee hears concerns over outsourcing content at RTÉ
Co-chair of the RTÉ Trade Union Group Trevor Keegan was among representatives from trade unions at the broadcaster, including the National Union of Journalists, SIPTU, Connect and Unite, who appeared before the Oireachtas Joint Committee on Arts, Communication and Media.
The committee is scrutinising the Revised General Scheme of the Broadcasting (Amendment) Bill.
The potential impact on RTÉ staff from a provision in the bill, which would require the broadcaster to spend a quarter of its annual public funding on programming commissioned from the independent sector, was a central theme in the discussions.
Mr Keegan said that while many independent production companies make "great television and radio", apart from a small number of larger firms, the content is generally provided by workers on "short-term contracts with fragile protections".
He added that "this is not conducive to long-term careers in TV and radio production".
Mr Keegan described moving programmes such as 'The Late Late Show' and 'Fair City' to the independent sector as RTÉ "exploiting" the requirement of the act for increased production spend to "pursue its goal to dismantle and privatise" whole sections of RTÉ.
He said that while there are "many laudable elements" of proposed amendments to the bill, they should not "come at the cost of breaking up the national broadcaster".
Adrian Kane from SIPTU said that increased funding should support new content and employment and "not a reallocation of work already being undertaken by RTÉ workers".
Mr Kane and President of Equity, the live performance and theatre trade union, Gerry O'Brien raised concerns over "buy-out contracts " by RTÉ and TG4.
Secretary of the RTÉ TUG Sorcha Vaughan said that the 25% requirement is already "being quoted as a reason that things are being moved out of RTÉ".
Ms Vaughan added that staff were "blue in the face" asking for consultation with management.
She said that "we had this issue with religious programming" in relation to the recent announcement by RTÉ that it was sending elements of religious programming outside to a commissioning process within the independent sector.
Ms Vaughan also said that her members had "had it again" with the current affairs programme Upfront with Katie Hannon when it was recently confirmed that the show was not returning in the autumn schedule.
Mr Keegan told the committee that programme teams were told "late in the day" about the situation.
He described as "horrific" the morale in RTÉ and Ms Vaughan said it was "awful".
The Unite union also raised concerns about the provision and said that it is "often the case" that smaller independent companies will offer "short-term contracts, precarious employment arrangements, lower pay and often misclassify workers as self-employed".
Seamus Dooley from the NUJ asked the committee to consider "what happens" when a public service programme which is outsourced "ceases to make enough money with the shareholder?".
Fianna Fáil TD Malcolm Byrne said that concerning issues of workers being "misclassified" as self-employed that it was RTÉ rather than independent producers who were "guilty of that".
He stated that public service broadcasting is not "just" going to be provided by RTÉ, and that it can be provided by TG4, and Virgin Media and "an increasingly diverse media landscape".
He added it is critical to ensure that "Irish stories get told".
Mr Byrne said that that can be done "very professionally by RTÉ" but not "exclusively" by RTÉ and he stated his view that he was a "little concerned" about "dismissing and challenging" what goes on in the independent sector.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RTÉ News
4 hours ago
- RTÉ News
Outcome of EU-US tariff talks 'not certain'
European Union commissioner Michael McGrath has said "the world has changed" and that economic terms "we had six months ago are no longer available" amid ongoing discussions on an EU-US tariff deal. Speaking to RTÉ's This Week programme, the commissioner also said that while it has been reported a 15% tariff deal could be agreed today, it is "not a case of turning up and signing on the dotted line" and that today's talks "will take on a dynamic of its own". Mr McGrath said this evening's meeting between European Commission president Ursula von der Leyen and Us President Donald Trump is a "positive" sign, the outcome is "not certain". He described today's talks as "a live negotiation", and said "we [the EU] are hoping for a conclusion and a good outcome, but we also have to be prepared, other outcomes are possible". Mr McGrath said "we are close to the deadline of 1 August" for a tariff deal to be struck and that "very often it's the case you narrow negotiations down to a select amount of items". Mr McGrath declined to discuss the prospect of a 15% tariff deal, saying he "can't get into numbers at this time". However, he said the EU's "objective" is to "bring clarity and certainty" to businesses, including the pharmaceutical sector, adding that "it remains to be seen whether that can be achieved today". "What we will see today is hopefully a political statement, a political declaration, although that is not certain," he said. Asked if a 15% tariff rate would be a bad deal for the EU, Mr McGrath said: "I don't think we should reach any conclusion yet". He added that any deal needs to be seen in the context that "the terms we had six months ago are no longer available". Questioned on whether EU member states will all agree to any potential deal, he said that would ultimately be up to member states themselves, before reiterating "the world has changed", and that negotiators are trying to find "the best deal for the European Union".
The Irish Sun
a day ago
- The Irish Sun
‘It's the end of an era' – Major blow as the only post office in one of Ireland's most scenic spots is set to close
A MAJOR blow is on the way for hundreds of locals as the only post office in one of Ireland's most scenic spots is set to close. The last post office on the Fánaid peninsula in Advertisement 2 Baile Láir Post Office is at risk of closing due to rising costs Credit: RTE 2 The spot is located on Donegal's scenic Fánaid peninsula Credit: RTE Situated on the edge of the northwest coast, Fánaid is a remote stretch of land known for its rugged beauty, golden Baile Láir Post Office has served this tight-knit Gaeltacht community since 1872, operated by the McElwaine Running the post office and attached grocery shop, Wendy and Ronan McElwaine say they can no longer keep it going under the current financial pressures. And after 150 years, the Advertisement READ MORE IN MONEY The area's population has declined over the decades, and the owners said the footfall isn't enough to cover the cost of running the post office year-round. Residents are now faced with a 15km journey to Kerrykeel or Carraig Airt for basic postal services. Local schoolteacher Gráinne Uí Dhubhthaigh told RTÉ that the community is heartbroken, calling the likely closure a huge loss to the area. And with Advertisement MOST READ IN MONEY She said: 'People and business in the area depend on the post office. The heart is being pulled out of the area. "If you get the Local Link bus to Kerrykeel some 20kms away, you will have to wait another 2 hours to return." Celebrity chef closes down seaside restaurant after 16 years Farmer Dónal Ó Siadhail told RTE that Fánaid once had 17 shops and a bustling local economy - a time when his milk rounds included a stop at the McElwaines'. He said: 'Now there are only two or three shops in the peninsula. It is the end of an era, without a doubt. Advertisement "Everything is closing down" Tourism has become more important to Fánaid in recent years, with the local lighthouse drawing thousands of visitors each Grínne Nic Suibhne, who works at the lighthouse, said they depended on the post office to send off visitor packages and merchandise. She said: "Now we will have to bring all that to Kerrykeel to send" Advertisement 'VERY REAL PROSPECT' They said: "Ballylar like most post offices in run by a Postmaster - an independent contractor who provides post office services for the people of that part of the Fanad peninsula. "An Post has been trying to find an alternative contractor to provide post office services here. We have been actively seeking a new business partner to take on the vacant contract, advertising the vacancy and canvassing local business. "No applications have been received to date, and we are in the process of advertising the vacant contract position a second time. Advertisement "We are facing the very real prospect of the post office closing in the coming months. "It is looking like that closure will take place in October and we will transfer customers to Kerrykeel post office which is some 14km away. "The closure, if it happens, is much regretted by An Post but right now we will continue trying to find a new contractor.' "It is not the case, as cited in local media that some action of An Post cased the current situation. Advertisement "Postmasters generate their income on the basis of transactions carried out with customers to the office. Their income is fixed to that level of transactions."
Irish Independent
2 days ago
- Irish Independent
The Irish Independent's View: Collective inaction on Gaza is a dark stain on humanity
The totally preventable tragedies of Gaza are a black mark on our age. But where is the global pressure to insist that the cruelty must end? One wonders if 21st-century life has really become so transactional as to be impervious to the traumas of defenceless children. If such is the case, we are in a very dark place. Surely the unwarranted cruelty witnessed daily in Gaza is intolerable to a rules-based order. Yet it appears that, even after 22 months, there are no depths of agony from which the people of the enclave can hope to be spared. The starvation in Gaza is of a magnitude that medics sent in to help are collapsing from hunger And so US secretary of state Marco Rubio thought it fitting to lash out at France for becoming the first G7 nation to recognise Palestine as a state. It was, he said, a 'slap in the face' to the families of the victims murdered by Hamas. Can he be unaware that since then, 60,000 Palestinians have been killed? Concerns for them and their remaining loved ones and the worsening death toll seems non-existent. All death is deplorable. To be casual about the mass taking of life is to risk being trapped in an inescapable moral vacuum. The starvation in Gaza is of a magnitude that even the medics sent in to help are collapsing from hunger. At the same time, the killing of desperate people – many of them children taking on the responsibility of fending for the families – continues. The lines of the skeletal and the destitute queuing for whatever scraps they might be offered belong in the Dark Ages. As daily bombardments continue, Israeli troops fire near where the aid is handed out. Recently returned from Gaza, Dr Nick Maynard told RTÉ he had seen young boys who were shot in the testicles. He believed they had been used as target practice as their wounds were all of a similar nature. But even as the deaths from starvation mount, Israeli heritage minister Amichai Eliyahu went on radio to claim: 'There's no hunger in Gaza.' Israel 'is racing ahead for Gaza to be wiped out', he said, calling Palestinians 'indoctrinated Nazis'. 'Thank God we are wiping out this evil,' he added. I can't imagine I'm going to die of starvation after 21 months of bombing One female doctor is quoted in the Washington Post as saying: 'I can't imagine I'm going to die of starvation after 21 months of bombing. We are all walking towards death.' Atrocities are no less atrocious because they are carried out by elected politicians and facilitated by democratic governments. Yet in this darkest hour, Donald Trump and Israeli prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu appear to be abandoning peace talks. Mr Netanyahu said it was clear that Hamas did not want a deal, and Mr Trump said they would have to now be 'hunted down'. That Hamas needs to be brought to account is not in question. But this 'forever war' in which civilians and children are deemed worthless and expendable is unjust and indefensible and must be stopped.
