Calcutta HC restraints Bengal from paying monthly stipend to sacked non-teaching staff
On June 9, Justice Amrita Sinha had reserved the judgement in the matter but had stayed the state government's plan to provide monthly stipends of Rs 20,000 to Rs 25,000 to the persons.
In its Friday order, the court reinforced that restriction, prohibiting such payments till at least September 26.
Sinha issued the direction on a writ petition challenging the provision of the allowance to the staff whose services had been terminated. The petition was filed by a candidate on the waitlist who was not recruited despite being on the merit list, allegedly due to irregularities in the hiring process.
On April 3, the Supreme Court upheld the High Court's April 2024 order terminating the appointment of about 25,000 teachers and non-teaching staff by West Bengal's School Service Commission. The bench passed the order after observing that the recruitment process was 'vitiated by manipulation and fraud'.
The top court on April 17 permitted 'untainted' teachers to be retained until the end of the academic year or until fresh appointments are made, whichever was earlier. However, it did not grant relief to the non-teaching staff, or Group C and Group D employees, whose appointments were also cancelled.
In response, the state government had announced in April that the sacked non-teaching staff would receive a monthly allowance until the Supreme Court delivered a verdict on its review petitions.
On Friday, the High Court criticised the state for attempting to financially assist individuals whose employment had been declared fraudulent by the Supreme Court and directed 'tainted' candidates to 'refund any salary/payment received', Live Law reported.
By introducing a stipend scheme, the state was undermining the Supreme Court's decision, the High Court observed.
'Once the highest court of the land has decided the issue of illegal appointment conclusively and opined that the appointments were result of fraud, no person who was the beneficiary of a fraudulent act of the statutory authority ought to be provided any support, that too, from the public exchequer,' the court said.
The court also instructed the state government to submit its counter-affidavit addressing the petitioners' claims within four weeks, and allowed the petitioners two weeks after that to file their response, PTI reported.
In April 2024, the High Court had passed its direction on the termination of the appointments based on the findings of a re-evaluation of the Optical Mark Recognition sheets from the 2016 recruitment examination in the case.
The re-evaluation found that the selected teachers had been recruited against blank Optical Mark Recognition sheets.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
29 minutes ago
- Time of India
Sebi Plans to Heighten Derivatives Surveillance
Live Events The Securities and Exchange Board of India (Sebi) is planning to enhance its surveillance system to check manipulation in the derivatives market, chairman Tuhin Kanta Pandey said on Monday. This follows the regulator barring US-based proprietary trader Jane Street from the securities market for allegedly generating illegal profits by manipulating indices through large derivatives positions.'This (Jane Street case) is essentially a surveillance issue,' Pandey said on the sidelines of an event. 'Surveillance mechanisms will be upgraded further to strengthen oversight.' He added that monitoring will continue at Sebi's as well as stock exchange levels.'Manipulative practices can be worked out by different players in different ways,' Pandey said. 'There is no one particular way in which you have to assess. Our regulations clearly mention that manipulative and fraudulent practices are not allowed in the market, and within the regulations, Sebi has all powers to investigate and act.'The chairman appeared to be of the view that such practices aren't widespread. 'There may not be many more such cases,' he said in response to a question on whether other funds may have manipulated the markets in a similar week, Sebi ordered the seizure of what it said were 'illegal gains' made by Jane Street to the tune of Rs 4,844 crore ($570 million) in one of the toughest punitive actions against an international trader. It's likely the largest amount thus impounded by the entities tied to Jane Street Group — JSI Investments, JSI2 Investments, Jane Street Singapore and Jane Street Asia Trading — have been prohibited from dealing in securities, directly or Street, which started its India operations in 2020, made a profit of about $4.3 billion between January 2023 and March 2025, the period under review, on its India regulator's finding is that the NSE's Bank Nifty Index — comprising stocks of India's top dozen lenders — was manipulated in a complex and illegal manner aided by JS Group's immense trading, financial and algorithmic Street would drive up prices with heavy buying in the morning and send them down through a selling spree later in the day, according to Sebi. It also sought to push index levels down with heavy sell orders close to the option expiry, the regulator found that Bank Nifty options alone contributed Rs 17,319 crore, amounting to 40% of the total index option's profits.
Economic Times
33 minutes ago
- Economic Times
Local electronics parts vendors plan non-Chinese JVs
Indian electronics companies are seeking partnerships. They are looking at South Korean, Taiwanese, and Japanese firms. This is for electronics component manufacturing. The reason is India's stance on Chinese investments. Companies like Dixon and Amber are finalising proposals. The electronics component manufacturing scheme deadline is approaching. The scheme aims to boost domestic value addition. Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads Technical alliance Raising local value addition Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads Kolkata: As the deadline for submitting applications for the electronics component manufacturing scheme draws near, home-grown contract manufacturers such as Dixon Technologies Epack Durable , Micromax's Bhagwati Products and Optiemus are finalising most of their proposals with South Korean, Taiwanese and Japanese companies as equity partners, CEOs of these Indian firms development is significant as China was the largest sourcing market for products and parts, as well as partnerships and JVs till now. Their decision stems from India's tough stand against Chinese FDI, which needs multi-ministerial nod under Press Note 3 move could also be attributed to continued business related conflicts such as the neighbouring country's rare earth magnet export curbs imposed on India, among other Press Note 3 norms were issued after the border clashes with China in 2020. Since then only a handful of large Chinese companies have received such clearances.'There is no denying that China is far ahead in large-scale component technology manufacturing, but we are careful about the government stand, as not just the initial investment will need government clearance, but even the subsequent ones. Such clearances will take a lot of time, impact our plans and incentive payout under the scheme,' said a CEO of one of the largest players in the industry.'So, wherever we have found the technology in Taiwan and South Korea, we would use that while for others we are still dependent on China. But we are trying to negotiate for a technical alliance or a minority shareholding with them,' he said, requesting Enterprises will put in Rs 4,000 crore application under component manufacturing scheme which will be invested through the tenure of the scheme, CEO Jasbir Singh part of a joint venture with South Korea's Korea Circuit, a Rs 3,000 crore application for manufacturing of high density interface and semiconductor substrates and a Rs 1,000 crore application for printed circuit board manufacturing will be submitted, said Singh. Amber is the largest contract manufacturer for largest home-grown smartphone contract manufacturer Dixon Technologies' managing director Atul Lall said the company is currently finalising its applications and terms for joint ventures with South Korean and Taiwanese firms. 'There might be applications with Chinese too, but the terms are being finalised,' he Products is betting on Korean, Taiwanese and Chinese firms for equity joint ventures and technical collaboration depending upon the approval from competent authority, said its director Rajesh window for applications under the electronics component manufacturing scheme closes by the end of July. The scheme has a budget outlay of ?22,919 crore and is spread over six years, with one year as gestation is aimed at developing a robust component ecosystem by attracting large investments, increasing domestic value addition, which is at 20% on an average at present, and integrating Indian companies with global value government has said it expects to attract investment of Rs 59,350 crore to produce goods worth Rs 4,56,500 crore and generate additional direct employment of 91,600 people, besides many indirect jobs during its tenure. Already, over 100 applications have been received under the Gupta, MD (operations), PG Electroplast, said the company will submit 4-5 applications, including with non-Chinese Optiemus, Taiwanese companies are the first preference for joint ventures, said executive chairman Ashok Durable will submit two applications of Rs 300 crore in total for components for sound, printed circuit board assembly and display, said its managing director Ajay DD Singhania. 'Our first priority is non-Chinese partners from Taiwan, South Korea and Japan,' he said.A company CEO said that it was a sensitive issue for companies having Chinese brands as clients as the existing component manufacturers for those brands are all mostly Chinese. 'Some are Taiwanese too. So, we are talking to the clients too before finalising the applications,' he said.
Time of India
36 minutes ago
- Time of India
Local electronics parts vendors plan non-Chinese JVs
Live Events Technical alliance Raising local value addition (You can now subscribe to our (You can now subscribe to our Economic Times WhatsApp channel Kolkata: As the deadline for submitting applications for the electronics component manufacturing scheme draws near, home-grown contract manufacturers such as Dixon Technologies Epack Durable , Micromax's Bhagwati Products and Optiemus are finalising most of their proposals with South Korean, Taiwanese and Japanese companies as equity partners, CEOs of these Indian firms development is significant as China was the largest sourcing market for products and parts, as well as partnerships and JVs till now. Their decision stems from India's tough stand against Chinese FDI, which needs multi-ministerial nod under Press Note 3 move could also be attributed to continued business related conflicts such as the neighbouring country's rare earth magnet export curbs imposed on India, among other Press Note 3 norms were issued after the border clashes with China in 2020. Since then only a handful of large Chinese companies have received such clearances.'There is no denying that China is far ahead in large-scale component technology manufacturing, but we are careful about the government stand, as not just the initial investment will need government clearance, but even the subsequent ones. Such clearances will take a lot of time, impact our plans and incentive payout under the scheme,' said a CEO of one of the largest players in the industry.'So, wherever we have found the technology in Taiwan and South Korea, we would use that while for others we are still dependent on China. But we are trying to negotiate for a technical alliance or a minority shareholding with them,' he said, requesting Enterprises will put in Rs 4,000 crore application under component manufacturing scheme which will be invested through the tenure of the scheme, CEO Jasbir Singh part of a joint venture with South Korea's Korea Circuit, a Rs 3,000 crore application for manufacturing of high density interface and semiconductor substrates and a Rs 1,000 crore application for printed circuit board manufacturing will be submitted, said Singh. Amber is the largest contract manufacturer for largest home-grown smartphone contract manufacturer Dixon Technologies' managing director Atul Lall said the company is currently finalising its applications and terms for joint ventures with South Korean and Taiwanese firms. 'There might be applications with Chinese too, but the terms are being finalised,' he Products is betting on Korean, Taiwanese and Chinese firms for equity joint ventures and technical collaboration depending upon the approval from competent authority, said its director Rajesh window for applications under the electronics component manufacturing scheme closes by the end of July. The scheme has a budget outlay of ?22,919 crore and is spread over six years, with one year as gestation is aimed at developing a robust component ecosystem by attracting large investments, increasing domestic value addition, which is at 20% on an average at present, and integrating Indian companies with global value government has said it expects to attract investment of Rs 59,350 crore to produce goods worth Rs 4,56,500 crore and generate additional direct employment of 91,600 people, besides many indirect jobs during its tenure. Already, over 100 applications have been received under the Gupta, MD (operations), PG Electroplast, said the company will submit 4-5 applications, including with non-Chinese Optiemus, Taiwanese companies are the first preference for joint ventures, said executive chairman Ashok Durable will submit two applications of Rs 300 crore in total for components for sound, printed circuit board assembly and display, said its managing director Ajay DD Singhania. 'Our first priority is non-Chinese partners from Taiwan, South Korea and Japan,' he said.A company CEO said that it was a sensitive issue for companies having Chinese brands as clients as the existing component manufacturers for those brands are all mostly Chinese. 'Some are Taiwanese too. So, we are talking to the clients too before finalising the applications,' he said.
