
India's unregulated pet care sector breeds scams, exploits animals and people
2
3
Pune: The lack of regulation in the animal welfare sector in India has allowed for the emergence of a breeding ground for fraudsters that exploit both animals and volunteers.
In the absence of proper oversight, there has been a disturbing proliferation of spurious animal shelters nationwide, operating as profit-making ventures while charging exorbitant monthly fees from rescuers and individuals.
The trend was exemplified in 2024, when a counterfeit shelter was set up near Delhi using the name of People for Animals, a well-known group run by Maneka Gandhi. "People have been calling me from across the country, particularly those familiar with our work at PFA, to inform us about this duplicity. An investigation is underway," Gandhi stated.
Puneeta Khanna, Pune unit head for PFA, explained to TOI that while people endeavour to "rescue" animals, they often lack the wherewithal for permanent adoption.
"They then relinquish the animals at any available shelter without conducting due diligence. They neither inspect the facilities nor research their credentials, simply transferring the animal and payments before disengaging completely. This prevalent behaviour enables fraudulent operations to flourish," she said.
Social media platforms have amplified duplicitous schemes, with fraudsters fabricating counterfeit NGO accounts and misappropriating content from legitimate organisations to conduct crowdfunding campaigns.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
Giao dịch CFD với công nghệ và tốc độ tốt hơn
IC Markets
Đăng ký
Undo
Swindlers manipulate digital platforms, disseminating emotive posts and reels to solicit donations — which never reach intended beneficiaries.
Richa Singh Choudhuri, who runs a senior dog shelter in Delhi, revealed how fraudsters pilfered photographs and videos posted by genuine animal welfare NGOs seeking funds for medical treatments. "This recurring issue recently affected our campaign for Mozart, a dog requiring costly surgery for luxating patella.
Scamsters already pocketed thousands before some people informed us about their posts, and we messaged them to shut it down and threatened them with legal action.
While some perpetrators remove such posts when confronted, many persist, necessitating formal complaints," Choudhuri said.
The post-pandemic surge in pet boarding services also witnessed inexperienced individuals offering boarding facilities, where pets frequently endure confinement without adequate care.
Pet parent Pallavi Doshi shared her harrowing experience with a Bengaluru-based facility, where her dog went missing when she came back to pick him up after a four-day stay. "Despite promises of daily updates, they did not send us anything and stopped picking up our calls.
We spent our holiday in panic. When we rushed back to pick him up, they claimed our pet ran away. We searched high and low and offered rewards, but he was nowhere to be found.
Later, we were informed by others who gave bad reviews to the facility that they too faced similar issues with their breed male dogs and suspected that they were sold to breeders," said Doshi.
Many establishments operate without standardised criteria for staff recruitment, occasionally employing individuals who demonstrate cruelty towards animals. Incidents have surfaced on social media, including in Feb 2025, when a Chow Chow endured brutal treatment at a Thane pet clinic, and the Oct 2024 tragedy involving a Cocker Spaniel's death at a Noida boarding facility.
Vineeta Tandon, who manages Animal Rescue Trust in Pune, said too many shelters operate sans proper registration, staff or capabilities. "Many just procure shop act licences and function ignoring safety guidelines. The Animal Welfare Board of India (AWBI) stipulates that shelters shouldn't retain healthy, self-sufficient animals or keep them caged. However, profit-driven facilities disregard this," she said.
"Healthy strays are unnecessarily removed from their natural habitat by emotional activists who believe institutional care is superior. They often end up confined without proper sustenance, contrary to natural street existence where they enjoy freedom and regular feeding," Tandon added.
This malpractice was evident when in Oct 2024, authorities rescued over 50 animals from a fraudulent shelter in Ravet. The proprietor distributed counterfeit receipts and falsely claimed veterinary credentials.
Similarly, in June last year, an illegal dog hostel was shut down in Jodhpur following PETA India's intervention, where animals had endured abusive training methods.
Geetanjali Taur, founder of Saahas for Animals, advocates for an urgent need for stringent industry regulation. "Transparency is key. When you find that an NGO is not being open for visitations and about their facilities or answering all questions, it should raise a red flag.
But it's time clear rules, standards, and guidelines are set and strictly implemented across all animal-related businesses and charitable establishments.
Volunteers must exercise prudence rather than making emotionally driven impulsive decisions that compromise animal welfare."
According to Meet Ashar, an animal rights advocate and cruelty case division legal advisor at PETA India, the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita in its current form does not strengthen legal protection for animals.
"While BNS removes different punishments based on the value of the animal and prescribes a uniform punishment for killing or maiming, irrespective of species, it has done more damage by totally removing the provision that penalised sexual abuse of animals," he pointed out.
Pune: The lack of regulation in the animal welfare sector in India has allowed for the emergence of a breeding ground for fraudsters that exploit both animals and volunteers.
In the absence of proper oversight, there has been a disturbing proliferation of spurious animal shelters nationwide, operating as profit-making ventures while charging exorbitant monthly fees from rescuers and individuals.
The trend was exemplified in 2024, when a counterfeit shelter was set up near Delhi using the name of People for Animals, a well-known group run by Maneka Gandhi. "People have been calling me from across the country, particularly those familiar with our work at PFA, to inform us about this duplicity.
An investigation is underway," Gandhi stated.
Puneeta Khanna, Pune unit head for PFA, explained to TOI that while people endeavour to "rescue" animals, they often lack the wherewithal for permanent adoption. "They then relinquish the animals at any available shelter without conducting due diligence. They neither inspect the facilities nor research their credentials, simply transferring the animal and payments before disengaging completely.
This prevalent behaviour enables fraudulent operations to flourish," she said.
Social media platforms have amplified duplicitous schemes, with fraudsters fabricating counterfeit NGO accounts and misappropriating content from legitimate organisations to conduct crowdfunding campaigns. Swindlers manipulate digital platforms, disseminating emotive posts and reels to solicit donations — which never reach intended beneficiaries.
Richa Singh Choudhuri, who runs a senior dog shelter in Delhi, revealed how fraudsters pilfered photographs and videos posted by genuine animal welfare NGOs seeking funds for medical treatments. "This recurring issue recently affected our campaign for Mozart, a dog requiring costly surgery for luxating patella. Scamsters already pocketed thousands before some people informed us about their posts, and we messaged them to shut it down and threatened them with legal action.
While some perpetrators remove such posts when confronted, many persist, necessitating formal complaints," Choudhuri said.
The post-pandemic surge in pet boarding services also witnessed inexperienced individuals offering boarding facilities, where pets frequently endure confinement without adequate care. Pet parent Pallavi Doshi shared her harrowing experience with a Bengaluru-based facility, where her dog went missing when she came back to pick him up after a four-day stay.
"Despite promises of daily updates, they did not send us anything and stopped picking up our calls.
We spent our holiday in panic. When we rushed back to pick him up, they claimed our pet ran away. We searched high and low and offered rewards, but he was nowhere to be found. Later, we were informed by others who gave bad reviews to the facility that they too faced similar issues with their breed male dogs and suspected that they were sold to breeders," said Doshi.
Many establishments operate without standardised criteria for staff recruitment, occasionally employing individuals who demonstrate cruelty towards animals. Incidents have surfaced on social media, including in Feb 2025, when a Chow Chow endured brutal treatment at a Thane pet clinic, and the Oct 2024 tragedy involving a Cocker Spaniel's death at a Noida boarding facility.
Vineeta Tandon, who manages Animal Rescue Trust in Pune, said too many shelters operate sans proper registration, staff or capabilities.
"Many just procure shop act licences and function ignoring safety guidelines. The Animal Welfare Board of India (AWBI) stipulates that shelters shouldn't retain healthy, self-sufficient animals or keep them caged. However, profit-driven facilities disregard this," she said.
"Healthy strays are unnecessarily removed from their natural habitat by emotional activists who believe institutional care is superior.
They often end up confined without proper sustenance, contrary to natural street existence where they enjoy freedom and regular feeding," Tandon added.
This malpractice was evident when in Oct 2024, authorities rescued over 50 animals from a fraudulent shelter in Ravet. The proprietor distributed counterfeit receipts and falsely claimed veterinary credentials. Similarly, in June last year, an illegal dog hostel was shut down in Jodhpur following PETA India's intervention, where animals had endured abusive training methods.
Geetanjali Taur, founder of Saahas for Animals, advocates for an urgent need for stringent industry regulation. "Transparency is key. When you find that an NGO is not being open for visitations and about their facilities or answering all questions, it should raise a red flag. But it's time clear rules, standards, and guidelines are set and strictly implemented across all animal-related businesses and charitable establishments.
Volunteers must exercise prudence rather than making emotionally driven impulsive decisions that compromise animal welfare."
According to Meet Ashar, an animal rights advocate and cruelty case division legal advisor at PETA India, the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita in its current form does not strengthen legal protection for animals. "While BNS removes different punishments based on the value of the animal and prescribes a uniform punishment for killing or maiming, irrespective of species, it has done more damage by totally removing the provision that penalised sexual abuse of animals," he pointed out.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Mint
27 minutes ago
- Mint
Starlink mostly recovers from ‘longest' global network disruption; company says ‘outage was due to failure of…'
Elon Musk's Starlink satellite internet service has 'mostly recovered' following a major global outage that left tens of thousands of users across the US, UK, Germany, Zimbabwe, Romania, and beyond without internet access for over two hours on Thursday. The disruption, which lasted approximately 2.5 hours, may be one of the longest recorded outages in Starlink's operational history. The incident occurred just one day after the company revealed a new T-Satellite rollout in partnership with T-Mobile, designed to extend connectivity to remote areas. Taking to X (formerly Twitter), Starlink Vice President Michael Nicolls confirmed the partial restoration of services, saying: 'Starlink has now mostly recovered from the network outage, which lasted approximately 2.5 hours. The outage was due to failure of key internal software services that operate the core network. We apologize for the temporary disruption in our service; we are deeply committed to providing a highly reliable network, and will fully root cause this issue and ensure it does not occur again.' Earlier in the day, Elon Musk also acknowledged the disruption, assuring users of an imminent fix: 'Service will be restored shortly. Sorry for the outage. SpaceX will remedy root cause to ensure it doesn't happen again.' The issue was first flagged by users around the world, with Downdetector—a real-time outage tracking platform—registering over 60,000 reports before 9pm BST. A staggering 65% of users reported experiencing a 'total blackout,' with many complaining of sudden disconnection without warning. From Colorado to Cologne, Bulawayo to Birmingham, users posted their frustration and confusion across social media. One UK-based customer wrote on X: 'The only downfall to Starlink is when it goes down, your only alternative is your phone network.' Many users relied on their 4G or 5G mobile connections to stay online, highlighting the growing dependency on satellite internet—particularly in rural or under-served regions. The disruption comes just a day after Starlink and T-Mobile announced the rollout of T-Satellite, a new service that integrates direct-to-cell satellite connectivity, aiming to keep mobile phones connected even in areas without traditional cell towers. Commenting on the service's performance, Musk posted earlier Thursday that the direct-to-phone network was 'growing fast.' The timing of the outage, however, has prompted scrutiny, with some questioning whether the launch had any unintended impact on Starlink's core infrastructure—a link SpaceX has yet to confirm or deny. Starlink, developed by SpaceX, is a global satellite-based broadband network designed to deliver high-speed internet access to remote, rural, and underserved regions. Operating across more than 130 countries and territories, Starlink has become a vital digital lifeline for homes, businesses, and emergency responders alike. Despite this setback, Starlink remains one of the most ambitious and widely deployed satellite internet constellations in operation today. While services have been restored for most users, Michael Nicolls reassured customers that a full investigation is underway to 'fully root cause this issue and ensure it does not occur again.' As digital infrastructure becomes more critical worldwide, the pressure on satellite networks like Starlink to deliver consistent, always-on connectivity continues to rise.


Mint
27 minutes ago
- Mint
Want "pin code-level granularity" in data - brands tell quick delivery firms
BENGALURU , NEW DELHI : Bengaluru/New Delhi: In India's fast-growing world of quick commerce, the real power lies not just in speedy deliveries and wholesome product portfolios, but in the data behind them. As major platforms expand private-label lines and monetize analytics, small consumer brands crib they are being shut out of critical insights on who's buying, where, and why. With limited visibility into customer behaviour, product performance, and advertisement effectiveness, these brands claim they are being priced out of planning and left behind in one of the country's most competitive new retail frontiers. From identifying best-selling products, timing of high demand, and deciding the right marketing budget, this data is crucial for brands to cut down unnecessary spending, improve operational efficiency, and keep up with cut-throat competition from brands. In the end, revenue preservation is the goal. This also signals the growing friction between sellers and marketplaces, as both try to build their own businesses with minimal expenditure and maximum output. Zepto and Blinkit have been doubling down on their private label efforts, with categories like staples, packaged food, and household items fetching higher margins. The founder of a Delhi-based kidswear brand, which sells baby accessories like feeding bottles and sippers through quick commerce channels in the top 5 cities, is worried that inadequate planning of inventory and pricing could seriously dent its revenues. 'On some of these quick commerce platforms, I can't see the distribution channels: where my ads are being shown, what kind of people are seeing them, how many are adding products to their cart, or proceeding to checkout," the founder said. A Delhi-based skincare brand founder concurs. 'Who is our customer? What's their age bracket? Within a city, which pockets are buying? That's the kind of insight we want. These platforms are sitting on pin code-level granularity." Quick commerce currently contributes about 5% to the company's revenue, but the share is growing fast. The firm expects the channel to account for 15-20% of its overall revenue in the next 18 months. 'On our D2C website, we track everything - conversion rates, drop-offs, repeat purchase percentages, and cohort behavior across months. If we could get similar insights from quick commerce, it would help us understand customer behaviour so much better," the founder added. To be sure, some platforms are making an attempt to share relevant information. In May, Zepto launched Atom, a paid analytics platform meant for providing access to relevant data points at a subscription fee. In an emailed response to Mint's queries, Zepto said it is already sharing anonymized, aggregated insights with over 100 partner brands through tools like Zepto Atom and Consumer Persona. 'Brands can now tap into real behavioural patterns like repeat purchase frequency, time-of-day affinities, category loyalties, and even cart correlations, all without compromising user privacy. These insights have helped brands optimize everything from product bundles to creative messaging and geo-targeted launches," Zepto said. Zepto Atom's pricing starts at around ₹30,000 per month, or 0.5% of the previous month's gross merchandise value (GMV), whichever is higher, and can go up to several lakhs depending on scale, said the D2C brands. Blinkit, on the other hand, charges listing fees (around ₹25,000 per product, typically credited to the brand's ad wallet) and generates revenue through commissions, ad placements, and user subscriptions like Blinkit Prime. 'Looking ahead… we're enabling brands to simulate buyer personas, run precision marketing experiments, and even validate new stock keeping units (SKUs) through city-specific sampling and surveys," Zepto added. Queries on the issue sent to Swiggy and Zomato did not elicit a response. The lookout for data and analytics comes at a time when brands are increasingly banking on quick commerce platforms for sales, with the channel accounting for the fastest growing one for many small as well as legacy brands. In the September quarter of FY25, Maggi-owner Nestle India saw 60% of its domestic e-commerce sales come from quick commerce. Nearly 7% of Mamaearth parent Honasa Consumer's business now comes from quick commerce and the firm expects its quick commerce market share to outperform that of e-commerce soon. 'We did the trial subscription (for the analytics), but don't plan to renew," said the founder of a Mumbai-based jewellery brand. 'For a growing brand, spending ₹30,000 to ₹2 lakh a month just to access data, we feel platforms should already be sharing is a big ask." 'It would make sense for us if most of our revenue came from quick commerce, or even just one specific platform," said the founder of the kidswear brand mentioned above, adding 'But right now, juggling three quick commerce platforms, along with e-commerce and logistics isn't the solution." Third parties to the rescue Brands are now seeking assistance from third-party analytics firms to help forecast demand to help plan their quick commerce actions better and reduce wastage. Startups like Inflexor Ventures-backed Clickpost, Info Edge Ventures-backed Gobblecube, and global analytics company Actowiz are at the forefront of providing revenue intelligence for brands active on quick commerce platforms, assisting them with demand forecasting and other data points like identifying best-selling products, shifting consumer preferences, fast-moving package sizes and pricing points, as well as improving ad performance. 'The information shared by marketplaces is limited and often delayed, as platforms require adequate data sets to be able to crunch it into relevant insights. We have enabled neighbourhood-level data that is so granular that brands can understand how their strategy should be shaped to suit geographical differences in demand and behaviour," said Naman Vijay, founder and chief executive of e-commerce intelligence platform Clickpost. Bengaluru-based Clickpost, which last raised $6 million from Inflexor Ventures, Athera Partners, and Riverwalk Holdings in April 2024, introduced a new feature called Prism last week, aimed at offering detailed quick commerce insights to brands at a dark store-level through API integrations with quick commerce platforms. Consumer behaviour on quick commerce often varies with regions, with different states and cities showing affinity to different brands, product sizes, and even time of purchase. 'Dark store-level data is too nuanced for brands to figure out themselves," Vijay added. Gobblecube, which raised $3.5 million from Info Edge Ventures and Kae Capital earlier this month, believes consumer brands often struggle with making sense of basic data that is crucial for decision-making. 'Quick commerce has unleashed an impressive amount of growth for small direct-to-consumer brands. However, true value lies in knowing the consumer well which is best done through real-time data," said Gobblecube's co-founder and chief executive Manas Gupta. The shift comes at a pivotal time for the quick commerce industry that is expected to triple in size by 2027, reaching ₹1.5-1.7 lakh crore, as per estimates by Kearney. The trade channel has expanded beyond being an impulse purchase mode, with 93% of sales coming at the expense of modern trade, e-commerce and kirana stores. 'Data isn't just for measuring performance. It's essential for planning, predicting demand, and connecting with customers. If brands don't know which products are selling quickly, where demand is growing, or how often items run out of stock, they're working in the dark. In today's fast-paced market, having the right data at the right time is crucial for keeping stock levels accurate, running effective marketing, and protecting sales," said Nitin Jain, managing director at consulting company Protiviti India Member that is part of Proviti's global network. The tiff between sellers and marketplaces in Indian e-commerce is not new. Several restaurants that joined food delivery platforms Swiggy and Zomato in its early days often complained about protective data sharing practices. In January, the National Restaurants Association of India (NRAI) criticized the aggregators' move to unfairly use customer demand data to model their private label offerings, thereby giving them an unfair advantage over restaurants. 'They have all our data, and they don't share it with us. They know exactly who our customers are, while we face consumer masking. They can easily divert traffic to their apps and sell similar products, like samosas or momos, under their private labels," NRAI president Sagar Daryani had told CNBC-TV18 channel earlier this year. Another personal care brand founder noted that inventory management is tough, especially with details of product movement generally under wraps. 'I don't have control over which part of Mumbai, Delhi, or Bengaluru my products are being sold in. That's a big limitation, because visibility without control limits strategy," the founder said. According to Proviti's Jain, as quick commerce grows, it is becoming more obvious that better teamwork between platforms and sellers is needed. 'Right now, many platforms keep their data closed off, which limits how efficient the whole industry can be." Naturally, the demand for revenue intelligence is picking up. Gobblecube currently helps break down data that is available to brands through platforms, however, it intends to expand its operations by enabling API integrations with platforms soon. 'The ecosystem is evolving rapidly. As the industry grows, hyperlocal behaviour can be understood better, resulting in efficient operations and better planning," said Gobblecube's Gupta. Proviti's Jain noted that setting up dedicated teams just for quick commerce is also becoming more prevalent. 'We're also seeing brands start to build hybrid data systems, pulling information from platforms, delivery partners, and third-party tools to get a clearer view of demand and deliveries. Looking ahead, there's a strong need for industry-wide rules around data sharing and transparency, similar to what happened in organized retail years ago."


Time of India
38 minutes ago
- Time of India
India, UK unveil road map to boost defence, tech, energy ties
India, UK unveil road map to boost defence, tech, energy ties Prime Minister Narendra Modi strongly raised issues like the need to shun double standards on terrorism, presence of Indian economic offenders in the UK and Khalistan extremism in his meeting with counterpart Keir Starmer, saying those who use democratic freedom to undermine democracy must be held accountable. Thanking Starmer for his strong condemnation of the Pahalgam terrorist attack, Modi said that the two leaders were united in their view that there can be no place for double standards in the fight against terrorism. Modi also said that Indian and British agencies would work together for the extradition of economic offenders, in what was seen as a clear message to fugitives such as Vijay Mallya, Nirav Modi, Lalit Modi and Sanjay Bhandari that government intends to get them back to face legal action in the country. Although government has got assistance, Mallya and Nirav Modi have been seeking to prolong their stay in the UK by using multiple forums for appeal. While the formalisation of India-UK free trade agreement was the highlight of Modi's visit to the UK, another significant takeaway was the launch of a Vision 2035 roadmap for boosting ties in areas like defence, technology, education, clean energy and people-to-people contacts. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like American Investor Warren Buffett Recommends: 5 Books For Turning Your Life Around Blinkist: Warren Buffett's Reading List Undo The leaders adopted a blueprint for defence industrial cooperation to promote, as the Indian government said, collaboration in co-design, co-development and co-production of defence products to meet the growing demand in both countries as well as for the world market. On the issue of Khalistan extremism, which he was expected to raise with Starmer, Modi said there was agreement between India and the UK that forces with extremist ideologies must not be allowed to misuse democratic freedoms. "Those who misuse democratic freedoms to undermine democracy itself must be held to account," said the PM, in his joint press statement with the UK PM. "On the matter of extradition of economic offenders as well, our agencies will continue to work together in close coordination and cooperation," added Modi, who sought the UK's cooperation in bringing the fugitives to justice. India and the UK also reached an agreement between the CBI and the UK's National Crime Agency to jointly fight organised crime. Foreign secretary Vikram Misri said that the leaders committed to strengthen the global fight against terrorism. "While noting that extremism and radicalisation pose threat to both societies, they agreed to further enhance bilateral cooperation to deal with the menace," said the official. Modi said that Vision 2035 will serve as a roadmap for a strong, trusted, and ambitious partnership in the areas of technology, defence, climate, education, and people-to-people connectivity. "It is our commitment that, from AI to critical minerals, semiconductors to cyber security, we shall create the future together," he said, while inviting Starmer to visit India soon. Starmer accepted the invitation. Amid concerns over the erratic US trade policies, both sides also sought to promote a fair, non-discriminatory and inclusive trading system. According to the roadmap, India and the UK reaffirmed their shared commitment to a rules-based international order and to strengthening multilateralism through meaningful reform. Importantly for India, the roadmap focuses on reform of the United Nations, including the security council, and other multilateral institutions such as the Commonwealth, WTO, WHO, IMF, and the World Bank, ensuring these bodies "reflect contemporary global realities and are equipped to address emerging challenges".