Legal Aid NT chair resigns amid backlash over government's 'captain's pick' for new director
Northern Territory Attorney-General Marie-Clare Boothby appointed South Australian barrister Catherine Voumard to take on the role earlier this month.
It came after an independent committee, headed by LANT chair Duncan McConnel SC, declined to interview Ms Voumard for the position after determining she did not meet the selection criteria.
In a letter sent to Ms Boothby last week and obtained by the ABC, Mr McConnel said he was "deeply disappointed" by her choice to override the panel's decision.
"The position requires an experienced senior lawyer with extensive executive management experience," Mr McConnel wrote.
"Your chosen appointee has none."
In the letter, Mr McConnel said the committee had provided Ms Boothby a report outlining its reasons for recommending a different candidate.
"Ms Voumard's appointment appears to have been based on reasons other than merit or otherwise marks a serious departure of judgement between the Attorney and the [Legal Aid] Commission," he wrote.
The panel process is advisory, with directors appointed by the Attorney-General under the Legal Aid Act.
In a statement, Ms Boothby told the ABC her decision to appoint Ms Voumard was for "a deliberate change in management approach".
"Legal Aid NT has long called for reform and that requires not just funding but strong leadership and fresh thinking in how the organisation is managed," she said.
"I am confident Ms Voumard will deliver the changes needed to keep Legal Aid NT sustainable and support its hardworking staff."
Ms Voumard comes to the role with 13 years of experience in the legal profession, including several stints in the NT.
She has previously worked for LANT and Aboriginal legal services in Darwin, Alice Springs and Port Augusta and as a summary trial prosecutor in remote and regional communities.
She also served as an associate to NT Supreme Court Justice Peter Barr and worked for prominent criminal law firm Maleys Barristers & Solicitors, headed up by former Country Liberal Party MLA Peter Maley, who is also the brother of current cabinet minister Gerard Maley.
In a statement, NT Bar Association (NTBA) president Mary Chalmers SC said the NTBA understood "a number" of board members had resigned "in response to a 'captain's pick' appointment of the new legal aid director".
Ms Chalmers said appointments "made contrary to the advice of a panel" could "damage community and organisational confidence in the appointment process".
"Legal Aid is a critical entity for the proper functioning of the justice system in the Northern Territory and the need for transparency in the appointment process is important," she said in a statement.
Opposition Leader Selena Uibo labelled Ms Boothby's decision "a clear overstep" and called on her to explain the appointment.
"When it comes to the legal profession in the NT, we want to see impartial and independent processes," Ms Uibo said on Tuesday.
Ms Voumard has been contacted for comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News.com.au
21 minutes ago
- News.com.au
Anthony Albanese to announce $31m mobile TAFE centres during visit to the 2025 Garma Festival
Anthony Albanese will promise mobile TAFE centres to train Indigenous students in remote communities, with the Prime Minister set to make the announcement when he attends the Garma Festival in remote Arnhem Land this weekend. The $31m commitment, to be delivered alongside state and territory governments, will allow teachers to travel Australia using utes and trailers to train students in construction, mining, agriculture, carpentry, plumbing and community work, to ensure Indigenous people don't have to leave their communities to access that training. 'So that instead of communities relying on drive-in, drive-out workers to build and maintain the new homes we are delivering … locals get that training,' he is expected to say on Saturday. 'And instead of people having to move away from home to prepare for a career in mining or agriculture, construction or the care economy, we will bring skills and jobs to communities. 'Hands-on training, on country.' Labor will also promise $75m to help resource-strapped native title holders negotiate land use deals, to 'secure better deals, drive faster approvals and deliver a real and lasting economic legacy for communities. 'We must end the stalemate that arises when native title organisations with little in the way of back of house, or legal and commercial expertise, are expected to negotiate with multinational firms,' he will say. 'This is the tone and the standard we want this partnership to set, from the very start – pragmatic action that brings economic development, ownership and equity to communities. 'Not doubling-up on advice, or getting in the way of processes that are working.' In what will be his fourth time attending the large-scale event as Prime Minister, Mr Albanese will say that Labor's second term of government will be focused on 'delivery', with the government shifting focus to boosting economic empowerment among Indigenous Australians following the failure of the Voice referendum. It also coincides with this week's release of the Closing the Gap report which revealed Australia was only on track to meet four out of 19 targets, with efforts to reduce rates of Indigenous adult imprisonment, suicide rates and removing children in out-of-home care, and bring them in line with non-Indigenous peoples worsening. Australia was, however, expected to reach its targets to boost Indigenous preschool enrolments, employment and two land rights goals. Although Mr Albanese is expected to concede that there is 'more to do,' he will urge that 'closing the gap is a challenge all of us must meet' and took aim at the 'culture wars' instigated by the Coalition. This follows a successful motion at the WA Liberal Party state conference, which was supported by high-profile Liberal senator Michaelia Cash, and called for Welcome to Country ceremonies to be banned at official events. Instead Mr Albanese will call on people to push back against people who 'choose the cheap politics of division over the patient work of lasting change or who seek to turn the grace and generosity of a welcome to country into a political weapon'. 'Culture wars are a dry gully. They offer us nothing, they lead us nowhere,' he will say. 'The way forward is to invest in Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people, trust in their aspirations and draw from their knowledge because when we lay these strong foundations together, there is no limit to what we can build.' New Liberal leader Sussan Ley will not attend the Garma Festival. Instead, shadow attorney-general Julian Leeser – who stood down from the front bench in 2023 because of his support of the Voice – will represent the Coalition. Ms Ley will, instead, travel to the Kimberley in Western Australia for a four-day listening tour with Indigenous communities and organisations. The Opposition Leader will also be joined by Coalition spokeswoman for Indigenous Australians Kerrynne Liddle and WA MP for Durack Melissa Price. Ms Ley said Mr Albanese had a 'personal obligation' to use his appearance at the Garma Festival to detail his government's plan to closing the gap. 'It is not good enough to just give speeches at festivals, we need to see his plan,' she said. 'Since the Voice Anthony Albanese has stepped back from Indigenous issues, that is not good enough. He led the referendum process, a process which was unsuccessful. So what is his path forward?' The four-day event, which started on Friday, will be the 25th anniversary of the Garma festival, which celebrates Yolngu culture – the name of Aboriginal peoples who inhabit northeastern Arnhem Land. The theme of this year's festival is 'rom ga waÅ‹a wataÅ‹u', or 'the law of the land, standing firm'.
ABC News
an hour ago
- ABC News
Anthony Albanese set to announce economic development plan at Garma Festival
Prime Minister Anthony Albanese is set to unveil a plan to lift Indigenous communities out of poverty, saying it's time First Nations people were supported to "unlock the true potential of their land". Mr Albanese is expected to address the Garma Festival in north-east Arnhem Land on Saturday, announcing a new "economic alliance" between the Commonwealth and First Nations people. The address marks the first significant announcement from the federal government on Indigenous affairs since it swept back into power with an increased majority at the May election. The prime minister will tell Aboriginal leaders gathered at Garma that past policies have cut off First Nations people from "the wealth of their land and waters". The Indigenous land estate in Australia is estimated to be around 70 per cent, however, these communities have often been locked out of economic development on their own country, as noted in the recent Yoorrook Justice Commission report. The government will invest in the First Nations Economic Empowerment Alliance — a partnership between the government and the Coalition of the Peaks, the representative body for more than 80 Aboriginal community-controlled organisations. "This builds on our commitment to the Closing the Gap Agreement, to its call for a new way of doing business and to the principle of shared decision-making," Mr Albanese will tell the Key Forum. "Working with Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people right around our nation to boost skills and education, create jobs and back businesses." The first announcements under the new partnership are $70 million for First Nations clean energy projects, and $75 million for Native Title reforms. "This is the tone and the standard we want this partnership to set, from the very start — pragmatic action that brings economic development, ownership and equity to communities," the prime minister will say. This will be the second economic announcement Mr Albanese has made at the Garma Festival. In 2024, in the wake of the failed Voice referendum that had dominated his first term of government, he announced he would be directing his focus to an "economic empowerment" agenda. But the government is also expected to face questions at Garma over whether it needs to intervene in the Northern Territory, where soaring numbers of Aboriginal people are going to jail and the relationship between the government and Indigenous organisation has deteriorated. With the government now holding a super-majority in the House of Representatives, it is expected that Labor could hold power for successive terms. Senior leader of the Gumatj clan Djawa Yunupingu says that will be front of mind in his address on Saturday. "I want to ask the prime minister to work with us, regardless of us losing the referendum. It's behind us now," Mr Yunupingu said. "We want you to work for the Yolŋu people, the Aboriginal people from around Australia, look for a better way." The federal government abandoned any plan for a Makarrata Commission for national truth-telling and treaty in its last term but Mr Yunupingu says he wants to reopen the conversation. "Treaty and Makarrata and the truth telling is yet to be decided, it is yet to be talked upon or talked amongst like we did for the Uluru Statement," Mr Yunupingu said. "It will start here and maybe go on for the next couple of years. [The] prime minister will still be in power and we need to have the discussion with him and his cabinet." Opposition Leader Sussan Ley is not attending the Garma Festival this year, instead opting to visit the Kimberley region in Western Australia with Shadow Indigenous Australians Minister Kerrynne Liddle. In a statement, Ms Ley accused Mr Albanese of "stepping back" from Indigenous affairs since the referendum was lost. "The prime minister traded in the politics of hope and made a number of promises to Indigenous Australians. On many measures these are promises he has not delivered. His referendum failed and we have seen worsening outcomes in critical areas. So what is his plan?" Ms Ley said. "It is not good enough to just give speeches at festivals, we need to see his plan. "Since the Voice Anthony Albanese has stepped back from Indigenous issues, that is not good enough. He led the referendum process, a process which was unsuccessful. So what is his path forward?" The Coalition has not announced any policies for Indigenous affairs since the election, but ran with a 10 point plan to deliver practical outcomes for First Nations peoples, including an audit into Indigenous spending, a royal commission into sexual abuse in Indigenous communities, and reforming land councils for economic development. The shadow Attorney-General Julian Leeser is the sole representative for the federal Coalition in attendance at the festival.
SBS Australia
2 hours ago
- SBS Australia
NITV Radio - On Air Program 1/08/2025
On today's program hosted by Lowanna Grant we explore a story as new data reveals the Northern Territory is the worst-performing state or territory when it comes to Closing the Gap, with youth advocates condemning recent government reforms around incarceration and detention. And as Indigenous leaders gather on Yolŋu Country for this weekend's Garma Festival, we reflect on its powerful legacy and continuing mission to shape a better future for First Nations people.
