Auckland Transport passenger Jovahna Samuels jailed after seizing control of bus during dispute
Samuels had gotten on the 83 bus, which starts at Massey University on Auckland's North Shore, last September.
When the bus got to the end of the line in Takapuna, she refused to disembark. Instead, the judge noted, she was verbally abusive before clambering into the driver's seat as the Auckland Transport employee stepped off the bus to call for backup.
Six days later, Samuels picked up wilful damage charges after throwing rocks at the Mairangi Bay Surf Life Saving Club and at the nearby North Shore Community Toy Library - damaging windows.
Mairangi Bay Surf Life Saving Club in Auckland's North Shore. Photo / Google
On October 3, she was caught taking a shower in a vacant home and locked herself inside when police arrived. The next day, she tried to shower in the men's locker room at Massey University before staff told her to leave.
'You remained in the dressing room and became verbally aggressive to the witness and other staff,' Judge Bonnar noted, explaining that police eventually had to pepper spray her after she threatened officers as well.
There were also multiple shoplifting and trespassing charges, including at Farmer's and the Northcote YMCA, and a charge of ignoring her community work requirements from a previous sentence.
Auckland District Court Judge Stephen Bonnar. Photo / Sylvie Whinray
Judge Bonnar ordered a four-month starting point for the bus charge, with an additional uplift of four months for all of the other charges. He then allowed a two-month discount for Samuels' guilty pleas, resulting in an end sentence of six months' imprisonment.
Once released, Samuels will be required to complete any treatment, counselling or programmes as directed by her probation officer.
'That's unfortunate she didn't want to go through New Beginnings,' the judge lamented to her lawyer as Samuels was led back to a courthouse holding cell.
Samuels stood for the entire hearing, declining the judge's invitation to sit. At different points in the hearing, she fanned herself with a notebook, pointed at empty spots in the courtroom and mimicked a choking sound.
Craig Kapitan is an Auckland-based journalist covering courts and justice. He joined the Herald in 2021 and has reported on courts since 2002 in three newsrooms in the US and New Zealand.
Sign up to The Daily H, a free newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
Billboard camera footage used by transport agency to spot cars and trucks
NZTA Waka Kotahi has used privately-owned automated number plate recognition cameras to identity number plates. File photo. Photo: 123RF Footage from cameras in billboards at city intersections have been secretly used by the NZ Transport Agency for the first time to spot cars and trucks. NZTA Waka Kotahi's trial started in February, and is designed to combat fraud by illegal garages issuing warrants of fitness to cars, or passing trucks. Two sources close to the vehicle inspection industry say the move is surprising and questioned why the agency would do it, especially with using third-party technology systems. Police already tap into privately-owned automated number plate recognition (ANPR) cameras to identity number plates hundreds of times a day. But this is the first known use of that power by another state agency. "The ANPR donor cameras in the trial are not being used 'to spy on mechanics issuing warrants', nor would they be capable of being used for that purpose," NZTA told RNZ. "These cameras are typically located in billboards at urban intersections. "The trial is simply looking at the potential for using images gathered by these cameras to be used as proof of the location of a particular vehicle at a point in time." An inspector who claimed they had checked a car in Auckland at a certain time could be exposed if the car was spotted at a Christchurch intersection at that time, it said. It "could be of benefit in supporting investigations into specific cases where fraudulent or illegal activity is suspected". A well-connected industry source told RNZ: "Yeah, that has been a bit secret." NZTA might not have wanted to tip people off, the source said. "For the purpose the agency is stating, I don't have much issue with that, but the way they have gone about it is what alarms me. Especially because it's third-party [cameras and ANPR system]. "What else might they use them for?" NZTA Waka Kotahi said it was not using the images in any actual fraud investigations, but only as a test for potential future use. The test is separate from how the agency is taking over many speed and red-light-runner cameras from police, and replacing some with higher-tech models, which it will own. A second source active in the industry was appalled by the move. "Oh my god," they said. "It is part of your right to know the audit process you go through. You can't sabotage your process because of a trial." Months of inquiries by RNZ in 2018 showed up mass deficiencies in NZTA's oversight of how truck certificates of fitness were being issued. The systems were reviewed and changed. There have been further reports of inspectors anonymously recounting examples of how they feel they have been subject to unfair targeting by the agency. "You have got layers and layers of issues here," said the second source. "What's the limit [of surveillance]?" They questioned why was the camera sting even needed when fraud would "show up in paperwork. There will be tons of other evidence that can be used against people". Many supermarkets, petrol stations, other businesses and councils have a total of thousands of cameras that link into ANPR software systems run by two Auckland companies - Auror and SaferCities. The new trial uses SaferCities vGrid system , NZTA said. Its system covered electronic billboard operators such as LUMO, which had built-in cameras with ANPR software, and CCTV operators including councils, individual businesses and car park operators, the agency said. Police accessed the vGrid system more than 400,000 times last year. "NZTA only has access to still images from ANPR donor cameras whose owners have specifically agreed to our usage," Waka Kotahi told RNZ in the OIA response. "Currently, this only includes LUMO and more recently, Hamilton City Council." RNZ approached LUMO for comment. As of 2022, the country had at least 1400 digital billboards and screen-posters, many of them with smart technology and ANPR cameras . The police tapped the ANPR systems 700,000 times last year. In October, two district court judges dismissed legal challenges to the police using them so much without a warrant, though it is expected there will be at least one appeal against that finding. The fraud camera trial comes at the same time Waka Kotahi is reviewing the WOF-COF system to reduce how often collectors of old vehicles, and motorhome users, have to get a warrant. The agency has been increasing a lot of the fees it charges motorists since 2023. Another batch of rises is due next January that are expected to push up total fees collected by $10m to $264m . Camera footage could be used where it was suspected that WoFs or CoFs had been issued to vehicles which had not been inspected at the time or place recorded by a vehicle inspector, the transport agency said. It gave a hypothetical scenario to RNZ: "If NZTA was investigating a vehicle inspector suspected of fraud, and if the inspector had issued a WoF to a vehicle which was recorded as having been inspected at a WoF garage in Auckland at 2pm on 1 July, 2025, and we were able to access a still image from a donor camera of the same vehicle driving past a billboard located in Christchurch at 3:30pm on 1 July, 2025, this could potentially be used as evidence to prove that the WoF had been issued fraudulently, because the vehicle was not in Auckland at the time of the recorded inspection." This would not be a part of regular compliance monitoring, it said. Regular compliance monitoring included scheduled reviews where compliance officers visited inspection sites, as well as 'mystery shopper' activity. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
Family violence: The hidden epidemic in Kiwi homes that costs the country billions
Photo: Every four minutes, New Zealand Police are called to a family harm incident. That's up to 400 call-outs every single day . It's a staggering and disturbing figure in a country that prides itself on kindness, community, and whānau. Yet, behind too many closed doors, the silent war rages, leaving victims bruised, broken, and often voiceless. The Detail looks at the alarming rate of domestic violence in New Zealand, and potential solutions, speaking to Auckland University professor of law Mark Henaghan, who was on the Family Violence Death Review committee for nearly decade, and Emma Powell, CEO of Te Puna Aonui, which has launched the government's Action Plan to eliminate domestic and sexual violence. "I would probably use the words hidden epidemic, basically," says Henaghan. "Nearly 50 percent of our murder cases involve family violence. "We only really detect ... about 20 percent [of domestic violence incidents], so there's a whole lot ... that doesn't get to the surface." He says something needs to be done, and immediately. New Zealand's rates of domestic and family violence are among the highest in the OECD . On average, 13 females and 10 males are killed every year. Māori women are particularly at risk - more likely to be killed by a partner and less likely to seek help. The financial cost to the country , Henaghan says, is huge. "They reckon it's worth, like to the country ... between $8 to $10 billion, probably more ... in terms of time off work, and how people suffer from it so they can't be productive, how children get into difficulty because all the costs of it, the medical costs, and all the rest of it, are massive. "But they're never talked about much in any political campaign, I think it's because ... we don't want to know about it. "We do need to hear about it; we need to have our eyes wide open to the realities of it." Powell, who is also a key member of the Executive Board for the Elimination of Family Violence and Sexual Violence, tells The Detail , "if you look at the numbers, the rates are stubbornly high", but she says the government is taking action to address the crisis. Late last year, it launched part two of Te Aorerekura - the National Strategy to Eliminate Family Violence and Sexual Violence - a 25-year strategy designed to achieve intergenerational change. Part one was introduced in 2021. Powell says over the next few years it's keying in on good investment and commissioning, how effective funding is, freeing up frontline workers to get them into the community and more productive places, getting into the regions, intervening earlier, focusing more on children, confronting perpetrators, and building an information sharing platform. "I really believe that the only way forward is doing things as collectives, and that's tough, it is hard, hard stuff to do, but it's really important," says Powell. "I think taken together and executed really well in a community, we should start to see a real shift." Last week, the government announced that, as part of the Action Plan, more training to help staff support in family and sexual violence responses will be rolled out across frontline services, with the goal of reaching 10,000 workers in the next two years. Minister for the Prevention of Family and Sexual Violence Karen Chhour says, "this will ensure victim-survivors receive best practice support, and will empower staff to safely recognise, refer, and respond to family and sexual violence". "This training is an important part of our response to family and sexual violence. I am proud of our progress against the second Te Aorerekura Action Plan, it shows the benefits of a multi-agency response and the dedication of government departments to best supporting victim-survivors." Powell says while change can be slow, a recent experience in Rotorua provides proof that it is starting to happen. "I was spending time on the ground with a multi-agency collaboration ... and I was talking to one of the leads there and she was telling me about just a story - stories that they [are] starting to see more and more - where 'she has left him', and we don't count that, we don't count that in government as an indicator of success. "But they are seeing more and more that women are feeling empowered, supported, and safe to actually leave very violent and difficult situations. And so, there are lives being changed by the work that we are doing." Check out how to listen to and follow The Detail here . You can also stay up-to-date by liking us on Facebook
RNZ News
12 hours ago
- RNZ News
Auckland woman horrified council tried to take rough sleepers' tents, sleeping bags
FOR WEEKEND - BULLETINS MATCHER An Auckland woman saw council workers collecting rough sleepers' belongings. Photo: RNZ / Luke McPake An Auckland woman who gave tents and sleeping bags to a group of rough sleepers says she stopped council workers from removing the items a few days later. Some days, Pip Scott walks to and from work in the central city with her dog, and stops to talk to those sheltering at Grafton United Cricket Club overnight. The building has bleacher seats and a roof, and Scott recently gave the people sleeping there two tents, sleeping bags and a pillow. "I have lots of conversations with homeless people on the way to work and most of them are really friendly," she said. "I just feel, you know, they're just going through a rough time, but they always like to say hello to my dog and have a chat. "You can visibly see it, if you're walking around the streets, there just seems to be a lot more people that have come into hard times ." A few days later, Scott was walking past, when workers exited an Auckland Council van with black rubbish sacks and started collecting the belongings. She said the men who slept there were absent, but had stashed the tents and sleeping bags in a small pile under the shelter. "They had found the place where the people had stashed all their warm stuff to sleep in and they were pulling it down out of its place. I walked straight up to them and said, 'Do not take their stuff - what are they going to do? They've got nothing else to keep them warm and it's been freezing this week'." Scott said the council workers left without taking the rough sleepers' belongings, but she was horrified they had tried to collect it. "It's upsetting and I don't know what the answer is, but taking people stuff from them is definitely not the answer," she said. "Imagine coming back from your day and you're about to bed down to sleep on some concrete stairs, and someone's taken your last warmth or barrier for that. "I just think it's cruel." Auckland Council compliance manager Adrian Wilson said there rough sleepers had no designated areas to store belongings and the council was exploring possibilities for this. He said council staff would seize items when they were not removed and "anything of value, including tents, sleeping bags and personal items are stored". The council retained such items for six months, if they were not claimed. "Council staff make every effort to identify the owner of any property left unattended. They initially leave notices requiring the individual to remove their items." Auckland Council's compliance manager Adrian Wilson. Photo: RNZ / Marika Khabazi Social services have warned of worsening poverty, due to economic hardship . On Tuesday, Auckland Council's Community Committee will discuss a report that updates the number of homeless living on Auckland's streets. The number of homeless people rose to 809 in May this year - a 90 percent increase since last September. This followed the release of the Ministry of Housing and Urban Development's latest Homelessness Insights Report, which showed 14 percent of people leaving emergency housing were likely homeless . The council report identified two key risks in response to the data provided by outreach services. Auckland Council received more than 500 requests from the public related to rough sleepers in the past 10 months. Head of community impact Dickie Humphries said these ranged from concern about a person's welfare to reporting bylaw infringements and blocked doorways. He said the increase in rough sleepers was concerning. "We are here to make sure that the city in this region is a thriving city for all and Auckland is experiencing homelessness [that] is the antithesis of that vision, so we find it very concerning. "The causes are complex, and what we're hearing from our agencies and what our observations are, is worsening social and economic conditions for people, but that is felt most acutely for those who are already quite vulnerable or on the margins." He said the council was working with social service organisations to respond to concerns from residents and actively patrol the city. "We do have constraints on our resources and the best way to make inroads on this is to do it together. "No one institution, no one organisation can solve this alone, so to get more value out of our offer here from Auckland Council to the region will come through the partnerships that we have." Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
