Texas may require medical records list patients' sex assigned at birth
Senate Bill 1188 encompasses 'multiple components' according to the bill's sponsor, Rep. Greg Bonnen, R-Friendswood, including restrictions on health care providers' storage of digital servers and their use of artificial intelligence. Democratic legislators on Thursday, however, largely zeroed in on a provision requiring all health records to include a new segment explicitly listing the sex a patient was assigned at birth and any physical sexual development disorders they may have.
SB 1188 is one of several bills moving through the Legislature aimed at restricting the health care of trans Texans, however SB 1188 does have an exemption stating it does not restrict gender identity information from being included in health records. To enforce its provisions, SB 1188 allows the attorney general to file for injunctions against violations of the bill, and would create penalties of up to $250,000 for practices who knowingly violate its provisions. The bill allows for gender markers to be changed for clerical errors or in certain cases for intersex patients.
Democratic lawmakers who spoke in opposition of the bill said the required reporting of gender assigned at birth excludes transgender and intersex patients who may be forced to have a gender displayed in their medical records they don't identify as.
'Knowing that documentation choices could trigger a government investigation discourages providers from recording accurate individualized information, especially in complex cases involving gender or sex variation,' Rep. Ron Reynolds, D-Missouri City, said. 'It places fear and legal exposure ahead of best medical practice.'
Bonnen provided rebuttals for all of the proposed amendments and ensured opponents of the bill that it would help physicians understand a more complete picture of a patient's medical history. Democratic representatives attempted to derail the bill down through two points of order and then brought a slew of amendments to the floor seeking to blunt some of the bill's requirements, but were unsuccessful.
'Listen, biological sex and medical records is an issue of accuracy, and impacting safe medical care in an acute situation, an emergency could lead to a misdiagnosis,' Bonnen said. 'The whole point of the section of the bill is to ensure the physicians always know the true biological sex from birth, and the language is carefully crafted to allow for exceptions based on other medical conditions.'
Bonnen provided his own amendment to the bill expanding the eligibility for those who could be listed as intersex and explicitly stating the bill does not ban AI use by medical professionals.
The bill outlines in statute its own definitions of several medical terms including 'sexual development disorder,' male and female. While its definition of female matches that of House Bill 229 — a bill seeking to define male and female across state statute that passed in the House in May — it differs in its definition of what a male is. HB 229 defines a male as someone whose biological reproductive system 'is developed to fertilize the ova of a female,' different from SB 1188's requirement that male systems are 'developed to produce sperm.'
Beyond its requirements on reporting biological sex, SB 1188 also gives parents and guardians of minors 'unrestricted access' to the child's medical records unless a court order is in place preventing them from doing so. The bill also requires medical professionals to disclose when they use artificial intelligence for diagnoses and review all AI-created documents.
The bill requires one more formal vote in the House, after which it will be sent for approval from the Senate as amended, then will head to Gov. Greg Abbott's desk for his signature.
First round of TribFest speakers announced! Pulitzer Prize-winning columnist Maureen Dowd; U.S. Rep. Tony Gonzales, R-San Antonio; Fort Worth Mayor Mattie Parker; U.S. Sen. Adam Schiff, D-California; and U.S. Rep. Jasmine Crockett, D-Dallas are taking the stage Nov. 13–15 in Austin. Get your tickets today!
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Hill
35 minutes ago
- The Hill
Pritzker says Texas Democrats who fled state will be protected amid arrest threats
Illinois Gov. JB Pritzker (D) said on Sunday that the state would protect Texas Democrats who fled to the Prairie State over GOP efforts to redraw the Lone Star State's congressional maps. 'They're here in Illinois. We're going to do everything we can to protect every single one of them and make sure that — 'cause we know they're doing the right thing, we know that they're following the law,' Pritzker told reporters at a press conference Sunday night held alongside the Texas state lawmakers. 'It's Ken Paxton who doesn't follow the law. It's the leaders of Texas who are attempting not to follow the law,' he continued. 'They're the ones that need to be held accountable.' The Illinois governor's comments came after Texas Democrats left their state to deny their GOP counterparts a quorum, or the minimum number of lawmakers needed to conduct business, during their special session. Texas Gov. Greg Abbott (R) called the special session in part to push forward a new congressional map that would give Republicans five more pick-up opportunities, something President Trump has been pushing for as the GOP braces for a potentially challenging midterm election next year. A Texas House panel on Saturday advanced the set of maps, teeing them up for a vote on the House floor. Because Republicans enjoy majorities in both chambers and hold the governor's mansion, the maps are all but assured to pass. In a bid to stop those maps from passing, Texas Democrats fled the state, mainly traveling to Illinois, New York and Massachusetts — all blue strongholds. Breaking quorum, however, means that each lawmaker incurs a daily penalty of $500 and the possibility of being arrested. Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton in a post on X earlier Sunday argued that 'Democrats in the Texas House who try and run away like cowards should be found, arrested, and brought back to the Capitol immediately.' Texas Democrats' decision to leave the state — following a similar tactic they took in 2003 when Republicans engaged in mid-cycle redistricting — underscores how the party is looking to use all tools at their disposal to thwart Republicans from changing their election maps. 'This is wrong, this is un-American and this is undemocratic,' said state Rep. Trey Martinez Fischer (D). 'And America, we need to wake up. Republicans are stealing our democracy right before our very eyes.' The redistricting battle is opening the possibility to a larger redistricting arms race as blue and red states alike leave the door open to changing their own congressional maps, which would sow uncertainty into next year's midterms. But the issue is also placing a spotlight on several potential 2028 hopefuls, including Pritzker and Govs. Gavin Newsom (D) and Ron DeSantis (R), who have all weighed in on the redistricting tit-for-tat.
Los Angeles Times
2 hours ago
- Los Angeles Times
Texas Democrats leave the state to block vote on gerrymandered congressional map
Democrats in the Texas House left the state Sunday in a last-resort bid to block new congressional maps sought by President Trump that would give Republicans a better chance of preserving their narrow U.S. House majority in the 2026 midterm elections. The dramatic revolt came before the GOP-controlled House was set to vote Monday on the proposed maps, which would give Republicans five more winnable congressional seats. In response to Texas' rare mid-decade political gerrymander, Democratic governors in other states have floated the possibility of redrawing their own maps in retaliation, but their options are limited. Many of the Texas Democrats were bound for Illinois and a welcoming from Gov. JB Pritzker, a potential 2028 presidential contender, who in recent weeks has offered them support. It was unclear how long they were prepared to stay out of Texas or whether the maneuver would succeed. Four years ago, House Democrats left Texas for 38 days in protest of new voting restrictions that still wound up passing once the holdout ended. 'This is not a decision we make lightly, but it is one we make with absolute moral clarity,' Rep. Gene Wu, chair of the House Democratic Caucus, said in a statement. Lawmakers can't pass bills in the 150-member Texas House without at least two-thirds of them present. Democrats hold 62 of the seats in the Republican-majority chamber, and at least 51 were leaving the state, said Josh Rush Nisenson, spokesperson for the House Democratic Caucus. In addition to the Illinois group, five lawmakers headed to New York and another group went to Boston, Rush Nisenson said. Republican House Speaker Dustin Burrows said the chamber would meet as planned Monday afternoon. 'If a quorum is not present then, to borrow the recent talking points from some of my Democrat colleagues, all options will be on the table,' he posted on X. Republican Atty. Gen. Ken Paxton, who is running for U.S. Senate, said on X that Democrats who 'try and run away like cowards should be found, arrested, and brought back to the Capitol immediately.' A refusal by Texas lawmakers to show up is a civil violation of legislative rules. The Texas Supreme Court held in 2021 that House leaders had the authority to 'physically compel the attendance' of missing members, but no Democrats were forcibly brought back to the state after warrants were served that year. Two years later, Republicans pushed through new rules that allow daily fines of $500 for lawmakers who don't show up for work. Republican Gov. Greg Abbott's office did not immediately respond to requests for comment Sunday. The quorum break will also delay votes on flood relief and new warning systems in response to last month's catastrophic floods in Texas that killed at least 136 people. Democrats had called for votes on the flooding response before taking up redistricting and have criticized Republicans for not doing so. Texas Republicans last week unveiled their planned U.S. House map that would create five GOP-leaning seats. Republicans currently hold 25 of the state's 38 seats. Pritzker, who has been one of Trump's most outspoken critics during his second term, had been in quiet talks with Texas Democrats for weeks about offering support if they chose to leave the state to break quorum. Last week, the governor hosted several Texas Democrats in Illinois to publicly oppose the redistricting effort, and California Gov. Gavin Newsom held a similar event in his state. Pritzker also met privately with Texas Democratic Party Chair Kendall Scudder in June to begin planning for the possibility that lawmakers would depart for Illinois if they did decide to break quorum to block the map, according to a source with direct knowledge who requested anonymity to discuss private conversations. Now, with many Texas Democrats holed up in Illinois and blocking the gerrymandered map proposal, the stage may be set for a high-profile showdown between Pritzker and Trump. The Republican president is looking to avoid a repeat of his first term, when Democrats flipped the House two years into his presidency, and he hopes the new Texas map will aid that effort. Trump officials have also looked at redrawing lines in other states, such as Missouri, according to a person familiar with conversations but unauthorized to speak publicly about them. Cappelletti and DeMillo write for the Associated Press. AP writer Nadia Lathan in Austin, Texas, contributed to this report.
New York Post
4 hours ago
- New York Post
Staten Island Democrats embrace Zohran Mamdani, turn on Andrew Cuomo: ‘Voters have spoken'
Democratic Party leaders in the city's most conservative borough are jumping on the Zohran Mamdani bandwagon in what critics are calling the political equivalent of a 'shotgun wedding.' Staten Island Democrats are making nice with the party nominee after backing his rival, ex-Gov. Andrew Cuomo in the June Democratic Party primary. Cuomo is now running in the general election on an independent, minor-party line. 'Zohran is the Democratic nominee. The voters have spoken,' said Laura LoBianco Sword, chairwoman of the borough's Democratic Party. 3 The Democratic Party of Staten Island is getting behind the Zohran Mamdani in the general election. Paul Martinka 'We want to work together. I want to make sure Staten Island has a seat at the table.' The Mamdani campaign confirmed it will have a big general election campaign launch Aug. 17 on Staten Island as the democratic socialist looks to expand his political base. 'While Zohran builds real support across all five boroughs, Cuomo's campaign is withering as New Yorkers learn he stands for absolutely nothing but his own ambition, dogged by scandal, corruption, and a record of sexual harassment and humiliation,' campaign spokeswoman Dora Pekec said. Mamdani won big as an outsider pick in the primary but he has made a push to expand his reach as he heads into the general election, where he'll face Republican Curtis Sliwa as well as independents Cuomo and incumbent Mayor Eric Adams. Rodneyse Bichotte, the Brooklyn Democratic chairwoman, endorsed Cuomo during the primary election but immediately backed Mamdani after he won the party contest. 3 The Staten Island Democrats endorsed former Gov. Andrew Cuomo in he mayoral primary. J.C. Rice Mamdani has also been in contact with party leaders in Queens, particularly officials who represent largely black neighborhoods in the southeast part of the borough that went heavily for Cuomo during the primary election, according to insiders. LoBianco Sword credited Mamdani with bringing new voters into the Democratic Party, and hopes to piggyback that trend in the borough. The island Democratic leader said Mamdani has correctly identified the city's problems. Whether or not one agrees with his controversial plan to open government-run grocery stores in the five boroughs, she said there's no question that there are 'food deserts' in city neighborhoods. Start and end your day informed with our newsletters Morning Report and Evening Update: Your source for today's top stories Thanks for signing up! Enter your email address Please provide a valid email address. By clicking above you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. Never miss a story. Check out more newsletters She also said the wealthy 'should pay their fair share' when asked about Mamdani's plans to raise taxes on millionaires and corporations by $9 billion to subsidize fare-free buses, child care and housing. Cuomo beat Mamdani in Richmond County but it wasn't a blowout — 46.5% of the vote to 37.5% during the initial round of the ranked-choice election. Staten Island Republican Party chairman Michael Tannousis, asked about the borough Democratic organization-Mamdani alliance, 'it's definitely a shotgun wedding.' 3 Republican mayoral candidate Curtis Sliwa expects to win Staten Island — but says he isn't taking voters in the borough for granted. Kevin C Downs forThe New York Post He predicted many moderate, law-and-order Democrats will back Republican nominee Curtis Sliwa, who won 65% of the vote in the borough against Adams in 2021, though Adams easily carried the other boroughs and won the mayoralty. Adams ran in that race on the Democratic line. 'There is no appetite for socialism and the socialist agenda,' said Tannousis, also a state assemblyman. 'Curtis will win Staten Island. He may get a bigger vote than four years ago. Staten Islanders will have a choice: either the Mamdani socialist Democrats or the Republican ticket.' Sliwa, for his part, is working hard to carry Staten Island again, but he's not taking the borough for granted. 'If I lose Staten Island, shame on me. It's a real battleground but I've been out there forever,' the Guardian Angels founder said. He said Staten Islanders will never forgive Adams for pushing migrant shelters in the borough as mayor and Cuomo is running on his legacy — making the GOP nominee the chief rival to Mamdani.
