Tariff hikes in City's draft budget face backlash from civic groups
The public has until May 2 to comment on the R84.1 billion draft budget, which Mayor Geordin Hill-Lewis tabled in last month's Council meeting.
Video Player is loading.
Play Video
Play
Unmute
Current Time
0:00
/
Duration
-:-
Loaded :
0%
Stream Type LIVE
Seek to live, currently behind live
LIVE
Remaining Time
-
0:00
This is a modal window.
Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window.
Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque
Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps
Reset
restore all settings to the default values Done
Close Modal Dialog
End of dialog window.
Advertisement
Next
Stay
Close ✕
The infrastructure investments include over R16.5bn for water and sanitation, R5bn for electricity grid upgrades, R3.4bn for roads, and a further R4.5bn for the new MyCiti bus route linking Khayelitsha, Mitchell's Plain and a host of other communities with Wynberg and Claremont.
As part of the City's R6.7bn Safety and Security budget, the mayor said over 700 new municipal police officers will be deployed.
Hill-Lewis announced major tariff restructuring reforms, which are expected to shield lower income households from financial pressures.
In this reform, water and sanitation fixed charges will now be determined by property values rather than connection size; while electricity rates will rise by 2% on average.
Residents will also see a City-Wide Cleaning Tariff explicitly reflected on their bills from July alongside refuse removal.
According to Hill-Lewis, this is not a new expense as customers previously helped fund this via property rates, and the tariff will be fully buffered by the reduction of electricity costs going to other forms of service delivery.
The increases from the tariff restructure have provoked strong opposition from civic associations.
Tokai Residents' Association chairperson, Don Kourie, says they are firmly opposed to the tariff restructure, noting that the City's Tariff Calculator shows a potential 20% increase in monthly rates bills for homeowners.
'The new cleaning tariff is unacceptable — it's based on property value, yet the service benefits all residents equally, not individual homes.
'The water connection tariff will also be based on property value. A fixed fee for every property, as there is for refuse collection, rather than a property value-based mechanism, would be more appropriate,' Kourie says, arguing that the current method is inequitable.
'Rates and refuse charges are going up by 7–8%, well above the current 2.8% inflation rate. These new tariffs fail the City's own promise of equity and fairness. Many residents, especially pensioners on fixed incomes, will face an unfair and disproportionate burden.'
Keith Barton, Bergvliet Meadowridge Ratepayer's Association chairperson, says the draft budget places the burden on middle- and upper-income households with sharp hikes in fixed charges — all tied to property value.
'If approved, this budget will cause financial strain for many middle-income homes.
"A typical R4.2 million property in our suburbs would pay R920 more per month in fixed charges — irrespective of the amount of electricity and water consumed. Households with solar and boreholes using minimal City services could see monthly municipal bills rise by over 30%.
'The City says this new structure ends the past practice of cross-subsidising other municipal services via electricity sales. We do not believe that municipal charges should be so heavily skewed towards a property's value instead of its consumption of services.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Citizen
11 hours ago
- The Citizen
#Reportback: Tracking the four investigations at KDM
#Reportback: Tracking the four investigations at KDM Four high-profile investigations are currently underway at KwaDukuza municipality (KDM), and I want to ensure the public remains informed with clarity and transparency. Firstly, the Special Investigating Unit (SIU) is probing three high-value tenders issued between 2018 and 2019, relating to roadworks and electrical infrastructure for the KwaDukuza Mall. These multimillion-rand projects are being scrutinised for possible irregularities, wasteful expenditure and misconduct. The investigation may run until late 2026, as SIU cases typically span up to 24 months. The process is expected to cost about R24- million, which will be billed to the municipality. Council has formally appealed to the SIU for a waiver or reduction of these costs and we remain hopeful that the request will be favourably considered. In addition, KDM is subject to an investigation by the Department of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs (Cogta), initiated under Section 106 by MEC Rev Thulasizwe Buthelezi in March this year. The probe focuses on alleged asset misuse, political interference and irregular appointments and hiring practices. Cogta requires around 90 days to gather evidence and finalise its findings. Once the report is submitted to the MEC's office, it will be tabled before Council and shared with the public. On the electricity front, we have heard your frustrations loud and clear. Following years of outages and deteriorating infrastructure, the National Energy Regulator of South Africa (Nersa) is conducting a full audit of the municipality's electrical systems. Their findings are expected to clarify the root causes of service delivery issues and provide guidance on corrective action. Nersa typically completes its audits within a month, and the report is expected to be tabled before Council by the end of this month. Lastly, I must address the R35.7- million cyber fraud incident that struck the municipality earlier this year. Hackers infiltrated our ABSA account using spyware, resulting in a significant financial loss. While R30.8-million has been recovered, R4.9- million remains unaccounted for. The Hawks are currently investigating all parties involved, including a company that received R4.4- million and withdrew it immediately. Council has secured a High Court liquidation order to aid in recovering the stolen funds and has established a commission of enquiry to ensure accountability. These measures are not without cost – the total legal and administrative expenses are estimated at between R1.5-million and R2-million, but they are necessary to ensure justice is served. Shortened – Ed. Stay in the loop with The North Coast Courier on Facebook, X, Instagram & YouTube for the latest news. Mobile users can join our WhatsApp Broadcast Service here or if you're on desktop, scan the QR code below. At Caxton, we employ humans to generate daily fresh news, not AI intervention. Happy reading!
IOL News
02-07-2025
- IOL News
Cape Town's 2025/2026 budget faces backlash from residents and civic groups
Mayor Geordin Hill-Lewis Image: Supplied Cape Town's newly adopted 2025/2026 'Invested in Hope' budget has been met with strong criticism from civic organisations and residents, who warn that the latest increases could disproportionately burden low- and middle-income households. Sandra Dickson, chairperson of STOP COCT, said the City had 'bluntly ignored' key objections raised during public participation. 'STOP COCT is deeply disappointed with the Mayor's flat refusal to address the homeowners' real concerns which is the rejection of the introduction of the Fixed Charges, the link to property values and the above inflation increases,' she said. 'If one look at the increase in total municipal accounts, it is only properties up to the R1.5 million mark that will receive increases resembling the current inflation rate. From R1.5 million properties upwards, the total increase is double inflation and above R3 million the increase is in double digits.' STOP COCT flagged the 7.96% increase in the rate-in-rand, along with multiple new fixed charges. 'This is exacerbated by the 38% increase in the fixed charge for electricity for the Home User category and the new fixed charge of R59.90 for the Domestic category. The new sanitation fixed charge and the new Cleaning Charge brings the total of new fixed charges on a municipal bill for a property of R1.5 million to almost R300 per month with no additional services provided by the City.' Despite submitting objections through their members, Dickson said residents were ignored. 'The general objection was against the 4 fixed charges and the link to property values. This is still intact in the approved Budget. Therefore the City bluntly ignored our objections.' She confirmed that STOP COCT, along with SA1STForum, is exploring legal action. 'SA1STForum and STOP COCT is currently busy with fundraising to pay for legal council to challenge aspects of this Budget in court. Afriforum indicated that they are looking to launch legal action as well.' Bas Zuidberg, interim chairperson of the Cape Town Civic and Ratepayers Association (CTCRA), said while the City appeared to make some concessions, they were largely cosmetic. 'While CTCRA was initially pleased that the City appeared to have listened to the thousands of comments and announced relief measures in their updated budget, our conclusion is that these measures do not address our fundamental points of dissent.' 'As CTCRA we are also of the opinion that every homeowner should pay for their utility connections out of principle, however small the contribution, since 'what is not paid for is not valued'. These three measures could have avoided the need to tie the fixed charges to property values, something which we reject as unfair, disproportionate, and potentially illegal.' He added, 'Commercial properties were exonerated from this cleaning charge for an additional year, which feels very unfair. Why did they get this extension and not the residential properties? We have not heard any argument for this that make sense.' The City of Cape Town has been criticised by civil organisations over their budget plans Image: Unsplash CTCRA was actively involved in public participation, helping mobilise more than 50 ratepayers' associations. 'It feels particularly frustrating to hear City say that they listened to the public and amended the budget accordingly, because that is clearly not the case. If they had truly listened they would not have tabled the budget in this form.' Zuidberg said CTCRA is consulting with other civic groups about legal options. 'The fury amongst the ratepayers is pronounced and people are actively encouraging us to mount a legal challenge, but this is not a venture to be taken lightly.' He called on residents to take civic action. 'Members of the public who are angry at this budget should write to their ward councillors, the party leadership they vote for and the Mayor.' 'CTCRA still believes this budget can be undone and we remain open to constructive dialogue with all stakeholders to back up this belief. It is never too late to fix a mistake, because that is what we believe this budget to be.' The City of Cape Town has defended its budget amid public outcry, emphasising that it balances long-term infrastructure investment with social support. It explained the R40 billion, three-year infrastructure plan includes major upgrades to transport, water, sanitation, policing, and informal settlements. According to Mayor Geordin Hill-Lewis, the budget 'asks a little more of those who can afford it' while safeguarding essential services for vulnerable households. Key relief measures include increased rebates for pensioners, expanded debt write-off schemes, and revised fixed charges that, according to the City, reduce costs for 200,000 homes under R2.5 million in value. The Mayor insists the fixed charges linked to property value are a fair way to ensure wealthier households contribute proportionately more, maintaining cross-subsidisation.
TimesLIVE
01-07-2025
- TimesLIVE
SA's illegal alcohol trade costs R16bn in lost tax revenue
South Africa's illicit alcohol market has grown by 55% over the past seven years, outpacing growth of the legal alcohol market, and is now worth R25.1bn. This has prompted a call from the Drinks Federation of SA (DF-SA) for collaboration between the government and the private sector to fight the growth of illicit trade in alcohol which has cost the government R16.5bn in lost tax revenue. Benjamin Rideout, research consultant at Euromonitor International, said nearly one in five alcoholic drinks sold in SA is illegal. 'Unlike some countries where home brews are the issue, SA is facing large-scale counterfeiting. The situation demands better control over production inputs like ethanol and much stronger enforcement.' The chair of DF-SA and CEO of SAB, Richard Rivett-Carnac, said illicit alcohol distorts the market and undermines trust in legitimate brands. 'In a tough macroeconomic environment, consumers are looking for bang for buck, goods that are affordable and the price gap of between 37% and 70% between illicit and legal alcohol makes illicit products more appealing, especially in low-income communities. He said 67% of surveyed consumers in the Euromonitor study, for instance, said they would knowingly buy illicit alcohol due to the lower price.' Moreover, he said illegal alcohol is a growing threat to South Africa's economy and public health. 'It drains billions from public funds, threatens jobs, and weakens the formal legal, taxed alcohol industry. Understanding the drivers of illicit alcohol growth and its magnitude is a step in the Right direction but we need stronger collaboration with the industry and government to really start removing the incentives that allow for the illicit market to thrive and intensifying enforcement.' During a panel discussion, Dr Shamal Ramesar, head of research at DF-SA, said 'communities are at risk, and the economy is the biggest loser when we delve into the pervasiveness of illicit alcohol. Recent testing with the University of KwaZulu-Natal found that many illegal products contain dangerous substances like methanol, which can cause serious harm. Unless we shut down illegal producers and educate consumers, lives will continue to be at risk.' DF-SA also announced a new national awareness campaign to help South Africans recognise illegal alcohol and understand the risks. The campaign will include tools for traders and consumers, tips on spotting fake products, and information on how to report them.
