A Dim Prognosis: Auckland ICU doctor's book calls for NZ health system overhaul
Hospital bullies, mismanaged priorities, disparities between public and private health care – Auckland-based Dr Ivor Popovich is not holding back. He speaks to Kim Knight about his new book detailing a health system in crisis.
'The skin crackled slightly as it separated.'
Seven pages in, and the reader is
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scoop
a day ago
- Scoop
Health And Gender Equality Are Indivisible And Fundamental Human Rights
'Right to health cannot be dislocated from gender equality and human rights. We have to ensure that gender equality and human right to health are recognised as fundamental human rights in all countries,' said Lucknow-based Shobha Shukla, who was the Lead Discussant for SDG-3 (health and wellbeing) at the United Nations intergovernmental High Level Political Forum (HLPF 2025) at UN HQ in New York (14-23 July 2025). She was the only Indian on the panel and speaking on behalf of Asia Pacific Regional Civil Society Engagement Mechanism. The theme of HLPF 2025 is 'Advancing sustainable, inclusive, science- and evidence-based solutions for the 2030 Agenda and its SDGs for leaving no one behind'. The 2025 HLPF with full appreciation for the integrated, indivisible and interlinked nature of the Sustainable Development Goals, is conducting in-depth reviews of: SDG-3 (ensure healthy lives and promote well-being for all at all ages); SDG-5 (achieve gender equality and empower all women and girls); SDG-8 (promote sustained, inclusive and sustainable economic growth, full and productive employment and decent work for all); SDG-14 (conserve and sustainably use the oceans, seas and marine resources for sustainable development); and SDG-17 (strengthen the means of implementation and revitalise the Global Partnership for Sustainable Development). 'Progress towards SDG3, continues to be stunted in the Asia Pacific region, such as on universal access to sexual and reproductive health and rights; communicable and noncommunicable diseases; universal health coverage; and access for all to safe, effective, quality and affordable disease prevention tools like vaccines, diagnostics and medicines,' said Shobha Shukla, who earlier taught physics at Loreto Convent College and leads CNS as Founder Executive Director. She is a feminist and development justice leader who coordinates Sexual Health with Equity & Rights (SHE & Rights). 'Gender disparities significantly impact health outcomes and evidence shows that SDG 3 goals cannot be realised without addressing SDG 5 on gender equality. Rise of anti-rights and anti-gender ideologies, including the regressive Geneva Consensus Declaration, the most recent trend of defunding development assistance for gender equality and health, the impact of austerity measures in debt-ridden countries, deprioritisation of health spending, and poor domestic resource allocation on health, are contributing to reversal in progress towards SDG3,' she added. Sexual and reproductive health and bodily autonomy are critical to deliver on SDG3 and other SDGs 'Essential health services must include sexual and reproductive health services - including safe abortion and post-abortion care, menstrual health hygiene, and mental health services, with particular attention to women, adolescent girls, persons with disability, indigenous peoples, gender diverse communities, older people, young people, migrant workers, refugees, people living with HIV, sex workers, people who use drugs, among others. They must also include all health and social support services for survivors of sexual and gender-based violence,' said Shobha Shukla. Save the medicines that protect us 'All countries must stop misuse and overuse of medicines in all sectors and prevent antimicrobial resistance using the One Health approach,' said Shobha Shukla who serves as Chairperson of Global Antimicrobial Resistance Media Alliance (GAMA). 'WHO FCTC Articles 5.3 and 19 empower governments to make tobacco and nicotine industries liable and pay for the harm they are causing to human health and our planet. All forms of corporate capture of public health policy must end and corporations that are causing harm to human health and the environment must be held liable,' she said. Gender-transformative reforms of global financial architecture is vital Gender transformative economic system that is based on rights to justice, care, and equality for everyone urgently. Because most of the countries in the Global South are in the cycles of perennial debt – which they have to keep servicing to international financial institutions. This results into austerity measures which include countries cutting down on public services, access to health services, education services, social protection services, among others. Governments must suspend patents and lift trade rules that impede access to medicines and medical technologies, said Shobha Shukla. UN Charter and other legally binding treaties like CEDAW, FCTC, etc have to take primacy over trade deals - we cannot let profit override people's interests. Also, we cannot forget COVID-19 when multilateralism failed the Global South. Vaccines were piled up and expired ones thrown by some rich nations when Global South nations had no dose for example. We cannot have Global North heavy multilateralism. 'Governments also need to address occupational health and provide meaningful 'right to know' to workers, prioritize prevention, and establish exposure limits protective of the most vulnerable populations. All SDG3 targets must be fully-funded and DAC countries (30 developed nations that give aid to developing nations) should fulfill their commitment to official development assistance (ODA) for gender equality and health. At the same time countries must mobilise domestic resources for health,' she added. Health responses and all public services must be person-centred, gender transformative and rights-based 'We have to ensure that health responses and all public services are people-centred, gender transformative and rights-based for all, without any condition or exclusion,' said Shobha Shukla, lead discussant for SDG3 at HLPF 2025. 'With less than 5 and a half years left to deliver on SDG3, we appeal to governments to step up their actions on gender equality and right to health - where no one is left behind,' she said.
RNZ News
2 days ago
- RNZ News
The business of playing for neurodiverse kids
Mac and Maria Pouniu, the owners and founders of Spectroom Photo: Misinformation v1 Mac and Maria Pouniu couldn't take their autistic son Mattias to a playground without feeling overwhelmed and judged by onlookers. Instead of staying at home, isolated and alone, the couple decided to take a negative experience and turn it into something positive - a play centre for kids like their son. About five years later, standing amidst the delightful chaos of a busy Wednesday morning, Poinui tells The Detail that Spectroom is more than just a play zone. It's a safe space where children with different disabilities - not just autism - can be themselves in an environment designed to let them play freely. "A lot of our kids have grown up in that environment where they have very limited access to resources and they have very restricted access to things. "Parents have become so used to, 'oh nah we've never done that, oh nah we're not going to do that'," Mac says. But when parents come into an environment where their child can explore and they can take a step back, they see a whole different child. "It's because we've never put them in a space where they can actually be themselves without restrictions," he says. The diagnosis of Mattias led Maria Pounui to leave her job in marketing, retrain and work for Autism New Zealand as a play coach. She's the other half of the driving force behind Spectroom. Her long term goal is to build a facility with wrap-around services for neurodivergent people of all ages, from day care for the little ones, to mock apartments for adults to practice everyday tasks. "We started with our little ones because that's all the funding that I had... but the goal is at the end to have these services where we can assist and support our community when they are adults," she says. Maria Pounui says while there are existing services already helping people with disabilities there simply aren't enough to serve all neurodiverse people. "We need to have services that are umbrella services... because transitions for our kids with disabilities are really hard," she says. Spectroom received global recognition within a year of opening, with FIFA asking Mac and Maria to build a similar sensory space at their centre at Eden Park. "It's a quiet, dim space for our kids, also for adults, for them to go when they get overwhelmed. "Especially for example at Eden Park when people get overwhelmed with crowd, crowded spaces, it could be anything, lighting, sound, and that triggers some people... and then sometimes they need a space to go into to recharge, recoup," Mac says. The sensory room was only meant to stay for the duration of the 2023 FIFA Womens World Cup but it was so popular that Eden Park asked for it to stay permanently. Now it's been expanded and Mac says they're working on a similar facility in Manukau, where he says the need is highest. "The original plan was to set one here (in Auckland), one in Wellington and one in Christchurch, that is still in the pipeline. But we have also recently become a trust. "Becoming a trust is not as straight forward as becoming a trust and then get funding, you still have to go through the whole process of proving who we are, why we need the funding and then we need to target our right audience. "It's really important that we get it right from the beginning, but we do plan to set more [facilities] around the country." Check out how to listen to and follow The Detail here . You can also stay up-to-date by liking us on Facebook or following us on Twitter .
RNZ News
3 days ago
- RNZ News
Wait times for autism assessments leave families stuck in limbo
Families in Auckland are turning to costly private assessments for their children as public wait times for autism diagnoses lengthen. After waiting several months for a public hospital appointment, a Chinese family paid $800 for a private autism assessment for their son. Rocky Xu became concerned in early 2023 when his three-year-old son, Lucas, remained nonverbal and showed signs of autism. The family's initial GP referral took four months, and Xu didn't receive a formal diagnosis through the public system for this son until August 2024 - 18 months after he first sought help. Xu's family is not alone. Between 2019 and 2021, Yuan Fang waited more than 15 months for a diagnosis for her seven-year-old son, Jining. The lengthy wait placed significant strain on the family. At the time, Fang was caring for a newborn alone while trying to manage Jining's increasingly difficult behaviour with little guidance or support. "There were times when Jining lost control and I had no choice but to call the police for help," she said. Jining also struggled at public school. Fang recalled her son often coming home hungry, his lunchbox either smeared with sunscreen or kicked aside by other children. "It was such a dark time, and every step forward felt difficult," she said. "My only hope came from what the social worker told me - that things would get better once he was diagnosed." Yuan Fang waited more than 15 months for a diagnosis for her seven-year-old son, Jining. Photo: RNZ / Yiting Lin A 2020 report compiled by Autism New Zealand found that the average wait time for an autism diagnosis through the public system was 10.9 months. However, Autism New Zealand chief executive Dane Dougan said the actual wait could stretch to three years for some children. "Autism involves a range of behaviours and can be difficult to diagnose," Dougan said. "There's also a lack of resources in the diagnostic system, and not enough trained professionals to meet the demand." In New Zealand, the process of diagnosing autism in children typically begins with a GP referral to a developmental or paediatric service. The referral is forwarded to a local District Health Board (now part of Health New Zealand), where the child is placed on a wait list for a multi-disciplinary assessment with professionals such as paediatricians, psychologists and speech-language therapists. Dougan described a formal diagnosis as the "key to unlocking the door" to support, noting that families could not access government services for an autistic child without it. Rachel Haggerty, funding/hospitals director at Health NZ, said the number of autism assessment referrals for children nationwide was high. "We know this is frustrating for parents and caregivers, and we are working hard to reduce the wait list for first specialist assessments," Haggerty said. "This includes establishing regional pediatric developmental project groups [that are] focused on helping ensure the children who require assessment can be seen, and on meeting the government's wait list target," she said. "We are also working with GPs in some regions to provide with specialist advice to enable them to manage their patients at this time." Xu relied on private intervention services for Lucas during their wait for an assessment, spending up to $2000 a week. The family eventually had to stop, as the cost became unsustainable. Autism New Zealand chief executive Dane Dougan Photo: Supplied Dougan said the situation had worsened in recent years, both in accessing a diagnosis and receiving support afterward. Families facing language or cultural barriers typically encountered even greater challenges. "There needs to be improvement and targeted support to ensure safe pathways for specific communities to navigate the process with resources that are culturally appropriate," he said. Yuchen Lin, a speech-language therapist and former member of the Ministry of Education's Learning Support team, said part of the delay stemmed from issues with GP referrals - a process that should be more transparent for families. "Some GPs lack a full understanding of how to write referrals and may have limited insight into the child's behaviour, which can lead to referrals being rejected or returned for more information," she said. She said many parents - especially Chinese families making a first-time referral - were unfamiliar with the process and unaware they could follow up with their GP, leaving them "waiting in limbo." Speech-language therapist Yuchen Lin Photo: Supplied Lin said some parents might dismiss their child's behaviour as part of adjusting to a new country or fear the stigma associated with an early diagnosis. She said such hesitation could delay early intervention - something that was critical to a child's development. "Early intervention can begin as early as age two or three, and plays a vital role in language, behaviour and overall development," she said. "It doesn't require a confirmed diagnosis and can happen alongside the assessment process." Xu experienced that hesitation firsthand with his son as the family struggled for a long time to accept reality. "I couldn't accept that he had autism," he recalled. "Even on the day we saw the specialist, I kept insisting it was just developmental delays or a language disorder. "But whether the diagnosis comes early or late doesn't change the outcome. The earlier you start preparing, the better." Lin also underscored the need for stronger translation services to ensure timely and accurate communication for non-English-speaking families. "Professional interpreters need to use clear, simple language with families and appropriate terminology with specialists," Lin said. "They are the bridge between the two." Yuan Fang's son, Jining, enjoys sailing in locations near Auckland. Photo: Supplied The Chinese Family Disability Support Group, which assists more than 300 Chinese families with autistic children in Auckland, said a growing number were turning to costly private assessments as public wait times stretched to 18-24 months. Many newly diagnosed families also relied on private services for support, struggling to navigate New Zealand's complex disability system. "Disability services here operate very differently from those in China," said Yoky Yao, the group's disability cultural advisor. "It takes time and experience to understand how the system works." "Many families miss out on support their children are eligible for," Yao said. "While some can afford private services, it's more beneficial in the long run to engage with the public system." Even when support was available, Fang said parents couldn't simply hand over responsibility to professionals - they needed to learn and work alongside them. Fang encouraged parents to prioritise their own wellbeing. "Caring for an autistic child is emotionally demanding and requires long-term commitment," she said. "To support your child over time, you need to stay strong - and that means taking care of yourself first."
