Gerry Adams awarded €100,000 in damages after suing BBC for libel
FORMER SINN FÉIN leader Gerry Adams has been awarded €100,000 in damages after winning his libel action against the BBC at the High Court in Dublin.
Mr Adams said that a BBC Spotlight programme, and an accompanying online story, defamed him by alleging he sanctioned the killing of former Sinn Féin official Denis Donaldson, for which he denies any involvement.
A jury at the High Court in Dublin found in his favour on Friday, after determining that was the meaning of words included in the programme and article.
It also found the BBC's actions were not in good faith and that it had not acted in a fair and reasonable way.
Adams said from his perspective, the case was about 'putting manners' on the BBC.
Mr Donaldson was shot dead in Co Donegal in 2006, months after admitting his role as a police and MI5 agent over 20 years.
In the programme broadcast in September 2016, an anonymous source given the pseudonym Martin claimed the shooting was sanctioned by the political and military leadership of the IRA and that Mr Adams gave 'the final say'.
In 2009, the dissident republican group the Real IRA claimed responsibility for the killing and a Garda investigation into the matter remains ongoing.
Speaking in Irish after the verdict, Mr Adams thanked his wife Collette and his family for standing by him throughout the trial.
Advertisement
He said he was mindful that Denis Donaldson's family had to 'watch all of this'.
Mr Adams called on Justice Minister Jim O'Callaghan to meet with Donaldson's family 'as quickly as possible'.
'There's an onus on both governments and everyone else, and I include myself in this, to try and deal with these legacy issues as best we can.'
The Journal
/ YouTube
'The highest public interest'
Adam Smyth, Director of the BBC in Northern Ireland, said the court accepted that the Spotlight broadcast and publication 'were of the highest public interest'.
'We didn't want to come to court, but it was important that we defend our journalism and we stand by that decision,' he said.
He said the implications of this case will be 'profound'.
'If the BBC's case cannot be won under existing Irish defamation law, it's hard to see how anyone's could.'
Jennifer O'Leary, a reporter who worked on the Spotlight broadcast, said she had 'nothing to hide, only sources to protect'.
She thanked witnesses who took the stand during the trial, including Ann Travers, whose sister Mary was murdered by the IRA in 1984.
O'Leary said she was thinking of the victims and survivors of the Troubles, who 'carry the burden of their grief and trauma with incredible dignity and courage'.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
‘People don't care that much': Frustrated sighs audible as students asked the ‘British or Irish' question
The students of Northern Ireland 's first integrated school, Lagan College in Belfast , visibly shudder when faced with a question about identity late in a conversation about the future they seek. 'How many of you would describe yourselves as Irish, and how many would describe yourselves as British?' they are asked. The sighs of frustration roll forward from the back of the P13 AS Government & Politics class. 'We get annoyed at the question because it's quite stereotypical. I would consider myself Irish, but I wouldn't exactly take issue with anybody else saying otherwise,' one student says. READ MORE 'Slowly over time, especially among our generation, it's becoming less of a problem. People don't care that much. It depends on your background, but most don't really care where you're from, don't really care what your identity is,' says another. Contrary to the image offered by this month's anti-immigration riots in Ballymena and elsewhere, the question, however, highlights changing attitudes among swathes of Northern Ireland's youth. For them, if not for everyone, identities of all kinds are fluid, important enough to be respected, or not important enough to fight over, even if many come from still-segregated communities. Facing often vicious opposition, Lagan was set up in September 1981 during some of the darkest days of the Troubles by Catholic and Protestant parents, who wanted their children to learn together. A total of 28 children came on the first day – 14 Catholic, 14 Protestant. Today, Lagan has grown to 1,460 pupils, with 200 new arrivals each year on a campus beside Gregagh Glen – one of 71 integrated schools in Northern Ireland. It's a warts-and-all approach, we don't stifle debate within the classroom. Everybody has an opinion, and they're all entitled to it, as long as they express it respectfully — Fergal McGuckin On a Tuesday afternoon, the P13 class and their teacher, Fergal McGuckin, interrupt class to talk about the lessons students have learned from going to Lagan, and their lives outside. Student Cillian Connolly has no doubts about the benefits. 'I have friends here from obviously Protestant backgrounds, from Catholic backgrounds, and Muslim backgrounds and everything else. 'In our group, no one would even know what you are, or care. I've been here for four years and I didn't even know if my mates were Protestant or Catholic half of the time,' he tells The Irish Times. Lagan College history teacher, Fergal McGuckin However, Northern Ireland's changing face is evident elsewhere, too, he asserts, citing the belief of friends in denominational schools who often, nevertheless, think that their own school is integrated. 'They'll say, 'There's loads of Catholics in our school.' So, they think it is integrated because of the numbers of other faiths, even though it isn't integrated, as such. That's kind of good, really, that they would think like that, it's unofficial integration.' Outside the classroom, however, students are still often badged by their first, or second names, or where they live: 'Sometimes, someone will say, 'Oh, you can just tell you're a Catholic,'' he says. Later generations will find the debate about integrated education puzzling, he believes. 'Our grandkids will look back and think, 'Wait, there were Catholic schools and Protestant schools? That's so odd.' Lagan College, Belfast, was set up in September 1981 during some of the darkest days of the Troubles. Photograph: Liam McBurney/PA Wire 'It's like us looking back and thinking that it was completely mad that there were separate toilets for black and white people in the United States. They'll think that it was all completely mad,' he says. Just eight per cent of Northern Ireland's students go to integrated schools, even though, depending on the poll, nearly 80 per cent of parents say that they want more such schools. 'However, none of the 8 per cent of places that we have were established by the government, or by government planning,' says Paul Caskey, chief executive of the Integrated Education Fund charity. The Irish language is studied by all first-year Lagan students. Dubbed 'enrichment Irish', it shows where it 'has come from and (explains) the significance it has, in place names, etc', says principal, Amanda McNamee. Sixteen years in post, principal of Lagan Colllege, Amanda McNamee. Photograph: Liam McBurney/PA Wire The numbers studying fall away in later years, she says: between six and 12 students take GCSE Irish examinations, while an A-Level option was dropped because it did not have enough demand. Students usually study three A-level subjects, so choices must narrow: 'And it is a difficult language, and I say that as an English teacher; it's not easy,' McNamee says. However, the first-year experience leaves its mark: 'The children love the songs, the cultural side. Some, though, find it difficult to pick up – from all different ability levels,' she says. Most of the P13 students are interested in some political issues, but have little interest in politicians – and very little, it has to be said, in the workings of the Stormont Assembly and Executive. Connolly's classmate, Francesca Keenan, voices an unhappiness shared by others: 'They're not really helping the majority of ordinary people. Even though they seem to have differing ideas of what should go on, they're really serving their own interests.' For the last 16 years, the English-accented Amanda McNamee, born in England to Irish parents, has led the school in a career honoured by an MBE from Queen Elizabeth, one that began in Omagh before the Real IRA bombing . [ End of segregation in Northern Ireland is a long way off, report finds Opens in new window ] Shortly after 3pm on August 15th, 1998, McNamee, then newly married, was preparing with her husband to pick up a new kitchen in a shop near the courthouse in the bustling Co Tyrone town. Nearing Omagh, she changed her mind: 'We'd been out the night before. I said to Adrian, 'Oh, we're tired and jaded. Let's go home,'' she says. A few minutes later, the bomb exploded, killing 29. Life's journey can be decided by a turn of the wheel. Today, McNamee's passion for the social value of integrated education, fuelled by her time in Drumragh Integrated College in Omagh, is evident. Lagan has a clear code based on the Christian principles of equality, service, reconciliation and respect, she says, 'where everyone is expected to be exposed to, and to respect, the beliefs of others'. Students gathered to consider the legacies of the queen and Pope Francis when they died 'because for many people in our school they were important parts of their lives' she says. 'If it's important to some of us, it needs to be respected by all of us, so it's not that someone can opt out of such an assembly because they don't recognise the queen, or the Pope – they can't,' she says. Years ago, Lagan students' uniforms marked them out, though such problems have faded. However, students coming from still-divided communities are often regarded locally as 'different'. 'Sometimes, you'll hear other people say things that you just haven't been exposed to here, because it's so normalised for me to be with people of other religions and stuff,' says one student. Coming to Lagan was 'like night and day' compared to elsewhere, another student says, 'the way people treat one another, attitudes to language and stuff, you get none of that hate'. Lagan's students are well versed in the Troubles throughout their school years, says McGuckin, right up to the end: 'So, they're probably sick of it by then. 'It's a warts-and-all approach, we don't stifle debate within the classroom. Everybody has an opinion, and they're all entitled to it, as long as they express it respectfully.' 'Students learn to be comfortable in their own skin, about being a nationalist or a unionist, or whatever.' The bonds made in Lagan last. 'Friendships made here endure. It's like a badge of honour,' he says.
Irish Independent
an hour ago
- Irish Independent
Eoin O'Malley: War is not a football match, so put those Palestinian flags away
Irish people have picked a side in the Gaza war but taking such partisan views can be a barrier to peace Today at 00:30 My flag is back in its drawer. A week after Limerick were put out of the hurling championship, I took it down. I was a bit surprised at how many people took joy in seeing us lose. But I didn't care.
Irish Independent
an hour ago
- Irish Independent
The Sunday Independent's View: Ireland can take Pride in progress on gay rights
The idea that the international community is waiting on the lead of a small island in the north Atlantic is easy to mock. Ireland was certainly unable to find many allies when leaders met in Brussels last Thursday to discuss the fate of EU-Israel economic ties in light of the Gaza war. The watered-down statement that eventually emerged deplored the 'catastrophic humanitarian situation' and called again for a ceasefire. But with hundreds of Palestinians now being killed as they seek aid, Taoiseach Micheál Martin lamented that more was not being done to put pressure on Benjamin Netanyahu's government. There is, however, one issue on which Ireland has undoubtedly led the way. When he took his place on O'Connell Street at the head of yesterday's Dublin Pride march, Micheál Martin did so as the leader of the first country in the world to legalise same-sex marriage by popular vote. The 2015 referendum was carried by 62pc of voters. Ten years on, the likelihood is that the Yes vote would be even more emphatic. Ireland is a far more progressive place to live than it has ever been Irish society in past decades was always more complex and diverse than the caricature of an oppressed Catholic theocracy that persists in popular myth. What is beyond question is that the country today, while by no means perfect, is a far more open and progressive place in which to live than it has ever been. Dublin's first Pride march in 1983 took place when homosexuality was still illegal. The numbers taking part could be counted in the dozens. Yesterday saw more than 12,000 participants and up to 100,000 people line the streets to show support. Other events were held around the country, including for the first time in Kilkenny, the last county to join the party. There is no downside to these changes. Whatever else is wrong with Ireland in 2025, a tolerance of who others chose to love is not one of them. ADVERTISEMENT These advances must not be taken for granted. In his message to Dublin Pride, President Michael D Higgins paid tribute to all who 'paved the way for progress when marching was not safe, who gave voice to truths that were long silenced and who set the foundations for the inclusive Ireland that we continue to strive towards today'. He urged parade-goers to remember them 'with gratitude'. There was a grim reminder this year that many countries have still not won such freedoms. The right-wing populist government led by Viktor Orban in Hungary, a fellow member of the European Union for more than two decades, passed legislation this year banning yesterday's Budapest Pride march and has even threatened to jail organisers and use facial recognition software to identify and fine marchers. That the right to peaceful assembly is under threat again in the heart of the EU is profoundly shocking. Pride marches are a threat to no one. Irish politicians can take justifiable pride, pun intended, in the part they played in moving this country beyond such ugly battles. If only they could put the same collective energy into solving more intractable challenges to inequality — such as housing, our crumbling infrastructure and health — there would be even more to celebrate.
