California man's 378-year sex abuse sentence dramatically overturned as judge rules migrant accuser made it up
Ajay Dev, 58, was released last week after spending 16 years in state prison for 76 convictions of sexual assault on a minor and related charges.
He had been convicted of the serial rape of an adopted daughter named Sapna Dev who he and his wife helped bring to the US from his home nation of Nepal in 1998, when she was 15-years-old.
Superior Court Judge Janene Beronio said in her ruling that the then-teen girl had broken up with her boyfriend and accused her adoptive father of causing their split.
Sapna then told authorities that he raped her two or three times a week for three or four years before she moved out of their home.
Four witnesses who had not been contacted by Dev's trial lawyers testified at a recent hearing that Sapna had told them that her accusations were lies or were motivated by her anger at him, The San Francisco Chronicle reported.
One of the witnesses said Sapna told him she made the accusations because she 'was determined to return to the United States and needed to use the criminal charges to do that,' Beronio said.
According to the Daily Democrat, Sapna had returned to Nepal at that time and was imprisoned there due to wrong information being printed on her passport. It was then she made the allegations and US authorities helped her with a new passport so she could return to the US.
Sapna was ultimately granted American citizenship in light of the case and her cooperation with prosecutors, according to CBS.
Critical evidence had been missed which stemmed from a phone call that cops had arranged between the two, the Chronicle reported.
The audio recording was not clear and the jury during Sapna's original testimony in the 2000s heard it as her father saying: 'You had sex with me when you were 18'.
Beronio said that an enhanced recording was now available which say he had actually told her: 'You came with me after you were 18'.
The judge also said that another witness had testified that Sapna had given contradictory statements when she said she had aborted or miscarried three kids after from alleged pregnancies.
Beronio said that Sapna had frequently sent her adopted parents cards, texts and email expressing her love for them from 1999 up until 2004.
She added: 'If jurors had heard that evidence, the result of this case could have and most likely would have been different.'
His lawyer Jennifer Mouzis had filed his habeas corpus petition seeking to have him freed in 2018.
Judge Beronio scheduled a hearing for June 13 for Yolo County District Attorney Jeff Reisig to decide whether to retry Dev. Prosecutors could also appeal the ruling.
Deputy District Attorney Adrienne Chin-Perez contended during a hearing last week that Ajay Dev continues to pose a flight risk and a danger to the community.
She also read a statement from Sapna, who wrote that she is 'deeply afraid that Ajay will harm me.'
The judge's decision 'dismantles the DA´s case,' said Patricia Pursell, a member of advocacy group that has held demonstrations in support of Dev, who is also his sister-in-law.
'We have known from the beginning that Ajay Dev was wrongfully convicted,' she told the Chronicle. 'Judge Beronio was the first judge to really look closely at the evidence and read every document.'
Pursell also told CBS that when he was arrested his oldest son was two and that his wife was pregnant with another child. He was in prison when the child was born.
In a statement to the court seen by the outlet, Ajay said: 'The absence of fatherhood has been the most difficult while doing time for a crime I never committed. You gave me a purpose to live. I cannot wait to be home with you.'
Mouzis said much of the prosecution's evidence was based on racial and ethnic bias that would be illegal today under California´s Racial Justice Act, a 2021 law barring testimony that appeals to prejudice.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Telegraph
21 minutes ago
- Telegraph
Paramount agrees to pay $16m to settle Trump's 60 Minutes lawsuit
Paramount Global, the parent company of CBS, has settled a lawsuit filed by Donald Trump which alleged election interference over an edited 60 Minutes interview with Kamala Harris. Paramount said it would pay $16 million to settle the suit with the money allocated to Mr Trump's future presidential library, and not paid to the US president 'directly or indirectly'. 'The settlement does not include a statement of apology or regret,' the company statement added. Mr Trump filed a $10-billion lawsuit against CBS in October, alleging the network deceptively edited an interview that aired on its 60 Minutes news program with then-vice president and presidential candidate Kamala Harris to 'tip the scales in favour of the Democratic Party' in the election. In an amended complaint filed in February, Mr Trump bumped his claim for damages to $20 billion. CBS aired two versions of the Harris interview in which she appeared to give different answers to the same question about the Israel-Hamas war, according to the lawsuit filed in federal court in Texas. CBS previously said the lawsuit was 'completely without merit' and had asked a judge to dismiss the case. Edward A Paltzik, a lawyer representing Mr Trump in the civil suit, could not be immediately reached for comment. A spokesperson for Paramount Chair Shari Redstone was similarly unavailable for comment. The case entered mediation in April. Mr Trump alleged CBS's editing of the interview violated the Texas Deceptive Trade Practices-Consumer Protection Act, which makes it illegal to use false, misleading or deceptive acts in commerce. The settlement comes as Paramount prepares for an $8.4-billion merger with Skydance Media, which will require approval from the US Federal Communications Commission. On the campaign trail last year, Mr Trump threatened to revoke CBS' broadcasting licence if elected. He has repeatedly lashed out against news publications, often casting unfavourable coverage as 'fake news', and has vowed to pursue more claims against media organisations. The Paramount settlement follows a decision by Walt Disney-owned ABC News to settle a defamation case brought by Mr Trump. As part of that settlement, which was made public on December 14, the network donated $15 million to Mr Trump's presidential library and publicly apologised for comments by anchor George Stephanopoulos, who inaccurately said Mr Trump had been found liable for rape. It also follows a second settlement, by Facebook and Instagram parent company Meta Platforms, which on January 29 said it had agreed to pay about $25 million to settle a lawsuit by Mr Trump over the company's suspension of his accounts after the January 6, 2021, attack at the US Capitol.
Daily Mail
27 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Famed criminology professor who taught Bryan Kohberger fears she may have 'inspired' Idaho murders and offers to study his 'dark side'
A professor who taught accused Idaho killer Bryan Kohberger criminology in college and took him inside the mind of serial killers fears she may have inspired him as she reveals she may like to study his 'dark side'. Dr. Katherine Ramsland, who has long been an expert in the field of serial killers and once wrote a book with the BTK strangler, taught four different undergraduate and graduate courses to Kohberger at DeSales University in Pennsylvania. Ahead of Kohberger's scheduled appearance in court on Wednesday when he's likely to plead guilty in exchange for life in prison and no death penalty as part of a plea deal, Ramsland is finally speaking out on her pupil. Ramsland - who called Kohberger 'a promising student who could have made a mark' on the field of forensic psychology - refused to believe he could be capable of killing, even after his arrest. But as she investigated the case more, Ramsland began to believe he may be responsible and was forced to ask herself a tough question. 'I have to look at the framework of what I taught and wonder: Did I inspire him?' she said. Ramsland continues her studies and teaching students, but accepts she must avoid the possibility the influence of his education, explaining 'unfortunately, in this field, that's what we live with.' She admits that given her research into the minds of the most vile of people, she knows a rare few of her students may turn out this way. 'We know that there's always a risk that we're attracting somebody that's going to do something terrible,' she revealed. 'I know, everyone in this field know that we could have students who might become offenders but we also know the vast majority of our students will not and will go into a field like law enforcement that will make the world better,' she added. Despite her disgust, Ramsland - who wrote the literal book on BTK killer, Confession of a Serial Killer: The Untold Story of Dennis Rader, the BTK Killer - admits she's interested in potentially studying Kohberger to help better understand how he got away with it. 'This is my work. If he wanted to do that, I would,' she said, adding that the study would be to try and learn 'developmental trajectories' and 'red flags' so killers can be sussed out faster. 'If he wanted to do that, I know that he's got the intellectual capacity to do it, to be self-reflective. I would definitely do it if he were willing. It would be hard but I think because I have so much material for him, I have questions for him that I think nobody but me could ask.' Ramsland, who taught Kohberger courses ranging from an intro to forensic psychology to one titled 'Dangerous Minds: the psychology of anti-social behavior,' at first was skeptical her former student could be capable of such heinous acts. 'I really thought Bryan was a promising student who really could have made a mark in this career in a very positive way,' she said. She added that 'he was polite, he was respectful, intense and curious. There was no reason for me to think that he was anyone other than someone interested in this potential career.' 'His demeanor was that he was confident that he was going to prove his innocence,' she told NewsNation. 'I wanted to give him the benefit of the doubt.' However, in March, when Kohberger revealed his excuse was that he was being framed by a real killer who planted evidence at the scene of the crime, Ramsland began to consider he could in fact be the right suspect. 'When he said his alibi - and it was clearly not an alibi and he would've known that through his classes and undergraduate work - that was when I was floored that this is my student who has done these things.' Kohberger's willingness to admit to these crimes in accepting the plea deal has left his ex-advisor Ramsland stunned, despite all her years working in this field. The professor expressed sympathy for the families of Kohberger's four victims. 'I'm disappointed, angry and shocked that this is who he turned out to be and horrified for the victims and their families. Kohberger, 30, was due to face a capital murder trial in August for the deaths of Kaylee Goncalves, 21; her best friend Madison Mogen, 21; as well as their housemate Xana Kernodle, 20; and her boyfriend Ethan Chapin, 20, in November 2022. But it was revealed on Monday that Latah County prosecutors have offered the former criminology graduate student a deal in which he would plead guilty to the murders and a burglary charge, in exchange for a sentence of life in prison without the possibility of parole. Kohberger is now expected to appear in court on Wednesday to have the deal signed off by a judge. The family of Kaylee Goncalves was quick to condemn the agreement, declaring on Facebook that the State of Idaho 'failed us' as they hit out at prosecutors for failing to notify them that a plea deal was going through. 'We weren't even called about the plea; we received an email with a letter attached,' family members said in a statement. 'That's how Latah County's Prosecutor's Office treats murder victims' families. 'Adding insult to injury, they're rushing the plea, giving families just one day to coordinate and appear at the courthouse for a plea on July 2.' Steven Goncalves, Kaylee's father, is urging the judge overseeing the case to reject the plea deal. 'If anyone knows Judge [Steven] Hippler... reach out to him and ask him to put his foot down and not accept this offer,' the grieving father begged members of NewsNation's Ashleigh Banfield's audience Monday night. 'This is not justice,' he continued, declaring that it goes against what the victims' families want. 'This isn't the will of the victims' [families]. This is just one person making a decision, and it doesn't reflect what we're calling for,' Goncalves said of Latah County Prosecutor Bill Thompson, whom he claimed, 'decided to play God and decide what this man's decision should be and not a jury, not his peers.' He then called for 'no plea deal,' saying, 'Let's go for this guy 100 percent. Let's do it,' as he argued that Thompson didn't 'have the courage to hold [Kohberger] accountable.' The route allegedly driven Bryan Kohberger allegedly drove on the night of the brutal Idaho murders, based on cellphone data Kaylee's sister, Aubrie, also called the last-minute plea deal 'shocking and cruel,' saying it 'feels less like an act of justice and more like an afterthought.' The family explained that they met with prosecutors on Friday, when the attorneys 'vaguely mentioned a possible plea.' They claim prosecutors then moved forward with the deal without seeking any input from the victims' families and presented the arrangement on Sunday. At that point, the victims' families received an email from prosecutors explaining why they decided to stop pursuing the death penalty against their wishes. 'We cannot fathom the toll that this case has taken on your family,' the letter, seen by the Idaho Statesman, reads. 'This resolution is our sincere attempt to seek justice for your family,' prosecutors continued, noting that they, 'weighed the right path forward and made a formal offer' to the murder suspect, according to ABC News. 'This agreement ensures that the defendant will be convicted, will spend the rest of his life in prison, and will not be able to put you and the other families through the uncertainty of decades of post-conviction, appeals. 'Your viewpoints weighed heavily in our decision-making process, and we hope that you may come to appreciate why we believe this resolution is in the best interest of justice.' It was signed by Thompson and his deputy Ashley Jennings, and noted that Kohberger would be sentenced to life in prison in late July should he accept the plea deal on Wednesday. But if he does not plead as expected, the scheduled trial will continue as planned. After receiving the letter, the Goncalves family said they were left 'scrambling'. 'We immediately jumped into panic mode and started making phone calls and sending emails,' they said in a statement. 'We met with prosecution today to reiterate our views on pushing for the death penalty. 'Unfortunately all of our efforts did not matter,' the family lamented, claiming they had been 'branded adversaries' after they questioned the police investigation into the students' stabbing deaths. 'The Latah County Prosecutor's Office's treatment of our family during this process is something I wouldn't wish on anyone,' the Goncalves family concluded, arguing that county residents 'should be ashamed of its Prosecutor's Office'. 'After more than two years, this is how it concludes, with a secretive deal and a hurried effort to close the case without any input from the victims' families on the pleas details,' they wrote. 'Our family is frustrated right now and that will subside and we will come together as always and deal with the reality that we face moving forward.' The Goncalves family was not the only one upset by the news of the plea deal, however, as Xana Kernodle's aunt was reportedly so enraged that she was brought to tears. Kim Kernodle explained to TMZ that prosecutors told her Kohberger's defense team approached them with a plea deal and prosecutors agreed to go along with it to 'spare the families' the pain of a trial. She claimed the prosecutors were especially concerned that the families would have to see gruesome crime scene photos of their loved ones - though Kernodle said, 'We know the graphics. They were not trying to spare us.' Kernodle also claimed that prosecutors did not mention they were taking death penalty off the table when they met on Friday, when she said prosecutors acknowledged they have enough evidence to secure a guilty verdict. The State has previously laid out how Kohberger purchased a balaclava from Dick's Sporting Goods store months before the savage murders inside the victims' off-campus home. Surviving housemate Dylan Mortensen later told police she saw a man wearing 'the same kind of mask' during the crime spree. She also described seeing a man with 'bushy eyebrows' - which fit Kohberger's appearance. The murder suspect also bought a Ka-Bar knife, sheath and sharpener from Amazon back in March 2022, according to a prosecution filing, and was ultimately linked to the murder of the four students by DNA found on the sheath of a knife found at the scene of their off-campus home. Data from Kohberger's cellphone also showed it connected to a cellphone tower near the victims' off-campus house a total of 23 times over the course of four months leading up to the grisly murders, according to court documents. Then, on the night of the November 13, 2022, prosecutors say Kohberger broke into the University of Idaho students' home on King Road shortly after they had gone to bed from a night of partying and stabbed them all to death. His white Hyundai Elantra was allegedly caught on a neighbor's home security footage at around 3.30am, and was seen circling around the block multiple times over the next half hour. By 4.07am, the vehicle came back drove by once again - then didn't come back into view until 4.20am, when it was seen speeding off. During that 13-minute window, sources close to the investigation told NBC's Dateline that Kohberger went directly upstairs to Mogen's bedroom, where he allegedly killed her and Goncalves. He is accused of the turning his attention to Kernodle on his way back out the house, killing her as she was up ordering food, and then targeting her boyfriend, Chapin, whom Kohberger allegedly 'carved'. Meanwhile, data from Kohberger's phone indicate he turned it off before 3am that morning, and when he apparently turned it back on at around 4.48am, it connected with a cellphone tower south of Moscow. But the phone also appeared to be briefly back in the city shortly after 9am, when Kohberger reportedly returned to his apartment in Pullman, Washington, where he took a chilling selfie, giving the thumbs up pose in a bathroom mirror. In the aftermath, Kohberger allegedly searched to buy a replacement knife and sheath. He was ultimately arrested nearly six weeks after the students were found dead at his parents' home in Albrightsville, Pennsylvania where he had returned for the holidays. Kohberger has remained behind bars ever since, and has been desperately trying to get the death penalty off the table over the past few months - even arguing at one point that his autism diagnosis precludes him from facing the ultimate punishment. In more recent efforts, Kohberger's defense attorneys tried to get his purchase of the balaclava deemed inadmissible to the upcoming trial, but prosecutors argued it was crucial to their case. It now appears that the defense moved to reach a plea deal after Judge Hippler slapped down their efforts to point the finger at four alternate suspects - blasting his legal team's evidence as 'entirely irrelevant' and 'wild speculation.' 'Nothing links these individuals to the homicides or otherwise gives rise to reasonable inference that they committed the crime; indeed, it would take nothing short of rank speculation by the jury to make such a finding,' the judge wrote in his decision last week. Just hours before news of the plea deal broke, the defense faced another setback after they apparently called the wrong witness and other witnesses expressed their bewilderment at being called at all.
The Guardian
27 minutes ago
- The Guardian
Paramount settles with Trump for $16m over ‘60 Minutes' Kamala Harris interview
CBS parent company Paramount on Wednesday settled a lawsuit filed by Donald Trump over an interview broadcast in October, in the latest concession by a media company to the US president, who has targeted outlets over what he describes as false or misleading coverage. Paramount said it would pay $16m to settle the suit with the money allocated to Trump's future presidential library, and not paid to Trump 'directly or indirectly'. 'The settlement does not include a statement of apology or regret,' the company statement added. Trump filed a $10bn lawsuit against CBS in October, alleging the network deceptively edited an interview that aired on its 60 Minutes news program with then-vice-president and presidential candidate Kamala Harris to 'tip the scales in favor of the Democratic party' in the election. In an amended complaint filed in February, Trump increased his claim for damages to $20bn. CBS aired two versions of the Harris interview in which she appears to give different answers to the same question about the Israel-Hamas war, according to the lawsuit filed in a federal court in Texas. CBS previously said the lawsuit was 'completely without merit' and had asked a judge to dismiss the case. The White House did not immediately respond to a Reuters request for comment. Edward A Paltzik, a lawyer representing Trump in the civil suit, could not be immediately reached for comment. Paramount said it also agreed that 60 Minutes would release transcripts of interviews with future US presidential candidates after they aired, subject to redactions as required for legal or national security concerns. A spokesperson for Paramount Chair Shari Redstone was unavailable for comment. The case entered mediation in April. Trump alleged CBS's editing of the interview violated the Texas Deceptive Trade Practices-Consumer Protection Act, which makes it illegal to use false, misleading or deceptive acts in commerce. The settlement comes as Paramount prepares for an $8.4bn merger with Skydance Media, which will require approval from the US Federal Communications Commission. On the campaign trail last year, Trump threatened to revoke CBS's broadcasting licence if elected. He has repeatedly lashed out against the news media, often casting unfavourable coverage as 'fake news'. The Paramount settlement follows a decision by Walt Disney-owned ABC News to settle a defamation case brought by Trump. As part of that settlement, which was made public on 14 December, the network donated $15m to Trump's presidential library and publicly apologised for comments by anchor George Stephanopoulos, who inaccurately said Trump had been found liable for rape. It also follows a second settlement by Facebook and Instagram parent company Meta Platforms, which on 29 January said it had agreed to pay about $25m to settle a lawsuit by Trump over the company's suspension of his accounts after the 6 January 2021 attack at the US Capitol. Trump has vowed to pursue more claims against the media.
