Govt employees, pensioners reject budget as 'cruel joke'
Various employee and pensioner associations, including the All Pakistan Clerks Association (APCA), All Government Employees Grand Alliance (AGEGA), Railway Workers Union, Punjab Teachers Union, Educators Association, and Railway Pensioners Association, have outright rejected the new federal budget, labelling it a "traditional charade of words." They warn that the budget will lead to a stormy increase in inflation, pushing 50% of families below the poverty line.
Leaders condemned the mere 10% increase in salaries as "insignificant and shameful," predicting a rise in suicides and starvation. They asserted that pension reforms have effectively "buried alive" pensioner families.
Shehzad Manzoor Kiyani, Central Vice President of APCA, and Divisional President Chaudhry Mubashir stated that the budget is a "severe joke" on government employees. They highlighted the stark contrast with the significant salary increases for Members of Assemblies and ministers, while employees are being "buried alive." The elimination of ministries, divisions, institutions, and 40,000 posts will devastate the lower-income segments.
Muhammad Shafiq Bhalwalia, Central Secretary General of the Education Pensioners Association, called the minimal salary increase for teachers, employees, and pensioners amidst soaring inflation "ridiculous." He pointed out that ministers, assembly members, senators, advisors, the Senate Chairman, and Speakers of Assemblies have seen a gradual 650% increase in their salaries before the budget. He argued that a comparison between the 2024-2025 budget records and the unchecked increase in privileges and salaries for the ruling class proves that this budget is pro-rulers but certainly not pro-employees or pensioners. He added that pension reforms are destroying the future of employees, pushing them into the abyss of poverty.
Mubarak Hussain, Central Secretary General of the Railway Workers Union, stated that the budget was designed to benefit the government's cronies, with the business and trading class reaping all the advantages from tax reductions. He accused the government of favouring its political and business fraternity, calling the 10% salary increase a "scrap allowance" and the 7% pension increase a "mockery," akin to giving poison to pensioners.
He claimed that the government extracts Rs600 billion in taxes from employees without providing any benefit, while those paying Rs8 billion in taxes enjoy benefits throughout the year. He demanded an abolition of salary tax for employees earning Rs600,000 to Rs1.2 million, and that the tax collection from those in grades 17 to 22 should be only 10%. He noted that no tax has been imposed on the salaries of Members of Parliament, Senators, and National Assembly members, suggesting a 25% tax should be levied on them.
Rana Liaquat and Basharat Iqbal Raja, leaders of the Punjab Teachers Union and Educators Association, asserted that the government has treated state institutions like a "widow" and employees as "widowers," leading to a complete loss of trust in the current administration.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Express Tribune
16 hours ago
- Express Tribune
11,000 taxpayers sent 'nudging' notices
FBR has served 'nudging' notices to nearly 11,000 companies and individuals, advising them to fix anomalies in their last sales tax returns Listen to article The Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) has served 'nudging' notices to nearly 11,000 companies and individuals, advising them to fix anomalies in their last sales tax returns or be ready for consequences such as penalties, freezing of bank accounts, and sealing of businesses. The notices were issued last month in the middle of negotiations between the business community and the government, underscoring the authorities' resolve to recover due sales and income taxes from individuals and companies. FBR Chairman Rashid Langrial believes that existing taxpayers are paying far less than their due taxes. He has begun applying a risk management system to identify loopholes in the tax returns filed by these entities and individuals over the past five years. Sources said that in the first phase, about 11,000 nudging notices were served by corporate tax offices in Karachi, Lahore, and Islamabad. Traders in Karachi and Lahore also observed a strike last month against the government's decision to give arrest powers to the FBR and add back half of over Rs200,000 in cash expenses in income tax calculations. When contacted, the FBR said these "non-intrusive and legally non-binding nudging notices" were served to encourage behavioural and social changes among taxpayers. "Please correct anomalies in your sales tax return. Your failure to act will be viewed as a choice not to comply," cautioned the FBR in its notices to companies and individuals in Lahore. The FBR warned that failure to address anomalies and file accurate returns in the future could lead to financial penalties, placement of FBR staff within businesses for monitoring, and best judgment assessments by tax commissioners, which can result in heavy fines. It also advised thousands of people that their bank accounts could be frozen and business premises sealed for non-compliance. Taxpayers were informed that the FBR used advanced data analytics to examine returns and benchmark them against peer businesses and jurisdictions. The analysis was fully automated without human involvement. The FBR said that for the tax years 2019 to 2024, its system identified anomalies in 2024 returns. These included unusually high sales claimed as exempt or under reduced-rate categories and low value addition based on the comparison of sales to purchases. "To avoid enforcement actions, ensure that these anomalies do not reoccur in subsequent returns and file correct sales tax returns for the upcoming due periods," the FBR cautioned. Jawed Bilwani, President of the Karachi Chamber of Commerce and Industry (KCCI), criticised the FBR's decision to serve notices during ongoing talks. He said many KCCI members received notices without any prior awareness campaign. Bilwani also criticised the FBR's method of comparing one shop's sales patterns with competitors', arguing that sales and value addition depend on brand and quality and are not uniform. "A customer may buy a shoe for Rs100 or Rs1,000. The FBR has no right to treat both values the same," he said. The FBR, however, claimed that nudging notices helped increase the number of returns filed in July. A final analysis will be made after the extended filing deadline ends on August 4. In another type of nudging notice, the FBR warned that reduced-rate sales were unusually high relative to domestic sales, with many sales claimed as exempt or under reduced-rate categories instead of taxable. "Your reported output tax is significantly lower than expected for businesses in your sector and location," the notice stated. However, the business community argued it is unjustified to compare similar businesses without accounting for differences in efficiency, cost structures, and management. The FBR also flagged excessive refund requests stemming from high input tax claims and an unusually high number of credit and debit notes. "Please correct anomalies in your sales tax return to avoid strict enforcement actions," stated another notice. The FBR added that enforcement actions, such as posting inspectors at business sites, particularly in cement factories, have significantly improved collections despite low sales. The FBR chairman has also transferred over 250 tax officers from grades 17 to 22 as part of a strategy to place only A and B category officers, as classified by various agencies, in key field positions.
Express Tribune
18 hours ago
- Express Tribune
Wheat cultivators to protest across Punjab
The Kissan Ittehad and the Sindh Abadgar Alliance have announced a protest movement across Punjab starting from August 11 due to the government's "failure" to fix the official wheat support price. "On August 11, a symbolic funeral for agriculture will be held outside the DC office in Kasur, and a protest will be held outside the Hyderabad Press Club on August 20," Kissan Ittehad Chairman Khalid Hussain Batth said on Saturday at a press conference at the Karachi Press Club. Sindh Abadgar Alliance President Zubair Talpur was also present on the occasion. Batth said protests would take place across all provinces, followed by a march toward Islamabad. "This time, we will protest before the wheat cultivation season begins," he said, clarifying that this movement has no affiliation with any political party. He added that over the past two years, the cost of wheat cultivation has been Rs4,000 per 40kg, while the government purchased wheat from them at only Rs2,200. "We are ready for a forensic audit," he said. "The government demands up to 45% in taxes but how can we pay taxes when we are not even making a profit?" He said if the government does not set a wheat support price before sowing begins, they will initiate talks with the prime minister and chief ministers. If there is still no decision, province-wide protests will be launched in Punjab on August 11 and in Sindh on August 20. "The government has failed to fix wheat prices for the last two years," he noted.
Express Tribune
18 hours ago
- Express Tribune
Govt urged to urgently decide PSM's fate
Steam rolls off a slab of steel as it rolls down the line at the Novolipetsk Steel PAO steel mill in Farrell, Pennsylvania, US. PHOTO: REUTERS Members of a Senate panel have urged the government to expedite its decision on the future of the Pakistan Steel Mills (PSM), which has been non-functional for years. The Senate Standing Committee on Industries and Production visited the PSM on Saturday under the chairmanship of Senator Aon Abbas Buppi. The committee toured various plants within the PSM and reviewed the organization's current debt challenges, payment delays and expenditures, and listened to the concerns of employee unions. They held discussions with PSM Chairman Asad Islam Mahni and other officials on major issues facing the PSM. During a briefing, Mahni informed the committee that by 2024, the mill had accumulated a total loss of Rs600 billion and was paying Rs20 billion annually in interest on current loans. He said the mills owes Rs89 billion to the National Bank of Pakistan (NBP) as most of the loans from the NBP have been used to cover expenses, including salaries for 934 current employees. The officials told the committee that the government is simultaneously considering two projects: One involves the revival of the mill using Russian firm Industrial Engineering LLC, which would utilize arc and blast furnaces for restoration. The other project considers winding down the mill after appointing a review firm to evaluate its viability. The committee also met with representatives of the workers' union, who apprised them of the hardships faced by both current and laid-off employees. To address their concerns, the committee formed a subcommittee tasked with holding talks with management over workers' complaints. The Senate committee appreciated the current management's efforts to reduce PSM's expenditures. However, it expressed anger over the continued incidents of theft within the organization and instructed authorities to assess the losses incurred from such activities. It also recommended accelerating the disposal of non-functional or expired assets that are no longer operational. The committee was briefed on the arbitrary allotment of PSM land by the Sindh government a few years ago. It expressed concern over the allotment of 1,370 acres and 400 acres of undisputed land to local villages, stating that such allotment cases should be referred to the Council of Common Interests (CCI). The committee toured various plants within Pakistan Steel Mills and recommended that the government expedite its decision on the future of the institution.
