‘Poppycock': Prosecutors contest claim from Kouri Richins of problems in detective's testimony
"This strategy holds no place in this serious proceeding or our profession," Summit County chief prosecutor Brad Bloodworth said in a response filed Monday.
Richins was arrested in 2023 and later charged with murder in the 2022 death of her husband, Eric Richins, who was 39. During the year between his death and her arrest, Kouri Richins published a children's book about grief.
Last week, attorneys for the Kamas woman asked the court to reopen the opportunity for testimony about what evidence should be presented at trial — including cellphone and electronic data — claiming there were problems with a state's witness testimony at a recent hearing.
Defense attorney Wendy Lewis said in the motion she would like to question at least four additional witnesses before she submits written briefs addressing the motions that were being considered when detective Jeff O'Driscoll and others testified.
The short motion asking to reopen questioning did not elaborate on what the problem was but cited Giglio — a U.S. Supreme Court case that established prosecutors are obligated to disclose evidence that could impact a witness's credibility.
Prosecutors opposed Lewis' request on Monday, saying the detective testified truthfully, and objected to Lewis publicly bringing into question the detective's character without citing any facts. "Defense counsel's feelings do not matter. Objective facts matter," the response says, adding that the facts show all detectives had testified truthfully.
Bloodworth did, however, cite a discrepancy between O'Driscoll's recollection and a second officer's recollection in preparation for the hearing, which the prosecution had outside attorneys investigate. Bloodworth's legal filing said they told Richins' attorneys about this discrepancy on Jan. 31 and provided them a report from the outside attorney on Feb. 6. The report, he said, found no evidence that the recollections were inappropriate or that either detective was not truthful.
The objection said Richins' attorneys filed their request on that same day without talking to prosecutors. In a conversation the day after, the document said Richins' attorney told prosecutors they feel O'Driscoll testified untruthfully, specifically when he testified that he did not think he knew Richins was represented by an attorney when he went to her home and spoke with her for multiple hours.
According to Bloodworth's legal filing, Richins' attorney also cited that O'Driscoll was prepared for questions from prosecutors but would respond that he "did not recall" to many of the questions from Richins' attorneys.
"It's shocking that detective O'Driscoll testified well to the state's questioning after the state exhaustively prepared him to testify, and equally shocking that he could not recall insignificant-at-the-time details about events that occurred nearly two years earlier in response to the defense's questioning. Poppycock," Bloodworth's opposition says.
Bloodworth said calling this disclosure of a potential conflict from prosecutors "potential Giglio information" was "inaccurate and irresponsible."
He said prosecutors had told attorneys they would be fine reopening evidence if it was deemed appropriate after the outside attorney presented findings. He also claimed Richins' attorneys did not talk to prosecutors before filing the motion only because they wanted to publicly bring doubt to testimony from the lead detective on Richins' case.
Bloodworth asked the judge to deny the motion, allowing the process to decide what evidence should be shown at trial to move forward.
For her part, Lewis asked for a hearing as soon as possible to address her motion, but the court has not yet scheduled a hearing.
The next hearing in Richins' case is scheduled for Feb. 21, and attorneys plan at that hearing to go over questionnaires that will be sent to potential jurors for her murder trial scheduled in April.
Richins is accused of administering a fatal dose of fentanyl to Eric Richins in March 2022 and has also been charged with giving a lethal dose of drugs to her husband on Valentine's Day a few weeks earlier.
The jury during Richins' upcoming trial will be asked to determine whether she is guilty of charges of aggravated murder and attempted murder, first-degree felonies; two counts of filing a fraudulent insurance claim, a second-degree felony; and one count of forgery, a third-degree felony.
Richins is also charged with two counts of mortgage fraud, a second-degree felony, and two additional counts of forgery, a third-degree felony. Those charges will be addressed in a separate trial.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


USA Today
2 days ago
- USA Today
What to know on Trump, Ghislaine Maxwell, and Jeffrey Epstein files: The latest
The Justice Department talked to Jeffrey Epstein's ex-girlfriend, convicted sex trafficker Ghislaine Maxwell, after weeks of bubbling outrage over a memo that appeared to close the Epstein case. Over two days, Justice Department officials questioned Jeffrey Epstein's ex-girlfriend, convicted sex trafficker Ghislaine Maxwell, as the White House continues to battle calls for more transparency over what Epstein did and who else may have been involved. It's unclear what came out of the interview, but Maxwell's lawyer David Markus said his client answered all of the government's questions, which covered about 100 people. "She answered questions about everybody and she didn't hold anything back," Markus said, without specifying who was mentioned. The Justice Department didn't immediately respond to a request for comment on what came out of the interview. The talks follow more than two weeks of bubbling outrage from members of President Donald Trump's base over the department's announcement in early July that it won't release its files on Epstein. DOJ said a systematic review of the files didn't turn up any list of clients involved in Epstein's crimes. Even some congressional Republicans have clamored for the files' release or introduced legislation to try to force the Trump administration's hand. Republican leadership has so far blocked the legislation and White House officials continue to resist those calls. Still, Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche has suggested that Maxwell could reveal new details about Epstein's circle and crimes. Here is all the latest on the fallout: July 25: Maxwell lawyer signals desire for pardon Maxwell was convicted in 2021 of trafficking a minor to Epstein for sexual abuse, and for conspiring to entice and transport minors for illegal sex acts. She is currently serving a 20-year prison sentence, and has an appeal pending at the U.S. Supreme Court. Markus indicated July 25 that his client could ask for a pardon soon, following the two days she spent talking to Justice Department officials July 24-25. "We haven't spoken to the president or anybody about a pardon just yet," he said. "The president this morning said he had the power to do so. We hope he exercises that power in the right and just way." Trump has the power to pardon Maxwell fully as well as to commute her prison sentence. But to many, that might look more like reducing than enhancing accountability – especially if Maxwell offers little in return. In the morning on July 25, Trump said he hasn't thought about pardoning Maxwell, but also didn't rule it out. "I'm allowed to do it, but it's something I have not thought about," Trump said. "I certainly can't talk about pardons now." July 25: 16% of voters in poll approve of Trump administration on Epstein Only 16% of of voters who responded to a poll released July 25 by Emerson College Polling approved of the Trump administration's handling of the Epstein files. Fifty-one percent disapproved, while 33% were neutral. The poll surveyed 1,400 U.S. voters from July 21-22. Its margin of error is ±2.5 points, according to the polling organization. July 23: Florida judge shields Epstein grand jury testimony In addition to approaching Maxwell, the Justice Department asked federal judges in Florida and New York to unseal transcripts of testimony before grand juries investigating Epstein and Maxwell. If judges allow for the transcripts' release, the department said it will first redact both victim-related information and personal identifying information from the transcripts. On July 23, federal Judge Judge Robin L. Rosenberg rejected the request in Florida, writing that she doesn't have the power to order the records' release because of a past ruling from an appeals court that presides over her trial court. Judges in New York haven't yet ruled on the administration's requests there. July 23: Reports emerge that AG Bondi told Trump in May he is named in Epstein files Attorney General Pam Bondi told Trump in May that he was named multiple times in the government's files on Jeffrey Epstein, according to reports from the Wall Street Journal and CNN. A White House official did not dispute that Trump's name is mentioned in the Epstein files, telling USA TODAY that briefing binders Bondi prepared for MAGA influencers in February included the president's name. But the official rejected any suggestion that Trump engaged in wrongdoing in connection with Epstein. Being named doesn't mean the person did anything criminal. July 22: House Speaker Mike Johnson starts summer recess early to avoid Epstein House Speaker Mike Johnson, R-Louisiana, announced on July 22 he is shutting down the House for its summer recess early to avoid a vote on releasing the Epstein files. Johnson said there was "no daylight" between the Trump administration and the House, and the White House needed "space" to address the issue. Members of Congress were scheduled to leave Washington for several weeks starting July 24, but Johnson said he would cut the schedule short and end with votes on July 23. Johnson took that step after Rep. Thomas Massie, R-Kentucky, and Rep. Lauren Boebert, R-Colorado, co-sponsored legislation calling for the release of the government's Epstein records. July 22: New footage shows Epstein at Trump wedding Archived video footage and photos revealed by CNN July 22 showed Jeffrey Epstein attended Trump's wedding to Marla Maples at the Plaza Hotel in 1993. Maples is the second of Trump's three wives. The couple divorced in 1999. "You've got to be kidding me," Trump told CNN when asked about the wedding photos on a phone call. He called the outlet "fake news" and hung up. White House Communications Director Steven Cheung said the images were "out-of-context frame grabs of innocuous videos and pictures of widely attended events to disgustingly infer something nefarious." July 22: House committee agrees to seek Maxwell testimony The House Oversight and Government Reform Committee agreed on July 22 to subpoena Ghislaine Maxwell to testify. Rep. Tim Burchett, R-Tennessee, said he pressed for the subpoena in order to learn more about Epstein's criminal conduct. 'This deposition will help the American people understand how Jeffrey Epstein was able to carry out his evil actions for so long without being brought to justice,' Burchett said. July 18: Trump sues Wall Street Journal over lewd Epstein birthday letter On July 17, the Wall Street Journal reported that Trump sent Epstein a lewd birthday letter for his 50th birthday, which took place in early 2003. Trump called the letter a "FAKE" on social media July 17 and sued the newspaper's publisher for libel on July 18. The letter contains typewritten dialogue between "Donald" and "Jeffrey," and at a later point "Trump." In the dialogue, "Donald" says, "We have certain things in common, Jeffrey" and that, "Enigmas never age, have you noticed that?" The dialogue ends with "Trump" saying, "A pal is a wonderful thing. Happy Birthday – and may every day be another wonderful secret." The dialogue is encased within a seemingly hand-drawn outline of a naked woman, the Journal reported. The letter includes a pair of arcs denoting the woman's breasts, and a "Donald" squiggly signature mimicking pubic hair. USA TODAY could not verify the details or origin of the letter. Contributing: Joey Garrison, Bart Jansen, Melina Khan, Savannah Kuchar, Christopher Cann - USA TODAY

Epoch Times
2 days ago
- Epoch Times
Trump Says SCOTUS Immunity Ruling Likely Helps Obama Following DNI Disclosures
President Donald Trump on Friday said that former President Barack Obama likely has immunity following a U.S. Supreme Court ruling in light of a report that was declassified by Director of National Intelligence (DNI) Tulsi Gabbard earlier this month. Gabbard said the documents showed that Obama and his then-Cabinet members 'manufactured and politicized intelligence to lay the groundwork for what was essentially a years-long coup against President Trump,' which Obama denied in a statement earlier this week. Gabbard said in a Sunday interview that she referred some Obama-era officials for criminal prosecution to the Department of Justice (DOJ) and the FBI.


USA Today
3 days ago
- USA Today
After accusing Obama of treason, Trump now says the former president 'owes me big'
Donald Trump has been intensely focused on Barack Obama in recent days, accusing his Democratic predecessor of "treason." Now the current president is saying the former president "owes" him. "He owes me, Obama owes me big," Trump said July 25 while speaking to reporters outside the White House before departing on a trip to Scotland. Obama's debt to Trump in the current president's mind? The fact that the U.S. Supreme Court ruled last year that presidents have immunity from criminal prosecution for official acts in office. The ruling came in a case involving Trump's alleged efforts to overturn the 2020 election results. Struggling to shake off questions about his administration's handling of the Jeffrey Epstein case, Trump has focused lately on leveling allegations against Obama. National Intelligence Director Tulsi Gabbard alleged in a press briefing that the Obama administration promoted a 'contrived narrative' that Russia interfered in the 2016 election to help Trump. Gabbard released declassified documents she said support her claims of Obama's "treasonous conspiracy" to undermine Trump. The Justice Department also announced the formation of a 'Strike Force' that would 'investigate potential next legal steps' stemming from Gabbard's disclosures. Russia attempted to interfere in the 2016 presidential election in favor of Trump, according to former Special Counsel Robert Mueller's 2019 final report and a 2020 bipartisan Senate Intelligence Committee assessment. Obama's office pointed to the Senate report in responding to Gabbard's claims. 'Nothing in the document issued last week undercuts the widely accepted conclusion that Russia worked to influence the 2016 presidential election but did not successfully manipulate any votes," Obama's office said in a statement on July 22. 'These findings were affirmed in a 2020 report by the bipartisan Senate Intelligence Committee, led by then-Chairman Marco Rubio.' Trump had long said the investigations into his first White House campaign and its connections with Moscow are a hoax. Before departing for Scotland, Trump claimed Obama committed "criminal acts" but "he has immunity" from prosecution. 'It probably helps him a lot, probably helps him a lot the immunity ruling," Trump said. Trump has faced intense backlash since the Department of Justice released a memo July 7 attempting to close the book on the Epstein case. Epstein died in jail in 2019 while awaiting trial on charges of sex trafficking minors. The memo supported the idea that Epstein died by suicide and said investigators did not find a "client list," dispelling conspiracy theories about the case. Obama's office said Trump's focus on the former president is a "weak attempt at distraction." 'Out of respect for the office of the presidency, our office does not normally dignify the constant nonsense and misinformation flowing out of this White House with a response," Obama's office said in the July 22 statement. "But these claims are outrageous enough to merit one." Contributing: Sudiksha Kochi