India Supreme Court reverses content takedown order against Wikipedia operator
Indian news agency ANI last year sued Wikimedia for defamation in the Delhi High Court over the way a Wikipedia page described the news agency. ANI said in its lawsuit it was being described on its Wikipedia page as an agency facing criticism for being a "propaganda tool" for the government.
Wikimedia, which has denied wrongdoing, was ordered by the High Court to take down another page describing the lawsuit.
The Supreme Court judges backed a legal challenge by Wikimedia, which had called that takedown order as one which would have a "chilling effect on free speech".
The Supreme Court said the takedown order was the result of the high court reacting "disproportionately."
"Courts, as a public and open institution, must always remain open to public observations, debates and criticisms," the 37-page Supreme Court order said.
ANI in a statement said it welcomes the court's "affirmation of the press's right to report on legal proceedings, while also noting that litigants may seek reporting restrictions in exceptional cases to avoid prejudice."
Wikimedia Foundation did not immediately respond to a request for comment on the Friday's verdict.
Reuters, which owns a 26% stake in ANI, also did not immediately respond to a request for comment. It has previously said it was not involved in ANI's business practices or operations.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Spectator
38 minutes ago
- Spectator
Fringe venue under fire over mixed-sex toilets
While the Supreme Court in April backed the biological definition of a woman, it would appear that in Scotland the ruling hasn't yet been taken into account. Women's rights campaigners have taken aim at an Edinburgh Fringe venue – Underbelly Bistro Square – for allowing biological men to use women's toilets. Dear oh dear… The venue has been accused of breaking the law, after it added a disclaimer below the female bathroom sign – which told attendees to 'use whichever toilet best fits your identity or expression'. While the men's toilets featured a similar note, the cubicles themselves were reportedly still labelled 'gents'. This is despite the Supreme Court ruling prompting new guidance from the Equality and Human Rights Commission, which says that although it is not compulsory for public services to have single-sex facilities, it could be indirect discrimination against women if the only toilets available are mixed sex. The landmark case was brought to the Supreme Court by women's rights campaign group For Women Scotland – after its argument (that the definition of women in the Equality Act referred to biological sex) was rejected by two Scottish courts. Susan Smith of the organisation told the Telegraph about the latest Fringe furore: 'This is plainly unlawful. You can't have a sign like that. You can either have a mixed sex space or a single sex space. It's not possible to have both at the same time. It's either one or the other.' Helen Joyce of charity Sex Matters added: 'Organisations that fail to get this right risk enabling sexual harassment and ultimately being sued.' Oo er. Will Underbelly push back? Stay tuned…
The Independent
2 hours ago
- The Independent
Top Trump aide says India financing Putin's war in Ukraine by buying Russian oil
A top aide to Donald Trump accused India of aiding Vladimir Putin 's war in Ukraine by purchasing Russian oil as tensions between New Delhi and Washington soared over ties with Moscow. India is lately facing relentless American pressure over its relations with Russia, a longstanding defence and trade partner. Just last week, Mr Trump threatened New Delhi with unspecified penalties over and above a new 25 per cent import tariff for buying oil and weapons from Russia. Mr Trump, who had listed ending the war in Ukraine a top priority for his second presidential term, has been threatening sanctions on countries trading with Moscow after accusing Mr Putin of stalling ceasefire talks. The US president has also resumed sending weapons to Ukraine. Mr Trump is threatening to impose a 100 per cent tariff on exports to the US from any nation purchasing Russian oil in defiance of Western sanctions unless Moscow agrees a peace deal with Ukraine and ends the war. 'What he said very clearly is that it is not acceptable for India to continue financing this war by purchasing the oil from Russia,' White House deputy chief of staff Stephen Miller told Fox News, referring to the US president. "People will be shocked to learn that India is basically tied with China in purchasing Russian oil. That's an astonishing fact." Mr Miller's remarks constitute Washington's strongest criticism yet of one of its key partners in the Indo-Pacific. 'India portrays itself as being one of our closest friends in the world, but they don't accept our products. They impose massive tariffs on us,' he said. 'We also know they engage in a lot of cheating on immigration policies that is very harmful to American workers.' The White House aide said Mr Trump sought a 'tremendous relationship' with India and its leader Narendra Modi but 'we need to get real about dealing with the financing of this war'. 'All options are on the table, to deal diplomatically, financially and otherwise with the ongoing war in Ukraine so we can achieve peace,' Mr Miller said. Russia is the leading oil supplier to India, the world's third-largest consumer of the commodity, accounting for some 35 per cent of its imports. Russia exported nearly 1.75 million barrels of oil to India per day between January and June this year, a rise of about one per cent from a year ago, Reuters reported. And despite Mr Trump's threats, Indian officials said the country would keep purchasing oil from Russia. 'These are long-term oil contracts," a government source told Reuters on Saturday. "It is not so simple to just stop buying overnight.' Justifying oil purchases from Russia, another official said India's imports from Russia helped avoid a global surge in prices, which remained subdued despite Western curbs on the Russian oil sector. Unlike Iranian and Venezuelan oil, Russian crude is not subject to direct sanctions and India is buying it below the current price cap fixed by the European Union, the official told Reuters.
The Herald Scotland
3 hours ago
- The Herald Scotland
Business must support LGBTQIA+ people
While in Scotland and the wider UK the rollback has not been as extensive, there have still been challenging moments for marginalised communities – not least the Supreme Court ruling on the legal definition of women a few months ago. Whatever you think of that decision, it would be fair to say that it has left some communities feeling more excluded than they already were. Read more Some say the backlash against DEI has been of its proponents' own making – they have pushed the issue too far and the pendulum needs to be swung back the other way. Inevitably there are some extreme voices on either side in any debate, but that does not mean there isn't a worthwhile point to address. And it is up to leaders of all descriptions to champion a middle ground, a balanced position, that will work for as many people as possible and help bring underrepresented groups into the fold. The starting point for that has to be one question: if we don't want a society that is diverse, equal, and inclusive, then what do we want? Surely, a world based on the inverse of these values isn't a world anyone would want to live in? Even at an individual business level, few people would want to work in an environment that championed uniformity, inequality, and exclusion and encouraged these types of behaviours. So, in the face of what's happening here and elsewhere, I believe it's more important than ever to support the LGBTQIA+ community year-round, building on our work as a Pride Hub at The Social Hub Glasgow, which saw us commit to a week of educational events and provide spaces for workshops for these groups, and the Better Society Academy, our initiative to support changemakers delivering social impact through a series of masterclasses across Europe. To that end, we are doubling down on our support for underrepresented groups with a range of new initiatives. This will start with Shout It From Our Roof in Glasgow – following the Pride celebrations in the city and Amsterdam – inviting the trans community to metaphorically and literally proclaim their identity by 'shouting it from the roof' of The Social Hub in Merchant City and at our other locations in Europe. On top of that, in the months ahead we plan to donate 99 hours of meeting and event spaces to local initiatives and activists supporting the LGBTQIA+ community across our Glasgow and Amsterdam hubs, as resistance to diversity and inclusion grows. Through the donation of these spaces, we want to create meaningful connections, with opportunities to meet, listen, and understand the needs of the community, working together to drive change. Read more It is all part of our ongoing commitment to social impact and diversity, which includes achieving B Corp certification and the launch of our non-profit TSH Talent Foundation back in 2024. Our ultimate aim is to be welcoming to a global community of guests and team members, inclusive of every identity – or none at all – and our purpose has always been to help build a better, more inclusive society. We know we are stronger when everyone is seen, heard and empowered. Of course, I talk about all of this as a privileged, educated, straight, white, able-bodied man. I've had many of the advantages our society can offer at my feet, but that only makes it more important that people like me stand up for those who have not had the same opportunities to help their voices be heard and their views understood. But, for my part, I want to proudly stand up and say that we will continue to weave DEI and support for the LGBTQIA+ community through everything we do in The Social Hub – at our sites in Glasgow and across Europe. And what we have going on over the next few months is just a taster of more to come. There is a lot happening in the world at the moment, much of which is no doubt causing many people a lot of worry. But I truly believe it's at times like these that we should look outward rather than in, opening doors wider rather than closing them – particularly to those who have been pushed to the side for far too long. Charlie MacGregor is CEO of The Social Hub
