Groomers and child abductors could be jailed without juries in major shake-up
People charged with more serious crimes could lose their automatic right to a trial by jury under major proposals to overhaul the courts system.
More than 150 offences - such as sexual grooming, child abduction or causing death by careless driving - would be tried in a new courts division, with two magistrates and a judge, instead of in front of a jury. The new 'Crown Court (Bench Division)', which could reduce the time of a hearing by at least 20%, would mark the most dramatic shake-up of criminal courts in a generation.
The change is proposed in a landmark review of the courts, which has been published today. In his almost 400-page review, Sir Brian Leveson laid out a system in deep crisis, which is leaving victims, witnesses and defendants waiting years for their cases to go to trial.
He warned it could not be fixed with more money or court sitting days, writing: 'The system is too broken. A radical and essential package of measures is therefore required to prevent total collapse of the system.'
He said the increasing complexity of criminal law, including the emergence of DNA and mobile phone evidence, the Covid pandemic, and strike action by barristers were all among reasons for its deterioration.
Currently offenders facing shorter sentences for cases known as 'summary offences' are tried by a magistrate, without a jury, while the Crown court handles more serious cases. Almost 77,000 cases are currently waiting on the Crown courts backlog, with some being listed as far away as 2029.
To slash the backlog, Sir Brian recommended some 32 offences, including possession of some class B and class C drugs and vehicle theft, be reclassified as 'summary offences' and face lower penalties. He also wants more cases to be settled outside of court, with an increased use of cautions.
And he said offenders should get up to 40% knocked off their sentence for a guilty plea - up from the maximum of a third currently - to speed up case resolutions.
Sir Brian also recommended that complicated fraud and money laundering trials be heard by a judge only, to stop a jury having to decide a verdict on a topic they might not understand. But he said work was ongoing to improve diversity among magistrates, who are also members of the public - not legally trained - and work in the courts on a voluntary basis.
Speaking to reporters, the former senior judge said he does not "rejoice" in the recommendations, but added: "I do believe that they are absolutely essential if we are to prevent our system from collapse."
Courts minister Sarah Sackman has previously backed plans to establish a new division in the court, where offences would be tried without a jury.
Justice Secretary Shabana Mahmood is actively considering all the measures, including the reduction of jury trials. She is expected to comb through the policy in detail, considering each offence on a case-by-case basis to assess whether they could be tried without a jury, before making any decisions.
Ms Mahmood said today 'swifter justice requires bold reform', adding: 'I will do whatever it takes to bring down the backlog and deliver swifter justice for victims.'
Baroness Newlove, Victims' Commissioner for England and Wales, said: 'This Review rightly recognises the scale of the challenge. It sets out bold, radical proposals to overhaul our criminal courts and bring them back from the brink, and deliver swifter justice for victims. I welcome this, though not without reservation. For many victims, plans to increase sentence discounts for guilty pleas and expand out-of-court disposals will feel like justice being diluted once again.'
Law Society president Richard Atkinson: 'This root and branch review shines a light on how decades of neglect of the criminal justice system mean this vital service is failing the public. Justice delayed is justice denied.' He added that the establishment of a new division, without juries, would undermine 'our historic jury system' without investment in the system, as a whole.
Mark Beattie, national chair of the Magistrates' Association, welcomed the review but said plans needed to be put in place to boost magistrate recruitment and retention, with the number of magistrates likely needing to increase by more than a third if a new division is implemented.
'Magistrates are ready and willing to support these and other initiatives aimed at reducing the pressure on crown courts,' he said. 'We urge the government to implement Leveson's recommendations as soon as possible. Every day that they aren't in place, is a day when victims, witnesses and defendants have to wait for justice.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Spectator
an hour ago
- Spectator
Amanda Spielman on the SEND row and Labour's Ofsted blind spot
As Labour looks to get a grip on public spending, one rebellion gives way to another with the changes to the Special Educational Needs and Disabilities (SEND) system threatening to become welfare round two. On this week's Saturday edition of Coffee House Shots, Lucy Dunn is joined by The Spectator's Michael Simmons and former Ofsted chief Amanda Spielman to explore what the government is planning – and why so many Labour MPs are worried. Is the system failing the children it's meant to support, or simply costing too much? And can Labour afford to fix it without tearing itself apart? Listen for: Amanda on the unintended consequences of the 2014 SEND overhaul; why teaching assistants may not be the silver bullet schools think they are; and Labour's mess over Ofsted. Michael Simmons also outlines the fiscal timebomb threatening local authorities; the cultural shift post-Covid that's changed how we approach education; and why one Labour insider is warning, 'If you thought cutting support for disabled adults was bad, wait till you try it with children.' Produced by Oscar Edmondson.
Daily Mail
2 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Who is mushroom killer Erin Patterson's dearest bosom buddy? Ali stood by her throughout everything - and was her ONLY friend in court when the jury found her guilty of murder
Apart from Erin Patterson 's own legal team, who were paid to be there, just one person turned up in court every single day to support the triple killer. Alison Rose Prior, known as Ali, has been the most devoted loyal friend Erin - or anyone else - could ever have hoped for. Day after day, regardless of the incriminating evidence, bitter cold or ever-growing media pack, Ms Prior stuck by her friend through thick and thin. And when the jury delivered its damning series of ' verdicts, it was Ms Prior the killer immediately turned to. 'See you soon,' Patterson told her bosom buddy before being led away to begin her likely life sentence behind bars for the three murders and one attempted murder. Ms Prior left the court thronged by media, and as she fought back tears behind large sunglasses, she told reporters: 'I'm saddened.' Escorted by G4S security staff through the precincts of Morwell Law Courts - where the Supreme Court had held Patterson's ten-week trial - Ms Prior battled to keep her composure. 'I didn't have any expectations,' she added. 'It's the justice system and it is what it is.' Patterson was later whisked away to Dame Phyllis Frost prison, 200km away on the other side of Melbourne, far from her Leongatha home in Gippsland. But despite the distance, Ms Prior immediately vowed to remain Patterson's best mate as the mother-of-two now faces decades behind bars. 'I will see her,' Ms Prior defiantly insisted to a reporter's question. 'I'm her friend and I'll see her - I'll visit with her.' Ms Prior begged media to leave her alone so she could get to her car. As a sign of the intensity and closeness of their relationship, Patterson has granted Ms Prior complete power of attorney over her estate, giving her carte blanche over her substantial wealth and property. The pair are believed to have met through Facebook, where Patterson was an avid contributor to several True Crime groups. Ms Prior, who has a daughter with a rare genetic condition, had previously campaigned locally to reform the law on registering sex offenders and to prevent them living near schools. In the weeks after the agonising deaths of her estranged husband's parents, Don and Gail Patterson, and Gail's sister, Heather Wilkinson - who were fatally poisoned by the beef Wellingtons she laced with death cap mushrooms - Patterson fled her Leongatha home as the net closed in on her. Patterson is said to have bunkered down at Ms Prior's four-bedroom bungalow, set in lush woodlands on the edge of rural Healesville, 65km north-east of Melbourne, as detectives pored over her own home looking for murder clues. Black sheets appeared around Patterson's Leongatha home ahead of the jury's verdict The night before Patterson was finally arrested, she threw a party at her home for Ms Prior and three other close female friends. On the evening of Wednesday, November 1, 2023, Patterson held the knees-up at the Leongatha property for her dwindling inner circle of friends. The weeknight gathering is believed to have been small and included Patterson's two children, a girl and a boy (who can't be identified for legal reasons). But it was still noisy enough that it was noticed by neighbours, who speculated Patterson threw the party in the certain knowledge that those murder charges were imminent. As the jury retired to consider her guilt 18 months later, it was rumoured Patterson would once again return to Ms Prior's home to hide out from the media if she was found innocent. Instead though, the jury unanimously found her guilty - and she was transported by prison van to her new jail cell as one of Australia's most notorious killers. The verdict ends one of the nation's most intriguing homicide cases - and now Patterson likely only has prison visits from Ms Prior to look forward to.
South Wales Guardian
8 hours ago
- South Wales Guardian
Badenoch says ‘rush' to meet net zero pushing up holiday costs
The Conservative Party leader opened a new domestic arrivals building at London Stansted Airport in her North West Essex constituency on Friday. She slammed Labour's 'ideological' plans to reach net zero by 2050, a target she previously dismissed as impossible to meet, and said they would hit holidaymakers. 'Labour's ideological rush to Net Zero 2050 is not only bankrupting our country and leaving us dangerously reliant on China, it's also making holidays more expensive, just as the cost-of-living crisis for working people gets worse. 'Under my leadership the Conservative Party are going to make things easier for the makers, the people who work hard to provide for their families, and not force up the cost of their summer holidays,' she said. The Tory leader pointed to plans to raise air passenger duty and the Climate Change Committee's call for the cost of decarbonising aviation to be reflected in the cost of flights. Speaking to airport staff during the visit, Mrs Badenoch told them how the pandemic showed how 'critical' Stansted was for the local economy. 'But I always tell the story of how when Covid hit and so many people lost their jobs, all of those people turned up in my surgeries. 'It really showed just how critical the airport was, how important it was for the local community and well beyond.' The new arrivals building was part of a £1.1 billion transformation at Stansted, the UK's fourth largest airport. The work, expected to continue over the next three to four years, will also include a £600 million extension to the main terminal, increasing its size by 40%.
