Public holiday pay: Are employees being cheated by the law?
Lawmakers have scrutinised the Basic Conditions of Employment Act (BCEA), pointing out gaps in how it addresses compensation for public holiday work.
Officials from the Parliamentary Legal Services recently briefed the Portfolio Committee on Employment and Labour on possible shortcomings or gaps in the current law.
The BCEA is a labour law that governs employment matters, including leave, wages, working hours, overtime, and pay for work on public holidays.
Law on public holiday pay questioned
Parliamentary legal adviser Telana Halley-Starkey informed MPs that section 18(2)(b)(ii) of the BCEA contains 'semantic ambiguity'.
This section states that if an employee works on a public holiday, they must be paid their normal daily wage plus extra pay for the hours they actually work that day – but only if this total is more than double their normal daily wage.
'So, the legal issue is the interpretation of that section is not clear. The confusion then lies in the pronoun 'it'.
'A question that may arise is which noun is 'it' referring to. What is the 'greater' that the section refers to?' Halley-Starkey asked.
ALSO READ: More than R140 million in salaries paid to suspended government employees
She explained that although section 18(2)(b)(ii) is faulty in syntax, there has been no interpretation issues raised by legal experts or any court.
'The common interpretation, therefore, is that the employer either pays the employee double the normal wage or the normal wage plus any amount that is earned on the day, whichever is greater of the two.'
Halley-Starkey proposed removing the phrases 'at least double' and 'if it is greater' from the section, and instead including the wording 'the higher amount of the following' to improve clarity.
MPs debate the need for legislative fix
ANC MP Sello Maeco questioned whether the ambiguity warranted a legislative amendment and whether it was essential.
'Is the use of the pronoun 'it' in the clause legally pragmatic or open to misinterpretation in its practise?' Maeco asked.
EFF MP Tebogo Mokwele expressed similar sentiments.
'Is it urgent to address the ambiguity or can it be included in a broader amendment bill to the Basic Conditions of Employment Act,' Mokwele said.
READ MORE: Increase in earnings threshold will protect more employees
However, DA MP Juliet Basson revealed that during an employment forum she attended two weeks ago, an employer argued that the law is unclear and allows them to choose how public holiday pay is calculated.
'The employer said it is my choice to decide on which scale I pay you because 'it' does not specify and I would be extremely happy if we can change this to specify better.
'I do believe that if you work on a public holiday, you are entitled to more income and you are entitled to the correct form of income because you are giving up free time with your family and loved ones,' Basson said.
She added that the current wording of the section seems to favour the employer.
Watch the meeting below:
Monday and Sunday both public holidays?
Another DA MP, Michael Bagraim, expressed surprise that previous litigation had not exposed the issue, describing this as 'weird'.
He also questioned whether the proposed amendment made the section 'crystal clear'.
Bagraim further emphasised the need to clarify how public holidays are treated when they fall on a Sunday.
The DA MP pointed out the confusion around whether both the Sunday and the following Monday are regarded as public holidays, or just one of them.
He noted that employees who normally work on Sundays are entitled to time-and-a-half pay.
'If the public holiday is indeed to be on a Monday, then you are going to get double, or are they both public holidays?' Bagraim asked.
MK party MP Hazel Mbele supported Bagraim's concerns.
'If people are working on a Sunday, is it regarded as overtime or as a public holiday to get double pay?' Mbele asked, adding that a legal amendment would bring clarity.
NOW READ: How does the minimum wage apply to workers not remunerated by the hour?
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
IOL News
2 hours ago
- IOL News
At 90, Mac Maharaj embarks on a film journey about Nelson Mandela's life
Former presidents Jacob Zuma and Nelson Mandela with Mac Maharaj in the 1990s. Maharaj, 90, is working on a film on Mandela's life. Image: Ken Oosterbroek / Archives ANC veteran and former Cabinet minister Mac Maharaj is working on a film about global icon and late former president Nelson Mandela's life. Maharaj was transport minister in Mandela's first Cabinet after the 1994 elections and they spent 12 years together incarcerated on Robben Island as political prisoners for fighting against apartheid. The erstwhile spokesperson of former president Jacob Zuma announced the making of the film during a students' colloquium convened by City of Tshwane corporate and shared services MMC and ActionSA councillor, Kholofelo Morodi, to commemorate Nelson Mandela International Day on Friday. 'It is interesting for me when I look back that I also have the opportunity today, over the last four years, to have been doing research to help to put together a film on Madiba (Mandela's clan name),' Maharaj revealed. Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Next Stay Close ✕ Ad Loading The 90-year-old described the film as 'not what others say about him but what he says through his own mouth'. Maharaj said this was a project he was busy with and which has also given him the opportunity to look back even more deeply. 'And I tried to understand what made him the leader he became,' he explained. According to Maharaj, he was not the best person to help draw lessons from Mandela's life because in their close interactions, he had many occasions to advise him, and as a dutiful disciple, he tried to learn from him. 'But sometimes the learning has led to consequences that are not so good. When I went to prison, I was a young man, an angry young man. I actually landed on Robben Island at the age of 29 and so my decade of the 30s, the prime of my life, was spent in prison. I came out of prison at the age of 41,' he remembered. Maharaj said he went to prison in a fighting mood, had been tortured for two months, and had reached a point where he attempted on three occasions, under torture, to commit suicide rather than talk. 'My experiences had shaped me that every moment in prison was becoming a moment to fight back, hence every time I got into an argument with a (prison) warder, I would end up using words and swearing (at) him, and the result was I would be charged for insulting the warder and the punishment took the form of deprivation of food,' he explained. However, one day while at the quarry, Mandela called him aside, reprimanded him and warned that his behaviour could cost him his life in prison. But Maharaj said he responded to him aggressively and asked what he wanted him to do as he would not listen to nonsense and obey racists. Mandela told him he was right to fight back, but in the argument with the warder, he tended to lose his temper and insult the warder. 'Calm down, you are right to stand up but when you do stand up, pause, count to 10, choose your words so that your words become like a scalpel that cuts, words such that he can't charge you for swearing,' Maharaj recalled Mandela telling him. He said his 12 years on Robben Island, between 1964 and 1976, were a journey into discovering new ways of defiance that would triumph over every rule in the book of prison regulations and in the armoury of apartheid.
Daily Maverick
3 hours ago
- Daily Maverick
We must honour Mandela by fighting the corruption in the heart of our democracy
Mandela was a lover and a fighter, a symbol of struggle against oppression and a champion of peace and forgiveness. His bravery in standing up against the evil empire is our bravery. His hope and humour and humanity are ours. It's in us and up to us to stand up against those in Mandela's party, and indeed any political party, who choose to rob us blind. Every year we celebrate Mandela Day on 18 July. It's a global campaign to honour the remarkable life and legacy of the founding father of our democracy, Nelson Rolihlahla Mandela. The Nelson Mandela Foundation turned Madiba's birthday into a call to action for individuals, communities and organisations, urging them to take time to reflect on Mandela's values and principles and make a positive impact in their own communities. I will never forget the warm, fuzzy feeling I felt when I stood shoulder to shoulder with thousands of people on the Grand Parade in Cape Town in 1990 as Mandela stepped on to the balcony of City Hall and said to all of us: 'I come to you as your servant.' It was the humility and dignity of this stately yet grandfatherly man; it was hearing a voice that had been banned for 27 years speak to our hearts; it was the realisation and the sense of relief that the years of campaigning against apartheid and inequality, risking jail and police batons and death, might just have been worth it. That we may have succeeded in toppling the evil empire of racism, exclusion and violence. And that maybe, just maybe, we could live in freedom. There are many of Mandela's heirs in the ANC and its political party offshoots like the MK party, formed as comrades turned on each other for their time to 'eat', and who have done nothing to build on the tremendous goodwill that we, the South African people, have granted them. The recent allegations by KwaZulu-Natal police commissioner Lieutenant-General Nhlanhla Mkhwanazi that a drug cartel based in Gauteng was controlling a high-level criminal syndicate that has the Police Ministry, politicians, prosecutors and judges in its pockets, came as no surprise. Because ever since 1994, more and more comrades have been in cahoots with criminals and gangsters, buying favours and seats at the table. Rot and Cancer We had former police commissioner Jackie Selebi's dalliance with his drug dealer friend, 'finish and klaar' Glenn Agliotti. And the rot and cancer has spread far and wide. The Guptas landed with their bums in bucket-loads of ghee when Jacob Zuma led his family, friends and the ANC into Saxonwold. Judge Raymond Zondo's State Capture chronicles feature a long list of ANC comrades whose fingers were in the trough. Criminality has stretched its tentacles all over the ANC at every centre of government, from local, provincial and national level to parastatals across the country. And when the ANC gets voted out, the criminals find politicians in other parties to cosy up to. It has come to the point where it is hard to trust any politician. We do not know which lobbyist or foreign agency or wealthy person is behind them. Our democracy is a marketplace where favours and influence are sold to the highest bidder. And global druglords who peddle poison to our youth have found ripe pickings in this country that gave Mandela to us and the world. Mandela was a human born of a different era. Our son of the South African soil arrived on 18 July 1918, deep in the era of the colonial conquest that saw the land of indigenous people taken by the minions of the Dutch East India Company and footsoldiers of the British Empire who distributed it to white settler populations. Mandela was a freedom fighter, a leader of the ANC who started the armed struggle and Umkhonto weSizwe (MK) when peaceful protest against apartheid was met with violence. He and his fellow Rivonia triallists' incarceration in the 1960s did not silence their resistance to the apartheid state. Nor could it silence generation after generation of South Africans, from Steve Biko and the Black Consciousness movement to the trade union movement, United Democratic Front, Mass Democratic Movement, Black Sash, Lawyers for Human Rights, Detainees' Parents Support Committee… and ordinary South Africans who stood up, fists clenched against what was wrong. Biko was a proponent of the Black Consciousness philosophy that emphasised the importance of black people freeing ourselves psychologically from the internalised effects of oppression. He urged us to embrace our own identity and take control of our own liberation. For his promotion of self-reliance and resistance to the notion that black people are inferior to white people, he was arrested and murdered in detention. There were others. Millions of others. They belonged to women's groups, churches, temples, artist groups. There were resistance organisations like the New Unity Movement, the Azanian People's Organisation and the Pan-Africanist Congress. Not just the ANC. Not just Mandela. Global icon What drew the world to Mandela and turned him into a global icon was that even though he was a freedom fighter who started MK, he didn't leave Robben Island to sing 'Kill the Boer, kill the farmer' at every opportunity, as ANC protégé and EFF leader Julius Malema does. Nor did he take to every political rally singing Umshini Wami (Bring Me My Machine Gun), as Jacob Zuma does. Mandela was a lover and a fighter, a symbol of struggle against oppression and a champion of peace and forgiveness. His long imprisonment created a powerful narrative of personal sacrifice that humanised the anti-apartheid struggle. On 18 July, and every day, many South Africans give 67 minutes of their time and more to do good — helping others, cleaning cities, caring for neglected children, raising funds for charitable causes in memory of the spirit of Mandela. We are a nation of generous, kind, warm-hearted, freedom-loving people. It is our spirit of resilience and generosity that created Mandela. His bravery in standing up against the evil empire is our bravery. His hope and humour and humanity are ours. It's in us and up to us to stand up against those in Mandela's party, and indeed any political party, who choose to rob us blind. There are no saviours coming to rescue us. In us resides the ability to build the kind of country we deserve. We stand on the shoulders of generations of giants who fought for freedom. It's our turn now. DM
The Citizen
3 hours ago
- The Citizen
Fallen councillor remembered, mourners demand action
Members of the metro's council recently held a special council meeting, which served as a memorial service for the late Councillor Thabang Masemola. The Ward 10 Councillor was gunned down by an unknown man outside a tuck shop on the main road in Stoffel Park, in the far east of Mamelodi, on July 9. Members of Masemola's family, as well as councillors from all political parties, gathered on July 18 to celebrate his life. Many councillors called for justice to come swiftly, demanding that Masemola's death not be in vain, and that the perpetrators not roam free. Councillor Katlego Makgaleng said that though they represent different political parties, they are one as councillors. 'He was a man of integrity. He was a great man. As Alderman Maluleka said, you would think he's very quiet looking at him from the outside, but inside, he was a man of integrity and wisdom, who was always willing to impart some of that wisdom with those he engaged with,' Makgalaeng said. Councillor Komaseroto Benjamin Disoloane of the EFF said the feeling was unreal as he and many others were used to seeing Masemola daily. He further called on the mayor and all councillors to wage war against all criminals in the city. 'If we really respect and want to honour Thabang, we have to fight crime like no one has ever seen before. We cannot come here and sit, and send our well wishes without doing anything. 'Tomorrow it might be you. The question is, what do we do now? If need be, let's have our own General Mkhwanazi here in the metro,' Disoloane said. Councillor Jacob Mathabathe said that it was not right that Masemola's life was needlessly taken and that his children remain heartbroken. 'We want to tell the Masemola family that we are with you, always. Thabang's death must not be in vain. 'We've had a lot of councillors who have been murdered, and we don't know what happened to this day; the culprits have not been found. 'We have to make sure that every culprit who commits murder, not only of councillors but any murderer, must be brought to justice. 'One murder is one too many. We've got to stand up and say: Enough is enough,' Mathabathe said. Councillor Déhan Harmse expressed his condolences to the family with two Bible verses which spoke of comfort during trying times. He said that Thabang's death has left the FF Plus with a heavy heart, and extended the party's condolences to the ANC. 'I saw Councillor Masemola's passion first-hand at the start of last year, during an oversight visit at Lusaka Clinic. 'He was very adamant about pushing the completion of the clinic so it could serve the community in and around the ward he served. 'This showed me that he truly cared for the people he served and truly cared for their well-being,' Harmse said. On July 9, Masemola and his companion were taking his new car out for a test drive. While stopping for food on Malapana Street and engaging in conversation with a friend, an unknown man, wearing a jacket with a hoodie, approached them and shot Masemola several times. Following the shooting, the suspect got into a car and left the scene. Emergency services declared Masemola dead on the scene. Police continue to ask residents with any information regarding the shooting to contact local law enforcement. Do you have more information about the story? Please send us an email to [email protected] or phone us on 083 625 4114. For free breaking and community news, visit Rekord's websites: Rekord East For more news and interesting articles, like Rekord on Facebook, follow us on Twitter or Instagram or TikTok. At Caxton, we employ humans to generate daily fresh news, not AI intervention. Happy reading!
