logo
Need for permanent chief medical officer of health 'dire,' says Alberta Medical Association

Need for permanent chief medical officer of health 'dire,' says Alberta Medical Association

CBC03-05-2025
Alberta's health minister says the search for a permanent chief medical medical officer of health is in the early stages, prompting concerns about health leadership as the province continues to battle its worst measles outbreak in nearly three decades.
The total number of confirmed cases since the outbreaks began in March surged to 210 on Friday. That's the highest case count since 1997, when 242 cases were reported.
The escalating case numbers come at a time when the province is without a permanent top doctor.
The provincial government appointed an interim chief medical officer of health after Dr. Mark Joffe opted not to renew his contract in mid-April. He had been in the role since November 2022.
Joffe left as calls grew for him to take to the podium and speak directly to Albertans about the measles outbreaks. At the time, doctors raised concerns about whether he was allowed to speak publicly on the matter.
The province has not yet found a permanent replacement.
"I think the need to get someone who has expertise in the role is dire," said Dr. Shelley Duggan, president of the Alberta Medical Association.
"It could be tricky. But I think it's important. There's lots of people trained in public health. We need to get somebody in Alberta. And we need to let them develop a campaign and work with their team to get the messaging out."
When asked by CBC News about the search for a replacement, Health Minister Adriana LaGrange did not say how much interest there is in the job. Nor did she say how many candidates have been interviewed.
"We're at the initial stages of the search," she said at a news conference on Thursday.
"We were quite hopeful that Dr. Joffe would have extended his contract. Since that hasn't happened, we are just at the initial stages of the search. And I'll keep you posted as we go along this road."
When it comes to concerns about how the province will handle its surging measles cases without a permanent CMOH in place, she said she's confident in the work of the public health teams.
"It's the local [medical officers of health] that are in the communities, that are on the ground working with those communities, that are most affected. They report up to the CMOH. So there's obviously a lot of interaction that happens."
LaGrange said measles immunizations have increased this year compared to last year due to the work of those teams.
When asked if she ever refused to greenlight any requests Joffe made about how to handle the measles outbreak, LaGrange did not answer directly, noting instead that she had many conversations with him about how to reach impacted communities.
"There are hot spots, but we do not have a provincial outbreak of measles," she said when pressed further.
Recruitment in question
"Recruitment and retention of qualified public health leaders and health leaders, in general in this province, has become increasingly difficult," said Lorian Hardcastle, associate professor in the faculty of law and the Cumming School of Medicine at the University of Calgary.
She said concerns about politicization of public health could be a deterrent.
"And given the revolving door of public health officials — of [Alberta Health Services] CEOs, of the AHS board — I think it's going to be difficult to recruit and retain qualified people to these kinds of roles in this province."
It's problematic, she said, to be facing measles outbreaks with people moving in and out of the job.
"You don't want to have those transitions in the context of a public health crisis. You want consistent, clear messaging from the same trusted authority. And I don't think they're positioned to do that."
The Alberta NDP said it, too, is skeptical about Alberta's ability to recruit a new top doctor.
"[Premier Danielle Smith] ran a leadership campaign showing disrespect to science, to public health, to experts, and it continues. And now she's got control over that office and it's caused a lot of chaos," said NDP health critic Sarah Hoffman, adding she's not surprised a permanent replacement is not in place.
"It is concerning because there should be separation between those who are in charge of gathering evidence and those who are in controlling political messaging."
Changes coming about through the UCP government's health system overall could be a further deterrent, according to Hoffman.
Bill 55, the Health Statutes Amendment Act, was tabled on Thursday. If passed, zone medical officers of health who are now part of Alberta Health Services will move to Alberta Health.
The plan has sparked concern about the consolidation of decision-making power — for matters relating to the health of Albertans — within the ministry.
"It is really important that we have experts that are entrusted to give their very best advice and direction. And when you're within the department, you don't have that same independence," said Hoffman.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Measles out of control ahead of September school start, doctors warn
Measles out of control ahead of September school start, doctors warn

CBC

time19 hours ago

  • CBC

Measles out of control ahead of September school start, doctors warn

Several Alberta doctors are warning the province could face "a perfect storm" as measles outbreaks balloon and children head back to school in September. During a media availability hosted by the Alberta Medical Association on Tuesday, the physicians appealed to parents to ensure their children are vaccinated immediately. And they called on the Alberta government to expand access to an early vaccine dose for babies and to consider requiring proof of immunization in schools. "There's no doubt that this is an epidemic," said Dr. James Talbot, a former chief medical officer of health for Alberta. "Worse, there can be no doubt that it's still not under control." Talbot worries children will be heading back to school in September after having attended family gatherings, sports tournaments, camps and other events where they may have been exposed to measles. "That represents a perfect storm where our children, grandchildren, nephews and nieces and family members will be at risk, increased risk, of getting measles," said Talbot, who is also an adjunct professor at the University of Alberta's school of public health. As of midday Tuesday Alberta had reported a total of 1,472 measles cases since the outbreaks began in March — and transmission is showing no signs of slowing down. The doctors are pleading with Albertans to ensure their children get vaccinated right away. "The best time to do it is now. Don't wait for the start of the school year. Do it now so they're protected when the school year starts, said Talbot. "That's the most important back-to-school preparation you can do, even more important than buying a back-pack or lunchbox." Edmonton-based pediatrician Dr. Tehseen Ladha is worried that the virus, unchecked, could make some children very sick. "There's this misconception that measles is a routine illness — a routine childhood illness — and it's not," she said. "It's one of the most contagious viruses on earth. And children, pregnant women and immunocompromised people are amongst the groups most vulnerable to it." The measles virus can hang in the air for several hours after an individual leaves a location and it can lead to serious complications, including pneumonia, brain swelling and brain damage, premature delivery and even death. "The risks of getting the illness are much worse and more frequent than getting the vaccine," said Ladha, noting that about 10 per cent of people infected with the virus will end up in hospital. Extra baby dose The doctors are renewing calls for the Alberta government to allow babies as young as six months old, living in all health zones, to have access to an early and extra vaccine dose. The province currently only offers the early shot to babies living in or travelling to the hardest hit south, central and north zones. "Although there are areas in the province with higher rates of measles, people travel within the province. There are no borders," said Ladha. "And we are approaching a school start in which there will be many siblings and playmates bringing measles home to their younger sisters and brothers." Talbot would also like to see the province consider requiring proof of immunization in schools. Ontario, for example, requires that students be vaccinated against a number of illnesses, including measles. "Ontario is better situated for September back to school than Alberta is," he said. If there are outbreaks at schools the physicians warned it may be necessary to send unvaccinated children and staff, who are exposed, home. "You really are meant to be quarantined for 21 days, I believe," said Dr. Lynora Saxinger, an infectious diseases specialist with the University of Alberta. "That is a long time and that is for people who are not sick. That is to try and contain the infection and reduce the successive rings of spread. And that's very disruptive." Measures 'not warranted,' province says As of July 12, 114 Albertans had been hospitalized due to the illness, including 15 intensive care unit admissions. No deaths have been reported. The Alberta government said it is taking the outbreaks seriously and working to limit further spread but that the steps suggested by the physicians are not necessary. "The response is guided by data and the advice of public health experts, including the Chief Medical Officer of Health," said an emailed statement from the Ministry of Primary and Preventive Health Services. "We will continue to adjust our approach as needed based on emerging data and expert advice; however, the measures currently being suggested are not supported by the latest data and are not warranted at this time." The province is pushing back against the idea of offering the early vaccine dose more widely to infants, saying it is an outbreak response in areas where the risk is higher and that the risk in Calgary and Edmonton remains "relatively low." "Offering early doses more broadly — without an identified need — would not be medically appropriate and could divert resources from areas where they are most needed," the spokesperson said. Provincial data shows 17 new cases have been reported in the Calgary zone in the last two weeks, bringing the total to 43 cases. The Edmonton zone, which has seen a slower uptick, has reported 16 cases this year. The government also said it has expanded immunization clinic hours an added clinics in some hard-hit areas. The spokesperson said the province's tactics, which also include targeted outreach, have worked, and vaccination rates have increased. "Messaging targeted to parents and guardians of school-aged children ahead of the school year is also being explored," the statement added, noting parents and guardians received a letter from the Chief Medical Officer of Health in June, outlining the risks and importance of immunization. The province also insists the measles outbreaks don't constitute an "epidemic" or "province-wide outbreak," because the vast majority of cases are outside of Calgary and Edmonton.

'Measles capital of North America': Alberta doctors sound alarm on immunization
'Measles capital of North America': Alberta doctors sound alarm on immunization

Edmonton Journal

time20 hours ago

  • Edmonton Journal

'Measles capital of North America': Alberta doctors sound alarm on immunization

Article content The Canadian government urges measles vaccination for all eligible individuals, including two doses at 12 and 18 months of age. Article content Smith said the provincial government is now allowing everyone to get their two doses by the age of two. Article content 'Before we waited until kindergarten, but now so many kids are going into daycare, so we've moved that back, but we also make a microdose available to those parents who want that extra protection and so they can get a smaller dose,' she said. Article content For now, Alberta is reaping the benefits of days when vaccine rates were higher. Article content Smith said she's 'pleased to see that we still have about a 90 per cent overall vaccination rate by the time young people get to be 17 years old — 95 per cent is what they recommend. But we're glad to see that the message is getting out,' she said. Article content Child, adult, pregnant woman alike, if you're in the room with an infected person and you're non-immune, your chances of getting the airborne illness is very, very high, said Ladha. Article content Article content 'That represents a perfect storm where our children, grandchildren, nephews and nieces and family members will be at risk, increased risk in getting measles because they've gone to school in September or because they've brought it home from school to infect the children who are still at home,' Talbot said. Article content There have been recent ICU admissions with measles victims requiring care, said Dr. Lynora Saxinger, an infectious diseases specialist with the University of Alberta. Article content 'I have just recently been called about pregnant women who have measles in pregnancy. I've also been called about transplant patients with measles. Article content 'The likelihood that there will be severe outcomes with really significant critical illness or death is just going up, because the longer we have circulation of disease and more cases that happen, that's basically just a matter of numbers and risk, and it's just a matter of time, unfortunately,' Saxinger said. Article content Article content Within the past few months, the province's health zones have stopped posting the areas of exposure to measles, where individuals travelled from their doctor's office to a lab to a radiology site to a store. Article content 'We don't see that from those sites anymore, because the volume is simply too high for them to be able to catch up. And so we just know that there's more transmission and more cases than are even being detected, and we're probably seeing, to some extent, the tip of the iceberg on the hospital side,' she said. Article content Practical considerations Article content As a doctor, Talbot said, he's an optimist in that he believes public health threats can be addressed — noting that more than 90 per cent of Albertans got at least one COVID vaccination during the pandemic. Article content All American states have laws requiring certain vaccines for students to attend school, although a number of states allow for exemption on the basis of religion or philosophy, according to the National Conference of State Legislatures. Article content In Canada, Ontario and New Brunswick have made immunizations mandatory for school attendance. Article content It may be time for a public debate on requiring measles immunizations for school attendance in Alberta, Talbot said. Article content 'The second (way to address school spread of measles) is to make sure that people are aware that if measles does strike a school and starts to spread, that it may be necessary to send unimmunized students and unimmunized staff home so that they are protected for the time until all of those people who have been exposed are safe to return,' he said. Article content Saxinger said for those who aren't immune, the current guidance for quarantine after measles exposure is 21 days. Article content 'That's to try to contain the infection and reduce the successive rings of spread — and that's very disruptive, if you think about that occurring in a school or in a workplace. It is a really strong practical argument to make sure that your immunization is up to date, and the immunization of your children is up to date,' Saxinger said. Article content Article content The experts agreed there's a unique window in the next month. Article content 'It takes time to book an appointment, and then the child's body needs 10 to 15 days to get the maximum protection. So book your appointment now for anyone going back to school and anyone under the age of five who's not immune in your household. That's the most important back-to-school preparation you can do even more than buying a backpack or a lunch box,' Talbot said. Article content 'It will ensure that they do not get measles, they do not get hospitalized, they do not go deaf or worse. It will give you the peace of mind that no matter what other people have done or failed to do, your child is safe. It will make your family and your community safer. And finally, it means that you will be able to say that you know the science and you've been smart in protecting your child, maybe not smart enough to get you on Jeopardy, but smart enough to show that you know what's important to the health of your children,' he said. Article content Article content Article content

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store