When will Miliband make up his mind on Mingyang?
Miliband appears to be dragging his heels in considering what exactly to do about a windfarm project in Scotland that could see British reliance on Chinese-made turbines. Mingyang Smart Energy is a private Chinese company with close ties to the Chinese Communist Party. The organisation is hoping to sign a contract with Green Volt North Sea – jointly owned by Flotation Energy, a Scottish company, and Vårgrønn, a Norwegian one – which is constructing the first commercial-scale floating offshore wind farm in Europe. The project aims to deliver electricity to oil and gas platforms (in place of power generated via gas and diesel turbines) and power the UK grid. Green Volt has been waiting on approval from the government to go ahead using Mingyang-made blades for months – but with no response as yet, the company remains in limbo. The contract would involve Mingyang establishing a turbine factory in Scotland – a move the Trump administration has directly warned the government against over security concerns. So much for a just transition, eh?
The decision to allow Mingyang machinery has left ministers divided amidst an 'ongoing discussion' on the role of China in Britain's critical infrastructure. Concerns centre around national security, as well as the possible use of forced labour in supply chains – such as from the repressed Uyghur population in Xinjiang province. Mingyang's CEO and chair Zhang Chuanwei has links to the CCP and is regarded as a longtime party loyalist. As noted in a 2021 profile of the company boss by Gavekal Fathom China, Zhang joined the People's Liberation Army as a clerk in 1978, aged just 16, before applying to join the party at 18. Zhang even served as a CCP representative in the 12th and 13th National People's Congress from 2013-2023. How very interesting…
Ministers are of course able to block any investment into the UK under the 2021 National Security and Investment Act of 2021 and the government has stopped Chinese investment in the past over 'national security risks'. In 2022, the government halted the takeover of the UK's largest producer of semi-conductors by Nexperia, a Chinese-owned manufacturer. And Miliband's dilemma comes just months after Chinese company Jingye came under fire over its steel production plant in Scunthorpe in April, when it threatened to turn off the blast furnaces. While Business Secretary Jonathan Reynolds suggested 'neglect' could have been the issue, reports at the time saw government officials pushing the theory that there had been a 'plot to sabotage' the British Steel plant. Tensions heightened when China snubbed a major 60-country UK summit on energy security the following week.
So why is Miliband taking so long to make up his mind? Well, the Energy Secretary has remarked before that the foreign power is integral for global climate action. 'It is simply an act of negligence…not to engage China on how it can play its part in taking action on climate,' Miliband said in March following his trip to Beijing for the UK's first formal climate talks with China since 2017. During his visit, Miliband met the Chinese vice premier Ding Xuexiang as well as the head of the country's National Energy Administration, Wang Hongzhi, and is said to have pointed to 'mutually beneficial results' of cooperation, including in the offshore wind sector.
But all that considered, there remain rather concerning questions of national security. For their part, a government spokesperson told Steerpike: 'We would never let anything get in the way of our national security, and while we would not comment on individual cases, investment in the energy sector is subject to the highest levels of national security scrutiny.' Whatever – and whenever – will Miliband decide? The clock is ticking…
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Herald Scotland
28 minutes ago
- The Herald Scotland
Greenpeace says activists arrested after ending Forth Road Bridge protest
Police Scotland said it had been alerted to the protest shortly after 1pm on Friday. That was after the group suspended themselves from the bridge using ropes, ending up about 25 metres above the water level at high tide. On Saturday morning Greenpeace announced it had ended the demonstration, saying they had 'achieved what we set out to'. The campaign group said its demonstration had prevented the Ineos tanker from delivering the gas for a full 24 hours, saying that the vessel could only travel to Grangemouth during high tides. As a result the specially trained activists began climbing down their ropes early on Saturday morning. Greenpeace said all 10 had descended safely and were voluntarily transported to Port Edgar in South Queensferry, where it said they were arrested by officers from Police Scotland on suspicion of culpable and reckless conduct. Amy Cameron, programme director at Greenpeace UK said: 'We've achieved what we set out to. 'By blocking Ineos, we've drawn global attention to the company's bottomless appetite for plastic production, false solutions and profit for its billionaire boss Jim Ratcliffe.' The Forth Road Bridge is closed due to a protest reported to us around 1.05pm on Friday, 25 July. Officers are in attendance and engaging with those involved. Please avoid the area. — Police Scotland Fife (@PSOSFife) July 25, 2025 Describing the 'plastic pollution problem' as being 'massive', she added: 'Less than 10% of plastic is currently recycled globally, and this is set to rise to just 17% by 2060, while the amount of plastic we're producing is set to triple. 'The only solution is to address the problem at source which means securing a strong global plastics treaty that imposes legally-binding caps on plastic production.' Ms Cameron continued: 'Ineos are cutting jobs at Grangemouth while trying to open a massive new plastics plant in Belgium, leaving Scottish workers high and dry. 'If Jim Ratcliffe really cared about skilled jobs in Scotland he'd invest his billions in supporting his workers to transition into the green industries of the future, instead of throwing money at Formula 1 racing teams and football clubs.' Greenpeace insists its protest was safe and caused 'minimal disruption' – stressing that the climbers had spent weeks training for the demonstration, also pointing out that the Forth Road Bridge carries low volumes of bus, cycle and pedestrian traffic. Police Scotland has been contacted for comment.
Scotsman
30 minutes ago
- Scotsman
Poll reveals 'confidence collapsing' SNP can usher in clean energy jobs as oil and gas declines
The transition from fossil fuels to green energy is a serious challenge that needs serious people in charge (Picture: Jonathan Nackstrand/AFP via Getty Images) | AFP via Getty Images Sign up to our Politics newsletter Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... Only one in five Scots believe the energy transition away from oil and gas will create jobs, a new poll has revealed. The nationwide survey, conducted by YouGov for the GMB and Prospect trade unions, shows that Scots have more at stake in the drive to cut emissions than anywhere else in the UK, but share far less confidence it will deliver economic or climate benefits. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad The transition from fossil fuels to green energy is a serious challenge (Picture: Jonathan Nackstrand/AFP via Getty Images) | AFP via Getty Images The UK and Scottish governments have insisted that a just transition will create hundreds of thousands of jobs in clean technologies for former oil and gas workers as the industry declines, but the poll of 2,100 people across the UK reveals most Scots are unconvinced. The survey suggests that 17 per cent of Scots work in the energy sector or know someone who does - a far higher proportion than anywhere else in the UK. But less than half, 47 per cent, feel positive about the transition from oil and gas to renewable energy - lower than in England, Wales and Northern Ireland - while 21 per cent feel negative, more than any of the other home nations. Almost one in three fear the energy transition will cost jobs in Scotland, also the highest proportion across the UK and almost three times the proportion in England. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Only 17 per cent of Scots think the transition will increase job opportunities, the lowest level of optimism across the country. Louise Gilmour, GMB Scotland secretary, said: 'Experienced and skilled workers across oil and gas know better than anyone what the scale of this transition will demand and what is at stake. GMB Scotland secretary Louise Gilmour | Andrew Cawley 'Promises of green jobs tomorrow mean nothing when real jobs are being lost today and, so far, this transition has been something done to our workers and their communities not with them. 'These workers understand change and know how to make it happen but their expert voice has been drowned out by the din of politicians and campaigners making a noise instead of a plan. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad READ MORE: Rosebank and other North Sea oil and gas fields could be given green light under new guidelines 'The insight and expertise of workers must be front and centre in this transition and, if it is not, this transition will fail.' Prospect general secretary, Mike Clancy, added: 'The government have raised the ambition on energy policy, which is welcome. 'Now they need to be bigger and bolder when it comes to energy jobs and put energy workers at the heart of this agenda.' Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad The Scottish Government is also under increasing pressure to reverse its ban on new nuclear power as the construction of new small modular reactors in England is poised to create thousands of well-paid jobs and apprenticeships. Scottish Labour net zero spokesperson, Sarah Boyack, said: 'Scotland can be a global clean energy superpower, but both the Tories and the SNP have been squandering this opportunity. Scottish Labour's Sarah Boyack 'Under the SNP green jobs targets have been missed, supply chain jobs have been sent abroad, our seabeds have been sold off on the cheap, and just transition funding has been frittered away with little to show for it.' Scottish Conservative energy and net zero spokesperson, Douglas Lumsden, said: 'With the SNP repeatedly missing their own emissions targets, it's little wonder public confidence is collapsing in their ability to deliver the renewable jobs they keep promising. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad 'Warm words on green jobs are cold comfort to the thousands of skilled oil and gas workers who have been chucked on the scrapheap by both Labour and the SNP.' Climate Action and Energy Secretary Gillian Martin said: 'We're clear in our support for a just transition for Scotland's valued oil and gas sector, which recognises the maturity of the North Sea basin and is in line with our climate change commitments. 'Communities, workers, and trade unions are at the heart of Scotland's renewable energy transition, and we are committed to ensuring local voices are central to any decisions we take, this includes the voices of the workforce within our oil and gas industry. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad 'Through initiatives such as the Just Transition Fund and the Energy Transition Fund, the Scottish Government has already invested £120 million in the North East's transition to net zero to help create green jobs, support innovation, and secure the highly skilled workforce of the future.
Scotsman
30 minutes ago
- Scotsman
Think Donald Trump is a clown? He's a serious politician and a warning to Scotland
Sign up to our daily newsletter – Regular news stories and round-ups from around Scotland direct to your inbox Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... I have some advice for John Swinney as he prepares for his chat with Donald Trump. Expected the unexpected. The President of the United States, who has popped over the Atlantic for a long weekend break at his golf courses in Ayrshire and Aberdeenshire, is no ordinary world leader. Not for him the niceties of protocol, the firm handshakes, the carefully scripted exchanges, drafted weeks in advance by diplomats. The Donald could, and may well, do or say anything. Theresa May never fully recovered from Trump holding her hand as they strolled through the White House gardens in early 2017. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Twenty years ago, I was a nervous press officer standing outside the lift in the lobby of Trump Tower, waiting for the signal to take the then First Minister up to Donald Trump's penthouse office for a meet and greet, as had been arranged with his office. Jack McConnell was in New York on a short trip to promote Scotland as a great place for inward investment. Donald Trump dances on stage at the Iowa State Fairgrounds in Des Moines earlier this month (Picture: Andrew Caballero-Reynolds) | AFP via Getty Images Trump's hidden mic Scottish Enterprise officials had set up a meeting with Trump, whose mother Mary Anne Macleod was from the Western Isles, after the property developer turned TV star expressed an interest in building a world-class golf resort on the North East coast. The lift doors suddenly opened and out swept Trump, with a camera crew in tow, shouting 'Where's the First Minister?' What followed was a classic Trump meeting. He insisted on doing press interviews first, which delighted the small Scottish media pack who were with us. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Then, on the way to lunch in the Trump Tower restaurant, he tried to make the First Minister wear one of his signature red baseball caps, emblazoned with his then-famous catchphrase 'You're Fired', from his hit TV show The Apprentice. Trump knew full well that if he had succeeded, the picture would have been splashed on the front page of every Scottish newspaper. I am grateful to this day that the FM saw through his schoolboy jape. Then, just as the burger and fries were served, McConnell asked his host to remove the microphone he had hidden under his tie. A shamefaced Trump apologised, saying he always wore one in case he came across anything 'interesting' for his TV show. An amusing tale, and one that says more about the 47th President than any number of Foreign Office briefings. Another word of advice, Mr Swinney. Check for hidden mics. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad 'Three-time loser' Trump is the world's biggest show-off. He has to be the centre of attention, whether he is meeting with the war-weary president of Ukraine or jousting with his erstwhile best friend, Elon Musk. Everything he says and does is content for TV networks or social media. And he has the attention span of a teenage girl scrolling TikTok. Only his beloved golf holds his interest for longer than a few minutes, and his weekend in Scotland will be no different. He also ditches people as soon as they are no longer useful to him. His friendship with Alex Salmond ended in tears when Trump objected to plans for windfarms near his Menie golf resort. Salmond dubbed Trump a 'three-time loser' while Trump hit back, calling Salmond a 'has been' with a 'bloated ego'. Take any compliment with a pinch of salt, First Minister. He doesn't mean a word he says. But as Trump flies back to Washington and Swinney and his team review the weekend's events, there is a far bigger lesson to be drawn from Trump's flying visit than that the President is a shameless exhibitionist. He is also a very successful politician whose populist messaging now appeals to a large swathe of America, and not just white, working-class rednecks – as the Democrats tried to argue before November 2024. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad A recent analysis of his election win by the Pew Research Center shows that he has built a diverse coalition of supporters from across Hispanic, Black and Asian communities and expanded his base of white, blue-collar, non-college educated voters. Extremism, as promoted by Trump, is now mainstream in the land of the free. Trump supporters in Scotland There may be thousands of Scots protesting his visit this weekend, screaming in anger about Gaza, the climate crisis and what they see as the damage Trump has done to the 'very principles of justice and humanity'. But the silent majority of voters will scarcely give the president's PR jaunt a second thought, and some will positively welcome him, pleased that he has singled out his mother's homeland for his first 'private' overseas visit since his election. Trump is often characterised by his opponents as a clown but, as he has shown, it is the politician who speaks directly to people in blunt, often politically 'incorrect' language who is more likely to succeed in today's unsettled and unsettling world. Voters, whether in Pennsylvania or Scotland, are disillusioned by career politicians who appear more interested in progressive issues like gender identity than everyday concerns such as the price of eggs or coffee. It was Trump's visceral appeal, more than his policy platform, that won him the popular vote last year, and it is not hard to imagine home-grown populists like Nigel Farage on the right and Jeremy Corbyn, with his new left-wing party, having a similar effect on Scottish voters. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad
