NYC carriage driver ‘ignored' signs of horse Ryder's distress before collapse: prosecutors
But driver Ian McKeever's lawyer shot back that the horse 'Ryder' merely 'tripped and fell' at the end of his shift on a sweltering summer day — and that his death months later was tragic, but not criminal.
'Make no mistake about it: Ryder's fall is heartbreaking, but the evidence in this case is not going to show that Ryder fell because Ian overdrove him,' defense attorney Raymond Loving argued.
Advertisement
3 Ryder the carriage horse died months after his sudden collapse on a Hells Kitchen street in August 2022.
Robert Miller
A jury of six Manhattanites heard the dueling narratives during opening statements at a trial where McKeever, 56, is charged with misdemeanor animal cruelty stemming from Ryder's August 10, 2022 collapse onto the hot pavement in the middle of West 45th Street and Ninth Avenue.
McKeever, an experienced horse driver, should have recognized that the malnourished Standardbred needed a break from lugging around his 100-pound carriage through Central Park, Assistant District Attorney Taylor Maurer contended.
Advertisement
3 Horse carriage driver Ian McKeever is charged with one misdemeanor count of animal cruelty in the episode.
Steven Hirsch
'Ryder couldn't tell the defendant with words that he was unfit to pull the carriage, but there are several signs and symptoms a horse exhibits when he is underweight and overworked,' the prosecutor said.
'His hip bones were protruding out. He was having difficulty scaling the mildest of hills in Central Park at a decent pace. Despite the defendant's zealous insistence, he was panting rapidly with his tongue hanging out,' Maurer added. 'But rather than recognize these signs of Ryder's distress…he worked Ryder for nearly eight hours in the intense heat of the day.'
3 NYPD officers tried to revive the fallen colt after he crumbled to the ground on the steamy summer day.
FNTV
Advertisement
Ryder's ordeal went viral after cellphone footage emerged of McKeever repeatedly trying to force the collapsed horse to stand back up by pulling on the reins. Ryder was sent in to retirement at an upstate farm following the episode, and was later euthanized after being diagnosed with serious medical ailments.
McKeever was arrested more than a year after the incident, in what he's called a 'political' response from Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg to pressure from animal rights activists.
The veteran horse handler will take the stand in his own defense, his lawyer Loving told the jury.
'Ian McKeever has been driving horses in Central Park for almost 20 years,' the attorney said. 'He's never been accused of mistreating a horse.'
Advertisement
Jurors heard Tuesday afternoon from Caroline Schmidt, a bystander who was in Central Park that day and took pictures of the malnourished horse out of concern, and Vincent Fontana, a sergeant in the NYPD's horse-riding Mounted Unit, who tried to revive the ailing steed after responding to the scene.
The trial will continue in Manhattan Supreme Court Wednesday morning.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Post
12 hours ago
- New York Post
Drunk teen killed groom-to-be in Harlem wrong-way horror after night out at NYC club, new suit alleges
The Long Island teen accused of driving the wrong-way on the Henry Hudson Parkway and killing a man 24 hours before the victim's wedding was allegedly drunk and being chased by an off-duty NYPD cop at the time of the crash. Jimmy Connors had allegedly spent the night drinking at Nebula on West 41st Street, where staff served him alcohol despite him being 'visibly intoxicated' in the hours before the horrific Aug. 24 collision, according to a lawsuit. After Connors, 17, left the club, he allegedly got behind the wheel of a white Chevy Silverado with Ontario plates and crashed into another car — prompting off-duty cop Boubacar Barry, who witnessed the wreck, to pursue him in his personal SUV instead of calling 911, according to the Manhattan Supreme Court filing. 4 Kirk Walker, a Manhattan dad of three, was just one day from marrying his fiancée when he was killed in the head-on crash. Advertisement Both vehicles then barreled south in the northbound lanes of the parkway, where the Silverado slammed head-on into a car driven by Kirk Walker and his cousin, Rob McLaurin, authorities said. Walker, 38, was one day from his wedding when he and McLaurin were killed. Walker and McLaurin had just left the groom-to-be's bachelor party and were driving north near West 154th Street in a Dodge Challenger when the 2:20 a.m. crash occurred, said Walker's fiancée, Shauntea Weaver, who filed the lawsuit this week against Connors, Barry, Nebula, the NYPD and the city. Advertisement Connors fled after the wreck, leaving behind his injured 21-year-old passenger. Police said the passenger tried to run but was caught 30 feet away. 4 The deadly 2:20 a.m. wreck happened as Walker and his cousin were returning from the groom-to-be's bachelor party. Post Mayor Eric Adams even put up $1,000 of his own money to help catch the suspect. Connors, of Syosset, was nabbed the next day at the Canadian border, limping, bloodied and without ID. Customs agents identified him using NYPD images that allegedly showed him bolting from the crash. Advertisement He was taken back to New York and indicted on charges including second-degree murder, manslaughter and leaving the scene of a fatal crash. He pleaded not guilty. His attorney Jonathan Perez previously told The Post that Connors is 'sick, autistic, has epilepsy' and believes he was manipulated by someone else in the car. Connors has been held without bail since his arraignment, the Manhattan District Attorney's office said. 4 Jimmy Connors, 17, was allegedly drunk and fleeing an off-duty NYPD officer when he drove the wrong way on the Henry Hudson Parkway, killing two men. Post Advertisement Walker, a Manhattan father of three and rental-car-business owner, was set to marry Weaver in a lavish New Jersey ceremony. 'Kirk was taken from me just as we were starting our new life together,' Weaver said in a statement released through her attorneys to The Post. 'He was the love of my life … We've been left trying to pick up the pieces of our lives and come to terms with a future without him in it. Our lives will never be the same.' Weaver, now the administrator of Walker's estate, argued in court papers that Barry acted as a cop — not a civilian — making the city and NYPD responsible for the unauthorized chase, which she contends isn't covered by emergency-response laws. Nebula also violated the state's Dram Shop Act, which allows victims to sue bars that serve alcohol to underage or visibly intoxicated patrons who later cause harm, Weaver said in the legal filing. 4 Walker's fiancée, Shauntea Weaver, is suing the city, NYPD, Nebula nightclub and Connors, alleging negligence and wrongful death. Weaver is seeking unspecified damages for wrongful death, conscious pain and suffering, negligence, emotional and psychological loss, funeral expenses and punitive damages. The NYPD and Nebula did not immediately respond to requests for comment. A spokesperson for the Mayor's Office referred questions to the NYPD. Advertisement Connors and Barry could not be reached for comment.
Yahoo
19 hours ago
- Yahoo
NYPD chief probed for allowing on-duty detective to care for cancer-stricken mom
NEW YORK — An unusual arrangement that allowed an NYPD detective to work for nearly a year on a special police detail assigned to her cancer-stricken mother has emerged as the trigger for an Internal Affairs investigation and may well have accelerated the retirement of Brooklyn North Chief Scott Henderson, the Daily News has learned. Henderson, a 30-year veteran who has led Brooklyn North since 2020, has come under scrutiny for allegedly allowing Detective Jaenice Smith, 51, to stay with her ailing mother, Barbara Ann Smith, the longtime president of Bushwick's 83rd Precinct Community Council, three law enforcement sources told The New York Daily News. Smith spent 11 months on the special detail before her mom died in December and three more months on bereavement leave. The investigation was triggered by an anonymous tip earlier this year that Jaenice Smith was not showing up to work. The NYPD then placed her on desk duty and demand the return of $150,000 in pay, the sources said. There has been no disciplinary action against Henderson. A 'walkout' – a ceremony used to honor retiring commanders – was initially scheduled for July 24 and then 'postponed,' the department confirmed — apparently by Henderson himself. The controversy has angered pastors and other supporters of Henderson, who oversees roughly 3,000 cops in the 10 precincts that make up Brooklyn North. They lay the blame for his retirement with Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch and Chief of Department John Chell. Rev. Kevin McCall, a Henderson ally, told The News plans are now underway for a community celebration of the chief's career. 'The community will host a walkout for our Chief Henderson and the Police Commissioner and John Chell (are) not invited,' McCall said. 'We will show the NYPD how you honor someone that served the community for 30 years.' An NYPD source said an investigation into allegations involving Henderson and Detective Smith is ongoing. A lawyer for Detective Smith declined comment. But a source familiar with the sequence of events said Detective Smith, once she came under scrutiny, explained to investigators that the arrangement was with 'the full permission and authority of Henderson.' The controversy started a couple of months ago with the anonymous tip that Smith wasn't coming to work at police headquarters where she was assigned. Investigators, the source said, have obtained 'countless' text messages verifying Henderson gave permission to her to be assigned to her mom because of her mom's 'critical role in NYPD community relations,' sources said. An attorney for Henderson did not immediately reply to a request for comment. Detective Smith's mother, Barbara Ann Smith, was so prominent in Bushwick as a president of the precinct community council that since her death at age 77 in December the precinct's muster room has been renamed in her honor. On July 14, 2025, the City Council also voted to rename Decatur St. between Central and Wilson Avenue as Barbara Ann Smith Way, a council spokesman said. 'Barbara worked tirelessly to bridge gaps, bring people together and make sure every voice was heard,' said Assemblymember Maritza Davila, a Democrat. Council Member Jennifer Gutierrez called her a 'true powerhouse and cherished community leader.' Detective Smith, meanwhile, joined the NYPD in July 2005. Across her 20-year career, she has been assigned to borough commands, the Personnel Bureau, Internal Affairs and Community Affairs before she was moved to Brooklyn North for the special detail. She had made 16 arrests in her career, three of them for felonies. In February 2024, when it was clear that Smith was gravely ill, Detective Smith was reassigned from her normal duties in Community Affairs to her mother's home, according to the sequence of events described by the sources. Smith's account, the sources said, is that Henderson assigned her to her mom via a Brooklyn North security detail without Smith initially asking for it. Once she began the new assignment, the sources said, she checked in regularly with the command. 'No one was hiding anything,' one police source said. 'All the supervisors were aware.' Meanwhile, police brass including then Chief of Department Jeffrey Maddrey and First Deputy Commissioner Tania Kinsella would visit from time to time, the sources said. After Barbara Smith died in December, her daughter was given another three months of bereavement leave. In the meantime, the Internal Affairs investigation started. Detective Smith was relieved of her guns and shield and placed on desk duty in Queens Courts on March 27. The NYPD filed disciplinary charges for stealing time and demanded she repay the $150,000 in salary she earned during the period she was assigned to her mom. Those charges are pending. After Smith disclosed that Henderson had approved the special assignment, investigators questioned him. He allegedly 'downplayed' his role in approving the assignment, the sources said. Smith's lawyers are pushing for her to be allowed to retire later this month. 'She's upset they are taking such a hard line on this,' a source familiar with the case said. 'She thought when the head of the borough approved it, she could rely on that.'
Yahoo
a day ago
- Yahoo
New York City police charge mother in the deaths of newborn twins found behind a building in 2020
NEW YORK (AP) — A 36-year-old woman was charged Friday in the deaths of newborn twins who were found behind a New York City apartment building nearly five years ago, police said. Stephanie Castillo, identified as the boys' mother, was arrested at a homeless shelter in the Bronx, police said. She is charged with murder and manslaughter. The superintendent of a Bronx apartment building discovered the boys' bodies on Nov. 9, 2020, in the building's courtyard. The Medical Examiner determined the babies died from blunt force trauma. It was unknown whether Castillo, who was in custody Friday, had an attorney who could comment on her behalf. The case weighed heavily on New York City police officers, who were still looking for the person responsible for the babies' deaths when they were laid to rest nearly a year later. Police officers organized a funeral service for the infants, whom they named Zeke and Zane. They were placed in a single white casket, with officers serving as pallbearers at the service. 'You look at the way that the DNA technology has progressed over the last couple of years, and we are at the forefront of it,' Assistant Chief Michael Baldassano told 1010 Wins radio after the arrest. 'This case speaks to that.' Details of the investigation that led to Castillo's arrest were not immediately released.
