Ministers ‘pushed ahead too fast' on welfare reform, says Phillipson
Ms Phillipson told the BBC's Sunday With Laura Kuenssberg programme that she was 'not going to pretend that it hasn't been a tough or a challenging week' after ministers were forced to scrap their plans for the personal independence payment (Pip) in the face of a backbench revolt.
'I'd be the first to acknowledge that, both in the pace and the nature of what we set out, we didn't get it right, but we do need to reform the system we've got,' she said.
Asked about the Prime Minister's authority, the Education Secretary said: 'What the Prime Minister has said, and what I also believe, is that what we set out, we pushed ahead too fast, we didn't listen enough to people, including, I would say, including to lots of people who had concerns about the nature of that change.'
Ministers have warned MPs that there will be financial consequences to the decision not to reform Pip as planned.
Labour backbenchers have also been pushing for the Government to scrap the two-child benefit cap.
When asked if there was now less chance of the cap being scrapped given the costs that come with Tuesday's decision, Ms Phillipson told the BBC that ministers were 'looking at every lever and we'll continue to look at every lever to lift children out of poverty'.
Pushed on whether the likelihood of the cap going was now slimmer, Ms Phillipson said: 'The decisions that have been taken in the last week do make decisions, future decisions harder.
'But all of that said, we will look at this collectively in terms of all of the ways that we can lift children out of poverty.'
Meanwhile, shadow chancellor Sir Mel Stride had written to the budget watchdog asking whether a new updated fiscal forecast was in the works after Labour's U-turns on welfare and winter fuel.
I've written to the @OBR_UK seeking urgent clarity on the multi-billion pound hole created by Labour's unfunded spending commitments. When governments lose control of the finances and transparency is sidelined, confidence in our economy is put at risk.
Parliament and the public… pic.twitter.com/2jEzjC4vGa
— Mel Stride (@MelJStride) July 6, 2025
In his letter to the Office for Budget Responsibility, Sir Mel said: 'The public, Parliament and markets deserve clarity and transparency about the impact of recent events on the nation's finances and the Government's fiscal strategy.'
The Conservatives will try to change the Government's welfare Bill to tighten up access to Pip and universal credit by laying a series of amendments this week.
Tory leader Kemi Badenoch will also pledge that the Tories are 'now the only party committed to serious welfare reform' in a speech expected on Thursday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The National
25 minutes ago
- The National
Mhairi Black: UK is following a familiar script over Gaza
On Thursday, at least 15 Palestinians – of which eight were children – were killed in an Israeli strike while queuing for nutritional supplements in front of a clinic in central Gaza. For more than 20 months, Israel has decimated Gaza with unconditional and unrestrained bombardment, and has created a man-made famine. Israeli strikes have continually targeted schools, hospitals and aid centres – all of which constitute war crimes. Yet, if you watched the UK news over the last two weeks, you might think the biggest horror facing the world right now was two bands performing at Glastonbury. READ MORE: TRNSMT main stage act calls out politicians' attempts to cancel Kneecap A report from Al Jazeera said there are satellite images showing Israeli plans to create a concentration camp in southern Gaza. The images show large tracts of land being cleared of buildings in preparation for the forced transfer of Palestinians. We know to expect this since Israel's defence minister has said it is its intention to forcibly move the entire population of Gaza – more than two million people – out of their homes. Given the atrocities inflicted upon Jewish people during the Second World War, you would expect there to be a natural degree of horror at the thought of building new concentration camps, and forcibly seeking to move or destroy an entire group of people. Of course, there is a deep history and link between the experiences and historic persecution of Jews and the creation of the state of Israel. However, it is crucial to remember that Israel is exactly that – a state. It is not a religion. Yet, our leaders in Britain continually capitulate to the idea that to criticise the actions of the Israeli government in any way is antisemitic. For example, the BBC claims to be an impartial source of news and a beacon of free speech, yet was more than happy to de-platform the unapologetically pro-Palestine band Kneecap on the basis that they are pro-Palestine. The BBC also apologised for broadcasting punk rap duo Bob Vylan's performance after the singer's 'death to the IDF' chants. You may find this distasteful or even violent but it is not antisemitic. The IDF is a military organisation, not a religion. It is a war machine used by Israel to commit war crimes. Calling for an end to a military organisation that consistently murders innocent civilians fleeing violence perpetrated against them by that very military organisation should not be controversial. The very fact that Keir Starmer, Kemi Badenoch and Nigel Farage are all more outraged about bands playing Glastonbury than they are at the genocide of the people of Gaza is as barbaric as it is illogical. READ MORE: Protests against Palestine Action ban set to take place this weekend However, when you consider the history of Britain's actions in the world, maybe it is logical? Its history is littered with examples of invading foreign countries to force our will and propaganda onto them, while extracting and profiteering from their wealth and resources at their expense. Any domestic resistance to this exploitation has always been immediately labelled as terrorism. Even if we only consider events from living memory, there were the mass arrests, torture and murders of Mau Mau leaders in Kenya in the 1950s. Up until 1960, in Malaya (now Malaysia), British forces herded hundreds of thousands of people into fortified camps. They heavily bombed rural areas, tortured and murdered innocent civilians for no reason other than to preserve the colonial profits Britain enjoyed from Malaya's rubber and tin. Cocoa and oil were extracted from Nigeria through exploitation. In South Africa, black labour was responsible for British diamond profits under apartheid. In Canada and Australia, indigenous kids were forcibly removed from their families to learn how to live 'sophisticatedly'. The UK's military interventions in Syria, Iraq and Afghanistan just so happened to coincide with our oil and gas interests. Through the actions in both Ireland and India, we know that Britain is no stranger to creating a man-made famine. Britain has always been the portrait of privilege built by the pain of others. Modern-day Britain refuses to acknowledge or learn from the racist and imperialist mistakes of the past, mainly because those in power do not view them as mistakes. Our history is soaked with elitism, and the blood and tears of foreign generations whose toil sustained that elitism. The UK still thinks of itself as an imperial world power, able to divvy up land and resources to whoever it pleases, when the reality is that the world has moved on. Today – July 12 – Northern Ireland will see multiple Orange marches similar to the ones held in the west of Scotland last week. READ MORE: How TRNSMT's gender balance is shaping up in 2025 – see the graphs It is difficult to take Starmer and John Swinney seriously when they call for bands like Kneecap and Bob Vylan to be cancelled for an alleged, perceived religious intolerance when they criticise Israel when, simultaneously, local councils are granting marching licences for an organisation whose followers routinely sing chants about being 'up to their knees in Fenian blood', and have built a bonfire with a mock migrant boat filled with brown faces at the very top waiting to be set alight. The hypocrisy and double standards are bewildering. Maybe it is time to stop looking for logic and instead look for – and reward – honesty and bravery.
The National
26 minutes ago
- The National
SNP have morphed into a shadow of the party they should be
I say 'repeat' as in the immediate post-World War Two period the then Labour secretary of state for Scotland, the commendable Tom Johnston, had a vision to build hydro dams in both the Highlands and south-west Scotland to provide cheap local energy which could be harnessed to create industrial activities and well-paid jobs in both regions, addressing the scourge of depopulation. The dams were built but the promise of cheap local electricity was never delivered. Once his plan was known to London, he was told 'oh no dear boy, it must all go into the National Grid'. No competitive advantage could be delivered to these areas of Scotland – what a naive plan. Scots – well nearly 50% of them, as yet – have still not woken up to the new post-Brexit regime in Westminster. It matters not whether that regime is Labour, Tory, Liberal or very soon likely Reform UK. There is no 'UK' in any of their thinking. This is the new 'Little England' post-Brexit nation. Starmer, when he agreed – well I should say 'accepted' – the recent trade terms with 'The Donald', announced on camera 'this is an important agreement for both our countries, England and America'. This was no slip of the tongue, that is their collective thinking, post-Brexit. They, meaning our southern neighbour, didn't just vote to leave Europe, their utopia is in the green and pleasant lands of England where, if Scotland exists at all, she is their colony to be exploited for all her resources and 'free gratis'. At the end of her informative article 'Why have the SNP consistently missed an opportunity with zonal energy pricing' (Jul 10), Lesley Riddoch asks: 'Who is making this political argument? Not the SNP, why the heck not?' The answer is surely 'ineptitude'. The SNP leadership appear to be ignorant of the benefits that zonal pricing would bring, not just to domestic users, but in helping Scotland rebuild an industrial capability. This, with zonal pricing, could be implemented now under devolution. Similarly, where was the outcry over Grangemouth? Why did the SNP not walk out of Westminster en masse after Brexit? Our friends in Europe expected us to, but no, and then the long list of unpopular English prime ministers, from the liar Boris Johnson, Liz Truss, 'now is not the time' Theresa May, Sunak, Sir Keir Starmer and waiting in the wings Nigel Farage. No opportunities were developed during these periods of great opportunity for the independence movement; the leadership of the SNP wasted every one of them. It is perhaps summed up best by Edwin Morgan, our great poet laureate who wrote, on the opening of the Scottish Parliament with such great promise, on October 9 2004: 'What do the people want of this place? They want it to be filled with thinking persons as open and adventurous as its architecture. 'A nest of fearties is what they do not want. 'A symposium of procrastinators is what they do not want. 'A phalanx of forelock-tuggers is what they do not want. And perhaps above all the droopy mantra of 'it wizny me' is what they do not want.' Well Lesley, there is your answer. It is exactly where we are with the current SNP leadership, exactly what Edwin cautioned us and our parliament to avoid, with John Swinney as the Chief Feartie in charge. Congratulations, John. A leadership with no vision for independence, no ambition to get us there, and not even a whimper at the ongoing, and deliberate, deindustrialisation of Scotland. 'Grangemouth no more, Falkirk no more!' The SNP have morphed into a shadow of the party they should be. People see through it. Shameful. We need radicalism, outrage, passion, and most of all new leadership. Ian Stewart Uig, Isle of Skye I AGREE with a lot of what Nick Cole said in his letter on Thursday, July 10, but he had at least two major omissions. Alex Salmond was in fact stitched up by SNP, so had a right to speak out against them. The SNP pushing gender recognition reform when they knew fine well it would split the indy vote was deliberate, as proven by them getting rid of those who would push for independence. Tim Rideout and Joanna Cherry spring to mind, but there were others. So the current version of SNP did nothing for a decade, and still does nothing except get rid of indy folk. The fact the party doesn't support the case at UN or adopting the UN charter on self-determination says it all. The real SNP that wanted independence has been hijacked by devolutionists. They likely supported indy at some point, but the salary and perks are too good to risk now. So although I'm desperate for independence, I'm not going to vote for the SNP to do nowt for another decade. If they don't get concrete plans on the board to go ahead without Westminster agreement if necessary, many Scots won't vote for them. Nick would do better for cause and party if he focused on why the SNP are not keen to proceed, and helped get them out of the party. A new NEC, and out with those who never mention independence. That's the cure for all SNP's woes, so what's stopping them? Grangemouth shows the long game is no longer a viable option so the best way to secure the party's future is to push ahead with indy. Voters who trusted them to act won't let them just be a devolution party. The biggest dividers of the indy vote in my opinion are gender recognition reform and SNP inaction on the supposed main goal. Heartbreaking, so it is. Bill Robertson via email
Daily Record
an hour ago
- Daily Record
Pubs in Scotland continue to struggle despite heatwave boost for businesses
EXCLUSIVE: Hospitality chiefs have called on the SNP Government to reform the business rates system which puts bars north of the Border at a "competitive disadvantage" to those in England. Pubs across Scotland are continuing to struggle due to rising costs despite enjoying a bumper weekend as a heatwave grips the country. Hospitality chiefs have today called on the SNP Government to reform the business rates system which puts bars north of the Border at a "competitive disadvantage" compared to those in England. UKHospitality Scotland, which represents members of the licensed trade, said the industry was being squeezed by sky-high energy bills and the impact of employer National Insurance contributions (NICs) being hiked by the UK Government. The trade body warned pubs and bars were now shedding jobs as a result of the NIC hike and is demanding a rethink ahead of the autumn Budget. Pubs are currently closing across Britain at a rate of one a day. The Record previously revealed how 56 bars closed for good in Scotland last year, compared to 42 that shut down in 2023. Around 1,000 pubs have closed north of the border over the last 20 years, with the total dropping from the more than 5,000 operating in 2004. In a letter to Keir Starmer, the trade body warned the 2024 Budget had directly contributed to a reversal in hospitality's ability to create jobs. Between October 2024 and May 2025, the sector lost 69,000 jobs across the UK. In the same period the previous year, hospitality created an additional 18,000 jobs. Leon Thompson, Executive Director of UKHospitality Scotland, said: "The damaging impact of increasing employer National Insurance contributions (NICs) is being felt by businesses and teams across Scotland, with thousands of Scottish hospitality jobs undoubtedly lost since the Budget. "While the damage caused by employer NICs was a decision made in Westminster, we still need Holyrood to step up and back our businesses with vital support. "The Scottish Government needs to speed up in delivering its promise to reform the broken business rates system, before it's too late and Scottish businesses are put at a further competitive disadvantage to those in England. "It's also critical that the Scottish Government maintains and extends business rates relief for the sector at the Scottish Budget later this year - this is the lifeline our venues need." Kate Nicholls, chair of UKHospitality, said: "In the years following the financial crisis we created one in five net new jobs and today employ 3.5 million people. The Government needs sectors like hospitality to create jobs and meet their ambition to get more people back into work. "We have a proven track record of being able to deliver those jobs in every part of the country and for people from all backgrounds. "The NICs change was socially regressive and had a disproportionate effect on entry level jobs." Shona Robison, the Finance Secretary, said: "Businesses are being hit by the impact of the UK Government's decision to raise employers' National Insurance contributions and rising energy costs continue to bite hard. "While many levers to grow Scotland's economy lie with the UK Government, we are providing a package of non-domestic rates reliefs worth an estimated £733 million in 2025-26, including 40% relief – capped at £110,000 per business – for hospitality premises liable for the Basic Property Rate. "Around half of properties in the retail, hospitality and leisure sectors also continue to be eligible for 100% Small Business Bonus Scheme relief – the most generous small business rates relief in the UK.'
