Moment carer throws dementia-stricken man, 88, around ‘like a rag doll' & threatens to ‘beat him up' before his death
Cruel Bilikesu Olagunju, 42, was caught on CCTV manhandling the pensioner like a "rag doll" in his own home in Bexley, Kent.
15
15
15
Disturbing footage, captured on Christmas Eve in 2022, shows 88-year-old John Attard being stripped naked and dragged across his living room floor during a horrifying 45 minute visit.
Woolwich Crown Court heard Olagunju, who was employed by Unique Personnel (Ltd) UK at the time, threatened to beat John up and ignored him as he repeatedly told her she was "hurting" him.
At one point she tells him: "Maybe I will beat you up. I will flog you.
"I will take you to the GP to get injections. I will call the police on you."
The following day, Mr Attard was found unresponsive - with blood dripping down the side of his face.
The pensioner was rushed to hospital, where he remained unresponsive, and tragically died ten days after the incident.
The horrific ordeal - that his family say he never recovered from - was captured on a camera set up by the great grandfather's son, Chris.
She goes on to taunt Mr Attard in the footage by pouring marmalade into his coffee despite knowing he was diabetic and threatening to 'flog' him - a slang term for 'beating him up.'
Chris told he was horrified by how visibly distressed his dad looked throughout the ordeal and described his face as "distorted" as he was being "manhandled."
Chris said: "She is physically trying to lift him like a rag doll. His face indicates the discomfort and pain he is feeling.
"She lifts him off the floor, dragging him toward his armchair. He tells her 'my head is banging'."
The carer is repeatedly told by John throughout: "You are hurting me".
The court also heard a breakdown of the footage, that starts when Olagunju arrives at 11.20am with the job of washing him and making him some breakfast.
After shouting at him to stand, he slips on the floor and as she struggles to dress him, she is seen stripping him naked in front of a window in full view of the street.
The carer is also seen dragging him by the arm and scruff of his collar across the floor and "yanking" him up, causing him "great distress".
At one point, the defendant is heard calling her employer to explain that John was on the floor.
She was advised not to touch him and to call an ambulance.
The defendant ignores this request, and instead continued to yank John up herself while complaining "a man" should have been sent to do the job.
Olagunju is shown making breakfast as she continues to threaten violence.
She picks up a plastic marmalade sachet and squeezes its entire contents into his coffee.
John's table is then pulled away from him, making it hard for him to reach any of the food and spilling hot coffee on him in the process.
As she leaves the house, she tells him, "Bye, I will report you to the police".
15
15
15
During Olagunju's sentencing, Prosecutor James Benson said her conduct towards Mr Attard had taken multiple forms including "rough handling, verbal aggression, and degrading treatment."
Chris said the the following day, Christmas morning, he found his father unresponsive with blood on his lips.
He added: "I called 999 for an ambulance.
"My wife and I were distraught at his condition and felt the carer's actions were solely responsible for this.
"The autopsy could not conclusively prove the carer was responsible.
"But the autopsy showed he had bruising on the left side of his chest."
During the sentencing hearing, Mr Benson described her actions as "brusque, inappropriate, and uncaring" and said she "played on her victim's vulnerability".
Woolwich Crown Court also heard a victim impact statement from Chris, who broke down in tears.
He added: "It was Christmas morning when I found my 88-year-old father unresponsive in bed.
"He was rushed to hospital and his room was declared a crime scene.
"This was the morning after he was physically and verbally assaulted by the very person entrusted to care for him.
"Three days after he was admitted to hospital I wrote a victim impact statement. My last words read: 'I am yet to discover the long-term effect this may have on my dad, and his physical and mental welfare'.
15
15
15
"Well, now I know - he never recovered and died seven days later in hospital.
"An autopsy could not link your actions to his death - but I feel personally that your actions contributed to his sudden death".
Addressing Olagunju, Chris continued: "When all of this becomes a distant memory for you, our pain will still be here.
"You can never ever take back the memories you left my father with at the end of his life, and the memories you have now left us with, for the rest of our lives.
"If you find it hard to understand how I feel, then just imagine it was me assaulting your loved one on that CCTV.
"Imagine I'm the one standing where you are now - what sentence would you like this court to give me?"
"For a very long time I was unable to get a full night's sleep due to dissecting the CCTV over-and-over again in my head.
"I constantly thought about the fear he must have felt - the indignity of being dragged around and then yanked up off the floor and unceremoniously thrown back onto his chair.
"That must have been very distressing for him."
Chris described his father, who had five children, 11 grandchildren, and seven great-grandchildren, as "kind-hearted, generous, compassionate, and funny".
"He was still enjoying what life he had left," Chris added.
Olagunju, of Abbey Wood, wearing a light blue satin shirt and jeans, cried silently during the emotional statement.
15
15
15
John was her first assignment as a care worker in the UK.
During sentencing, Judge Charlotte Welsh told her: "Frankly it beggars belief that someone would be allocated an elderly man with dementia as their first client.
"Being a carer is a very, very difficult job and frankly people don't appreciate it until they need it.
"I am convinced that you had not received the sufficient training."
"Your actions are evident of your failure to treat Mr Attard as a person deserving of as much dignity and respect as the rest of us.
"I accept that there was no malicious intent to your actions and you show genuine remorse. But none of this will help Mr Attard's family.
"They have lost a father, grandfather, and great-grandfather, and their memories of him are now tainted by what they have seen on the CCTV footage - and the way you behaved towards him."
Olagunju's defence barrister Mr Tijani said she accepted full responsibility for her conduct and was "ashamed" of how she had acted.
He continued: "She accepts that she failed in her duty as a carer.
"She has been suffering from mental anguish as a result of this incident and has instructed me to tell the family she is very sorry."
In mitigation, Mr Tijani said Olagunju had no previous convictions and that Mr Attard had been her first patient, after arriving in the UK from abroad to be a carer.
"On the CCTV, you can see a woman who was not trained properly to deal with the situation she was faced with," Mr Tijani added.
15
15
Olagunju pleaded guilty to one count of ill-treating or willfully neglecting an individual whilst acting as a care worker.
She was given a six week sentence, suspended for 18 months, along with 50 hours unpaid work, at Woolwich Crown Court.
Speaking after the hearing, Chris, who blasted the lenient sentence as an "insult".
He fumed: "If those cameras had not been there, that person could still be out there treating elderly people like this.
"I was expecting a suspended sentence but the length and community service aspect is an insult.
"What kind of a deterrent is that?"
He added: "From now on that woman is out of my head, and my mission is to expose this company - Unique Personnel.
"They should have been in the dock alongside [Olagunju].
"Had they done their due diligence she never would have been sent near an elderly person.
"This is a care company sending people to the homes of elderly and vulnerable people and putting them at risk of harm.
"I want to speak about that so this doesn't happen to anyone else."
"They tried to excuse it by saying she had only been there six days. But where were the checks and the training?"
Unique Personnel has been contacted for comment.
15
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
42 minutes ago
- The Independent
‘Smell detectors' and AI cameras to be considered to monitor criminals
Cameras fitted in offenders' homes and 'smell detectors' to catch out drug use in and outside of prison could be introduced as new technology to monitor criminals and curb reoffending. Tech companies pitched devices to prisons and probation minister James Timpson on Tuesday, as ministers seek to overhaul the justice system. A smell detector likened to the human nose, which uses synthetic brain cells and artificial intelligence to detect drugs such as spice or fentanyl, was among the proposals to be used in prisons and probation offices. It could improve staff safety and also help detect if an offender in the community has breached licence conditions. Companies developing artificial intelligence home monitoring were among the seven finalists of 90 submissions selected for the process. AI cameras could be set up in homes of offenders in the community to check their behaviour on licence. It comes as Justice Secretary Shabana Mahmood has said emerging technology has the potential to 'impose a digital prison outside of prison'. The Government has accepted recommendations from the independent sentencing review to tackle overcrowding behind bars, which will see fewer criminals jailed and more serving sentences in the community. Lord Timpson said: 'We inherited a justice system in crisis and in need of reform. Prisons and probation are working in analogue while tech drives forward a new digital age. 'That's why we have invited companies to present bold new ideas to help us deliver tough punishment and enhanced surveillance. 'Embracing new technologies will help us to protect victims, reduce reoffending and cut crime as part of our plan for change.' Other pitched tech ideas included software to help staff consistently input information on offenders and transcription tools to cut administrative tasks. Successful proposals will be considered to be rolled out under pilot schemes. Decisions on the plans are expected over the coming months.
Daily Mail
43 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
EXCLUSIVE Prosecutors are looking at charging serial killer nurse Lucy Letby with MORE baby murders
Detectives investigating child killer Lucy Letby have passed a file of evidence to prosecutors alleging she murdered and harmed more babies. The Mail understands there are more than a dozen potential offences included in the file, which the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) last night confirmed would be examined to see whether she should be charged with more crimes. That process is expected to take several weeks and involve consultation with the most senior legal brains in the country, including Stephen Parkinson, the director of public prosecutions, and Lord Richard Hermer KC, the Attorney General. The news emerged hours after Cheshire Police confirmed it had arrested three senior executives who worked at the Countess of Chester Hospital, where Letby carried out her 13-month killing spree, on suspicion of gross negligence manslaughter. The unnamed managers were quizzed at separate police stations in Cheshire for several hours before being bailed pending further enquiries on Monday. Their arrests form part of Cheshire Constabulary's parallel investigation into corporate manslaughter at the NHS Trust, but it is understood that prosecutors have not yet been asked to offer advice in connection with that second inquiry. Letby, 35, is currently serving 15 whole life terms for the murder of seven babies and attempted murder of seven more - one of whom she attacked twice - at the hospital's neo-natal unit, between June 2015 and June 2016. In December, Cheshire police confirmed that the serial killer had been questioned in prison in connection with more murders and attempted murders at both the Countess of Chester Hospital and Liverpool Women's Hospital, where she underwent two periods of training. Police are examining 4,000 babies Letby cared for between January 2012 and July 2016 The Trial of Lucy Letby: The Inquiry Listen and follow on Spotify and Apple Podcasts now. As part of their ongoing inquiry, codenamed Operation Hummingbird, detectives have been examining the cases of 4,000 infants she cared for during the 'footprint' of her nursing career, which dates back to January 2012, and includes two student placements she undertook at the Liverpool Trust, in 2012 and 2015. However, the handing over of evidence to the CPS is a significant milestone in their investigation. A spokesman for the CPS said: 'We can confirm that we have received a full file of evidence from Cheshire Constabulary asking us to consider further allegations in relation to deaths and non-fatal collapses of babies at the Countess of Chester Hospital and Liverpool Women's Hospital. 'We will now carefully consider the evidence to determine whether any further criminal charges should be brought. 'As always, we will make that decision independently, based on the evidence and in line with our legal test.' According to an independent report, leaked to the Mail's Trial+ podcast, Letby was on duty, or had been working the shift prior, for 12 of 13 baby deaths that occurred at the Countess between April 2015 and July 2016. In November, Dr Stephen Brearey, the senior paediatrician on the hospital's neo-natal unit, told the public inquiry investigating Letby's crimes that he believed she 'likely' murdered or attacked more babies before she killed her first victim, a premature twin boy known as Baby A, in June 2015. He said, looking back, he now had suspicions about other deaths and collapses, which at the time staff believed were due to natural causes. Dr Rachel Lambie, who worked as a registrar at the Countess, also told the Thirlwall Inquiry that around a fortnight before Baby A died another 'very, very unusual event' occurred on the ward. Although she didn't go into detail, the medic confirmed she has since given a statement to detectives about the incident. During the hearings, at Liverpool Town Hall, it also emerged that babies' breathing tubes became dislodged on 40 per cent of shifts Letby worked at Liverpool Women's Hospital, between October and December 2012, and January and February 2015. According to the BBC, babies suffered potentially life-threatening incidents on almost a third of the 33 shifts she was on duty while training at the Trust. In one case, from November 2012, a baby boy she was caring for collapsed and water was later discovered in his breathing tube, which experts say is highly irregular. Dr Dewi Evans, the former lead prosecution witness at Letby's original trial, also previously told the Mail he had concerns over the deaths of at least three children and the collapses of as many as 15 more, including one potentially poisoned with insulin, all of which were not included on the original indictment. He said he had suspicions that Letby experimented with moving babies' breathing tubes as a method of causing harm before she began injecting air into their bloodstreams, or into their tummies via their nasal feeding tubes in a bid to kill. 'One thing we can be reasonably sure of is that Lucy Letby did not turn up to work one day and decide to inject a baby with air into their bloodstream,' Dr Evans said. 'I think the modus operandi evolved over time and I think that prior to air embolus tube displacement was probably something that she did.' Neonatologist Professor Neena Modi, Letby's barrister Mark McDonald, Sir David Davis MP and retired medic Dr Shoo Lee, during a press conference to announce 'new medical evidence' which they say casts doubts on her convictions The BBC's Panorama programme also claimed to have seen evidence that a baby boy, whose case was not included in the original trial, was potentially poisoned with insulin in November 2015. Letby was convicted of attempting to murder two children on the unit by administering the drug into their drips, in August 2015 and April 2016. Letby, formerly of Hereford, has always maintained her innocence but two applications for leave to appeal her convictions have already been refused by the Court of Appeal. In February her new legal team presented reports from a panel of 14 international experts which, they say, casts doubt on the jury's guilty verdicts. Led by Canadian neonatologist, Dr Shoo Lee, the panel said no murders took place at the Countess and instead babies collapsed or died because of natural causes or poor care. In April, their findings, plus that of another 12 experts, were submitted to the Criminal Cases Review Commission, the body that investigates potential miscarriages of justice. It subsequently confirmed it is examining whether her case should be sent to the Court of Appeal for a third time. A spokesman for Cheshire Police said: 'We can confirm that Cheshire Constabulary has submitted a full file of evidence to the CPS for charging advice regarding the ongoing investigation into deaths and non-fatal collapses of babies at the neo-natal units of both the Countess of Chester Hospital and the Liverpool Women's Hospital as part of Operation Hummingbird.'
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
CHRISTOPHER STEVENS reviews To Catch A Stalker: This stalking exposé ramped up the emotion but left out the facts
To Catch A Stalker That's the gulf between Gen Z and the rest of us. It's not the lip fillers, nor the fact you probably remember Zara McDermott from Strictly Come Dancing instead of Love Island. What makes the gap unbridgeable is her technique for slicing pizza. She uses scissors. And she's proud of it. 'It's a good idea, to be fair,' she crowed, snipping up her evening meal as she chatted to a harassment victim on To Catch A Stalker. 'I cut loads of things with scissors: bacon, cheese . . .' What's wrong with a knife and fork? It's true many parents now regard it as harmful, even abusive, to ask their children to help with household chores. But is it too oppressive to teach them to use cutlery? Zara was visiting Jen, a recruitment consultant whose life is being made hell by a man she met once, in 2022, when he answered a job advert. Since then, he has bombarded her with bizarre and sometimes threatening messages, from declarations of undying love to creepy sexual fantasies. According to the Office for National Statistics, 80 per cent of victims are female, and more than 20 per cent of women in Britain have experienced stalking — two statistics that Zara didn't think to mention. Jen's tormentor has been jailed three times for stalking her, and was sectioned in a psychiatric unit following his latest release. But Jen still lives in terror: the hospital is just 20 minutes drive from her home. Clearly, he is mentally ill and requires treatment, but it's inexplicable that his health needs are apparently being prioritised over Jen's safety. Police have told her to 'use your common sense' to avoid being attacked, and this dismissive attitude seems typical of that displayed by many forces. Perhaps we shouldn't be overly surprised: in the past two years, officers from Avon and Somerset police, the Met and North Yorkshire have admitted charges of stalking. Zara didn't tell us that either, but this two-part documentary, aired as a 90-minute double bill on both BBC1 and BBC3, was more concerned with the emotional context than data and stats. When Jen promised she would try not to cry, Zara assured her, 'No, honestly, it's not a problem.' In an ill-judged effort to heighten this sense of vulnerability, the camera kept zooming in so tightly on faces that the women's eyes and mouths filled the screen. Perhaps this is effective if you're watching on a phone, but the result is bizarre on a widescreen telly. The show tipped over into melodrama when Zara spent a night at one woman's home, waiting to see if her ex would come and lurk in the bushes outside. Whispering urgently in the darkness, Zara could have been presenting a ghost-hunting foray. The stalker failed to show up, and there was no paranormal activity either.
