Ex-councillor refusing to pay gorse bill share
Karen Arnold has been embroiled in a battle with the Invercargill City Council since 2022, when her section at Theodore St, Bluff, began failing inspections due to overgrowth.
A report prepared for a March hearing showed it had drawn three "request for service" complaints and failed eight of 10 inspections.
But Ms Arnold disputes the issue, saying compliance notices from the council were unlawful and breached the New Zealand Bill of Rights.
Ms Arnold said she would not pay her share of a $5320 bill for council contractors clearing the section following an October 2022 bylaw notice, despite receiving monthly reminders.
"They keep sending it out. I've ignored it."
Council group manager consenting and environment Jonathan Shaw said a decision was made to split the cost 50:50 with Ms Arnold when she met the council in January last year.
The section was also the subject of a council hearing in March where Ms Arnold unsuccessfully appealed a bylaw notice from December last year.
Although the panel accepted it was unhelpful gorse existed on co-owned council land at the boundary of the property, removal still rested with the owner.
"They say that it's got to be cleared again, and I'm not going to do it and so it's going to be the same thing," Ms Arnold said.
"They'll go and clear it and then they'll charge me."
The section backs on to Bluff Hill/Motupōhue, which is co-owned by the council and Department of Conservation.
Ms Arnold claims the council conceded it had failed on a range of issues at a January 2024 meeting where the council's chief executive and lawyer were present.
That included that two compliance notices in 2022 and one from 2023 were unlawful and breached the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act, that the council did not manage its gorse under the regional pest management plan until prompted and that it had a conflict of interest in dealing with her concerns.
In response to questions, Mr Shaw said the council did not accept gorse was not being managed on its land at Bluff Hill prior to Ms Arnold's complaint.
The cancellation of a December 2023 notice for procedural reasons did not mean the compliance problems raised in the original notice were invalid, Mr Shaw said.
Two councillors on the hearing panel declared conflicts of interest but felt it did not warrant them stepping aside, he added.
"The council staff involved in the decision considered the issues raised by Ms Arnold on each occasion in a fair and balanced manner.
"This included preparing for and attending the hearing, which Arnold chose to leave partway through."
Ms Arnold was elected to the council in 2013 and 2016, but stood down near the end of her second term.
She was declared bankrupt in 2018 after losing a defamation suit against Stuff and then-mayor Sir Tim Shadbolt, RNZ reported.
• LDR is local body journalism co-funded by RNZ and NZ On Air.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
11 hours ago
- RNZ News
Auckland City Rail Link maps go up at Britomart
Photo: RNZ/Calvin Samuel A glimpse of a new era in Auckland Transport was unveiled on Monday. At Britomart Station, an updated map gives commuters a preview of the new stations and rail lines it will use when the long-awaited City Rail Link (CRL) opens. The over-budget and over-time CRL is nearing completion, but officials are not ready yet to say exactly when it will open. Auckland's Onehunga, Eastern, Western and Southern lines are being replaced by the Onehunga-West line, the East-West line and the South-City line, new routes detailed in the new map. It is hoped the re-configured network will make it easier for Aucklanders to get around town, as more trains run from more stations - like ones near Karangahape Road and in Mt Eden - more frequently, and link with express buses. Work began on the $5.5 billion CRL in 2017. It was due to be completed last year, and its initial cost was expected to be between $2b and $3b . Auckland Transport chief executive Dean Kimpton said capacity on the network had been boosted. "Currently at peak into the city, we have about 12,000 people per hour," Kimpton said. "The capacity we're creating though the new CRL, day one, will be up to 19,000. Quite the number of people will depend on demand, but we have that capacity ready and available to go." Dean Kimpton unveils the new CRL transport map at Britomart, August 2025. Photo: Finn Blackwell / RNZ Parts of Auckland's rail network had been temporarily closed this year for upgrades ahead of the CRL opening, causing significant disruption. Kimpton said the work was necessary. "We have got very specific planned disruption between our CRL-go-live, and that's designed to bring the network up to a standard to support the frequency that CRL anticipates, and that's the rail network rebuild programme." KiwiRail programme director Bobby Fischer said the short-term pain for commuters was part of a bigger picture. "We're going through a significant period of investment in the network that is all in the lead up to CRL opening, once the CRL is open that level of disruption will reduce significantly." She said KiwiRail has run more than 1600 test trains on the network since February. Photo: RNZ/Calvin Samuel "There's a lot of system testing that's going on, from the signalling system right through to the station system - so the emergency systems testing, ventilation system etcetera, to make sure that when we open everything operates seamlessly as it's meant to," Fischer said. Auckland Councillor Andy Baker said the CRL build had been big for the city. "Politicians we're always pretty keen to find something to grizzle about," he said. "But I think there is, underneath it all, a level of excitement and acceptance that this is what it is." As for an exact date for next year's opening, Kimpton said that was still up in the air. "There's still a lot to be done, and we don't want to promise a date until we're ready to promise a date, but you can be sure when we know, you'll know." Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Otago Daily Times
13 hours ago
- Otago Daily Times
Unemployment to hit nine-year high
By Gyles Beckford of RNZ Unemployment is set to hit its highest level in nearly nine years, as the lagging effects of last year's recession and the sluggish recovery hit hiring and wages. Economists expect the rate to rise to 5.3%at the end of June - the highest since the end of 2016 - and up from 5.1% in the previous quarter, with jobs having been shed and hiring almost at a standstill. "We expect the unemployment rate to rise... as very modest growth in the labour force - labour supply - meets a small contraction in employment - labour demand," ANZ senior economist Miles Workman said. Economists have picked that the labour market was close to the bottom, but the lack of meaningful growth in the past quarter has cast doubt whether this might be the case. Workman suggested a degree of "labour hoarding" had suppressed unemployment as firms opted to hold on to staff in anticipation of an economic upturn. "If a recovery in economic momentum doesn't do the heavy lifting when it comes to 'right-sizing' firms' labour input, a further reduction in headcount may be needed." ASB senior economist Mark Smith said partial indicators since the last set of numbers had shown falling job advertisements, firms still shedding staff, little problem in finding staff except in specialised positions, and people quitting the workforce. "Earlier falls in hiring and more competition for jobs is expected to continue to deter some candidates from actively seeking work." No hiring, some firing Westpac senior economist Michael Gordon said chief among the casualties of the downturn and job losses have been young people. "As the economy cooled off, this group has found themselves out of work again or are struggling to get into work in the first place." The overall slide in immigration from post-Covid gains of more than 130,000 a year to a mere 15,000, and a subsequent exodus to Australia, are likely to be marginal influences for the labour market. However, cooling wage growth may be a more significant factor. Expectations are that private sector labour costs grew about 2.3% in the June quarter - a four-year low - as the weaker employment market shifted the bargaining advantage to employers from workers. That would mean wages falling behind rising inflation, but would also reduce wage pressures on domestic prices. "Wage inflation can be considered broadly consistent with CPI inflation around target, but given we're a decent clip from the labour market entering inflationary territory... it's fair to say that disinflation pressures stemming from the labour market are set to continue for a while yet," Workman said. Kiwibank economists said conditions were right for another Reserve Bank interest rate cut on August 20. "Downside risks to medium term inflation are growing given the soft labour market and dimming global outlook. "We expect the RBNZ to cut the cash rate by 25bps (basis points) at the August meeting. And they'll need to go to 2.5% eventually," they said in a commentary.
RNZ News
13 hours ago
- RNZ News
Unemployment rate expected to hit nine-year high
As many as 40,000 jobs may have been shed in the in past couple of years, say economists. Photo: RNZ Unemployment is set to hit its highest level in nearly nine years, as the lagging effects of last year's recession and the sluggish recovery hit hiring and wages. Economists expect the rate to rise to 5.3 percent at the end of June - the highest since the end of 2016 - and up from 5.1 percent in the previous quarter, with jobs having been shed and hiring almost at a standstill. "We expect the unemployment rate to rise... as very modest growth in the labour force - labour supply - meets a small contraction in employment - labour demand," ANZ senior economist Miles Workman said. Economists have picked that the labour market was close to the bottom, but the lack of meaningful growth in the past quarter has cast doubt whether this might be the case. Workman suggested a degree of "labour hoarding" had suppressed unemployment as firms opted to hold on to staff in anticipation of an economic upturn. "If a recovery in economic momentum doesn't do the heavy lifting when it comes to 'right-sizing' firms' labour input, a further reduction in headcount may be needed." ASB senior economist Mark Smith said partial indicators since the last set of numbers had shown falling job advertisements, firms still shedding staff, little problem in finding staff except in specialised positions, and people quitting the workforce. "Earlier falls in hiring and more competition for jobs is expected to continue to deter some candidates from actively seeking work." Westpac senior economist Michael Gordon said chief among the casualties of the downturn and job losses have been young people. "As the economy cooled off, this group has found themselves out of work again or are struggling to get into work in the first place." The overall slide in immigration from post-Covid gains of more than 130,000 a year to a mere 15,000, and a subsequent exodus to Australia, are likely to be marginal influences for the labour market. However, cooling wage growth may be a more significant factor. Expectations are that private sector labour costs grew about 2.3 percent in the June quarter - a four year low - as the weaker employment market shifted the bargaining advantage to employers from workers. That would mean wages falling behind rising inflation, but would also reduce wage pressures on domestic prices. "Wage inflation can be considered broadly consistent with CPI inflation around target, but given we're a decent clip from the labour market entering inflationary territory... it's fair to say that disinflation pressures stemming from the labour market are set to continue for a while yet," Workman said. Kiwibank economists said conditions were right for another Reserve Bank interest rate cut on 20 August. "Downside risks to medium term inflation are growing given the soft labour market and dimming global outlook. "We expect the RBNZ to cut the cash rate by 25bps (basis points) at the August meeting. And they'll need to go to 2.5 percent eventually," they said in a commentary. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
