Committee on Health Welcomes Findings of Section 59 Investigation Panel
'The report paints a concerning picture of the disproportionate impact that medical schemes' fraud, waste and abuse systems have had on black healthcare providers,' said Dr Dhlomo. 'The statistical evidence presented by the panel's expert, clearly demonstrates that black providers were significantly more likely to be found guilty of fraud, waste and abuse compared to their non-black counterparts.'
The panel's analysis revealed that across the three major schemes investigated – Discovery, GEMS and Medscheme – black providers were between 1.5 to 3.5 times more likely to be identified as guilty of fraud, waste and abuse. In certain disciplines, such as physiotherapy, psychology and social work, the risk ratios for black providers were even higher, reaching up to 12 times more likely to be found guilty.
'These findings are deeply troubling and point to systemic flaws in the design and implementation of the fraud, waste and abuse systems,' continued Dr Dhlomo. 'It is unacceptable that black healthcare providers have been subjected to such blatantly discriminatory treatment, which has undoubtedly had a devastating impact on their livelihoods and the communities they serve,' he said.
The committee commends the panel for its thorough and independent investigation, and welcomes the recommendations made to the Council for Medical Schemes (CMS) to ensure the ongoing monitoring of the fraud, waste and abuse systems to prevent further discriminatory outcomes.
Dr Dhlomo stated that he is in discussions with the Minister of Health, Dr Aaron Motsoaledi, about the report. The aim is to ensure that the Minister, the Department of Health, and the entities that the committee oversees and that have been implicated will be invited to provide a briefing to the committee on the findings, outcomes and recommendations presented in the report.
'We cannot allow such systemic discrimination to continue unchecked, as it undermines the transformation of the healthcare sector and the constitutional right to equality,' said Dr Dhlomo.
Distributed by APO Group on behalf of Republic of South Africa: The Parliament.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Zawya
15 minutes ago
- Zawya
South Africa: Resilient, equitable healthcare demands smart integration
Global health systems are in a period of profound disruption. From overburdened hospitals in Europe to strained clinics across Africa, the Covid-19 pandemic didn't just test our systems; it exposed deep-rooted flaws. But disruption can be clarifying. It forces us to ask: What kind of healthcare system can withstand future shocks while serving all people equitably and sustainably? This was the central theme at the 2025 International Federation of Health Plans (iFHP) CEO Forum in Singapore, where I had the honour of representing the Board of Healthcare Funders (BHF). The answer, across regions and different healthcare models, was clear: resilience is built not in isolation, but through the integration of sectors, systems, ideas, and people. Good intentions do not guarantee good outcomes Nowhere is this lesson more critical than in South Africa and the broader Southern African Development Community (SADC), where health inequities are compounded by economic and infrastructural constraints. And yet, we stand at a policy crossroads. South Africa's National Health Insurance (NHI) Act is an ambitious attempt to equalise access to care. But good intentions do not guarantee good outcomes. The current design of the NHI risks creating a single-point-of-failure system by centralising funding and removing a viable role for medical schemes and private sector partners. Rather than building resilience, the NHI as it stands may undermine it by reducing patient choice, straining already fragile public services, and ignoring the fiscal realities of implementation. Without a clear, sustainable funding mechanism or operational readiness plan, the NHI threatens to replace existing strengths with uncertainty. Smart, strategic integration To be clear, equity cannot be achieved through exclusion. It must come from smart, strategic integration of public and private capacity, governed by accountability, and aligned to outcomes, not ideology. Importantly, resilient, equitable health systems are flexible, layered, and collaborative. This principle is already visible across SADC, where BHF members are helping pilot integrated care models that extend services to underserved communities, often in partnership with governments and civil society. Examples include: - Medical schemes offering low-cost benefit options tailored for lower-income workers. - Community-based risk pooling initiatives. - Partnerships with civil society, including the Gift of the Givers, to rehabilitate health infrastructure, restore water access in hospitals, and fund specialist training. These are not stopgaps. They represent a different way of thinking where the private sector is not merely tolerated in the pursuit of universal health coverage (UHC) but is strategically engaged to close systemic gaps. Too often, reforms focus on mechanisms rather than outcomes. But the real test of any health system is this: Can it deliver timely, quality care where and when it's needed? Resilience begins with frontline functionality, including adequate staff, reliable infrastructure, clean water, and access to diagnostics and medicines. Partnerships that address the social determinants of health, from infrastructure to education and water security, are key. These factors drive long-term health outcomes more than policy documents alone. Innovate from insurer to innovator Medical schemes have a critical role to play in these partnerships. In the 21st century, the medical scheme sector must evolve from insurer to innovator. It must deliver not only coverage but impact. Critical to achieving this is the government creating platforms for structured collaboration, including: - Health outcomes-based contracts. - Incentives for infrastructure investment and training. - Data-sharing frameworks that protect privacy while driving integration. - Co-governance models for regional health preparedness. Such mechanisms don't dilute the state's control over the public health sector, but rather enhance it by making it more effective, better resourced, and more accountable to real-world outcomes. At the iFHP CEO Forum, it was clear that Africa has something vital to offer the world. In countries like Rwanda, Namibia, and Kenya, hybrid models are already delivering UHC-aligned services through strategic public-private partnerships. These are the stories that must shape global health thinking, not just stories of aid, but of agency and innovation. South Africa, and Africa more broadly, does not need a revolution in healthcare. It needs a reconfiguration of what already works, and a clear-eyed recognition of what doesn't. That means reforming without dismantling. Innovating without alienating. Expanding access without eroding quality. We can't afford to chase ideals at the expense of functionality. Resilience must be engineered through cooperation, not confrontation. And the private sector, if wisely regulated and ethically engaged, can be a powerful force for equitable, sustainable health. In this new era, resilience is not about returning to what was. It's about designing what's next with all hands on deck.
Emirates 24/7
4 hours ago
- Emirates 24/7
Europe loses 171,000 hospital beds in decade
Recent data from Eurostat, the statistical office of the European Union, has revealed that EU member states lost approximately 171,110 hospital beds between 2012 and 2022, reflecting a decline of around seven percent over the decade. According to Eurostat, the decrease is partly attributed to a shift in healthcare strategies, including shorter hospital stays and a growing reliance on outpatient services. The data highlights disparities among countries. Bulgaria and Germany recorded the highest ratios, with 823 and 766 hospital beds per 100,000 inhabitants, respectively. In contrast, Sweden and Denmark had the lowest, with 190 and 248 beds per 100,000 people, due to their focus on strengthening primary healthcare. Meanwhile, the Netherlands and Sweden lead the EU in long-term care bed availability. While this transformation reflects progress in service delivery, health experts caution that the overall reduction in hospital beds could pose risks, particularly in the event of future health emergencies or crises. Follow Emirates 24|7 on Google News.
Zawya
5 hours ago
- Zawya
JLL's strategic advisory bolsters institutional confidence in Saudi healthcare sector
Firm's strategic counsel instrumental in landmark $500M IPO of leading Saudi healthcare provider, demonstrating robust investor appetite Riyadh, Saudi Arabia – JLL, a leading global commercial real estate advisory and investment management company, has successfully delivered comprehensive market due diligence for the Initial Public Offering (IPO) of Specialized Medical Company (SMC), a prominent Saudi healthcare provider. SMC recently made its trading debut on the Saudi Exchange, raising an impressive SAR 1.88 billion ($500 million), a significant milestone that underscores the robust and growing institutional investor confidence in the Kingdom's healthcare sector. JLL's specialized healthcare advisory team crafted the market analysis section of the IPO report, delivering crucial sector expertise and strategic insights that proved instrumental throughout the complex offering process, particularly in articulating the compelling investment thesis of Saudi Arabia's burgeoning healthcare market to a global investor base. The overwhelming demand for SMC's shares, with the institutional tranche oversubscribed by an extraordinary 65 times and generating orders exceeding SAR 121.3 billion ($32.3 billion), is a powerful testament to the maturity and attractiveness of the Saudi capital market and its underlying sectors for global institutional investment. SMC's final offer price was set at SAR 25 per share, the top of the announced range, implying a market capitalization of SAR 6.25 billion at listing. This clearly signals trust in the long-term growth trajectory of Saudi Arabia's healthcare sector, driven by Vision 2030 initiatives and expanding hospital infrastructure and diagnostic networks. Sandeep Sinha, Head of Healthcare and Life Sciences Consulting for MEA at JLL, said: 'The unprecedented institutional oversubscription in SMC's IPO reinforces the exceptional growth potential and strong investor appetite for high-quality assets within Saudi Arabia's healthcare sector. Our insightful advisory services offered regional and global investors a comprehensive understanding of the Kingdom's market dynamics and SMC's robust fundamentals. This successful debut is a testament to both SMC's strength and the increasing maturity of Saudi Arabia's capital market.' The IPO marks a major milestone for SMC and underscores JLL's proven expertise in providing nuanced, data-driven insights essential for high-stakes capital market transactions. This has bolstered investor confidence in Saudi Arabia's healthcare sector, laying a robust foundation for future growth and investment within the Kingdom. About JLL For over 200 years, JLL (NYSE: JLL), a leading global commercial real estate and investment management company, has helped clients buy, build, occupy, manage and invest in a variety of commercial, industrial, hotel, residential and retail properties. A Fortune 500 company with annual revenue of $20.8 billion and operations in over 80 countries around the world, our more than 111,000 employees bring the power of a global platform combined with local expertise. Driven by our purpose to shape the future of real estate for a better world, we help our clients, people and communities SEE A BRIGHTER WAYSM. JLL is the brand name, and a registered trademark, of Jones Lang LaSalle Incorporated. For further information, visit About JLL MEA Across the Middle East and Africa (MEA) JLL is a leading player in the real estate and hospitality services markets. The firm has worked in 35 countries across the region and employs over 2000 internationally qualified professionals across its offices in Dubai, Abu Dhabi, Riyadh, Jeddah, Al Khobar, Cairo, Casablanca, Cape Town, Johannesburg and Nairobi. For further information, visit Media Contact: Medha Sandrasagara JLL MEA Reem AlTajer | Janine Alamir Burson |
