Caster Semenya declares victory after ECHR rules she was denied fair hearing
She unsuccessfully took her challenge against those rules to the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS) and then the Swiss Federal Supreme Court, but complained to the ECHR that her rights had been violated in that process.
The Grand Chamber of the ECHR ruled on Thursday that the Swiss legal system had 'fallen short' in providing what they felt should have been a 'rigorous judicial review that was commensurate with the seriousness of the personal rights at issue' and that Semenya's right to a fair hearing had therefore been violated.
The ruling, which is binding and cannot be appealed, is almost certain to mean that the case returns to the Swiss courts for further consideration, but does not have any impact at this stage on eligibility rules set by World Athletics or any other body.
Semenya, an Olympic gold medallist over 800 metres in 2012 and 2016, said in a statement released by her legal team: 'I have waited 15 long years for this judgment.
'Today, my patience in this journey has been rewarded with a result that will pave the way for all athletes' human rights to be protected.
'I have given up what I wanted in the hope that others may have what they need. I hope this victory will inspire young women to be and to accept themselves in all their diversity.
'There is still much work ahead to achieve justice for women in sport and I will continue to support this effort and fight for young women athletes.'
World Athletics has not commented on the judgement, given that it is not related to their female eligibility guidelines but rather about whether Semenya had been granted a fair hearing in Switzerland or not.
The Swiss Human Rights Institution (ISDH), an independent body which does not speak for the country's federal authorities, felt the Grand Chamber had 'emphasised the significant power imbalance between the individual athlete and the world governing body before the Court of Arbitration for Sport and insisted that, given this imbalance, the Federal Supreme Court had interpreted its own review power too narrowly'.
Grand Chamber judgment Semenya v. Switzerland – Complaint by international athlete concerning set of World Athletics regulationshttps://t.co/JcWLWspX33#ECHR #CEDH #ECHRpress pic.twitter.com/6hFqJzTpgv
— ECHR CEDH (@ECHR_CEDH) July 10, 2025
The ECHR ruled Semenya's complaints that other human rights were violated inadmissible, including the prohibition of discrimination. It found Semenya did not fall within Switzerland's jurisdiction in respect of those complaints.
World Athletics has consistently stood by the rules it introduced on testosterone levels, and earlier this year has gone even further.
Its ruling council has approved the introduction of cheek swab tests to determine eligibility for the female category. Only athletes found to be biologically female will be allowed to compete, effectively barring transgender women and some athletes with differences of sexual development (DSD).
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
2 hours ago
- The Guardian
World Athletics monitoring outstanding Grand Slam Track payments to athletes
Sebastian Coe says World Athletics is closely monitoring outstanding athlete payments from Michael Johnson's Grand Slam Track series, admitting: 'There is no point in pretending this is a satisfactory situation.' Johnson unexpectedly cancelled the final Los Angeles leg of his new four-meeting series last month following low spectator numbers at the opening three editions in Kingston, Miami and Philadelphia. The series announced a total prize fund of $12.6m (£9.3m) at its launch earlier this year, but a number of athletes are understood yet to receive payment. It is not unusual for a time lag between competition and remuneration but, given the abrupt end to the aborted first season, runners are increasingly concerned over individual payments that stretch well into six figures. 'It's not good,' said Lord Coe, the global governing body's president. 'The one thing that World Athletics has always stood strongly behind is the athletes. So yeah, this is not a good situation. It's a startup, but the athletes do need paying.' He added: 'For these things to work, they can't be vanity projects. They have to be suffused in practicality and deliverability. I just want the events that are going to add lustre, that we can find space for, and we will encourage them to at least have the courtesy of spending that kind of time and that kind of effort, both intellectual and resource, in making sure they work.' Grand Slam Track champions at each meet receive $100,000 (£74,000) in addition to substantial appearance fees. Britain's 400m Olympic medallist Matthew Hudson-Smith won the short sprint category in Kingston and Philadelphia, with Josh Kerr triumphing in the short distance category in Miami. While Grand Slam Track declined to comment, it is understood agents have been informed that their athletes will receive payment for the Kingston event by the end of this month, with later meet payments following before the end of September. The Guardian understands that some athletes have received appearance money from the opening meet. Asked if World Athletics has the power to intervene on athletes' behalf, Coe replied: 'Well, let's just watch this space.' Johnson's brainchild has been touted as a direct competitor to World Athletics' Diamond League circuit, which had stood unchallenged as the primary season-long athletics competition since it succeeded the Golden League in 2010. Speaking to the Guardian in April, Johnson denied fears that the $30m of investment in Grand Slam Track could run out before he is able to change the sport. 'We're in this for the long haul,' he said. 'Startups aren't profitable in year one. You know, if anybody comes to you with a startup, saying: 'Hey, we're going to be profitable in year one,' run away as fast as you can. But we will continue to grow.' Coe insists he remains fully supportive of privately funded athletics events. 'It was in everybody's interest for something like this to be successful,' he said. 'We're not the 'computer says no' command-and-control federation. Sign up to The Recap The best of our sports journalism from the past seven days and a heads-up on the weekend's action after newsletter promotion 'From the very moment I became president of World Athletics, I talked about the need to be more creative and partner – don't shy away from forming those relationships. So we were very clear that this had to be done properly and executed properly. Hopefully, [create] an additional attraction in the sport.' Meanwhile, Coe confirmed World Athletics remains committed to introducing DNA tests for all elite female athletes ahead of September's world championships. Coe initially announced the policy in March to 'guarantee the integrity of female women's sport'. It will involve a non-invasive one‑time cheek swab or dry blood test. Tests are due to begin in the coming weeks once the World Athletics Council has confirmed procedural regulations.
North Wales Live
3 hours ago
- North Wales Live
Aldi announces opening date for new North Wales store
A new Aldi store is set to open in North Wales. The German-owned discount chain are launching a new site on The Airfields, Welsh Road, Deeside on Thursday, August 14. The new store - which throws open its doors at 8am that day - will be run by store manager Spencer Kearney, along with a team of 27 colleagues from the local community. When it was mooted earlier this year the 21,000 sq ft supermarket just off the A494 was expected to be one of the largest in the UK. Mr Kearney and his team will be joined by Olympic bronze medal-winning diver Lois Toulson to celebrate the store opening by cutting a ribbon on the opening morning. Lois will also give away complimentary bags of fresh fruit and vegetables from Aldi's famous Super 6 range to the first 30 customers in the queue. Mr Kearney said: 'We can't wait to open the doors to the new store in Deeside. It's set to be a special day and having Olympic hero Lois Toulson join us will make it a morning to remember.' Lois added: 'I'm so excited to be opening Aldi's new store. It will be great to chat to customers and a lovely way for me to thank Aldi for its support of Team GB.' The new Aldi store is also calling on local charities and food banks in Deeside to register with Neighbourly, a community engagement platform that links businesses to charitable organisations in the local community. Local charities that register will be able to collect surplus food and perishable products, such as fruit, vegetables and baked goods, seven days a week. Any charities in the area that would like to partner up with the new Aldi store should email aldi@
Times
5 hours ago
- Times
Lord Coe worried by unpaid fees of Michael Johnson's Grand Slam Track
Lord Coe has said World Athletics is closely monitoring the situation amid concerns that Michael Johnson's Grand Slam Track league still owes athletes millions of dollars in prize money and appearance fees. Johnson, the former Olympic sprint champion and now BBC pundit, had to cancel the fourth leg of the new league in Los Angeles at the end of June because of financial issues, sparked, not least, by poor attendances in the first three events. As The Times revealed earlier this month, track stars are still waiting on payments due after the opening event in Jamaica at the beginning of April. Indeed, an email from a Grand Slam Track official to agents chasing the money on behalf of their clients promised payment for the Jamaica meet by the end of this month and the following two events, in Miami and Philadelphia, by the end of September. Even so, there is talk of them owing as much as $13million with key stakeholders also as yet unpaid.
