RFU rebels demand significant changes after Sweeney survives confidence vote
The rebel clubs who called for Bill Sweeney's resignation as chief executive of the Rugby Football Union say they want to see significant changes to the way the union operates within the next three months despite failing to win sufficient support for their motion of no confidence at Thursday's special general meeting (SGM).
Alistair Bow, chair of Nottingham and co-chair of the Whole Game Union who forced the SGM, said the clubs now expect to see words put into action after Sweeney survived the vote on a turnout of just 54% of the membership. The Whole Game Union has already tabled 11 proposals for further governance changes before the union's annual general meeting (AGM) on Monday 30 June.
'We have got the AGM coming up and we have to see fundamental change,' said Bow, who is now waiting to see whether Sweeney is prepared to work alongside those who sought to oust him. 'I think we will see over the next two or three days how he takes this. But this is a democratic vote at the end of the day, which we will take on board, and now we want to see action.
'I think he is either going to work with us or he won't. I am hoping he will. We'll work with his team and we have got to change. What we will not allow is for this to continue. We have got the AGM coming up and we have to see fundamental change.'
The proposed rule changes involve more oversight over executive decisions, increased transparency, more attention to be paid to member clubs' views and greater accountability for RFU board members. Bow has already flagged the need for more direction and better leadership and hopes Sweeney will now respond accordingly.
'If he does deliver, then fantastic. But he's got a lot of work to do, as we have. The AGM will be the test now. Can we get the reforms through to change the structure and governance we need for the future? If we work together then we stand a chance.
'We want to see our proposal adopted. There are 11 points that we've already put forward on the agenda. We want those to be put through the AGM and voted on to bring reform, governance and accountability back to our game. We want members to get back some control of major decision-making within the game.'
Paddy McAlpine, chair of Chichester RFC, also said he hoped the SGM had served a useful purpose. 'I walk away absolutely encouraged that the RFU have listened and therefore positive change is going to happen. And that has to be good for the whole game. It's not just about England at Twickenham, it's about all rugby all the way down to the five-year-old who wants to be a part of an England team that's winning.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Belfast Telegraph
35 minutes ago
- Belfast Telegraph
Michael Dunlop sets new lap record on way to Superbike double at Tandragee 100: ‘I'm riding faster than ever'
Riding his MD Racing BMW, Dunlop – back at the Co Armagh road race for the first time since 2013 – followed up his win in the Open race with a majestic display to win the six-lap finale for his 13th win at the meeting. The Isle of Man TT history-maker had to dig deep to fend off the threat from Republic of Ireland contender Michael Sweeney on the Martin Jones Racing BMW, who kept in touch with Dunlop over the first three laps. Dunlop shattered Sweeney's lap record of 109.796mph – set in the earlier Open race – on the second lap with a new mark of 110.497mph. Sweeney hit straight back, upping the ante to 110.997mph on the third lap as they broke away from Conor Cummins and Shaun Anderson. Dunlop finally gained some daylight by the end of lap four and was 1.3s ahead. He then turned the screw, recording the first 111mph lap at Tandragee to raise the absolute record to 111.584mph (2:52.403s) around the 5.3-mile course. It was enough to seal the deal and Dunlop went on to close out victory by eight seconds over Sweeney. Banbridge man Anderson finished on the podium in third on the Team Classic Suzuki while Cummins' chance was thwarted when he overshot at the last corner. The Manxman still finished fourth on the Burrows/RK Racing BMW. It has been a glorious year for Dunlop, who won three races at the North West 200 and increased his record of Isle of Man TT wins to 33 following another four-timer. The 36-year-old's achievements in the sport have been recognised with an MBE in the King's birthday honours. Dunlop, who will next be in action at the Southern 100 when he returns to the Isle of Man next month, said: 'The main job for me is the North West and TT, and I think we've done a successful job there and proven we're still one of the top men. 'For the first time in a while I was really competitive at the North West, which was good. 'To do a triple there and go to the TT and win another four it's been a great year. 'I'm riding faster than ever and there's no reason why we can't keep winning and adding to the tally.' Dunlop had to work hard to hold off Sweeney in the Open Superbike race earlier in the day. He was headed off the line by Sweeney and Mike Browne (BPE by Russell Racing Yamaha 600) and was lying in third at the end of the first lap. Dunlop worked his way into second place behind Sweeney on the next lap and then nudged ahead. Sweeney blitzed the seven-year-old absolute lap record set by Dan Kneen in 2018, raising the bar to 109.796mph on the fourth lap – slightly faster than Dunlop (109.755mph). The scene was set for a grandstand finish but it was Dunlop who held on by 0.4s. Cummins passed Browne on the last lap to earn a podium. Browne made it a double in the Supersport class, leading all the way from pole. The Republic of Ireland rider won Friday's non-championship race and followed up yesterday with another win. Sweeney was ruled out with an issue on the warm-up lap on the EM Building Yamaha. Dunlop, riding the Milwaukee Ducati, finished second on corrected time and set a new lap record at 109.276mph. He had to start from 17th position after failing to qualify on the Ducati on Friday, when he pulled in after a lap with an issue. Cummins claimed third on the Burrows/RK Racing Ducati after fending off Darryl Tweed (Novo Gen by FAO Racing Honda). Anderson had a successful day at his home race meeting, dominating the Classic Superbike race on the Wiz Norton to win by 20 seconds from Tweed (Stanley Stewart Yamaha 750). The Banbridge man later won the Lightweight race on a 250 Honda for a double. In the Supertwin race, Ballymoney's Tweed was toasting a thrilling win when he capitalised on a mistake by race leader Sweeney on the last lap. Sweeney went wide on his Aprilia at the final corner, leaving the door wide open for Tweed, who grabbed the win by 1.5s on his Aprilia. The Junior Support race, won by Sean Brolly on his Aprilia 660, was stopped on the final lap following a red flag incident. No official details were provided. The final national road race of the season takes place next month with the Armoy meeting in Co Antrim from July 25-26.
Telegraph
2 days ago
- Telegraph
English rugby braces for pivotal vote that will decide its future
On Saturday, the British and Irish Lions make their bow on Australian soil while England settle in Buenos Aires ahead of a Test series against Argentina that begins the following weekend. But back in Birmingham, away from the spotlight, is a potentially pivotal day for the future of rugby union in this country. There, at the Rugby Football Union's annual general meeting, members will vote on a set of proposals designed to address the unrest that resulted in a special general meeting three months ago. Bill Sweeney, the chief executive, survived a vote of no-confidence in March, but the same summit delivered a strong mandate to expedite governance reform. The Whole Game Union, a body spearheaded by Alistair Bow, from Nottingham RFC, and Paddy McAlpine, of Chichester RFC, has tabled 11 resolutions in an effort to secure meaningful change and requires 66 per cent approval for them to be passed. What changes are being proposed? The resolutions include a desire for the council to be able to approve the union's annual strategic plan, as well as its budget and business plan. The thorny issue of directors' pay, which sparked outrage across the game, would be addressed with the implementation of a published 'people and pay policy', which members could comment on and influence. As a whole, the Whole Game Union's mission statement is to 'put members back at the heart of major decisions' and 'restore strategic control' to an elected council. A letter to members, seen by Telegraph Sport, lists six reasons why reform has become essential, including the removal of development officers on the ground and reduced investment, in real terms, into the community game. What does it mean for the grass-roots game? At the heart of this campaign is the belief that the RFU executive and board have neglected amateur clubs in favour of a focus on the elite game. It is felt, for example, that £33 million per year was committed to Premiership clubs 'without meaningful consultation with members'. Jeff Blackett, who served as RFU president between 2020 and 2022, has been an adviser to the Whole Game Union and backs the proposals. 'The difficultly is that the game has been struggling to become professional since 1995 and the governance structure has not really caught up to where we are today,' he said this week. 'The professional game and the grass-roots game are two different beasts and it is very difficult to have one organisation in charge of all of it. Our concern is that the senior executive and the board have only concentrated on the elite game. The community game is dying on its feet, unfortunately; numbers are down, clubs are down and fixtures aren't fulfilled. 'It's a watershed moment and these proposals are meant to redress the balance, to put some of the power back into the council, acknowledging that the council has to be reformed itself to be more accountable to its membership, so that the big decisions can be scrutinised properly.' How could it affect the RFU council? The RFU council has been branded as bloated and archaic, with Blackett describing the 2016 Sport England governance code as a 'final nail in the coffin' that reduced its power. An independent review recently labelled it as 'dysfunctional' and advised that it should be scrapped entirely. However, the Whole Game Union argues that this consultation document 'lacks transparency and ambition' and would only create a system 'where members will have less ability to scrutinise the executive and the board'. 'One of the criticisms of the council is that too many of its members are people who have done great jobs for CBs [constituent boards] and are effectively given a reward of going up to Twickenham and having nice seats to enjoy their latter years in rugby,' Blackett added. 'There are people like that, but there are also many good people. The Whole Game Union would have council more accountable to the game. One of the resolutions is for the nominations committee to write a report on each council member that will go back to their constituents. They also want to make the council smaller, because it's difficult to have meaningful debate with 60-odd people in a room, and make it so members feel an attachment to those council members. 'What we're trying to do is to restore democracy. The friction comes because it is also a multimillion-pound business and the board also has to have the ability to run that. We've got to get the balance right.' Could this impact rugby's funding? The Whole Game Union has also addressed the RFU board's criticisms of the resolutions. It disputes, for instance, that reform would cause Sport England to remove funding from the RFU and decline to support the hosting of international tournaments such as World Cups. Blackett suggested that the image of the Whole Game Union as disruptive upstarts is grossly unfair. 'The RFU position is that they're a bunch of rebels and malcontents,' he said. 'They're not. They are people with a genuine interest in making rugby a great sport again and none of them are in it for personal gain.' His endgame would be for the RFU board to oversee both the professional and grass-roots game: 'The way I see it is that the board would delegate a good chunk of money to both and effectively urge them to manage it in accordance with business plans they have put forward. 'I do think it's important that the whole game stays together. And the professional game is the Premiership and the Championship. I think there has been real, valid criticism that the Championship has not been properly supported by the RFU and that needs to be put right as well.' Voting has been open for a fortnight or so, meaning many members will have made up their minds. Blackett would urge any stragglers to give themselves an opportunity to lend their voice to a critical debate. 'The RFU is a members cooperative and every member should have a voice on major issues,' he said. 'The trouble in the past with AGMs is that fewer and fewer people have turned up and things go through without proper scrutiny. 'It's absolutely vital that members look at the merits of this and vote. And, of course, I would urge them to vote for the resolutions that will ensure the future of our game.'
The Herald Scotland
5 days ago
- The Herald Scotland
Andrew Cavenagh: Why Rangers and why Russell Martin
All four resolutions at the meeting, held at the Doubletree by Hilton at Glasgow Central, were passed, and that means unrestricted investment is now permitted, beyond the ten per cent cap which was in place following the previous AGM. Cavenagh was asked whether he was looking to make a return on his investment and insisted he has no exit plan, just a growth one. The health tycoon was quizzed on a host of other issues, including his motivations for coming to Scotland and Rangers, and why Russell Martin was the best choice as manager. On the former, the businessman explained there were four factors attracting him to the club. Read more: Explaining where he was when he took the phone call that 'changed his life', he said: 'I was on the Upper East Side of Manhattan, outside a coffee shop, about to go to a New York Yankees game. I've known about Rangers forever as a football fan. So when the phone call came to ask if I'd have an interest, it was a lightning bolt moment. The call was from Les Allan, a banker in New York. I had met him six months prior, and he knew our group was interested in a rare but good opportunity in football. Les called me and I said absolutely. Three seconds later, I was on the phone to Paraag. "There are many things about this club that are attractive. But the big three are the supporters - the breadth and depth of the fanbase is incredible. We've not seen many other clubs in Europe with this sort of scope and passion. Ibrox is an incredibly magical place to attend as a supporter. And the competitions in which we play, the league, the cups and Europe." He has taken in games at Ibrox while the takeover talks progressed, so already has plenty of experience of what it feels like to take in that famous atmosphere on a matchday. Like many before him, he was captivated by the historic stadium. 'It's a physical experience when you walk upstairs at Ibrox," he explained. You walk up the marble stairs to the Blue Room, and in the trophy room in particular, you can just feel the history. There's no other way to describe it. "You walk in and instantly feel indebted to the people who have come before you. But you also have the desire to do everything you possibly can, not just to improve the history, but also to improve the trajectory." Rangers fans want to see ambition and are enthused by the fact that, so far, that is what the new faces are showing. Paraag Marathe (middle, left) is the new Rangers vice-chairman (Image: Craig Foy - SNS Group) Cavenagh and new vice-chairman Paraag Marathe want to return the club to the very top of the Scottish game. He insists they wouldn't be here for any other reason. But at the same time, he acknowledges that it will be hard work and will not happen overnight. "There is real work to be done, I think everyone is aware of that," he said. "Paraag and I are two of the least patient people you will meet and we are also incredibly competitive, so we share our supporters' sense of urgency. We are in with both feet today, and we will move this forward as fast as we can. "We relish that challenge. We are impatient, we are competitive, and so we look forward to the challenge. In terms of the rivalry, I think rivalry is one of the things that makes football great. Our rivalry with Celtic, Rangers wouldn't quite be the same without that rivalry. It's top five in the world. Boca-River Plate, Lazio-Roma, Celtic-Rangers, those would be the three that come to mind. It's fantastic to have that rivalry. And we look forward to the challenge.' Asked how far away those dreams are, he added: 'I would give you the simple answer, which is we have been finishing second and we would like to finish first. We are one position away from where we would like to be. "We think it is achievable, or we wouldn't be here. We don't think it will be easy. It is not going to happen instantaneously but we will strive to improve the on-field performance and we will continue to build the infrastructure of the club. If we didn't think we could win, we wouldn't be here. We are here because we think we can."
