TRAI seeks comments on regulating sale of foreign telcos' SIMs in devices meant for exports
IoT devices are everyday objects that have sensors, software, and other technology inside them. This helps them connect to the internet and talk to other devices.
The TRAI paper invites public and industry feedback on whether and how such SIM cards -- issued by foreign operators -- should be allowed for use in devices manufactured in India but not intended for domestic use.
The development follows a request from the Department of Telecommunications (DoT) dated September 17, 2024, asking TRAI to frame recommendations for granting and renewing No Objection Certificates (NOCs) related to the import and sale of these foreign SIM/eSIM cards.
Stakeholders have been invited to submit written comments by August 1 and counter-comments by August 18. Ministry of Communications
Meanwhile, TRAI said it has sent its response to the back-reference received from the DoT in respect of the TRAI's recommendations on 'Assignment of Additional Spectrum to Indian Railways for its Safety and Security Applications' to DoT.
DoT informed TRAI that Indian Railways had requested for an additional 5 MHz of paired spectrum in the 700 MHz band to be allocated free of cost to them for enhancing its safety and security systems.
'Through the said reference dated 26.07.2023, DoT requested TRAI to examine and provide its recommendations on the subject. In this regard, after following a comprehensive consultation with stakeholders, TRAI, on 20.12.2024, sent its recommendations on 'Assignment of Additional Spectrum to Indian Railways for its Safety and Security Applications' to DoT,' said the telecom regulator.
In this regard, after a careful examination, TRAI has sent its response to the back-reference to DoT.
TRAI seeks comments on regulating sale of foreign telcos' SIMs in devices meant for exports
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
19 hours ago
- Time of India
RBI acts tough against cyber frauds, directs all banks to use DoT's FRI technology to protect bank customers
Academy Empower your mind, elevate your skills What is the Financial Fraud Risk Indicator and how can banks prevent cyber frauds occuring with customers? FRI helps banks take real time preventive measures to stop cyber frauds What experts say about DoT's FRI technology? Customers enjoy more secure transactions, early alerts, and reduced losses. Banks get data-driven tools, real-time decisioning, and regulated guidance from RBI. Overall ecosystem sees improved resilience in India's digital payment landscape. Real-Time Threat Detection Uses AI and machine learning to identify fraudulent activities (e.g., phishing, account takeovers, payment fraud) in real time. Analyses behavioural patterns to detect anomalies. Risk Scoring & Fraud Prevention Assigns risk scores to transactions, logins, or user activities to flag potential fraud. Helps businesses block high-risk transactions before they occur. Automated Intelligence & Threat Feeds Integrates threat intelligence from multiple sources (dark web, breach databases) to identify compromised credentials or fraud schemes. Proactively alerts customers about emerging fraud tactics. Collaboration with Fintech & Banks Fraud detection models help financial institutions block suspicious transactions. Reduces financial losses for customers. Identity Verification & Authentication Enhances identity proofing with biometrics, device fingerprinting, and behavioural analytics to prevent impersonation fraud. Adaptive Fraud Mitigation Continuously learns from new fraud patterns to improve detection accuracy. Reduces false positives, improving customer experience while maintaining security. Regulatory Compliance & Reporting Helps organizations comply with anti-fraud regulations (e.g., PSD2, GDPR) by providing audit trails and fraud analytics. Cross-sector integration Combines telecom, banking, and cybercrime reports to produce a real-time fraud risk indicator (FRI) per mobile number. Actionable risk scoring (Medium/High/Very High) This gives banks immediate, automated inputs during transactions—something few countries offer in this structured way. RBI-Mandated Usage Unlike many countries where data-sharing is voluntary or siloed, India has made this integration a regulatory requirement. API-first model Makes it scalable, real-time, and platform-agnostic—ready for adoption by private banks, fintechs, and payment gateways. False Positives / Data Bias: If mobile numbers are wrongly flagged (e.g. recycled SIMs), customers may face unfair friction. If mobile numbers are wrongly flagged (e.g. recycled SIMs), customers may face unfair friction. Privacy & Consent: Cross-sharing of telecom and banking data must be privacy-conscious under the DPDPA Act. Cross-sharing of telecom and banking data must be privacy-conscious under the DPDPA Act. Fraud Adaptation: Scammers may move to untraceable channels (e.g. WhatsApp or foreign VoIP numbers), needing TRI to evolve further. The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) has declared war on cyber fraud affecting bank customers in India. On June 30, 2025, the RBI directed all Scheduled Commercial Banks, Small Finance Banks, Payments Banks, and Co-operative Banks to incorporate the Financial Fraud Risk Indicator ( FRI ) developed by the Department of Telecommunications (DoT) into their developed this cyber security system known as FRI and rolled it out in May 2025. To give a brief overview of this technology, the FRI allows for the automated exchange of data and information between the banks and DoT's Digital Intelligence Platform (DIP). This system aids banks in safeguarding customers from cyber frauds by facilitating real-time responses to any fraudulent activity and providing continuous feedback to emhance the fraud risk a press release dated July 2, 2025, DoT said: 'The system's utility has already been demonstrated with leading institutions such as PhonePe, Punjab National Bank , HDFC Bank, ICICI Bank, Paytm, and India Post Payments Bank actively using the platform. With UPI being the most preferred payment method across India, this intervention could save millions of citizens from falling prey to cyber fraud. The FRI allows for swift, targeted, and collaborative action against suspected frauds in both telecom and financial domains.'Check out the info below to learn more about this technology and how it can protect regular bank customers from the threats of cyber the press release, the DoT said that the Financial Fraud Risk Indicator (FRI) is a risk-based metric that classifies a mobile number to have been associated with Medium, High, or Very High risk of financial fraud.'This classification is an outcome of inputs obtained from various stakeholders including reporting on Indian Cyber Crime Coordination Centre (I4C's) National Cybercrime Reporting Portal (NCRP), DoT's Chakshu platform, and Intelligence shared by banks and financial institutions.'DoT said that the FRI technology empowers stakeholders-especially banks, NBFCs, and UPI service providers- to prioritize enforcement and take additional customer protection measures in case a mobile number has high said in the press release: 'The Digital Intelligence Unit (DIU) of DoT regularly shares the Mobile Number Revocation List (MNRL) with stakeholders, detailing numbers disconnected due to cybercrime links, failed re-verification, or misuse—many of which are tied to financial frauds.'The telecom department said that banks and financial institutions can use FRI in real time to take proactive steps like declining suspicious transactions, issuing alerts or warnings to customers, and delaying transactions flagged as high Wig, Co-founder & CEO, Innefu Labs says: 'Banks can leverage FRI to proactively alert customers about suspicious calls or messages originating from numbers identified as high-risk. By integrating FRI into their digital banking platforms, customer service workflows and fraud detection engines, banks can strengthen their ability to identify potential threats in real-time. Moreover, by coupling FRI data with AI-based risk scoring and user behaviour, analytics can help banks predict and prevent fraud before it occurs. This enhances customer trust and reduces financial exposure, while also helping law enforcement trace fraud networks more effectively.'Sheetal R Bhardwaj, executive member of Association of Certified Financial Crime Specialists (ACFCS), says: "Already adopted by major players like HDFC, ICICI, PhonePe, and Paytm, FRI enables institutions to flag suspicious activity, protect consumers, and reduce scam exposure. Its collaborative model bridges telecom and finance, creating a unified defense against cyber threats. As UPI continues to dominate India's payment landscape, FRI enhances transaction integrity and consumer confidence. With its scalable, data-driven approach, FRI could become a global model for fintech-telecom collaboration in fraud prevention—positioning India as a leader in digital trust."DoT further said: 'This move marks a new era of digital trust and security, reinforcing the Government's broader Digital India vision. DoT continues to work closely with RBI-regulated entities to streamline alert mechanisms, accelerate fraud detection, and integrate telecom intelligence directly into banking workflows. As more institutions adopt FRI into their customer-facing systems, it is expected to evolve into a sector-wide standard, reinforcing trust, enabling real-time decision-making, and delivering greater systemic resilience across India's digital financial architecture.'ET Wealth Online has asked various experts about how DoT's FRI technology can help consumers, here's what they said:There are few countries who use similar technology like USA, UK, Singapore, Australia, China etc. This latest development layers telecom intelligence into banking workflows, creating a proactive fraud shield:Here's how banks can use TRI technology to help their customers in respect to cyber fraud:Strengths of this technology:The Financial Fraud Risk Indicator (FRI), launched by the Department of Telecommunications' Digital Intelligence Unit, is more than a fraud detection tool—it's a digital trust enabler. By classifying mobile numbers based on fraud risk using data from cybercrime portals, telecom intelligence, and financial institutions, FRI empowers banks and UPI providers to take real-time, preventive action.
Mint
20 hours ago
- Mint
Telecom department and regulator clash over over key spectrum to Indian Railways
The department of telecommunications (DoT) and the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (Trai) are sparring over the allocation of a portion of the key 700 MHz spectrum to the Indian Railways. The spectrum band is crucial for Indian Railways to deploy safety and security applications as a part of its indigenous radio-based train collision avoidance system (TCAS) or Kavach. In a letter dated 16 June, the telecom department told Trai that the assignment of an additional 5 MHz spectrum would be considered only once the 5 MHz spectrum already assigned in the 700 MHz frequency band was used. The back reference from DoT came on Trai's recommendations to assign additional spectrum to Indian Railways for its safety and security applications. Trai had sent the recommendations on 20 December 2024. In response to DoT's back reference on 4 July, the regulator expressed concern over the department's view on the spectrum allocation. 'It is imperative that an additional 5 MHz of paired spectrum in the 700 MHz band is assigned to the Indian Railways forthwith so that they can plan, design and implement an optimised communication network for meeting the bandwidth requirements of their safety and security applications in a timely manner,' Trai told the DoT. Another issue between DoT and Trai is on how much Indian Railways will be charged for the spectrum. The department wants the assignment of spectrum to bebased on the auction determined price (ADP) instead of a formula prescribed by DoT, which would be less expensive as per the regulator. ADP is the market price set during 5G auctions. The price of per megahertz (MHz) of spectrum in the 700 MHz band was set at ₹ 3,927 crore for commercial use. 'In order to harmonise all such administrative assignment of spectrum in the IMT (international mobile telecommunication) bands, the department is of the view that it may be appropriate to adopt the spectrum charging methodology of upfront payment of the ADP mechanism for all administrative assignment of spectrum in the IMT bands, henceforth on prospective basis,' DoT told Trai. It added that so far, Indian Railways has also not paid any spectrum charges for the already assigned 5 MHz spectrum in the 700 MHz band. DoT said this charging mechanism would allow for efficient use of spectrum, avoid hoarding/blocking of spectrum, and avoid accounting problems from the assignment of spectrum in phases. 'This upfront payment of ADP mechanism will also be applicable to the already assigned 5 MHZ of paired spectrum to the Indian Railways with prospective effect,' DoT said. Trai, however, said, 'Considering the critical role played by Indian Railways and NCRTC (National Capital Region Transport Corporation) in serving public and national interests, it would not be appropriate to levy spectrum charges for these entities based on ADP that reflects the value placed on the spectrum by entities intending to use it for commercial use.' 'The economic value of spectrum for entities such as Indian Railways and NCRTC is fundamentally different from that of commercial service providers, as it does not include revenue-generating activities like commercial use of internet, voice, or data services,' Trai added. Trai noted that spectrum charges for respective spectrum bands assigned administratively to various ministries/departments engaged in national safety and security, such as defence and space, are determined using the formula prescribed by DoT. 'The spectrum charges for these ministries/departments are not determined based on ADP. Further, since both NCRTC and Indian Railways require spectrum for the purpose of enhancing safety and security, there is no justification for levying spectrum charges based on ADP,' Trai told DoT. With a 45 MHz total size, the 700 Mhz band has already been allocated for the use of different government ministries/departments/agencies, which includes 10 MHz for the defence ministry, 5 MHz for Indian Railways, 5 MHz for National Capital Region Transport Corporation (NCRTC), and 10 MHz for BSNL. In the 2022 spectrum auctions, Jio acquired 10 MHz of the 700 MHz spectrum worth ₹ 40,000 crore. The remaining 5 MHz band has been sought by the Indian Railways. The 700 MHz band is considered a premium band for 5G services as it has the potential to offer wider coverage and in-building penetration.
Hindustan Times
a day ago
- Hindustan Times
Delhi govt looks at engaging third party agency to give fire NOCs
The Delhi government is considering engaging certified third-party agencies to handle fire safety certifications and no objection certificates (NOCs), potentially relieving the fire department of this responsibility, officials aware of the matter said on Friday. The move is part of a broader effort to improve the ease of doing business in the city. Delhi ire Services last month denied frie NOC to LNJP Hospital. (HT Photo) 'In some states, fire departments no longer issue fire NOCs. Instead, the task has been delegated to private fire safety agencies that are certified by the state after an assessment of their capabilities and expertise,' said an official in the home department, which oversees the fire services. 'This is being explored to allow fire departments to focus on their core job—firefighting—without the added burden of handling certification requests. While the idea is under examination, no proposal has been drafted yet,' the official added. As per the tentative plan, third-party agencies may be tasked with auditing large establishments such as factories, with the fire department issuing certificates based on their reports. For smaller establishments like office spaces, the agencies could be authorised to issue certifications directly. 'Nothing has been finalised yet. All options are being considered,' the official said. The development comes shortly after the Delhi government scrapped the requirement of Delhi Police licensing clearance for seven categories of businesses, including hotels, restaurants, discothèques, swimming pools, amusement parks, video game parlours, and auditoriums, in a bid to reduce bureaucratic hurdles. Fire NOCs are currently mandatory for high-rise residential buildings, commercial establishments, factories, hospitals, restaurants, and offices. The official cited above said in a recent meeting chaired by lieutenant governor VK Saxena and attended by chief minister Rekha Gupta, departments were directed to explore steps to improve ease of doing business in Delhi. 'As part of those directions, we are exploring the feasibility of shifting the responsibility for issuing fire certificates. But the department wants to proceed cautiously and study models adopted by other states to ensure that fire safety standards are not compromised,' the official said.
