Province meets with Telus after man dies during 911 outage
The two failures of the emergency system had the Opposition Progressive Conservatives asking heated questions in the legislature Thursday. The NDP government said it has spoken to Telus about a multiple-day outage that occurred in March.
'Manitobans obviously expect good reliable access to emergency services, which includes 911,' PC MLA Derek Johnson, who represents Interlake-Gimli, said Thursday.
MIKE DEAL / FREE PRESS FILES
Innovation and New Technology Minister Mike Moroz said Telus hasn't yet given him all the details of its investigation into a 911 outage in Manitoba.
'It is pretty much part of our public safety necessity, especially in rural Manitoba and it can mean the difference between life and death.'
Fisher Branch-area resident Dean Switzer, 55, died of a heart attack on March 23.
Switzer's family couldn't be reached Thursday.
Johnson said family and friends tried to help Switzer while calling 911 on their cellphones.
'They placed 22 calls and they just didn't get routed to 911,' Johnson said, arguing it wasn't an outage.
'There is a difference between an outage because their cellphones still worked for every other phone call. They could call neighbours for help so it wasn't an outage… So when they are trying to save their loved one, they did CPR for an hour and a half, they were still trying to call 911. Friends and neighbours are now over there helping, while she is doing CPR on her husband, trading off with friends and family, trying to resuscitate him and keep him alive.
'(They) ultimately ended up reaching out to an off-duty RCMP officer on his cellphone.'
The officer went to the RCMP detachment and an ambulance was called.
Johnson said he is calling for the province to hold a public inquiry about what happened with the 911 service.
'How many (other calls) were there? Without an inquiry by the minister, how are we going to know?
'If there is a failure in that, maybe with a specific provider, that is not holding their end of the deal up, maybe they shouldn't be allowed to remain in Manitoba.'
Meanwhile, Willy Ginter, who lives on a farm near Zhoda in southeast Manitoba, said he saw a fire near his property and immediately called 911.
'They put me on hold,' Ginter said. 'I hung up and I tried again — they put me on hold again.
'I figured there was no time to wait so I called the municipality. When they asked if I called 911 I said I did, but they didn't answer.'
Ginter said the municipality contacted the fire department and soon the fire was out. His house was spared, but a vacant farmhouse on the neighbouring property was destroyed.
'911 should be available 24/7, every minute. This was a matter of life and death — it was an emergency. It's not a toy, it's not a joke. If it doesn't work, shut it down and let us call our own fire department.'
Tory MLA Konrad Narth, who represents LaVerendrye, said he wants to know why Ginter was put on hold.
'It's concerning for my constituency right now, being under immediate risk of active wildfires, as people's homes are under threat, that they won't be able to access 911 services,' Narth said.
He said he is even more concerned after speaking about the 911 service with fire chiefs at a fire evacuation centre in the RM of Piney.
'There were eight different fire chiefs there,' Narth said. 'They say in the last 12 months it is commonplace that staffing shortages are not allowing 911 calls to go through to the rural 911 service in Brandon.
'All the fire chiefs are greatly concerned there is going to be a loss of life one day if the province doesn't address this.'
Innovation and New Technology Minister Mike Moroz said he had a meeting with officials from Telus late Thursday afternoon.
'We are deeply concerned about the situation,' Moroz said. '911 should be there when you need it, particularly in a medical emergency, like the one experienced. We had a long and very comprehensive conversation with Telus.'
Moroz said he has asked Telus to notify the province if there are future outages.
He said Telus didn't give him all the details of its investigation because the company is still looking into it and will submit a report to the Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission.
He said Telus told him the outage, which hit all of its equipment linking cellphone users to 911 service, began on March 22, at 8:15 p.m. and lasted until March 24 at 11 a.m. The company refused to say how many Manitobans were affected, citing business confidentiality.
Winnipeg Jets Game Days
On Winnipeg Jets game days, hockey writers Mike McIntyre and Ken Wiebe send news, notes and quotes from the morning skate, as well as injury updates and lineup decisions. Arrives a few hours prior to puck drop.
The outage did not affect Manitobans with different cellphone providers.
'We know the system was down, we know one family was tragically impacted by it, and we know Telus needs to do better,' Moroz said.
'We're going to be there to insist that they are.'
Moroz said the province's justice minister is investigating how the Zhoda-area resident ended up on hold with 911 and hopes to provide more information Friday.
kevin.rollason@freepress.mb.ca
Kevin RollasonReporter
Kevin Rollason is a general assignment reporter at the Free Press. He graduated from Western University with a Masters of Journalism in 1985 and worked at the Winnipeg Sun until 1988, when he joined the Free Press. He has served as the Free Press's city hall and law courts reporter and has won several awards, including a National Newspaper Award. Read more about Kevin.
Every piece of reporting Kevin produces is reviewed by an editing team before it is posted online or published in print — part of the Free Press's tradition, since 1872, of producing reliable independent journalism. Read more about Free Press's history and mandate, and learn how our newsroom operates.
Our newsroom depends on a growing audience of readers to power our journalism. If you are not a paid reader, please consider becoming a subscriber.
Our newsroom depends on its audience of readers to power our journalism. Thank you for your support.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CTV News
2 hours ago
- CTV News
Shots ring out, vehicle struck in Airdrie community; RCMP investigating
Mounties out of Airdrie were called on to investigate a shooting Monday evening. Mounties out of Airdrie were called on to investigate a shooting Monday evening. Around 6 p.m., members of the RCMP attended the newer neighbourhood of Lanark, in the southeast part of the city, for reports of shots fired. An SUV with a busted-out window and holes in the side was visible at the scene. 'Officers are currently on scene and are investigating,' police said in a release to media. 'There is no risk to the public at this time. 'An update will be provided when more information becomes available.' Officers could be seen canvassing the area Monday night.
CTV News
3 hours ago
- CTV News
B.C. RCMP officer who ‘groomed' teen girl must pay $825K in damages for sexual battery, court rules
A statue of Themis, Goddess of Justice, in the B.C. Supreme Court building in downtown Vancouver on June 26, 2024 (Zak Vescera / Investigative Journalism Foundation and CTV News) A B.C. RCMP officer who 'groomed and manipulated' a teenage girl into an exploitative sexual relationship decades ago has been ordered to pay more than $825,000 in damages, according to a recent court decision. William Pound was found liable for sexual battery after a civil trial in Vancouver Supreme Court earlier this year and the judge's decision on damages was posted online Friday. Pound, the decision noted, has never been criminally charged. CTV News is not naming the woman who filed the notice of civil claim. '(The woman) submits that, from the time she was 15 years old, Mr. Pound engaged in a pattern of increasingly intrusive grooming behaviours which led up to sexual intercourse shortly after (her) 16th birthday. She has testified that the sexual relationship continued until she was in her early 20s. (She) is now in her early 60s,' Justice Amy D. Francis wrote, summarizing the claim. 'She submits that the psychological pain she suffered as a result of her relationship with Mr. Pound led to crippling alcohol addiction, social anxiety, and, for approximately 30 years, an inability to live any kind of productive life.' Court hears conflicting accounts of relationship The court heard two 'starkly different accounts' about the relationship between Pound and the woman who filed the civil suit, according to the judgment. She told the court she met him when she was 15, soon after her family moved into the Vancouver Island neighbourhood where he lived with his wife and children. 'She was sunbathing on the front lawn of her house, and Mr. Pound drove up in his police car. He was wearing his police uniform. He introduced himself to (the plaintiff), and to her mother. He told her that he lived close by. (She) found him to be very nice and charming,' Justice Amy D. Francis wrote in the decision, summarizing the woman's account of the first meeting between the two. During subsequent encounters in the neighbourhood, the woman told the court Pound began paying her compliments, saying 'I think you are pretty' and 'I have been thinking about you.' The relationship became 'more intimate' as time passed, and escalated to sexual intercourse. '(The woman) testified that almost all the sexual encounters she had with Mr. Pound took place in his bedroom, on Sunday mornings, while Mrs. Pound and the two children were at church,' the judge wrote. 'Mr. Pound spoke to (her) about adult matters. He discussed his work with her, describing bad car accidents and referring to burn victims as 'crispy critters.' Mr. Pound also told (her) that he was unhappy with his wife. (The woman) interpreted this to mean that there was a romantic future for her and Mr. Pound and this made her very happy. At 16, she believed herself to be in love with Mr. Pound and she wanted them to have a future together.' Pound, for his part, told the court he had sex with the woman when she was 20 years old, and that they had sex on a total of three occasions. 'Mr. Pound's version of events with respect to his sexual relationship with (the woman) was brief and lacking in any detail. In part, this is because he claims he barely knew (her),' the decision said. 'He described her as a neighbour, not a friend and not a romantic partner. He testified that, before they had sex in 1984, he had only spoken to (the woman) a few times and didn't know anything about her.' Ultimately, the judge found the woman's testimony more credible and reliable than Pound's –rejecting his account of the first time they had sexual intercourse as 'utterly improbable' and describing him as a 'challenging witness' overall. 'Mr. Pound referred a number of times to this lawsuit as 'extortion' and suggested that (she) after losing so many years to alcoholism, needed a way to find money and the 'Me Too' movement was the 'opportunity,'' the decision said. Consent and the law After deciding that she preferred the woman's evidence, Francis next turned to the applicable law – focusing on the issue of consent. The woman testified that she consented to the relationship and the sexual acts at the time they occurred, starting when she was 15 with kissing and oral sex. 'The key liability question in this case is therefore whether (her) consent was legally effective in light of the circumstances of the relationship between Mr. Pound and (her),' the judge explained. At the time, there were Criminal Code provisions in place prohibiting 'seduction,' according to the decision, which reproduces the definition of one of the offences. 'Every male person who, being 18 years of age or more, seduces a female person of previously chaste character who is 16 years or more but less than 18 years of age is guilty of an indictable offence and is liable to imprisonment for two years,' the Code said at the time, according to the judgment. The woman's claim argued that given this, the woman would not have been able to legally consent and therefore Pound's conduct would have 'given rise to criminal liability.' Another argument the woman put forward was that her consent was rendered 'legally ineffective' because of the nature of the relationship, specifically that Pound was in a position of power over the woman when she was a teen and the relationship was exploitative. Pound argued he did not occupy a position of power, trust or authority in the teen's life because 'was not a parent, stepparent, teacher, doctor, or priest who could wield power over her day-to-day life,' the decision said. The judge rejected this argument, providing a number of reasons why she determined Pound and the woman were in a 'power-dependency' relationship. '(The woman) was a shy teenager who was bullied at school. She did not have any experience with boys. Mr. Pound pursued her from the outset,' the decision said. 'Mr. Pound was a uniformed RCMP officer and an adult neighbour. Due to his age and social stature, he was someone (the woman) would have looked up to and respected.' He also ingratiated himself with the woman's family, and hired the teenaged girl to babysit his children, the decision said. The judge also said Pound controlled 'every aspect of the relationship,' including when and where sexual activity would occur, further cementing himself in a position of power. Given all of this, the judge found the relationship was one in which the woman did not have the capacity to legally consent to the sexual activity. 'It is eminently clear that Mr. Pound exploited (the woman's) age, immaturity, and lack of sophistication for his own sexual gratification,' the judge wrote. Impact and damages The woman has been sober since 2013, has since obtained an advanced degree, is working as a counsellor and living an overall 'happy and fulfilling life,' the decision said. However, decades of her adult life were consumed by a 'tragic battle with alcohol-use disorder,' according to the decision. The impact of her alcoholism was wide-ranging. She was hospitalized and jailed, lost jobs and housing, struggled with suicidal ideation and was involuntarily committed to a psychiatric facility. 'During the more severe periods of alcohol addiction, it is fair to describe her life as a living nightmare,' Francis wrote. The woman's alcohol misuse, she told the court, started when she was a teenager and was inextricably linked to her relationship with Pound. Pound argued the woman's alcohol use disorder was not 'causally connected' to the relationship or the sexual battery. The judge disagreed. 'While it is possible that (she) would have developed alcoholism in any event, on a balance of probabilities I think it is more likely than not that, but for sexual exploitation by Mr. Pound, (the woman) would not have developed alcohol use disorder.' As compensation for her pain and suffering, the judge awarded $200,000 in damages, in part because the woman 'lost almost everything as a result of her alcohol use disorder.' The decision also described the impact on the woman 'separate and in addition to' her alcoholism. 'Mr. Pound groomed and manipulated her for his own sexual gratification. Her confidence and her very sense of self were deeply impacted by the harms she suffered,' Francis wrote. 'The defendant has consistently demonstrated a callous lack of regard for (the woman) and her suffering. Not only does he deny responsibility for the damage he inflicted, but in the course of his testimony he made gratuitous irrelevant statements, the only purpose of which could be to embarrass and humiliate (the woman).' Pound's conduct was also cited as a reason for awarding $50,000 in punitive damages – which the decision explained are 'the exception and not the rule' and only meted out when a judge determines they are necessary to further punish 'outrageous' wrongdoing. 'His conduct was wrong by contemporary standards, and by the standards of the time,' Francis wrote. 'Notwithstanding his high degree of culpability, Mr. Pound expressed no acknowledgment nor remorse on the witness stand…To this date, Mr. Pound is willfully blind, and seemingly indifferent, to the harms caused by his actions. He appears to view himself, rather than (her), as the victim.' The bulk of damages awarded, $567,000, was compensation for loss of past earning capacity, bringing the total award to $826,000.
CBC
5 hours ago
- CBC
Celebration of cycling in B.C's Okanagan turns tragic with fatality, injuries
A celebration of cycling in B.C.'s Southern Interior turned tragic on the weekend. One person was killed and another two were injured during the 155-kilometre Okanagan Granfondo, which departed from Skaha Lake Park in Penticton. As CBC's Chad Pawson reports, RCMP and race organizers are trying to figure out what caused the tragedy.
