TikTok given High Court permission to challenge €530m fine over transfer of personal data to China
The fine was imposed on the video-sharing site last April, for what the DPC described as an infringement on data protection regarding its transfers of European users' data to The People's Republic of China via remote access to data stored in the US and Singapore by personnel based in China.
In addition to the €530 million fine, the April 30th censure also included an order suspending TikTok's transfer of data to China if its processing was not brought into compliance with European directives on transparency within six months.
On Monday, Ms Justice Mary Rose Gearty granted permission for TikTok to pursue a legal challenge against the DPC decisions and put a stay on them pending the outcome of the legal review.
READ MORE
The High Court action is being taken by TikTok Technology Limited, with an address at The Sorting Office, Ropemaker Place, Dublin 2, and by TikTok Information Technologies UK Limited, Kaleidoscope, Lindsey Street, London, UK, against the DPC, Ireland and the Attorney General.
TikTok Ireland is a private company limited by shares incorporated in the Republic of Ireland and is a wholly-owned subsidiary of TikTok UK.
Both TikTok entities seek the quashing of the decision of the DPC of April 30th, 2025.
Lawyers for the applicants appeared in the High Court on Tuesday on an ex parte basis, where only one side is represented. They submitted that the sections of the Data Protection Act under which the DPC made their decision are invalid when viewed in relation to the Constitution, the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) and the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the EU.
In papers lodged to the High Court, TikTok says that the Ireland and UK arms are 'joint controllers' for the processing of personal data of users based in Europe but add that TikTok UK is 'the entity that will ultimately bear the cost of the administration fines imposed in the decision'.
Ireland and the Attorney General are joined as respondents to the proceedings.
TikTok submits that the imposition of 'administrative' fines of €485 million and €45 million 'constitutes the imposition of a sanction that in its nature and severity is properly characterised as 'criminal' or penal'.
TikTok contends that 'even if the imposition of the fine did not constitute a sanction of a criminal nature, the DPC was nonetheless not exercising merely limited functions and powers of a judicial nature within the meaning of Article 37.1 of the Constitution'.
Article 37.1 aims to validate the delegation of certain judicial powers to administrative bodies without infringing on the exclusive jurisdiction of the courts in criminal matters.
TikTok claims that the fines 'cannot be said to be of a limited nature'.
TikTok submits that the ECHR provides that 'in the determination of civil rights and obligations or of any criminal charges, an individual is entitled to a fair and public hearing within a reasonable time by an independent and impartial tribunal established by law'.
The applicants further claim that the fine 'constitutes an interference with the applicants' right to private property protected under Article 40.3 or 43, or both, of the Constitution'.
'The decision to impose a fine, the amount of the fine and the absence of a full right of appeal constitutes an unjust, unjustified and disproportionate interference with the applicants' right to private property,' TikTok claims.
Ms Justice Gearty granted leave for the judicial review and adjourned the matter to October.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
21 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Tariffs may kill EU-US trade and hunt for auction house treasure
US president Donald Trump's threatened tariffs of 30 per cent would realistically cut off the European Union's ability to keep trading with the United States as it has done for years, the union's top negotiator has said. Jack Power reports. The State is 'well positioned against the backdrop of uncertain markets' even though the Ireland still has debt of more than €200 billion and there is no place for complacency, National Treasury Management Agency (NTMA) chief executive Frank O'Connor said as the agency published its latest annual report. Martin Wall has the story. UK bank NatWest is to exit its stake in PTSB, just over three years after it invested in the Irish bank as part of Ulster Bank's exit from the Republic. Joe Brennan reports. Business lobbying group Ibec has called on the Government to reduce the growth of public expenditure in an effort to reduce the State's reliance on 'volatile' corporate profit tax receipts. Hugh Dooley reports. READ MORE Cantillon looks at the woes Rachel Reeves is enduring as UK chancellor, while also asking why markets are so calm this time in the face of Trump's latest salvos. Many of us have seen someone turn up on the Antiques Roadshow or Cash in the Attic with something they bought for buttons that turns out to worth thousands if not more, but does could it happen to you? Fiona Reddan shows how to find out if that cheap copy you have is actually the real thing. In Your Money, Dominic Coyle answers reader questions on how to treat retirement funds, and whether a widow should hold on to her late husband's broker account. The average wholesale price of electricity per megawatt hour fell for the fifth month in a row in June to drop to its lowest level since April 2024. Colin has the details. The High Court has granted social media giant TikTok permission to pursue a legal challenge against what it argues is the 'penal' €530 million fine imposed upon it by the Data Protection Commissioner (DPC) over the alleged transfer of site-users' personal data to China. Paul Neilan reports. A construction firm is suing a glazing company over alleged defects in glass installed at the Exo Building in Dublin's Point village which it says cost some €6.8 million to repair, the Commercial Court heard. A Milanese court placed exclusive clothing label Loro Piana under judicial administration for subcontracting production to suppliers that allegedly exploited workers, making the LVMH-owned cashmere brand the latest fashion house to be caught up in a series of investigations into labour rights violations. European Commission vice-president Teresa Ribera has warned China that the EU will not tolerate ' dumping ' of low-cost Chinese electric vehicles in Europe. And she rejected the idea that the EU should accept 'cheap equipment' to help member-states to reach their decarbonisation goals. Denis Staunton reports. Shortlists for the annual Business to Arts Awards, which take place at the National Concert Hall September, have been announced . The awards, which recognise businesses that have partnerships with artists and arts organisations, will be judged by representatives from CBRE, ESB, Community Foundation Ireland, Irish Life, The Irish Times, and TileStyle. If you'd like to read more about the issues that affect your finances try signing up to On the Money , the weekly newsletter from our personal finance team, which will be issued every Friday to Irish Times subscribers.
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Shortlists for annual Business to Arts Awards announced
Shortlists for the annual Business to Arts Awards , which take place at the National Concert Hall September, have been announced. The awards, which recognise businesses that have partnerships with artists and arts organisations, will be judged by representatives from CBRE , ESB , Community Foundation Ireland, Irish Life, The Irish Times, and TileStyle. Louise O'Reilly, chief executive of Business to Arts, said this year's shortlists 'attest to businesses engaging at a deep and considered level, ensuring there is a positive impact on both partners and wider society'. The ESB is supporting a new category in the awards this year. Its creative sustainability award recognises partnerships that address issues around the environment, climate crisis, and the circular economy. ESB corporate reputation manager Sarah Sharkey said the group 'recognises the important role that artists play not only in recording and interpreting social and economic developments, but also in engaging communities by fostering creativity and innovation'. Denise Charlton, chief executive of Community Foundation Ireland, said access to the arts is 'an equality issue'. The Juggle: the issues facing women with young children when balancing childcare and their careers Listen | 44:30 'Our partnership with Business to Arts is to recognise and grow awareness around this important contribution by Irish philanthropy and its ability to deliver projects and work which elevate voices. Everyone should have the opportunity to express themselves through the arts,' she said. The awards have 10 categories and three bursaries, celebrating arts sponsorship, commissioning, philanthropy, staff engagement programmes, corporate social responsibility, sustainability, access programmes, and creative community initiatives. The companies shortlisted range from small-scale initiatives to large-scale and long-term engagements with national reach. The event will take place on September 8th. A total of €25,000 will be presented to successful artists and arts organisations through bursaries and awards on the night.
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Rachel Reeves to put on a brave face in Mansion House address
A politician crying in parliament may be generally viewed unwise, but there was a spin-off benefit for British chancellor of the exchequer Rachel Reeves from her recent emotional interlude in the House of Commons. British government bond yields spiked the moment Reeves's tears were flashed across television screens, a signal that markets feared her potential removal. It could, therefore, be interpreted as a vote of confidence – of sorts – in the chancellor by the financial industry, even if it was rooted more in fear of what might follow her. After a torrid few weeks, Reeves will take whatever solace she can find. She will look to regain momentum on Tuesday evening, when she gives a big speech to City of London financiers in the Mansion House, home of the lord mayor of the financial district. British chancellors generally use their annual Mansion House speeches to lay out their approach to financial industry regulation, as well as to flag big fiscal policy adjustments that might of interest to institutional investors and their chief economists. READ MORE In her inaugural address last November, Reeves suggested post-crash financial regulation of bankers and insurers had 'gone too far' and was stifling growth. She is expected to build on that theme on Tuesday with a promise to slash red tape. The Juggle: the issues facing women with young children when balancing childcare and their careers Listen | 44:30 Reeves is expected to announce a loosening of the 'senior manager's regime' that places greater personal responsibility on the shoulders of financial executives for the ramifications of decisions they make on the job. She is also expected to flag an easing of the regulatory regime for the pre-vetting and approval of senior appointments. For the investment professionals in the room, there may be crowd-pleasing announcements to boost auto-enrolment in pensions, as well as a campaign to encourage retail investors to buy shares instead of saving cash. But many will also want answers from Reeves about where she intends to find £6.5 billion (€7.5 billion) of welfare savings she has had to give up, after her plans to cut the winter fuel allowance for pensioners and reduce access to disability payments were killed off by Labour rebels. Her problem could be that she doesn't yet know the answer herself.
