National Association of Realtors defeats Utah brokerage's antitrust lawsuit
National Association of Realtors
has persuaded a federal judge to dismiss a lawsuit by a
Utah
brokerage accusing the powerful industry group of controlling rules for home sales and purchases in the United States too tightly, causing consumers to pay higher prices.
In a ruling on Tuesday, U.S. District Judge Dale Kimball in
Salt Lake City
, Utah said discount home brokerage
Homie Technology
had not presented enough information showing that industry rules developed by the realtors' group harmed the company. Kimball also said Homie's claims were untimely.
The 2024 lawsuit accused the realtor group and several large U.S. brokerages of violating antitrust law by conspiring to boycott Homie, which marketed itself as a new entrant focused on using technology to lower brokerage prices for consumers.
Kimball said "antitrust laws are intended to protect competition, not individual competitors."
Homie's lawyers did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
In a statement, the realtors association said it welcomed the judge's ruling and would continue working to foster competition in real estate markets.
The Chicago-based association denied that its policies hurt Homie, telling the court that Homie, founded in 2015, was once among the largest brokerages in the state.
The realtors association has faced a wave of lawsuits in recent years from home sellers and others that challenged some industry rules, including brokerage commissions.
Last year, the group had agreed to pay $418 million in a nationwide settlement to resolve claims that it conspired with brokerages to inflate commissions that home sellers pay for residential real estate sales.
In its lawsuit, Homie said the association's rules "imposed substantial barriers to the entry and expansion of brokers offering low prices to compete across the United States and in Utah."
Kimball said Homie's lawsuit missed the four-year window to bring claims for U.S. antitrust law violations.
Homie, as a rival to traditional brokerages and a self-described industry disruptor, "actually stood to benefit from the higher prices imposed by the supposed conspiracy," the judge wrote.
Kimball also dismissed Homie's allegations against brokerages including HomeServices of America; Anywhere; and Re/Max. The brokerages had all denied any wrongdoing.
The case is Homie Technology Inc v. National Association of Realtors, U.S. District Court, District of Utah, No. 2:24-cv-00616-DAK-JCB.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
29 minutes ago
- Time of India
Nepal, China steel may face duty evasion probe
The Directorate of Revenue Intelligence may investigate steel imports from Nepal and China. This action aims to shield the Indian steel industry from substandard products. Nepal has become a major steel exporter to India. Concerns arise about Chinese steel being routed through Nepal. Some Chinese companies are allegedly falsifying quality compliance documents. Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads The Directorate of Revenue Intelligence could initiate a probe into steel imports from Nepal and China, a move aimed at protecting the domestic industry from cheap, substandard imports, said people familiar with the comes after Nepal emerged as one of the top three steel exporters to India despite the absence of significant manufacturing facilities, they said."In some instances, a Nepal-based company was exporting steel many times over its nameplate capacity," an official told ET on condition of triggered apprehensions of Chinese steel being routed through Nepal, as alleged by the Indian has unilateral duty-free access to the Indian market, allowing its exporters to send steel products to India without paying any duty. On the contrary, direct exports from China attract at least 12% safeguard share in India's finished steel imports during the first three months of this financial year averaged 15.93%, making the neighbouring country the third largest steel exporter to India during this another instance, China's Shangyang Steel wrote to India's Directorate General of Foreign Trade alleging that other Chinese companies were falsifying documents affirming quality compliance. Shangyang Steel holds a certificate issued by the Bureau of Indian Standards (BIS)."The company alleged that other Chinese companies were misrepresenting the BIS certificate issued to Shangyang Steel and lying while exporting to India," the official month, the steel ministry issued a clarification saying that not only are finished and semi-finished steel imports required to adhere to quality control orders (QCOs) but also the raw material used as input needs to comply with the quality also found that some Indian importers with a BIS certificate were importing substandard steel products from China or Nepal and doing just cosmetic value addition to them."The QCO norms require importers not only to comply with the coating part for which it has certification, but also to ensure that the base material also sticks to quality norms," the official said.A BIS certificate is enforced through QCO, which the government order mainly affects the traders who act as middlemen in importing steel without adding any value to the steel. "MSMEs (micro, small and medium enterprises) are not affected by this order; it hurts the middle parties, and they are the ones who are creating a furore over this," the official added.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Govt mulls life tax exemption for tourism caravan vehicles in AP
Vijayawada: The state govt is likely to give life tax exemption for tourism caravan vehicles to encourage their registration exclusively in Andhra Pradesh under the new 'caravan tourism policy' which is expected to be unveiled soon. Apparently, the life tax exemption would be provided to the first 10 or 20 caravans. According to the tourism department officials, the base variant of a caravan vehicle is pegged at around Rs 1 crore, while the cost of high-end models run into multiple crores depending on their specifications and bespoke customisations opted by the operators. "As per the existing life tax rates, i.e., five percent in AP, a caravan owner needs to pay Rs 5 lakh as life tax while registering the vehicle with the transport department. Accordingly, the tourism department believes the caravan operators can save an average of Rs 10 lakh on life tax, following their exemption, collected during the vehicle registration with the transport department," a senior tourism department official said. The official said that the decision aims to encourage more number of operators to register new caravan vehicles in state. "Chief minister N Chandrababu Naidu launched a caravan vehicle at the tourism conclave organised recently by the tourism department. However, the caravan flagged off by the chief minister on a trial basis, belonging to the Hyderabad-based Luxe Caravans, was a Telangana-registered vehicle," the official mentioned. After rolling out the new policy, the govt aims to see caravans registered with the AP transport department plying on AP roads rather than those registered in the neighbouring states, he added. Get the latest lifestyle updates on Times of India, along with Friendship Day wishes , messages and quotes !
The Hindu
2 hours ago
- The Hindu
Bio-fortified potatoes to hit Indian market soon
Bio-fortified potatoes, with added iron content, will soon be available in Indian markets, said Dr. Simon Heck, Director General of the Peru-based International Potato Center (CIP), in an interview to The Hindu. Bio-fortified sweet potatoes, additionally added Vitamin A using technology developed by the CIP, are already available in Karnataka, Assam, West Bengal and Odisha, and the CIP will take efforts to make available the seeds of bio-fortified sweet potato to more farmers, said Dr. Heck. He is in India as part of the establishment of the South Asia regional centre of the CIP in Agra. Dr. Heck expressed the hope that the centre will help farmers to access better quality potato and sweet potato seeds and better access to the market. The CIP believes that the location outside Agra, in the heart of the potato belt of India, is ideal for the new centre, as the Indo-Gangetic plains are the largest potato-producing area in the world. Dr. Heck said the Government of Uttar Pradesh had made available the land and handed it over to the National Horticulture Board, which invited the CIP to establish a centre. This agreement between the CIP and the Union Agriculture Ministry was signed in the last week of July. It was set up at the demand from the Government of India in recognition of the potential for economic growth and the value generated from the growing potato sector. Dr. Heck said India had the strongest momentum for potato production. 'It may be noted that international companies, especially potato firms from Europe and North America, are increasingly investing in potato production in India,' he said. Part of market chain Dr. Heck said farmers wanted better varieties of potatoes that grew well with fewer agrochemical inputs, and they also wanted to be part of the market chain, including food processing. 'What they needed was access to potato seed of the right quality, of the right variety, and at the right time of the year. There are constraints. They don't have enough potato seeds, or they come too late for planting, or they are not of good quality. We need to build the capacity for companies to multiply potato seeds. That will be a major contribution of the CIP,' he said. The CIP was working with private companies and public research institutes to make sure that throughout the chain, right from the initial breeding of new varieties, through multiplication every year, in the right locations, farmers throughout India would have access to good quality planting material. He said the CIP would also ensure that the vulnerable parts of society had access to nutritious potatoes. There were a number of opportunities along that road, one of which was to work with the government, with public sector food procurement, for school feeding, such as mid-day meals, to link nutritious potatoes into those programmes, more specifically and consistently, to give children access to that. 'Another one was to breed a more nutritious potato,' Dr. Heck said. The focus was on iron fortification in potatoes. 'We have already shared the germ plasm with the Indian Council of Agricultural Research's [ICAR] Central Potato Institute in Shimla. The first variety has been released in Peru, because iron deficiency is even higher in Peru. Now it is under the evaluation of the ICAR, and it needs to be adapted to the Indian growing conditions,' he said. He said bio-fortified sweet potatoes with added Vitamin A were being grown by farmers in Odisha, West Bengal, Karnataka and Assam. 'It is already widely produced. They are bright orange inside,' he said. Coordination committee The CIP regional centre would be governed by a coordination committee that comprises the Secretaries of Agriculture of India, Nepal, Bhutan and Bangladesh. The CIP would also study the market in the region that failed to provide adequate prices for potatoes. 'The open market has the glut or sometimes the shortage. The government needs to step in there through market boards and see how they can anticipate supplies ahead of time. New varieties can also expand the window seasonality so that not everybody harvests on the same day or in the same week. That will help with stabilising the price and the supplies,' he said. On the growing consumption of sweet potatoes around the world, he said it was a tropical crop, unlike potatoes. 'The prospects are very strong for India to be a global supplier of sweet potato. You need to stabilise sweet potatoes through some kind of processing early on. It can be stored without refrigeration, without any chemical additives, for two years. So, for India, places in Africa, that is a very interesting product, from a commercial point of view. It is a final product. You can eat it like that in a school meal and is highly nutritious. It is for the food industry to further utilise it in baking and confectionaries,' Dr. Heck said.
