Scottish Ministers call in hotel demolition decision
East Lothian councillors voted to approve plans to tear down the Golf Hotel, in North Berwick, and replace it with 14 flats at a meeting earlier this year.
The decision went against planning officers recommendations and objections from Historic Environment Scotland who are a statutory body.
In a letter to the local authority Scottish Ministers have confirmed they will consider the application themselves and issue a decision.
It comes after the Architectural Heritage Society of Scotland (AHSS) also called for Government intervention describing the unlisted building as 'architecturally distinguished' adding it occupies a 'key position in the North Berwick conservation area.
The Golf Hotel closed commercially in 2006 and had been used by its owners for staff accommodation until it was bought by its current owners during the pandemic.
However plans to demolish the building and build 14 flats on the site, on Dirleton Avenue, were recommended for refusal by planning officers who said it had not been proven that the hotel could not continue to operate as a commercial venture.
And Historic Environment Scotland (HES) objected to its demolition after describing the building as having historic and architectural significance in the town.
At a planning committee meeting in March East Lothian councillors heard the former hotel had initially been a house for a single family who used it in the last century as a holiday home evening bringing their own cattle with them so the children did not have to drink local milk.
Caledonian Heritable bought the building in 2021 and applied for permission to demolish it and build 14 luxury flats on the site.
Objectors to the demolition said the building should be given listed status and was an important part of the town's conservation area.
A council spokesperson said: 'Scottish Ministers have called in the application for the demolition of the former Golf Hotel meaning it will now be for them to determine.
'We have submitted the necessary information required to begin the process and made all local members, the community council and objectors aware of this action.'
By Marie Sharp Local Democracy Reporter
Like this:
Like
Related
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The National
3 hours ago
- The National
Building memories brick by brick at the home of LEGO in Denmark
To be fair, I was a massive fan of LEGO when I was wee, back when it was just simple bricks you bashed together to make unrecognisable approximations of things I loved, like planes and boats. As I grew up and LEGO morphed into a confusing array of theme parks and special ranges – from LEGO Friends and the Asian-themed Ninjago – I lost sight of LEGO as my two daughters grew into it. It was not something at 53 I thought I would take any pleasure re-visiting. READ MORE: Scottish transport company acquires historic English bus firm I thought my honesty with Kathrine would fall on deaf ears. Far from it. 'We too realised we had to simplify things and get back to the core of what this family-run business does,' she beams as she brews me a proper coffee in LEGO House's café – it's always a great sign when a managing director chips in. 'We got back to basics, selling off the theme parks and focusing back on the brick. Again, it's all about the brick.' It is all about the brick in Billund – the self-styled 'Capital of Children' – as we find out when we fly into the airport and see the immediate image of LEGO. Billund is still home to LEGO's headquarters and lives and breathes LEGO, nowhere more so than LEGO House (below), which has been a roaring success since opening in 2017. LEGO House is the single biggest investment by LEGO in years and took a year and a half to build, with 20 million LEGO bricks woven into the structure. I love that the vast reception is free for anyone to enter and play in. And that numbers are strictly limited beyond the ticket barriers to the upper floors so that families can really enjoy themselves without feeling rushed or overcrowded. The focus is indeed back on the brick, with building using LEGO paramount over fancy themed kits. For a family attraction to work, it has to engage everyone; LEGO House does. My daughters delight in building wee boats and buses, taking photos that are recorded on their bracelets, negating the 'need' for my teenagers to walk around with their phones. Indeed, they soon ask us to store their phones while they throw themselves into the action, peeling back the years. Priceless. We bond over family portraits made of LEGO, but they also skip off happily on their own with none of the bickering that can accompany visits to family attractions. And my wife and I don't just slump in a café either, making what is, of course, deemed an 'embarrassing' LEGO movie about how we met and married. As we move from yellow zone to red, to green and to blue, my cynicism slowly dissolves. My own journey is complete in the basement museum, which catapults me back to my childhood. Not ones to stand on their hard-won plastic laurels, Kathrine shows me into the 'Masters Academy'. 'LEGO House already has 20 million LEGO bricks and soon it will have another five million more,' she explains. It doesn't open until September, but the limited slots are getting snapped up fast at this new year-round attraction. It looks like a TV show and will have two actors leading just 40 guests through the weird and wonderful world of becoming a 'LEGO Master'. Often restaurants at theme parks are just refuelling stops bathed in grease. Not so at LEGO House with Mini Chef. Kathrine insists they 'serve proper food'. She is right, just that it is served by robots. The delightful Robert and Roberta dispense our lunchboxes. We choose our meals – mine is falafel followed by a delicious cauliflower curry – on the screen at our table then insert our orders – built, of course, in LEGO. Kathrine insists there will only ever be one LEGO House, but there are 11 LEGOLAND theme parks globally. The original, of course, is in Billund. LEGOLAND may no longer be owned by LEGO, but the second-biggest tourist attraction in Denmark outside Copenhagen swirls around the brick. We spend a whole day at LEGOLAND. Again, it proves, for me, surprisingly enjoyable. The Billund incarnation is much more laidback than the frenetic Windsor one. My teens enjoy bashing around rides that may not have the adrenaline wows of Florida's parks, but are fun for us all to share together. If you're visiting the LEGO House, a visit to the adjacent theme park remains essential. For busier times, they have an efficient fast-track system too – 'Reserve and Ride'. Heading home, I'd expected the kids would be sated with LEGO. Instead Tara is gleaming with the LEGO kit she bought by the designer who was casually signing boxes in the LEGO House, and Emma insists the first thing she is going to do when she gets home is get out her LEGO. I may well be joining her. For more information on LEGO House, see Make sure to book ahead for the house, the Mini Chef experience and the LEGO Masters Academy
The National
3 hours ago
- The National
SNP under fire over public energy firm as Wales launches wind projects
The Labour-run administration in Cardiff set up Trydan Gwyrdd Cymru (which translates to Green Electricity Wales) in 2024, and in July announced plans for three wind farms on publicly owned Welsh woodlands – as well as more renewable energy projects yet to be finalised. Trydan said the initial three wind farms would be able to generate up to 400 MW of clean electricity – enough to power around one in four Welsh homes – with 'all profits generated reinvested in Welsh communities and public services'. In 2017, then-Scottish first minister Nicola Sturgeon pledged to establish a 'publicly owned, not-for-profit energy company', but the policy was dropped after the 2021 Holyrood elections. Robin McAlpine, from the Common Weal think tank, said that they had partnered with Plaid Cymru during their time in the Welsh government to lay the groundwork for Trydan Gwyrdd Cymru. 'The whole point of that conversation was to explain how to create a public energy company under a devolved settlement – and the fact that this is happening in Wales shows that it certainly could have happened in Scotland too,' he said. READ MORE: UK energy bills to rise as Ofgem approves £24bn investment 'Common Weal has made this point over and over again – the letter of the devolution settlement says the Scottish Government can't own a wind farm, but we've set out about six different workarounds. 'The fastest is to create an energy company which is co-ordinated and funded by the Scottish Government, but in which the actual wind farms are owned by local authorities. 'We have told the Scottish Government this again and again. It is a very active choice to maintain an almost wholly privatised energy system in Scotland.' Scottish Greens co-leader Patrick Harvie MSP also called for more to be done to ensure communities in Scotland see the benefits of energy generation projects. Scottish Green co-leader Patrick Harvie (Image: PA) 'Scotland has seen extraordinary growth in renewables, but this hasn't come with the growth of local, community and public ownership that some countries have achieved,' he told the Sunday National. 'We have an abundance of natural resources at our disposal that can generate clean, green, renewable energy, and we also have highly skilled people with years of experience working in the energy sector. The Greens want these resources to benefit everyone, not just giant private investors. 'It is great to see Wales taking steps in this direction. As Greens, we've long made the case for every local community to have its own energy company, as well as a role for the national level. 'The Scottish Government can do far more to ensure that the ownership models for renewable energy put money back into communities across Scotland, at the same time as cutting emissions. Local ownership, community ownership and public ownership should all be playing a much bigger role.' READ MORE: Scottish Government approves one of world's biggest wind farms amid controversy However, a Scottish Government spokesperson insisted that they did not have the powers required. 'A national public energy company that is involved in large-scale energy generation would only be possible in an independent Scotland where we had full powers over the energy market and full access to borrowing,' they said. 'We are committed to maximising the public benefits of our renewables revolution, and while many powers remain reserved, we will use the powers we do have and continue to grow community investment in energy-related projects and technology.' In January, Scottish Energy Secretary Gillian Martin told MSPs that setting up a publicly owned energy firm was "not something we are able to do at the moment with the current devolution settlement". Rebecca Evans is the Economy Secretary in the Welsh Labour Government (Image: Welsh Government) Announcing the Trydan Gwyrdd Cymru plans for 400MW of wind farm capacity, Welsh Labour's Economy Secretary Rebecca Evans said: 'These proposals demonstrate our commitment to harnessing Wales's abundant natural resources to generate clean energy while ensuring the benefits are felt locally. 'By developing these projects on the Welsh Government Woodland Estate, we're making best use of our public land to tackle the climate emergency and create sustainable economic opportunities." A press release said that the developments will 'create hundreds of jobs during construction and operation, with Trydan committed to involving Welsh companies throughout the process'.
Daily Record
3 hours ago
- Daily Record
Scots losing free ATMs at rate of nearly four per week in cash access crisis
Figures from LINK, the UK's cash machine network, show free-to-use ATMs in Scotland have declined by about 30 per cent since 2018. Scots are losing free ATMs at a rate of nearly four per week amid a mounting cash access crisis, data shows. Figures from LINK, the UK's cash machine network, show free-to-use ATMs in Scotland have declined by about 5100 in 2018 to around 3500 today. That means there's about one free cash machine for every 1600 Scottish adults. Campaigners say the decline of bank branches along with ATMs is a 'disaster' for remote and rural communities and vulnerable groups who depend on cash. Ron Delnevo, of the Payment Choice Alliance, said: 'It's a bit scary for Scotland, because once you get out of the big cities, there's not a lot left. It's pathetic.' He used the example of Edzell, near Brechin, which lost its only bank branch, a Bank of Scotland site, in 2016. Delnevo said: 'There's no ATM in Edzell, so if you want cash from an ATM you have to go as far as Brechin. That's a 12-mile round trip. "These people have suffered, in the last ten years, a massive deterioration in the service. "If you go all around Scotland, it's the same thing when you find small places. "In the UK, I think Scotland is worst affected, because taking into account population, we've got a massive geographic area and there are many isolated communities. "They've been badly let down by the banks." The relentless pace of bank branch closures - particularly across remote and rural areas - has coincided with the rise in online banking. The Covid pandemic also saw a drive by firms towards cashless payments. But LINK's own research shows cash remains the most trusted payment method, with 76 per cent of British consumers saying it's important to have the option to pay with hard currency. Douglas Ross, Tory MSP for the Highlands and Islands, said: 'The rapid decline of free-to-use cash machines is deeply worrying, particularly for older Scots and vulnerable people who rely on cash to manage their day-to-day lives. 'Access to cash isn't a luxury, it's a necessity, especially in rural areas and for supporting local businesses that still depend on cash payments. 'We need a clear strategy to safeguard the remaining cash machines across Scotland before it's too late.' It comes as Scottish Labour has today launched a new consultation to tackle 'scandal of financial exclusion' including issues with cash access to help tackle poverty. The party's finance spokesman Michael Marra said: 'Low-income families are often reliant on cash, and the loss of bank branches and ATMs has hit them hardest.' Join the Daily Record WhatsApp community! Get the latest news sent straight to your messages by joining our WhatsApp community today. You'll receive daily updates on breaking news as well as the top headlines across Scotland. No one will be able to see who is signed up and no one can send messages except the Daily Record team. All you have to do is click here if you're on mobile, select 'Join Community' and you're in! If you're on a desktop, simply scan the QR code above with your phone and click 'Join Community'. We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like. To leave our community click on the name at the top of your screen and choose 'exit group'. If you're curious, you can read our Privacy Notice. Some of the most vulnerable groups in the country often rely on cash, including people with disabilities, older people and those in abusive relationships who might depend on cash as an escape route from controlling partners. UK-wide, free cash machines hit a peak of around 55,000 in 2018 but have since plummeted to around 35,000, latest data shows - a drop of more than a third. Insiders say the UK total could eventually "bottom out" at around 15,000. Delnevo added: "What would that mean for Scotland? It would certainly be a dramatic loss. It might mean Scotland is left with fewer than 1500 ATMs. "If it goes down to that level, you're going to have miles and miles without any ATM coverage."
