2025 Emmys Predictions: Outstanding Comedy Series
The State of the Race
The Outstanding Comedy Series nominations have been the most consistent among the main series categories, so it feels really easy to say that 'Abbott Elementary,' 'The Bear,' 'Hacks,' and 'Only Murders in the Building' are all set for their third or fourth nominations in the category. 'What We Do in the Shadows' also feels like a safe prediction, even though it was not nominated every season it was on, because it made the cut last year, and is in its last eligible year.
More from IndieWire
Everything to Remember from 'Squid Game' Season 1 and 2
'Matlock' Production Designer Adam Rowe on How Two Canceled Shows Gave the CBS Hit Its Scale
In terms of new contenders, Netflix has uncharacteristically entered this season with the most comedies, which could be seen as a good thing or a bad thing for the streaming service. The consensus is that romantic comedy 'Nobody Wants This' is a shoo-in for a nomination, as it has had a long runway of campaigning that includes some winter TV award wins, but it has been harder to parse whether voters preferred 'The Four Season' over 'The Residence,' or 'A Man on the Inside' over 'Running Point.' All the shows have run strong campaigns, to the point where an Emmy voter would have a different answer on which ones they're voting for any given day.
Apple TV+ has been more succinct. 'The Studio' is its big new comedy, and although people have questions about who the show is for outside of people who work in Hollywood, the Emmys are importantly voted on by people who work in Hollywood. 'Shrinking' also stands out as a strong candidate for a nomination, even though it did not receive one for Season 1, because it is one of the series that has leaned heavily into being shot in Los Angeles, even having voters come visit the set as part of its official For Your Consideration event. The devastating wildfires in January have really put that element into focus, as the influential Television Academy members that are going to all these shows' FYC events are largely LA-based creatives that want to keep more work inside the city.
Surprisingly, the big wild cards in the comedy race are HBO series. While 'Hacks' has helped the develop the identity of HBO Max as this hub for broader shows with an edge that comes from not having to worry about standards and practices as much, HBO proper has seen its comedies get darker and weirder in the past couple years. Ultimately, that has led to continued critical success, but on the Emmys front, voters have not been as welcoming to 'The Righteous Gemstones' or 'The Rehearsal,' which is a shame, because they are two contenders that have made their audiences laugh the hardest.
With this being the last season for 'The Righteous Gemstones,' and 'The Rehearsal' becoming a bigger hit that does not have to deal with comparisons to 'Jury Duty' this time around, there is a glimmer of hope that the Emmys will embrace both shows this year, or the small but adored 'Somebody Somewhere.' After all, this is the network that absolutely dominated this category with 'Veep' less than a decade ago.
Predicted Nominees:'Abbott Elementary' (ABC)'The Bear' (FX)'Hacks' (HBO Max)'Nobody Wants This' (Netflix)'Only Murders in the Building' (Hulu)'Shrinking' (Apple TV+)'The Studio' (Apple TV+)'What We Do in the Shadows' (FX)
Contenders:'Agatha All Along' (Disney+)'The Four Seasons' (Netflix)'The Rehearsal' (HBO)In a Perfect World:'Colin from Accounts' (Paramount+)'Ghosts' (CBS)'Overcompensating' (Prime Video)
More Comedy Category Predictions:Outstanding Lead Actor in a Comedy SeriesOutstanding Lead Actress in a Comedy SeriesOutstanding Supporting Actor in a Comedy SeriesOutstanding Supporting Actress in a Comedy Series
View IndieWire's full set of predictions for the 77th Emmy Awards.
Last Year's Winner: 'Hacks'Still Eligible: Yes.Hot Streak: While 'Ted Lasso' is the most recent series to win the Emmy for Outstanding Comedy Series twice in a row, it's been years since the category has had a true hot streak with a specific show and/or network winning the category year after year.Notable Ineligible Series: 'Reservation Dogs' (ended); 'Curb Your Enthusiasm' (ended); 'The Gentlemen' (Season 2 is not eligible); 'Palm Royale' (Season 2 is not eligible)
Best of IndieWire
2023 Emmy Predictions: Who Will Win at the Primetime Emmy Awards?
2023 Emmy Predictions: Outstanding Documentary or Nonfiction Special
2023 Emmy Predictions: Outstanding Documentary or Nonfiction Series
Solve the daily Crossword
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Post
22 minutes ago
- New York Post
Jon Stewart addresses possible ‘Daily Show' cancellation after Stephen Colbert gets axed
Is 'The Daily Show' next to face the chopping block? Jon Stewart addressed the speculation that his late-night Comedy Central talk show might be canceled as the network's parent company, Paramount Global, prepares to merge with Skydance Media. The comedian's remarks came the same day that CBS announced its plan to cancel 'The Late Show With Stephen Colbert' after the program's next season. 13 Jon Stewart attends Comedy Central's 'The Daily Show' FYC Event at Linwood Dunn Theater on June 7, 2025, in Los Angeles, California. Getty Images for Comedy Central 13 Stephen Colbert during 'The Late Show with Stephen Colbert' on June 25, 2025. CBS via Getty Images 'Boy, that's a good question,' Stewart, 62, said during 'The Weekly Show' podcast on Thursday, July 17. 'Unfortunately, we haven't heard anything from them. They haven't called me and said like, 'Don't get too comfortable in that office, Stewart!'' 'But let me tell you something: I've been kicked out of s—-ier establishments than that,' he added. 'We'll land on our feet.' However, Stewart also noted that the show could avoid potential cancellation because it is one of Comedy Central's most popular programs. 13 Jon Stewart talks possible 'Daily Show' cancellation during the July 17 episode of 'The Weekly Show' podcast. The Weekly Show With Jon Stewart/YouTube 13 Jon Stewart during the July 17 episode of 'The Weekly Show' podcast. The Weekly Show With Jon Stewart/YouTube 'I'd like to believe that without 'The Daily Show'… I don't know. Comedy Central is kind of like muzak at this point,' he shared. 'I think we're the only sort of life that exists on a current basis other than 'South Park.' But it's the only thing on there.' Premiering in 1996, Stewart has hosted 'The Daily Show' for 16 of its nearly 30-year run. After serving as the show's main anchor from 1999 to 2015, he returned in 2024 as a part-time host. 13 Jon Stewart discusses 'The Daily Show' during the July 17 episode of 'The Weekly Show' podcast. The Weekly Show With Jon Stewart/YouTube 13 Jon Stewart hosts 'The Daily Show with Jon Stewart' on August 6, 2015, in New York City. Getty Images for Comedy Central The long-running Comedy Central talk show earned a 2025 Emmy nomination for Outstanding Talk Series earlier this week, and Deadline reported that the program recently scored its highest ratings since August 2015. That still might not be enough to save it from cancellation should Paramount merge with Skydance in a deal valued as high as $8 billion. 'I'd like to think we bring enough value to the property,' Stewart continued. 'If they're looking at it as purely a real estate transaction, I think we bring a lot of value.' 13 Jon Stewart at a Comedy Central event for 'The Daily Show' on June 8, 2025. Image Press Agency/NurPhoto/Shutterstock 'But that may not be their consideration. They may sell the whole f—ing place for parts. I just don't know,' he concluded. 'We'll deal with it when we do.' Meanwhile, this week also saw CBS announce the cancellation of Stephen Colbert's beloved late-night show next year. The network claimed it was 'purely a financial decision' in a statement released on Thursday. 13 Stephen Colbert during an episode of 'The Late Show with Stephen Colbert' on May 15, 2025. CBS via Getty Images 13 Stephen Colbert during 'The Late Show with Stephen Colbert' on July 14, 2025. CBS via Getty Images 'We consider Stephen Colbert irreplaceable and will retire 'The Late Show' franchise in May of 2026,' the statement read. 'We are proud that Stephen called CBS home. He and the broadcast will be remembered in the pantheon of greats that graced late-night television.' 'This is purely a financial decision against a challenging backdrop in late night,' the CBS execs added. 'It is not related in any way to the show's performance, content or other matters happening at Paramount.' Colbert addressed the shocking cancellation during the show's Thursday taping. 13 A marquee is displayed at the Ed Sullivan Theater, where 'The Late Show with Stephen Colbert' is filmed, in New York City on July 18, 2025. REUTERS 13 Stephen Colbert poses for a picture with the award for Outstanding Variety Special at the 73rd Primetime Emmy Awards in Los Angeles on September 19, 2021. REUTERS 'I share your feelings,' Colbert, 61, said after his audience booed at the news. 'I'm not being replaced, this is all just going away.' 'The Late Show' premiered on CBS in 1993 with host David Letterman. Colbert took over in 2015 after Letterman, 78, left the show. 'The Late Show With Stephen Colbert' is set to end in May 2026. 13 Jimmy Kimmel at his desk for an episode of 'Jimmy Kimmel Live!' on May 20, 2025. Disney via Getty Images 13 Jimmy Fallon during a segment of 'The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon' on Wednesday, May 21, 2025 Todd Owyoung/NBC via Getty Images Jimmy Kimmel, whose competing late-night show airs on ABC, threw his support behind Colbert and blasted CBS over its surprising decision. 'Love you Stephen,' Kimmel wrote on his Instagram Story after the news was announced. 'F–k you and all your Sheldons CBS.' Jimmy Fallon, another fellow late-night host, also took to his Instagram Story to weigh in on CBS' decision to cancel 'The Late Show With Stephen Colbert.' 'I'm just as shocked as everyone,' the 'Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon' host wrote on Friday morning. 'Stephen is one of the sharpest, funniest hosts to ever do it.' 'I really thought I'd ride this out with him for years to come,' he added.
Time Magazine
23 minutes ago
- Time Magazine
Colbert's Cancellation Puts Late-Night TV in Apocalypse Mode
Thursday's episode of CBS's The Late Show with Stephen Colbert opened with the host turning in his desk chair and appearing startled to see viewers he's been entertaining for the past decade: 'Oh hey, everybody,' he greeted them, with the kind of self-conscious folksiness that has defined his post-Colbert Report persona. But the bit prefaced a bombshell. Colbert revealed that he'd just been told that his show would end in May 2026. A chorus of boos reverberated through the studio audience. Colbert matched their energy: 'Yeah, I share your feelings!' Moreover, the host explained, 'It's the end of The Late Show on CBS. I'm not being replaced. This is all just going away.' Running down a list of thank-yous, he sounded both mournful and characteristically magnanimous: 'It is a fantastic job. I wish somebody else was getting it.' By the time the announcement aired, the news had been ricocheting around the media for hours, the rare entertainment story that merited push notifications from major publications and timely reactions from high-profile politicians. One of the latter was Elizabeth Warren, who fired off a scorching social media post. 'CBS canceled Colbert's show just THREE DAYS after Colbert called out CBS parent company Paramount for its $16M settlement with Trump—a deal that looks like bribery,' the senator wrote. 'America deserves to know if his show was canceled for political reasons.' The timing of The Late Show's demise is indeed concerning, and if the lawsuit did influence the network's decision to can Colbert—a perennial Trump critic—the implications for free speech in cultural commentary as well as in comedy are nothing short of terrifying. Still, as that story develops, it's also worth acknowledging what we know for sure: The end of The Late Show is the biggest nail yet in the coffin of a dying late-night talk show format. Senator Warren is hardly alone in making the connection between Colbert's firing and Paramount's settlement with the President. To summarize the facts behind the furor: On July 1, Paramount Global agreed to pay $16 million to settle Trump's lawsuit alleging that CBS's flagship news magazine 60 Minutes edited an October 2024 interview with then-VP and presidential candidate Kamala Harris with the aim of persuading viewers to vote for her. Because the suit was widely seen as baseless, with legal experts and Paramount itself lining up to insist it had no merit, the news of the network's capitulation sent shockwaves through the media. As First Amendment expert Amy Kristin Sanders told TIME earlier this month: 'CBS selected clips from the interview that they thought would be the best to inform their audience—a very common journalistic practice… It's been recognized by the Supreme Court as the process of editorial discretion or editorial decision making and it's protected by the First Amendment.' It didn't escape widespread notice, either, that Paramount's concession coincided with the company's merger with David Ellison's Skydance Media, for which it will need the federal government's approval. This was the aspect of the settlement that seemed to most offend Colbert, who returned from a summer hiatus on Monday with some strong words in criticism of what he described as Trump's 'nuisance lawsuit': 'As someone who has always been a proud employee of this network, I am offended. And I don't know if anything will ever repair my trust in this company—but just taking a stab at it, I'd say $16 million would help,' the host quipped at the top of his monologue. 'I believe that this kind of complicated financial settlement with a sitting government official has a technical name in legal circles—it's big fat bribe.' To hear Paramount and CBS execs tell it, Colbert's speech had nothing to do with The Late Show's cancellation. 'This is purely a financial decision against a challenging backdrop in late night,' they maintained. 'It is not related in any way to the show's performance, content or other matters happening at Paramount.' For his part, commenting on Truth Social Friday morning, the President further inserted himself in the narrative. 'I absolutely love that Colbert' got fired. His talent was even less than his ratings,' Trump wrote. 'I hear Jimmy Kimmel is next. Has even less talent than Colbert!' Regardless of what the full story might be—and of any disagreement one might have with POTUS's estimation of Colbert or skepticism one might harbor that he possesses inside knowledge of Kimmel's fate—both statements capture the ominous outlook for late night in general. Network late-night shows have been in ratings freefall for years now, with culprits ranging from the rise of streaming to the supremacy of social video platforms among the young adults who could once be counted on to tune in at midnight to the long pandemic hiatuses and subsequent socially distanced lockdown comebacks that broke many viewers of a nightly habit. This shift has manifested, over the last few years, in broadcasters cutting corners, from NBC snipping the Friday installment of Jimmy Fallon's Tonight Show to CBS scrapping The Late Late Show after the departure of James 'Carpool Karaoke' Corden. It has also led to conservative decision-making in the late-night realm; as nice as it has been to see Jon Stewart back on The Daily Show every Monday, his return was basically a tacit admission that the onetime cultural juggernaut could not survive without him. And it has accelerated despite such experiments in cultivating Gen Z audiences as NBC's A Little Late with Lilly Singh, whose host made her name on YouTube, and CBS's own Late Late Show replacement After Midnight, helmed by 31-year-old comedian Taylor Tomlinson—both canceled after less than two years on the air. The thing is, as many commentators have already pointed out, by the diminished standards of network late night in 2025, Colbert is having a good year. He's beating his broadcast competitors, Kimmel and Fallon, in the ratings. Just this week, The Late Show scored yet another Emmy nomination (even as the TV Academy snubbed late night's most promising debut in ages: Netflix's Everybody's Live with John Mulaney). At a moment when late-night programs' presence on the internet is considered a crucial indicator of their brand value and cultural impact, it boasts nearly 10 million YouTube subscribers and has recently gone viral on TikTok with interviews of such Gen-Z-relevant figures as Zohran Mamdani (3.9 million views) and Megan Stalter (1.8 million views). Not that Colbert, despite his vocal opposition to Trump, is some kind of outspoken lefty. When Mamdani appeared alongside his also-progressive opponent-slash-ally, Brad Lander, in advance of June's New York City mayoral primary, Colbert hastened to clarify: 'I am not endorsing either one of you.' Then he grilled Mamdani with centrist criticisms of the candidate's embrace of democratic socialism and support for Palestinians. All of which is to say that, within the realm of broadcast late night, Colbert is an outlier only insofar as he's doing better than the competition. And yet The Late Show—which has been airing for nearly 32 years, originally under the envelope-pushingly weird leadership of David Letterman—is the first of the three big network late-night dynasties to be canceled. When it goes dark next May, only Kimmel and Fallon will remain in the 11:35 timeslot. Even if you're convinced that Trump's preferences are weighing on every entertainment exec's every programming choice, don't be surprised if 2016's hair-ruffle heard 'round the world doesn't save Fallon, who has been trending at the bottom of the heap with roughly half as many viewers as Colbert. Whatever sealed The Late Show's fate, the result is an acceleration of late night's demise from slow decline to full-on apocalypse mode. Because for a company of Paramount's or NBCUniversal's or ABC parent Disney's size and vulnerability—given an ailing entertainment industry—every decision is ultimately financial. That would certainly include any decision based on the 'challenging backdrop in late night' (I assume that since the statement explicitly disputes that 'the show's performance' and 'content' played any role, this vague turn of phrase refers to the expense of making The Late Show, the outlook for future seasons, or both). It would also include any decision made in hopes of appeasing the Trump administration. What is the Skydance merger, after all, but a financial arrangement aimed at improving Paramount's financial prospects? None of these factors are mutually exclusive. Nor would a 'purely financial' choice to end The Late Show, thereby eliminating one of vanishingly few outlets for political commentary, make its cancellation any less destructive to the discourse. The bottom line is: If it can happen to Stephen Colbert, it can happen to anyone—and might well happen to everyone, with effects that are sure to extend beyond the realm of TV comedy.
Washington Post
23 minutes ago
- Washington Post
What made ‘The Late Show with Stephen Colbert' special, in six clips
There may be no tougher — and sought-after — gig than hosting a network late-night TV show. Stephen Colbert joined that rarefied list of late-night hosts in 2015, when he took over CBS's 'The Late Show' from David Letterman. Ten years later, on Thursday night, Colbert announced that not only would he be departing the show, but CBS was canceling the entire 'Late Show' enterprise, in a stunning move that some have speculated may have political motives (CBS strongly denied this, saying it was ending the popular program for financial reasons).
