Convicted paedophile brands residential school abuse allegations ‘rubbish'
The inquiry is investigating abuse in residential settings including boarding schools, religious establishments and foster care.
On Tuesday, an ex-teacher referred to as Evan gave evidence via videolink from prison, where he is serving an eight-year sentence for sex offences.
The rapist was jailed at the High Court in Edinburgh in 2021 for seven charges against five girls aged 12 to 16.
Three of these overlapped the period when he was a teacher at Ovenstone Residential School in Pittenweem, Fife, in the 1980s – though the girls were not pupils there.
The man was given anonymity by the Scottish Child Abuse Inquiry (SCAI) and was referred to as Evan.
Ovenstone was a school for children with behavioural and emotional problems.
He was asked about three convictions of rape and sexual assault on the school premises, but denied the crimes had occurred, the inquiry heard.
The former teacher repeatedly answered 'no comment' to allegations of violence and sexual assault made by the father of a pupil, and branded it a 'load of rubbish', the inquiry heard.
Giving evidence, Evan described Ovenstone as 'the end of the line' for pupils he described as 'castaways', and recalled 'a little village school', praising the 'caring attitude' of staff he worked with in the Fife fishing village.
Evan said: 'It was our job to re-integrate children into mainstream schools and society.'
He denied general allegations of abuse, and said he was unaware of allegations of abuse during his time at the school.
However, he replied 'no comment' to a string of allegations of violence.
Counsel for the inquiry Ruth Innes KC said: 'I'm going to ask you about allegations made against you [by a pupil's father]. Did you ever grab him by the back of the head?
'Did you ever hit his head on a desk? Did you ever slam the lid of the desk down on his hands?
'Did you ever press your finger into his forehead making him bend his head back? Whilst doing that did you shout in his face?
'Did you ever hit him with a pool cue? Did you ever sexually assault him with a pool cue?'
After replying 'no comment', Evan said: 'This has been investigated. All my lawyer said is to say 'no comment'. I am finding it very difficult, because that list is a load of rubbish.'
Chair of the inquiry, Lady Smith said: 'It's a matter of fairness that the questions are given to you.'
Evan said: 'I'm sorry it's just so frustrating, that I can't unload myself to you. Obviously I've got to do what my lawyer tells me to do.'
Ms Innes asked if he had physically disciplined any pupils; physically assaulted any pupils, or sexually assaulted any pupils – all of which Evan denied.
She said: 'We know about the convictions and they did not involve any children attending Ovenstone. Did you commit any similar offences against any child at Ovenstone?'
Evan said: 'No.'
Ms Innes said: 'Some of the offences in respect of which you were convicted took place at the time you were teaching, and in one case on the premises. How was it you were able to commit the offences and not be detected?'
Evan said: 'No comment on that.'
Ms Innes added: 'How was it you were able to commit those offences at Ovenstone and it not be detected?'
Evan said: 'Quite simply because it never happened.'
He described pupils as 'fragile' and 'castigated', the inquiry heard.
Evan denied any awareness of staff abusing pupils, or peer group abuse, but said that there was a lack of training on child protection.
He said: 'If children were being bullied we cut that off very quickly, because these children were fragile in many ways.'
Ms Innes said: 'Do you have any comment on lessons as to how to better protect children in the future?'
Evan said: 'I would say there's an ongoing need for closer inspection, ongoing oversight as to what is going on in residential settings.
'It's a very intimate setting as you're there 24 hours a day. There needs to be an ongoing oversight into residential settings, both council and private, and it needs to be quite rigorous.'
He added: 'The six years I spent at Ovenstone were the happiest of my life. We built a playground; the kids developed emotionally and physically. I look back on it with fond memories. I've still got kids who are in touch with me.'
Lady Smith said: 'We are all doing the best we can in the interests of children who for one reason or another have to be in residential care.'
The inquiry continues.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
30 minutes ago
- The Independent
Kneecap fans at Glasgow gig rally around trio after festival slot cancelled
Kneecap fans gathered outside the band's gig in Glasgow have spoken of their support for the Irish rap trio despite them being axed from festival slots. The three members of Kneecap arrived at the O2 Academy in Glasgow on Tuesday evening ahead of their gig there, where they were greeted by pro-Palestinian demonstrators waving flags. Kneecap were axed from the line-up of TRNSMT in the city amid a row over an investigation by counter-terror police into Liam Og O hAnnaidh, who performs as Mo Chara, who is accused of terrorism offences related to a Hezbollah flag he allegedly held up on stage. The rap group, who perform in English and Irish, have been outspoken critics of the war in Gaza and claim the prosecution is linked to their views on Palestine. A number of fans and demonstrators spoke to the PA news agency outside the venue about their support for Kneecap, often declining to give their surnames. One called Meghan said she and her friend Amy had originally planned to go to TRNSMT before deciding to go to the Kneecap gig instead. She said it was 'disgusting' the band had been dropped from the line-up, adding: 'I think people are just scared for them to express proper problems in the world. 'They just want to shy away from it whereas Kneecap just come out and say it like it is.' Pro-Palestinian protester Naomi said: 'We're of the opinion the establishment is so under threat, they're having to look to ridiculous means to try and silence outspoken voices. 'We applaud Kneecap.' Cat Train, of the group Mothers against Genocide, said: 'They've been cancelled by money, haven't they? They've been cancelled by capitalism. 'So whoever booked them to play the O2 did absolutely the right thing.' Another fan called Asha, who has been to see the group 11 times, said: 'It's not like they're saying anything that's wrong, everything they're saying is absolutely correct. 'People don't like hearing the truth.' TRNSMT cancelled Kneecap's performance at the end of May over safety concerns from Police Scotland. The police force said it has a 'proportionate and considered policing plan' ahead of Kneecap's gig in Glasgow, which replaced their cancelled slot at the TRNSMT festival. As well as Kneecap's sold-out gig, Billie Eilish and Kendrick Lamar are also performing in Glasgow on Tuesday. In May, Scotland's First Minister John Swinney called for TRNSMT to cancel the performance on July 11, saying that 'organisers of TRNSMT have got to consider that issue'. O hAnnaidh was charged under the name Liam O'Hanna by the Metropolitan Police in May, over the alleged display of a Hezbollah flag at a gig, and appeared at Westminster Magistrates' Court on June 18. The furore led to calls from Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer and Conservative Party leader Kemi Badenoch for Glastonbury to cancel a performance from the Belfast rappers on June 28, which the festival organisers did not do. Ahead of the Glasgow gig, Superintendent Paul Douglas of Police Scotland said: 'We are aware of a number of events and concerts due to take place in the Greater Glasgow area in the week beginning Monday July 7. 'A proportionate and considered policing plan is in place within the city and we are working with a number of stakeholders to ensure the safety of all those attending these events and where possible minimise disruption to the people of Glasgow.'
Telegraph
32 minutes ago
- Telegraph
Mother ‘murdered by former fiancé she took pity on'
'At times she thought it was easier to give in to his pestering than to challenge it,' Ms Oakley said, adding that Ms Mickleburgh told friends and family that she was going to follow through with a promise to spend his 60th birthday at the hotel in Bagshot in April. 'She didn't wish him any ill, but she no longer wanted to live with him and no longer wanted to be in a relationship with him,' Ms Oakley said. 'But part of her also felt bad for him, believing that he had no one else to spend that day with.' Mr Cartwright is said to have spent the morning of his birthday with his other girlfriend in Devon before Ms Mickleburgh picked him up from the station. The pair arrived at the hotel at about 5.30pm and had arranged to have dinner in the hotel restaurant. They are said to have had champagne and cake on the terrace before returning to the room. CCTV shows Samantha changed clothes, but the prosecutor alleged that Mr Cartwright had spent nearly the entire time in the room communicating with other women, including his other girlfriend. During the meal Ms Mickleburgh reportedly started to feel unwell with staff said to have noticed her 'falling asleep at the table'. The pair left, with staff describing Mr Cartwright as 'holding the lady up' as they returned to their bedroom. The prosecution believes Ms Mickleburgh was likely dead by about 1.30am, as at 1.22am Mr Cartwright started deleting images of her from his phone. Mr Cartwright, 61, is standing trial at Guildford Crown Court accused of raping and murdering Ms Mickleburgh between April 12 and 14 last year. He also denies one count of controlling and coercive behaviour between May 1 2022 and April 14 2024. Mr Cartwright called the emergency services to hotel on the morning of April 14 last year after he 'apparently discovered the cold, lifeless body of his partner, lying on her back next to him'. The prosecutor said a post mortem examination had revealed bruising to Ms Mickleburgh's forehead, scalp, right jaw, left neck and the bursting of blood vessels under the skin. A 'blunt impact' to the forehead is said to have been so severe that it fractured her skull. Tests revealed the presence of Mr Cartwright's semen inside her body, the prosecutor said. 'You will have to consider with great care whether…. she voluntarily engaged in intercourse with him,' the prosecutor said. Cartwright denies the rape and murder of Ms Mickleburgh and controlling and coercive behaviour. The trial continues.
The Sun
an hour ago
- The Sun
Gregg Wallace hit by 50 allegations claiming star pulled down trousers and groped colleague as he's fired by BBC
GREGG Wallace has been hit by misconduct claims from 50 new people, it was sensationally revealed last night. They include allegations that the star - now sacked as MasterChef presenter - groped one show worker and pulled his trousers down in front of two others. 5 5 One of the two described it a 'predatory' encounter. She also claimed a boss dismissed her report of the alleged incident as she was over 16 and 'not being Jimmy Savile-d '. Another woman claimed Wallace groped her bottom while he spoke to ex co-host John Torode at the bar, during a wrap party in 2013. The bombshell claims emerged after a nine-month sexual misconduct investigation into the star, who denies any wrongdoing. And the claims come after Wallace, 60, stepped down as MasterChef presenter last November. He exited the show after 13 people accused him of making inappropriate sexual comments. Wallace - who has also fronted Celebrity Masterchef, Masterchef: The Professionals and Saturday Kitchen - came out fighting yesterday after it emerged he had been axed. In a lengthy online statement he insisted he had been cleared of 'the most serious and sensational accusations'. On Instagram, where he has 220,000 followers, Wallace said: 'After 21 years of loyal service to the BBC, I cannot sit in silence while my reputation is further damaged. 'The most damaging claims were found to be baseless after a full and forensic six-month investigation.' Gregg Wallace offers advice to fans for £200 But hours after Wallace's online post, BBC News revealed the new claims against him during a probe by independent law firm Lewis Silkin. It was hired by MasterChef production company Banijay to conduct a thorough investigation. The BBC said last night it had not seen the Banijay report. But its story said the corporation had been contacted by people across a range of shows and settings. Most allegations were said to centre on inappropriate sexual comments, though 11 women are said to have accused him of inappropriate sexual behaviour. That behaviour is said to include groping and touching. The allegations raise fresh questions for the Beeb and Banijay over their oversight of Wallace's alleged behaviour and their duty of care to staff. One woman - called Alice by the BBC - claims Wallace took his trousers down in front of her in a dressing room. She accused TV veteran Wallace of 'disgusting and predatory' behaviour. Another, using the name Sophie, says she was left feeling 'absolutely horrified' and 'quite sick' when he allegedly groped her. Others who contacted the corporation with fresh claims about the star include a participant on Saturday Kitchen, which Wallace hosted in 2002-2003. The morning cooking show was, at that time, produced in-house by the BBC. During a dinner ahead of filming in 2002, 'Sophie' claimed Wallace put his hand under the table and onto her groin, saying: 'Do you like that?' Another woman is a university student who says she met Wallace in a nightclub with friends in 2013. She claims that - after she asked to take a photo with him - he reached under her skirt and grabbed and groped her bottom. The BBC reported that another woman alleged that Wallace put his hand up her dress at an industry ball in 2014 and groped her. And a junior worker claims that - in 2012 - Wallace dropped his trousers in front of her. She alleges he was not wearing underwear. 5 A string of men have also claimed they witnessed Wallace making inappropriate sexual comments, it was reported. A former male cop has also said he tried to raise concerns about Wallace's sexually inappropriate language to the BBC in 2023 but was stonewalled. And other recent claims include a 19-year-old MasterChef worker who says she tried to complain about Wallace's comments about her body in 2022. The BBC said many of the women were young freelancers who felt unable to complain about Wallace's behaviour at the time amid fears it would hamper their careers. But one - 'Alice' - said she voiced concerns to bosses but claims they were dismissed. She worked on MasterChef between 2011 and 2013 when she was in her 20s. At the time, the show was produced by Shine, a company now owned by Banijay. She alleged that Wallace once asked her into his dressing room, saying he needed help getting into a black-tie outfit. She claimed he pushed her down onto a sofa, pulled his trousers down and told her he wasn't wearing any underwear, the BBC said. She reported what had happened, she says, but was told by a senior production member: 'You're over 16, you're not being ' Jimmy Saviled '.' Gregg Wallace - MasterChef scandal in Brief GREGG Wallace has stepped down from his MasterChef hosting role after a probe into alleged inappropriate behaviour. But what's the situation? Regular MasterChef host Gregg Wallace is currently the subject of a probe after an investigation was launched into his alleged misconduct over a number of years. Gregg has been accused of making sexual remarks to 13 colleagues including Beeb anchor Kirsty Wark - accusations he denies. The 60-year-old has now stepped away from the BBC show while historical misconduct allegations against him are investigated. Yet the former greengrocer spoke out on social media to blast the "women of a certain age" who he claimed were behind the allegations. The cooking show's production company, Banijay UK, has said law firm Lewis Silkin would lead the investigation into Wallace's alleged misconduct. Alice said she felt let down and left with the impression she should 'be grateful and get on with it' due to her lowly role. She has contributed to the Banijay inquiry, the BBC said. A woman - 'Anna' - claims Wallace pulled his trousers down in front of her as she worked on a photo shoot with him in 2012. The alleged incident occurred when they were alone together in a dressing room area - and she could see he was not wearing underwear. Wallace is said to have changed into the clothes she was holding from before she left. She also claimed Wallace made lewd comments and was 'touchy-feely'. Anna said she felt 'undermined' , unable to complain due to her junior position. She told the BBC she had spoken up after being angered by Wallace's Instagram video last year which saw him claim allegations had come from 'a handful of middle-class women of a certain age'. The Beeb reported her as saying: 'Is he saying it was OK to behave that way with younger women, like I was at the time?' Another MasterChef worker, Sophie, claims she was groped by the presenter at a wrap party at the end of the 2013 series. She described the incident - which she claims happened as she was talking to Wallace and then co-host John Torode - he was about as 'a full-handed squeeze'. She added: 'I turned around and it was Gregg.' There is no suggestion Mr Torode was aware of the incident. Again, the woman feared complaints would be ignored. Sophie has also contributed to the Banijay inquiry. Some new allegations happened away from television - one of them in the mid-to-late 2000s in Nottingham during a book tour. Publicist 'Esther' said Wallace pushed his way into her hotel room, took off his clothes, and then asked her: 'Exactly what is it that you do?' She says she was shocked and made it clear she was not interested, telling him: 'That's not part of my job.' Esther claims he then says he climbed into her bed and fell asleep - prompting her to sleep at the edge of the bed, with her clothes on. She claims that - when he woke up - Wallace put his hand on her bottom and commented that she had a 'nice arse'. She ordered him to leave, and he did, it was reported. Esther did not complain at the time, but has contributed to the Banijay inquiry. Yesterday, Wallace said: 'I will not go quietly. I will not be cancelled for convenience. I was tried by media and hung out to dry well before the facts were established.' He also accused the BBC of 'peddling baseless and sensationalised gossip masquerading as properly corroborated stories'. On Instagram, he said: 'I recognise that some of my humour and language, at times, was inappropriate. For that, I apologise without reservation. But I was never the caricature now being sold for clicks.' The BBC News report also said some people had got in touch to insiated Walace's behaviour amounted to 'jokes' and 'banter'. But a cameraman, who worked on the BBC show Eat Well For Less in 2016, said he heard Wallace make inappropriate comments in front of the production team. This is alleged to have included asking a gay female director about her 'lesbian clothing'. He said: 'It's not banter, it's not how you should behave in a professional workplace,' the BBC reportded. A recent report into the BBC found that a small number of its stars and managers 'behave unacceptably' at work, and that bosses often fail to tackle them. In response, the broadcaster said it would introduce reforms, and its chairman Samir Shah said he would draw 'a line in the sand'. Banijay has said that it will not comment on the accusations until the report is published.
