Quarter of children found not to have disability after assessment of need, Health Service Executive figures show
children
who received an assessment of need on the State's oversubscribed public system in the first quarter of 2025 were deemed not to have a
disability
.
There was a 20 per cent increase in applications for an
assessment of needs
between January and March, as the number waiting well beyond their legal entitlement for an assessment swelled to more than 15,000.
The Health Service Executive
said this was an 8 per cent increase on the 14,221 children waiting longer than six months for an assessment at the end of last year.
[
Third of referrals for assessment of need 'inappropriate', says HSE chief
Opens in new window
]
It said the increase was 'largely due' to a rise in applications, court judgments clarifying the rights of more children to access an assessment and the proportion of them receiving an assessment who did not have a disability.
An assessment of need is a way to quantify the educational or health needs of a child. It is often sought by parents as a way to access crucial services such as speech and language or occupational therapy and can be required before a child's school enables access to supports such as a special needs assistant.
The HSE said it received 3,131 new applications for an assessment of needs in the first quarter, a 20 per cent increase on the same period a year earlier.
The number of assessments completed between January and March increased to 1,412, up from 849 in the same period last year. This was largely driven by an extra €4.5 million being given to the HSE in Budget 2025 to address the backlog.
[
Fianna Fáil declares 'red line' over disability supports in schools
Opens in new window
]
Of the assessments completed by the HSE in the first quarter, some 26 per cent found the child had 'no disability'.
The HSE said the percentage of assessments that showed 'no disability' in 2010 stood at 15.8 per cent. It also said that 'it is not possible to extrapolate information on each individual Assessment of Need completed which showed 'No Disability''.
Under the Disability Act 2005, the State is legally required to carry out an assessment of need within six months of an application. The Health Service Executive again indicated that the number of children waiting longer than six months is estimated to reach almost 25,000 by the year's end.
Will Fianna Fáil and Sinn Féin abstain from the presidential race?
Listen |
40:42
The figures were released in response to a parliamentary question from Sinn Féin leader Mary Lou McDonald.
She said it was 'unacceptable' that assessments of needs were taking so long and 'even more astonishing that the HSE expects the number of overdue assessments to increase this year to over 24,000, when it is already astronomical at 15,000'.
'In each one of these cases, the Government is breaking the law,' she said. 'In 2022, the government was caught cutting corners when the High Court struck down their illegal shortcut. Three years on, and they still do not have a plan to deliver on the legal rights of children with disabilities. Children's rights are being denied.'
The Dublin Central TD said parents and families 'have had enough' and she called on the Government to 'take emergency action' and make funding available to clear the backlog.
'It must set a specific target date for complying with the Disability Act 2005, underpinned by a workforce plan to train, recruit, and retain enough staff to finally end this breach of children's rights.'
The HSE said that despite millions in additional funding being made available, including funding for it to pay private providers to carry out 3,636 assessments from June 2024 to last March, 'the number of people overdue an assessment of need is growing as demand outstrips system capacity'.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Independent
3 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Mental health service in Limerick looking for volunteers
According to the HSE, one in four Irish people will experience a mental health problem during their lifetime with depression being considered a very common condition affecting 450,000 people or one in ten people at any one time in Ireland alone. Dr Susan Brannick, Clinical Director at Aware told the Irish Independent: 'We're looking for volunteers across our support services, we have three main volunteer-led services that are seeking to recruit people for, the first is our support group, they run across the country, we offer them both virtually and in person and they are facilitated by two volunteers where people can come together for peer support and connection around difficulties like depression and anxiety. "We're also looking to recruit volunteers to our support line so that's online and runs from 10 in the morning til 10 at night offering a space where people can share their difficulties with their mental health and also maybe their concerns about a loved one.' She continued: "Our third service is our life skills online which is our self-help programme which is based on cognitive behavioural therapy principles and the volunteer supports people who do that on a weekly basis for the eight weeks. "There's a variety of different platforms that someone might be able to volunteer with us if they choose to so whether that's in person or on the phone or doing something more online, there will definitely be something to suit you if you're interested.' Aware are looking for people who are over the age of 21 and have about three hours to spare each week. Volunteers are not required to have a background in mental health training or experience as Aware offers over 20 hours of initial training to support people into the role that they choose. Susan said: "Then we offer ongoing support and training, all of our support services have a support manager that supports volunteers as they go through so there's a lot of training that we offer to enable people to do those roles. She continued: "The main thing in being a volunteer is that you have an interest in people, an interest in mental health and a willingness to listen and to allow people that space to talk about their own difficulties.' "We know from the research that being a volunteer and volunteering in and of itself can help your own mental health so there's also benefits to your own mental health as well as the training and support that are available if you do volunteer so I guess if people are interested, maybe having a look at our website would definitely be something that would meet your interests if this is an area of volunteering that appeals to you.' When asked about how the current cost of living, inflation and the housing crisis has affected uptake of various services, Lisa explained that there is a high need for services. She explained: "There's generally a high level of need anyway across the services in Ireland, some volunteers we've had with us for many years, others for one or two years so we ask that people maybe can commit at least 18 months or so. "I think there's an ongoing need for mental health support I suppose as mental health literacy increases, we're becoming better and more able to recognise conditions like depression, anxiety, so I guess it's the more people are more aware of these challenges, the more people, on a positive note are actively seeking help for them so certainly we've come a long way. "Since Aware began 40 years ago, we've certainly come a long way in our ability and willingness maybe to talk about mental health, that's a good thing. "Unfortunately, there's still a high need, people are facing very distinct challenges now maybe more so than 10, 15, 20 years ago so I guess there's an ongoing need for that support.' Susan concluded: "In the health budget, typically about 6 per cent of the health budget is allocated to mental health which is an under-investment really, the World Health Organisation, even Sláintecare would suggest that it should be at least 10-12 per cent of the overall health budget so I guess as long as there's an ongoing under-investment in statutory services there's going to be a continuing need across all the NGOs for ongoing mental health support.' Sláintecare is the HSE and Department of Health's overall improvement plan which outlines their strategies to reform Ireland's health and social care system and act as a pathway to universal healthcare.
RTÉ News
6 hours ago
- RTÉ News
More than 2,700 wait over recommended HSE timeframe for urgent colonoscopy
More than 2,700 people across Ireland waited longer than the recommended timeframe for an urgent colonoscopy between January and May this year, figures obtained by RTÉ News show. The Irish Cancer Society has said the delays are putting patients lives at risk. Urgent colonoscopes are required for patients who have symptoms such as weight loss or blood in their stool. HSE guidelines say these people should be seen within 28 days. However, figures show that 2,764 people waited between 29 and 60 days for an urgent colonoscopy between January and May this year. A total of 3,623 people waited over the recommended timeframe of 28 days in 2024. Consultant Gastroenterologist at St James's Hospital in Dublin Finbar MacCarthy said patients in need of an urgent procedure must be seen within the recommended timeframe. He said the number of patients who will ultimately be diagnosed with either a cancer or inflammatory bowel disease is small, but added, that "out of that group of people, there are undoubtedly patients who already have cancers or who already have another bowel disease that requires prompt diagnosis and prompt access to treatment." Dr MacCarthy said hospital capacity needs to increase in line with demand for colonoscopies. "Without an increase in capacity to meet the demand there will inevitably be increasing waiting lists for colonoscopies. "In addition, there are hospitals across the country where the endoscopy unit is significantly curtailed over the winter months in order to facilitate access through the emergency department. This is not a strategy that is tenable in the long term." The Irish Cancer Society described the figures as "extremely worrying". CEO Averil Power said: "In 2017, no one in Ireland waited more than the 28 day target for an urgent colonoscopy, yet this year if the current trend continues, over 6,500 people will. "That's a shocking deterioration in service and it's putting lives at risk. "The Irish Cancer Society is calling on Government to stop these delays now, by providing urgent investment in colonoscopy services nationwide." In a statement, the HSE said a number of initiatives have been developed to reduce waiting lists, including the expansion of capsule endoscopy services. 'So painful, I couldn't stand it' Paul Vickers from Rathcoole in Dublin was diagnosed with Stage 4 colon cancer in 2017. Despite signs of serious illness including constant pain, Paul waited over three months for an urgent colonoscopy. He said: "I was having symptoms and like a lot of men my age I was ignoring them, there was blood on the toilet tissue from around October 2016. "My symptoms got that bad I actually collapsed in early February 2017 in the house. I went over to Tallaght A&E and the doctor there that saw me gave me pain killers and Buscopan and told me to go to my own GP for a referral for a colonoscopy." Three months later, in May 2017, Paul finally got an appointment for an urgent colonoscopy but he says there were worrying signs in the weeks leading up to the procedure. "If I wasn't on pain killers, sitting down going to the toilet would have been so painful I couldn't actually stand it. "I would get a huge amount of wind cramps. I was working nights and that in itself was tiring, but dealing with all the stress as well was wearing me out. I actually lost quite a bit of weight during that time." Paul believes if he had been given an appointment for an urgent colonoscopy earlier, his recovery would have been much faster but he is also eager to encourage people with symptoms to go the GP as soon as possible. "In saying that, had I gone in when I got my first symptoms I may not have been diagnosed with cancer, at least not Stage 4 anyway." "It took me three years to recover from everything" Paul says by the time he got the urgent procedure, his symptoms were so bad he was treated as an emergency case. "My colon and large bowel were in such a state that they didn't let me home. They kept me in that day and two days later I got an ostomy bag in to shut my entire large bowel, digestive system down. "It was actually that bad I became an emergency then. I spent that summer on chemo and radiation therapy." Paul is now healthy and is looking forward to the future. "It took me three years to recover from everything, the radiation was quite severe, I was on a lot of radiation five days a week for six weeks and that has left a lot of damage to my large intestine but I have to manage that."
RTÉ News
6 hours ago
- RTÉ News
More than 2,700 wait over recommended HSE timeframe for colonoscopy
Figures obtained by RTÉ News show that over 2,700 people across Ireland waited over the recommended timeframe for an urgent colonoscopy between January and May this year. The Irish Cancer Society has said the delays are putting patients lives at risk. Urgent colonoscopes are required for patients who have symptoms such as weight loss or blood in their stool. HSE guidelines say these people should be seen within 28 days. However, figures obtained by RTÉ News show that 2,764 people waited between 29 and 60 days for an urgent colonoscopy between January and May this year. A total of 3,623 people waited over the recommended timeframe of 28 days in 2024. Consultant Gastroenterologist at St James's Hospital in Dublin Finbar MacCarthy said patients in need of an urgent procedure must be seen within the recommended timeframe. "This is a concern, as I said the number of patients who will ultimately be diagnosed with either a cancer or inflammatory bowel disease is small. "But out of that group of people, there are undoubtedly patients who already have cancers or who already have another bowel disease that requires prompt diagnosis and prompt access to treatment." Mr MacCarthy said hospital capacity needs to increase in line with demand for colonoscopies. "Without an increase in capacity to meet the demand there will inevitably be increasing waiting lists for colonoscopies. "In addition, there are hospitals across the country where the endoscopy unit is significantly curtailed over the winter months in order to facilitate access through the emergency department. This is not a strategy that is tenable in the long term." The Irish Cancer Society has described the figures as "extremely worrying". Irish Cancer Society CEO Averil Power said: "In 2017, no one in Ireland waited more than the 28 day target for an urgent colonoscopy, yet this year if the current trend continues, over 6,500 people will. "That's a shocking deterioration in service and it's putting lives at risk. "The Irish Cancer Society is calling on Government to stop these delays now, by providing urgent investment in colonoscopy services nationwide." In a statement the HSE said a number of initiatives have been developed to reduce waiting lists, including the expansion of capsule endoscopy services. Paul Vickers from Rathcoole in Dublin was diagnosed with Stage 4 colon cancer in 2017. Despite signs of serious illness including constant pain, Paul waited over three months for an urgent colonoscopy. He said: "I was having symptoms and like a lot of men my age I was ignoring them, there was blood on the toilet tissue from around October 2016. "My symptoms got that bad I actually collapsed in early February 2017 in the house. I went over to Tallaght A&E and the doctor there that saw me gave me pain killers and Buscopan and told me to go to my own GP for a referral for a colonoscopy." Three months later, in May 2017, Paul finally got an appointment for an urgent colonoscopy but he says there were worrying signs in the weeks leading up to the procedure. "If I wasn't on pain killers, sitting down going to the toilet would have been so painful I couldn't actually stand it. "I would get a huge amount of wind cramps. I was working nights and that in itself was tiring, but dealing with all the stress as well was wearing me out. I actually lost quite a bit of weight during that time." Paul believes if he had been given an appointment for an urgent colonoscopy earlier, his recovery would have been much faster but he is also eager to encourage people with symptoms to go the GP as soon as possible. "In saying that, had I gone in when I got my first symptoms I may not have been diagnosed with cancer, at least not Stage 4 anyway." "It took me three years to recover from everything" Paul said by the time he got the urgent procedure, his symptoms were so bad he was treated as an emergency case. "My colon and large bowel were in such a state that they didn't let me home. They kept me in that day and two days later I got an ostomy bag in to shut my entire large bowel, digestive system down. "It was actually that bad I became an emergency then. I spent that summer on chemo and radiation therapy." Paul is now healthy and is looking forward to the future. "It took me three years to recover from everything, the radiation was quite severe, I was on a lot of radiation five days a week for six weeks and that has left a lot of damage to my large intestine but I have to manage that."
