BBC documentary breaches editorial guidelines over Hamas link, says review
The documentary 'Gaza: How To Survive A Warzone', was removed by the broadcaster from its streaming service in February, following revelations that its 13-year-old narrator, Abdullah, was the son of Ayman Alyazouri, a Hamas official who served as the deputy minister of agriculture.
A review found that the independent production company, Hoyo Films, responsible for creating the documentary, did not share the 'critical information' of the narrator's family background with the BBC before broadcast.
The probe concluded that Hoyo Films bore the majority of the responsibility for this oversight, although it was deemed unintentional.
Following the controversy, Britain's media regulator Ofcom said that it would launch an investigation into the matter and probe the documentary under a specific rule that mandates factual programmes to avoid 'materially misleading the audience'.
'Regardless of how the significance or otherwise of the Narrator's father's position was judged, the audience should have been informed about this,' said the report by Peter Johnston, BBC Director of Editorial Complaints and Reviews.
BBC Director-General Tim Davie said that the report had identified a crucial failing concerning accuracy.
'We will now take action on two fronts – fair, clear and appropriate actions to ensure proper accountability and the immediate implementation of steps to prevent such errors being repeated,' Davie said in a statement.
Will 'improve processes and prevent similar problems', says Hoyo Films
After courting controversy over the documentary, the production company Hoyo Films released a statement apologising for the breach and affirmed its commitment to 'improve processes and prevent similar problems'.
'We take the findings in Peter Johnston's report on Gaza: How To Survive A Warzone extremely seriously and apologise for the mistake that resulted in a breach of the (BBC) editorial guidelines,' the statement read.
'We are pleased that the report found that there was no evidence of inappropriate influence on the content of the documentary from any third party. We appreciate the rigorous nature of this investigation, and its findings that Hoyo Films did not intentionally mislead the BBC, that there were no other breaches of the editorial guidelines in the programme, and that there was no evidence to suggest that the programme funds were spent other than for reasonable, production-related purposes,' it said.
'Hoyo Films welcomes the report's recommendations and hope they will improve processes and prevent similar problems in the future. We are working closely with the BBC to see if we can find an appropriate way to bring back to iPlayer the stories of those featured in the programme,' the statement added.
'We didn't run those questions to ground, ' says BBC News chief
Chief executive of BBC News and Current Affairs Deborah Turness, in an interview with BBC Radio 4, said the broadcaster has taken the matter 'incredibly seriously' and it will share the action plan that has been put in place in order to ensure that this kind of 'mistake' does not happen again.
'We've said we're sorry, and I am sorry,' Turness said.
'At BBC News, we are fully accountable,' she said. 'And we didn't run those questions to ground.'
'Yes, they should have known because their questions should have been answered at the many times of asking' by the production company, she added.
The BBC's coverage of the war has faced intense scrutiny, with critics on both sides – pro-Israel and anti-Israel – accusing the broadcaster of failing to strike the right balance.
(With inputs from BBC, Reuters and AP)
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Economic Times
17 hours ago
- Economic Times
She revolutionised Bollywood, worked at age 3 for starving family but betrayal, pain and loss followed her
Synopsis Saroj Khan, Bollywood's most celebrated choreographer, led a life marked by hardship, resilience, and artistic brilliance. Born after India's Partition, she began working in films at age three to support her family. At 13, she was unofficially married to a man three decades older who misled and abandoned her. After losing a child, she later embraced Islam, driven by faith and personal loss. Despite her personal struggles, Saroj revolutionised Hindi film choreography, mentoring generations of stars and earning widespread respect before her death in 2020. Saroj Khan's Tumultuous Journey Was From A Child Artiste to Bollywood's Dance Legend Saroj Khan, one of Bollywood's most influential choreographers, lived a life that was as dramatic and layered as the film industry she helped shape. Born in 1948, a year after India's independence, her family had fled Pakistan during Partition, resettling in India under severe financial strain. Saroj lost her father while she was still a child, and by the age of three, she had already entered the film industry—not out of ambition, but out of those difficult early days in a BBC interview, Saroj said her mother would pretend to cook by placing empty pots on the stove, hoping the children would fall asleep thinking food was being prepared. She soon became the primary earner, supporting her siblings and handling family responsibilities even before she was a teenager. Saroj's natural inclination toward dance was initially misunderstood. She would mimic expressions and movements in front of her shadow, leading her worried mother to consult a doctor. The doctor instead suggested cinema, recognizing Saroj's talent and the family's financial need. By age three, she had started acting, often working with actor Balraj the glamour of early stardom faded quickly. By ten, she was deemed too old to play a child and too young for adult roles. She shifted to background dancing and appeared in the song 'Aaiye Meherban' from Howrah Bridge. It was during these years that she met Sohanlal, a much older, already married choreographer. Saroj, only 13 at the time, believed she was married to him when he tied a black thread around her neck—without revealing that he had a wife and four gave birth to a son at 14. Later, she had a daughter who tragically died at eight months old. The experience left a lasting mark. Sohanlal never officially accepted her or their children, and after a brief reunion when he suffered a heart attack—resulting in the birth of their daughter Kuku—he left again, this time for good. Saroj would later speak of the emotional void that pushed her into the relationship, describing Sohanlal as a father figure who became a romantic interest in her 1975, Saroj married Sardar Roshan Khan, who was already a father of four. She agreed to the marriage on the condition that he adopt her children. Roshan Khan accepted, and Saroj said he never made her children feel like outsiders. This marriage also marked a spiritual turning point. Born Saroj Kishan Chand Sadhu Singh Nagpal into a Sindhi Punjabi Hindu family, she converted to Islam, stating it was a decision made out of love and faith. She explained in an interview with Doordarshan that her deceased daughter appeared to her in dreams, calling from inside a mosque, which led her to embrace the her personal struggles, Saroj Khan revolutionised Bollywood choreography. In a male-dominated industry, she claimed her space and became the force behind some of Hindi cinema's most iconic dance numbers. From training Sridevi and Madhuri Dixit to choreographing for Shah Rukh Khan, Salman Khan, and Katrina Kaif, her imprint on Indian cinema is affectionately as 'Masterji,' Saroj transformed dance into a respected profession in Bollywood at a time when choreographers were rarely credited. Her work elevated the importance of song-and-dance sequences and shaped the careers of many leading Khan passed away in 2020 during the early phase of the COVID-19 pandemic. The film industry mourned deeply, acknowledging her immense contribution. Her choreography remains a benchmark in Hindi cinema, and her story stands as a powerful reminder of resilience, talent, and the pursuit of dignity in an often unforgiving world.
News18
20 hours ago
- News18
The Woman Who Made Bollywood Dance, Tricked Into Marriage At 13, Forced To Convert To Islam
Fondly remembered as 'Masterji', Saroj Khan trained some of Bollywood's biggest stars, from Sridevi, Madhuri Dixit to Karisma Kapoor. Her own life, however, was marked by hardship Today, no Bollywood film seems complete without lively songs and elaborate dance sequences. Directors such as Sanjay Leela Bhansali and Sooraj Barjatya are renowned for their grand sets and opulent choreography. However, long before these visual spectacles became the norm, Saroj Khan brought dance choreography into the limelight and gave it the respect it deserved. At a time when choreographers were often overlooked, she carved a niche for herself and redefined Bollywood dance. Her journey, however, was anything but easy. Fondly remembered as 'Masterji', Saroj Khan trained some of Bollywood's biggest stars, from Sridevi and Madhuri Dixit to Karisma Kapoor. Her own life, however, was marked by hardship. Before she was born, her family fled Pakistan during the Partition and settled in India. Their financial condition deteriorated after migration, and Saroj lost her father at a young age. In a BBC interview, Saroj once shared how her family often went to bed hungry. Her mother would place empty pots on the stove to pretend she was cooking, just so the children would fall asleep peacefully. Worked As Child Artist Saroj began working early to support her family. In a 2016 interview on Doordarshan's show Koshish Se Kamyaabi Tak, she shared that she had to earn to feed her family, educate her siblings, and even arrange their marriages. She worked as a child artist in films, but by the time she turned ten, the offers stopped coming. She was no longer considered a child actor, nor old enough for adult roles. Early Marriage At just 13, she married 43-year-old Sohanlal, a much older man who was already married with four children. Saroj had met him during her early years as a background dancer. He misled the young Saroj and convinced her to marry him. She later gave birth to a daughter who died shortly after birth and had another child with him. It was only later that Saroj Khan discovered Sohanlal's first marriage and his children. She spoke about this painful chapter during an interview with DD, sharing that he refused to acknowledge their marriage publicly. Upon learning the truth, she decided to part ways with him. In 1975, Saroj married Sardar Roshan Khan. Before their marriage, she made it clear that he would have to accept her children as his own. Sardar Khan already had four children, and with Saroj Khan, he had two more. Born as Saroj Kishan Chand Sadhu Singh Nagpal, she converted from Sindhi Punjabi to Islam before marrying Roshan Khan. Saroj once said she felt a deep spiritual connection when her daughter appeared in her dreams, calling her into a mosque. She had a daughter named Kuku with Sohanlal, who sadly passed away in 2011. Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
Time of India
20 hours ago
- Time of India
She revolutionised Bollywood, worked at age 3 for starving family but betrayal, pain and loss followed her
Saroj Khan, one of Bollywood's most influential choreographers, lived a life that was as dramatic and layered as the film industry she helped shape. Born in 1948, a year after India's independence, her family had fled Pakistan during Partition, resettling in India under severe financial strain. Saroj lost her father while she was still a child, and by the age of three, she had already entered the film industry—not out of ambition, but out of necessity. Recalling those difficult early days in a BBC interview, Saroj said her mother would pretend to cook by placing empty pots on the stove, hoping the children would fall asleep thinking food was being prepared. She soon became the primary earner, supporting her siblings and handling family responsibilities even before she was a teenager. Explore courses from Top Institutes in Select a Course Category Product Management Technology others Finance Artificial Intelligence Leadership healthcare Data Science Data Science Degree Management Others Healthcare MBA CXO MCA Cybersecurity Public Policy Operations Management Design Thinking Data Analytics Digital Marketing Project Management PGDM Skills you'll gain: Product Strategy & Roadmapping User-Centric Product Design Agile Product Development Market Analysis & Product Launch Duration: 24 Weeks Indian School of Business Professional Certificate in Product Management Starts on Jun 26, 2024 Get Details Skills you'll gain: Product Strategy & Competitive Advantage Tactics Product Development Processes & Market Orientations Product Analytics & Data-Driven Decision Making Agile Development, Design Thinking, & Product Leadership Duration: 40 Weeks IIM Kozhikode Professional Certificate in Product Management Starts on Jun 26, 2024 Get Details Skills you'll gain: Creating Effective Product Roadmap User Research & Translating it to Product Design Key Metrics via Product Analytics Hand-On Projects Using Cutting Edge Tools Duration: 12 Weeks Indian School of Business ISB Product Management Starts on May 14, 2024 Get Details Childhood Shaped by Dance and Exploitation Saroj's natural inclination toward dance was initially misunderstood. She would mimic expressions and movements in front of her shadow, leading her worried mother to consult a doctor. The doctor instead suggested cinema, recognizing Saroj's talent and the family's financial need. By age three, she had started acting, often working with actor Balraj Sahni. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Join new Free to Play WWII MMO War Thunder War Thunder Play Now But the glamour of early stardom faded quickly. By ten, she was deemed too old to play a child and too young for adult roles. She shifted to background dancing and appeared in the song 'Aaiye Meherban' from Howrah Bridge. It was during these years that she met Sohanlal, a much older, already married choreographer. Saroj, only 13 at the time, believed she was married to him when he tied a black thread around her neck—without revealing that he had a wife and four children. Motherhood, Loss, and Betrayal Saroj gave birth to a son at 14. Later, she had a daughter who tragically died at eight months old. The experience left a lasting mark. Sohanlal never officially accepted her or their children, and after a brief reunion when he suffered a heart attack—resulting in the birth of their daughter Kuku—he left again, this time for good. Saroj would later speak of the emotional void that pushed her into the relationship, describing Sohanlal as a father figure who became a romantic interest in her life. Second Marriage and Spiritual Rebirth In 1975, Saroj married Sardar Roshan Khan, who was already a father of four. She agreed to the marriage on the condition that he adopt her children. Roshan Khan accepted, and Saroj said he never made her children feel like outsiders. This marriage also marked a spiritual turning point. Born Saroj Kishan Chand Sadhu Singh Nagpal into a Sindhi Punjabi Hindu family, she converted to Islam, stating it was a decision made out of love and faith. She explained in an interview with Doordarshan that her deceased daughter appeared to her in dreams, calling from inside a mosque, which led her to embrace the religion. A Trailblazing Legacy in Cinema Despite her personal struggles, Saroj Khan revolutionised Bollywood choreography. In a male-dominated industry, she claimed her space and became the force behind some of Hindi cinema's most iconic dance numbers. From training Sridevi and Madhuri Dixit to choreographing for Shah Rukh Khan, Salman Khan, and Katrina Kaif, her imprint on Indian cinema is unmatched. Known affectionately as 'Masterji,' Saroj transformed dance into a respected profession in Bollywood at a time when choreographers were rarely credited. Her work elevated the importance of song-and-dance sequences and shaped the careers of many leading stars. Saroj Khan passed away in 2020 during the early phase of the COVID-19 pandemic. The film industry mourned deeply, acknowledging her immense contribution. Her choreography remains a benchmark in Hindi cinema, and her story stands as a powerful reminder of resilience, talent, and the pursuit of dignity in an often unforgiving world.
