'Political expediency': Lawyer for IDF soldiers critical of war-crimes probe
There is a growing backlash after the RCMP announced this month it is investigating whether Canadian citizens involved with clashes in or around Israel were in contravention of this country's Crimes Against Humanity and War Crimes Act.
Article content
Amid outcry from Jewish groups, the force said it wasn't a criminal probe, but to 'collect, preserve and assess information' for potential future prosecutions.
Article content
Article content
Article content
Foreign governments, such as Belgium and Brazil, have also opened investigations into their own citizens who served with the Israel Defense Forces.
Article content
Article content
Lt.-Col. (ret.) Maurice Hirsch, director of the Initiative for Palestinian Authority Accountability and Reform, at the Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs, suggests these are politically motivated probes.
Article content
He has been retained by IDF soldiers who have been questioned by foreign government representatives. Hirsch has previously served as senior legal analyst for Human Rights Voices in New York, lawyer for the Israel Defense Forces, director of the legal department for Palestinian Media Watch, senior military consultant for NGO Monitor, and adviser to the Israeli Ministry of Defense.
Article content
I can't tell you exactly as to what their motivation is, but I believe that it's somewhere in the realms of political expediency, and internal demographic politics. It requires these governments to almost change what they've been doing traditionally, even to the point of potentially abandoning allies.
Article content
Article content
Their voter base has changed. And so now you have a situation where you need to almost pander, to cater, to a more fringe population.
Article content
Article content
In May, U.K. government lawyers told the High Court that there was no evidence Israel was deliberately targeting civilians in Gaza, and that evidence exists of Israel making efforts to limit harm to civilians. If the government doesn't believe that war crimes are being committed, then obviously they won't then take that forward, and actively engage in an investigation of something that they don't believe is happening.
Article content
But if the government is so prejudiced, and predisposed, that war crimes are being committed, then obviously you launch an investigation.
Article content
Video footage, forensic analysis, operational logs — all impartially examined. What they have is so weak and poor, it's impossible to say it's 'evidence.' I think it's just so circumstantial and flimsy, even imagined.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBC
35 minutes ago
- CBC
Man charged after coaches say he threatened to stab someone at girls' soccer game in GTA
Social Sharing Police have charged a man with uttering threats after an incident during a a U13 girls soccer game in Vaughan last week where coaches say a parent threatened to stab someone. Who exactly the threat was directed at, however, is in dispute between the two teams. The incident happened during a game between Kleinburg Nobleton Soccer Club (KNSC) and Glen Shields Juventus FC on June 20 at Concord Thornhill Regional Park. About 10 minutes into the second half, a KNSC player collided with a Glen Shields player, said Nikita Moriarity, assistant coach for KNSC. A video recording of the game provided by KNSC appears to show a moment where two players collided, with one girl falling to the ground. After the referee blows the whistle, a voice can be heard shouting, "I'm going to f—king stab you." A young player can be heard saying: "He told me he's going to stab me" with a spectator adding "Yeah, I heard that. I also heard that." York Regional Police said a man was arrested on Friday in connection with the incident and was charged with uttering threats. Differing accounts of who threat was directed at Moriarity said the threat was directed at a KNSC player, who was "obviously distraught, very fearful" after the comment was made. "When you have parents who are supposed to be role models, who are supposed to be encouraging and developing young minds, acting or saying those kind of things on the bench, regardless of who it's directed at, that's concerning," she told CBC Toronto. However, in a statement posted to Instagram Friday, Glen Shields Juventus FC said they conducted an internal review of the incident, which including analyzing "available footage" and gathering eyewitness accounts, and found the comment was made toward an adult at the game, not a player. "While early media reported an public statements suggested the comment was made toward a young player, our findings do not support that account," the club said in its statement. The individual alleged to have made the comment has been temporarily restricted from from participating in any club activities, "pending the outcome of a full investigation by the appropriate authorities," the statement says. "Glen Shields Juventus FC upholds a strict zero-tolerance policy toward abusive behaviour in any form, whether directed a players, referees, coaches, or spectators." Both clubs are part of the York Region Soccer Association (YRSA.) The association's sporting director Tony Fonseca said it is aware of the incident in an email to CBC Toronto, and that the teams and the YRSA are "acting accordingly" as the police investigation continues, he said. "This does not reflect the great sportsmanship and respect demonstrated at all times by all our member clubs in York Region every time they step on the field," he wrote. "Such deplorable behaviours do not have a place in our environments." Ontario Soccer said it was also aware of the incident in a statement, but the YRSA is managing the case since it involves clubs in their district. If a formal complaint is filed with Ontario Soccer, the organization said an independent third-party will manage the case.
CTV News
42 minutes ago
- CTV News
River in cottage country closed for police investigation
Police closed a road and river for an investigation in Kawartha Lakes, Ont., on Sat., June 28, 2025. Provincial police have closed an area in the Kawartha Lakes region for an investigation after a vehicle appeared to have submerged in a local river. In a social media post, City of Kawartha Lakes OPP shared an image of what appears to be an upside-down vehicle completely submerged in a river. The post stated that Talbot River Road was closed from Shrike Road to Kirkfield Road for an investigation, and that the river in the area is also closed. Anyone with information about the vehicle is asked to contact City of Kawartha Lakes OPP. Note: This is a developing news story. We will provide updates when they become available.
CTV News
an hour ago
- CTV News
7 displaced following a cigarette fire in Gatineau, Que.
Seven residents have been displaced following a fire that broke out in a wall in a low-rise residential building in Gatineau, Ont. Saturday morning, according to the local fire department. Firefighters say they received a call around 5:45 a.m. reporting a fire in a two-story building located at 168 Rue Fontaine. When crews arrived at the scene, they evacuated seven residents from the building, which has three units. They then extinguished the fire in the wall. The wall was partially destroyed and the estimated cost of damage is around $10,000, according to the fire department. No injuries were reported. Firefighters say investigation shows that someone was smoking a cigarette outside. That person threw the cigarette out when they were done near a window and close to a wall. The cigarette fell between the brick and the wall. Crews say it was an accident, and police are not involved in the investigation. The investigation into what led to the fire continues.
