
Those Passions by TJ Clark review – a timely study of the connection between art and politics
Clark writes from a 'political position on the left'. He reflects on epoch-making events such as the Russian revolution, which spawned socialist realist art. He says the Dresden-born artist Gerhard Richter, 93, maker of abstract and photorealist works, is 'haunted by his past' in the former East Germany. But there are also dustier subjects, including the Situationist International, a group of avant-garde artists and theorists who were active from the 1950s to the 1970s.
Clark's take on art and power is timely, though. Donald Trump's friends the tech bros are a new class of fabulously rich patrons with political clout to match. They are sponsoring a revolution in image-making through AI and social media. Clark writes about widely shared and often manipulated photographs of rioting in England in 2011 (and calls the typical subject of these visuals 'the un-elated looter'). But his pieces, the oldest of which dates back 25 years, have been overtaken by leapfrogging developments in the digital sphere.
His definition of what constitutes political art is broad; or better, say, elastic. One chapter examines a crucifixion done in grisaille, or shades of grey, by a northern Renaissance master. Is this political art? According to Clark, the painting expresses 'a Christian nihilism… lacking the consoling vehemence of the isms to come'. In fact, the picture was made in the immediate aftermath of a pretty vehement ism: a monk called Savonarola was responsible for the fanaticism of tossing books and paintings on to the Bonfire of the Vanities in Florence. Clark examines faces painted by Rembrandt. These are 'political' in the sense that the artist became the society portraitist of a new class in Dutch society, the bourgeoisie; but then the entire golden age of art in the Netherlands was paid for by their wealth.
Confronted in a gallery by the alchemy that transforms pigment, canvas and mark-making into a canonical work, some of us are content to attribute this to genius or serendipity. We imagine a silken thread connecting the artist's eye, hand and the picture. But to an art historian such as Clark, it's more of a Gordian tangle, and untying it is correspondingly knotty. He worries away at the inscrutable expression on the face of Mars by Diego Velázquez, with the god of war seen in what looks like a French firefighter's helmet and very little else, like an exhausted strippergram. Clark finds a similar look on a rifleman in The Surrender of Breda, also by Velázquez, who was painter to Philip IV of Spain. 'Mars's expression still eludes us,' Clark concedes, though one reading he offers of this poker face is that it was the default look at Philip's court, and that went for his tame artist and his portraits, too: 'Keeping things superficial, and therefore not subject to malicious misinterpretation, may be a virtue, not to say a survival skill.'
Clark doesn't indulge himself or the reader with the felicities of a stylist such as the critic Robert Hughes (who beautifully draws our attention in The Surrender of Breda to Velázquez's 'palisade of lances' and makes Clark's point about the artist with effortless succinctness, calling him 'the greatest impersonal painter who ever lived').
There are moments when Clark's inquiries are beneath his considerable dignity. Art historians have something in common with mediums and spiritualists: they attempt to get in touch with the other side. While there's a certain amount of empirical data about an artwork – its age, the materials it was made from, its provenance and so on – some commentators like to round out their appreciation with a kind of seance involving the artist. What was he thinking as he made his masterpiece? (See the art historians pitch up at the National Gallery in their gaudy headscarves and Romany caravans!) Clark divines the intentions of Hieronymus Bosch (who died in 1516) from the tiniest lick of paint on the face of a small figure on one of four panels now in Venice: 'I'm very sure that Bosch had an idea from the start how the man's mouth might serve his purposes.'
This communing with long-dead artists to channel what was going through their heads made me think of a British film star who once played a badly wounded war hero. He nailed a heartbreaking scene in which he woke up in hospital to find his leg had been amputated, and his co-stars begged him to reveal how he did it. He said: 'I just thought: 'I hope they've still got some beef sandwiches in the trailer.'' Is it bathetic, or simply an acknowledgment of human nature, to imagine that Velázquez, Bosch and the rest sometimes thought of beef sandwiches, so to speak? After all, the old masters were hired hands, working to commission. They were fulfilling the wishes of a client – often a demanding one – rather than expressing themselves or chasing a muse.
The sign of a good painting, it used to be said, was that the eyes follow you around the room. For Clark, indefatigable scrutiniser of facial features, the hallmark is that he follows the eyes around the room instead.
Those Passions: On Art and Politics by TJ Clark is published by Thames & Hudson (£40). To support the Guardian and Observer order your copy at guardianbookshop.com. Delivery charges may apply
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Daily Mail
a day ago
- Daily Mail
Self-declared far-right fascist proudly shares his beliefs on popular podcast... then begs for cash after firing
A man who openly identified as a 'fascist' during a political debate with former MSNBC star Mehdi Hasan has raised over $26,000 on a Christian crowdfunding site after claiming he was fired for voicing his far-right political beliefs. The man, only identifying himself as Connor, had bragged to Hasan on Sunday how he was a 'fascist' and wholeheartedly believed in 'autocracy.' The assertion, delivered during an episode of the YouTube debate series Surrounded, left Hasan briefly at a loss. Hasan, in turn, said he did not 'debate fascists', and shut the conversation down. The very next day, 'Connor' was begging for a buck on on GiveSendGo, where, as of writing, he has already racked up almost $30,000. 'You're braver than most and also 100 percent correct,' a caption for one donation reads. 'Keep strong and keep speaking the truth,' someone who gifted the conservative $50 said. 'Nothing Connor said was wrong and I'm tired of having to pretend I don't agree,' scathed someone else. Others offered blessings after Connor had introduced himself as a Catholic, during an advertised debate that saw Hasan face off against him and 19 other 'far-right conservatives' as part of Jubilee's 'Surrounded' series. There, after quoting Nazi political theorist Carl Schmitt and praising Spanish dictator Francisco Franco, Connor found himself being pressed by Hasan on whether he was 'a fan of the Nazis' 'I think that there was a little bit of persecution and stuff like that, which is bad,' Connor answered, referring to the regime's persecution of Jewish people. He went on to slam the Nazis' treatment of the Catholic clergy, some of whom were sent to concentration camps along with six million Jews. 'I, frankly, don't care being called a Nazi at all,' he added A stunned Hasan could only say in response: 'We may have to rename this show, because you're a little bit more than a far-right Republican.' A grinning Connor quipped: 'Hey, what can I say?' - before being met with Hasan's reply: 'I think you can say, "I'm a fascist."' 'Yeah, I am,' Connor said with a lighthearted laugh, before being met with applause from others in attendance. Within hours, the same man was asking for financial help from onlookers for being 'unfairly cancelled', without providing details of the role or company he was supposedly fired from. He has raised nearly $30,000 Daily Mail has reached out to 'Connor' - who operates several conservative commentary pages on platforms like X and Instagram - for comment Within hours, he was asking for help without providing details of the role or company he was supposedly fired from. 'I'm raising money as an emergency fund and for other expenses while I look for a new job,' he said. 'Unfortunately voicing fully legal traditional right wing political views results in real consequences,' he continued, calling the occurred 'cancel culture and political discrimination on full display. The page originally sported a $15,000 goal but seems poised to collect more. 'We need a white nation! It's our only future! Vive le Fascisme,' another donor wrote.

The National
2 days ago
- The National
Activist arrested at Glasgow pro-Palestine protest breaks silence
Veteran protester Sean Clerkin was arrested and charged under the Terrorism Act after he displayed a sign which read 'Genocide in Palestine, Time to Take Action' with the words '[[Palestine]]' and 'Action' enhanced at a demonstration in Glasgow city centre on Friday. The direct-action group Palestine Action was recently named a proscribed organisation in the UK, and it is a criminal offence to show support for the group. Speaking to The National, Clerkin recalled the fear he felt when he was held in a cell for around three hours after he was arrested for displaying a sign expressing support for a proscribed organisation. READ MORE: Scotland's people do not endorse these war crimes by Israel 'The most disturbing part of being on your own in a cell is you have no control over anything, and you're at their control,' he said. Clerkin added that despite being scared that police may raid his home while he was detained, he reminded himself why he decided to protest, for all the children, women, and men in Gaza who are risking their lives daily for food and are enduring extreme suffering at the hands of Israel's military. 'Being held in a police cell is nothing like what they're suffering,' he said. The 64-year-old said he believes that it is an enormous waste of taxpayer money arresting protesters holding up signs and that police resources would be better spent on tackling 'real crimes'. (Image: Gordon Terris) If found guilty, Clerkin, who has now been banned from entering the city centre of Glasgow until his court hearing on October 7, which he believes is more than just a coincidence, could face a £10,000 fine, a minimum jail sentence of six months with a maximum of 14 years. Earlier last week, 46 other protesters were arrested at a demonstration against Palestine Action being designated a proscribed terror group in central London. Despite knowing the risks that his actions could land him in jail, Clerkin decided standing up for his civil rights and showing solidarity with the people in Gaza was worth the risk. 'This is how this is,' he said. 'This is now Keir Starmer's Britain, where law-abiding citizens who show our conscience, who show that we care for our fellow human beings, are being arrested and jailed. 'That shows we're losing our civil liberties, freedom of association, freedom to protest, freedom of speech. 'These are now being eradicated, and we've got to stand up and fight for these rights.' (Image: Gordon Terris) Clerkin added that he held the sign because of his own conscience and because of his faith as a Christian. 'I believe in the sanctity of human life, and I'm a non-violent protester, always have been, but I do believe in direct action. 'I felt like I had to take stronger action as an act of conscience, and I believe what I did was morally the right thing to do. 'It was an act of conscience, even for the people of Palestine to show solidarity with them and their suffering.' During the same day Clerkin was arrested, an Israeli military chief who had overseen the slaughter of thousands of Palestinians visited the UK. Major General Tomer Bar (below), the head of the Israeli Air Force, reportedly attended a conference hosted by the Royal Air Force in Gloucester where he held a series of meetings with air force commanders. (Image: YouTube) When asked what he thought about the fact he was arrested for holding a sign showing support for Palestine on the same day Bar was hosted by RAF in the UK, Clerkin said: 'He is being invited as a guest of the British Government which means the British Government, the Labor Government, support genocide in Palestine by the Israelis. 'He should have been arrested as soon as he stepped on UK soil and taken into custody and handed over to the ICC at The Hague as an international war criminal." He added: 'The fact that he was hidden in secret and brought in here, and he has committed crimes against humanity, shows that the British Government are complicit in crimes of genocide, crime the crime of genocide, crime against humanity.' Clerkin's anger was not just reserved for the UK Government, and he was also immensely disappointed with the SNP as their MPs 'sat on their backsides and abstained' during the vote to proscribe [[Palestine]] Action. On Sunday, The National, along with The Ferret, revealed the minutes from the Scottish Government Minister Angus Robertson's secret meeting with Israel's deputy ambassador to the UK, Daniela Grudsky. It was revealed that the [[Scottish Government]] tried to set up an earlier meeting with John Swinney and the ambassador and was talking itself up as a 'critical friend' of Israel. Clerkin said the Scottish Government should follow the Irish government and be in 'complete unison with Palestine' and support a Palestinian state. 'Surely the SNP could have done the same instead of sitting on the sidelines,' Clerkin said. He added that the [[SNP]] MPs who abstained in the [[Palestine]] Action debate could have done more and voted with the independent MPs, like Jeremy Corbyn, against proscribing them as a terrorist organisation. (Image: Jordan Pettitt/PA Wire) 'I just know that the [[SNP]] leadership at Westminster and in Edinburgh is devoid of a spine. 'They're spineless. They're spineless chickens.' A veteran activist, Clerkin is best known for being the person who made the complaint to Police Scotland which led to Operation Branchform, a probe into the finances of the [[SNP]] which led to the arrests of Peter Murrell, Nicola Sturgeon, and Colin Beattie in 2023. Clerkin believes the proscription of Palestine Action has set a dangerous precedent and thinks the UK Government could go after peaceful protest groups like Extinction Rebellion next. 'It's a slippery slope to an authoritarian British state where there is no democracy,' he said. 'That's where we're sliding to, and it's a very, very bad day when this is happening.' Speaking about how he feels about his upcoming trial, Clerkin said: 'At the current time, I'm not anxious about it, I'm more anxious about what happens to the people in Palestine.'


Glasgow Times
2 days ago
- Glasgow Times
At least 20 dead following latest Israel strikes on Gaza
The expansion of Israel's ground invasion comes as Israel and Hamas have been considering terms for a ceasefire for Gaza that would pause the fighting and free at least some hostages. The latest round of talks has dragged on for weeks with no signs of breakthrough, though negotiators have expressed optimism. With Israel expanding its control over large chunks of Gaza, an expected pullback of troops is a major point of contention in the talks. The Trump administration has been pushing Israel to wrap up the war and has shown signs of impatience. Smoke and flames erupt from an Israeli airstrike in Gaza City (Jehad Alshrafi/AP) On Monday, President Donald Trump's press secretary, Karoline Leavitt, said Mr Trump was 'caught off guard' by a recent Israeli strike on a Catholic church in Gaza. Top Christian clergy visited that church last week and in a press conference Tuesday in Jerusalem called for the war to end. In the latest round of strikes, at least 12 people died when tents sheltering displaced people in the built-up, seaside Shati refugee camp on the western side of Gaza City, were hit, according to the city's Shifa Hospital, which received the casualties. The dead included three women and three children, Dr Mohamed Abu Selmiyah, director of the hospital told the Associated Press. Thirty-eight other Palestinians were wounded, he said. The strike tore apart tents, and left some of the dead lying on the ground, according to footage shared by the health ministry's ambulance and emergency service. An overnight strike that hit crowds of Palestinians waiting for aid trucks in Gaza City killed eight, hospitals said. At least 118 were wounded, according to the Palestinian Red Crescent. The Israeli military had no immediate comment on the strikes. Israel blames the deaths of Palestinian civilians on Hamas because the militants operate in densely populated areas. It accuses the group of prolonging the war because Hamas has not accepted Israel's terms for a ceasefire – including calls to give up power and disarm.