
Geldof's threat to quit Tony Blair's Africa Commission
The Live Aid campaigner was instrumental in persuading Mr Blair to set up the commission to examine the problems of the continent ahead of a crucial summit of the G8 at Gleneagles in Scotland, which the UK was chairing.
But official papers released to the National Archives in Kew, west London, show he was outraged when - after just one meeting - the commissioners were sent a document setting its "emerging conclusions".
In an angry letter to the commission's director of policy, the economist Nick Stern, dated 9 August 2004, he said it was impossible to have come to any conclusions it such a short period of time.
The Boomtown Ratts front man warned that he was not prepared to serve on a body which was simply there to push "pre-determined government policy".
"To be clear, policy must be determined by the commission independently sitting and independently deliberating and concluding of its own volition. This distinction is vital. If I have got this wrong please inform me so I may tender my resignation," he wrote.
"More broadly, the whole notion of emerging solutions is laughable. If the solution to the misery of Africa can be 'concluded' within a mere six week time span, it is a truly remarkable feat.
"How blind we must all have been these past years. The fact is that there are not and cannot as yet be any emerging conclusions.
"The commission will lose all credibility if it is not clearly seen to be an independent entity. If it seems to advance pre-determined government policy it will be correctly viewed as a laughable grotesque."
Geldof went on to complain that the involvement of some of the commissioners - including some of those from Africa - appeared to have been "minimal".
"Is it not the secretariat's function, on behalf of the chair, to ensure that this is not the case? Or is this all some farcical political game played out at the expense of the wretchedly poor? If so, I ain't playing."
Mr Stern wrote back hurriedly to assure him the that the document was not an attempt pre-empt the commission's findings, and that the input from British politicians had been "comparatively minor".
"Far from being an attempt to rush conclusions the paper is intended to be a tool to help promote discussion and ensure a real interchange between commissioners at the second meeting in October," he wrote.
"I would be very keen to sit down and discuss these questions with you; perhaps we could meet for a drink as soon as we are both around?"
Geldof's reply is not recorded in the files, but he was sufficiently placated to carry on.
After the Gleneagles summit the following year agreed to double aid to Africa and extend debt relief, he hailed it as "mission accomplished".

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Irish Daily Mirror
2 hours ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Bob Geldof in furious Gaza rant as he shouts 'shut up' in live interview
Sir Bob Geldof has revealed that footage of malnourished youngsters in Gaza "enrages" him whilst condemning the UK Government for failing to take sufficient action. The Band Aid founder accused Israel's administration of "lying" about the absence of "no famine caused by Israel", declaring: "They're dangling food in front of starving, panicked, exhausted mothers." During an impassioned Sky News interview, an incensed Sir Bob questioned how Britain could develop a cutting-edge supercomputer this month whilst infants in Gaza were forced to survive on mere teaspoons of salt and minimal water supplies, demanding: "Shut up. What have we become that we can do this miracle and perpetuate this agony?". He also criticised the UK administration, claiming they had achieved "not enough". Sir Bob dismissed the idea that recognising Palestinian statehood - something Keir Starmer faces mounting pressure to do - would make any "difference" to the humanitarian crisis, reports the Mirror. Palestinian Yezen Abu Ful, 2, whose health has deteriorated due to lack of access to food and nutritional supplements. (Image: Anadolu via Getty Images) A charity organization distributed food to Palestinians facing severe difficulties accessing basic necessities due to Israel's ongoing blockade and military operations in the Gaza Strip on July 24, 2025. (Image: Anadolu via Getty Images) He urged Labour MPs to cease signing correspondence calling for recognition, branding it a form of "virtue signalling" at this stage, stating: "Enough. Guys, focus on the issue to hand." The political activist emphasised that the most urgent matter is to prevent starving mothers and infants from being exploited as "instruments of war". Regarding the Israel-Hamas conflict, he stated: "I'm really not interested in what either of these sides are saying. When you target infants and children, when their wounds are no longer capable of healing, when breastfeeding mothers can no longer do this, then everything goes out the window." Sir Bob expressed his views on the situation in Gaza, suggesting that Israelis who disagree with their government's actions should take direct action: "What's unfair is what's happening to these babies.... What's unfair is that one hour from the hunger, people are sitting down to their unthreatened dinners to turn on the next Netflix show." He boldly proposed a solution for Israeli protesters: "So if Israelis want to protest, get in your cars. This is very bold stuff, I know, sorry about that. Get in your car, stuff your cars full of food and drive through that border and let your own army stop you." Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest news from the Irish Mirror direct to your inbox: Sign up here.


RTÉ News
8 hours ago
- RTÉ News
Scottish National Party to 'force a vote' on recognising State of Palestine
The Scottish National Party has threatened to bring forward legislation on recognising Palestinian statehood and "force a vote" if UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer continues to oppose the move. The party, which pushes for the independence of Scotland, said it would table a "Palestine Recognition Bill" when the UK parliament returns after its summer recess if Mr Starmer did not change his position. The prime minister has committed to recognising Palestinian statehood but said it must be part of a peace process in the Middle East. The SNP threat comes after more than 220 British MPs, including dozens from Mr Starmer's ruling Labour party, demanded Friday that the UK government follow France and recognise a Palestinian state. The call, in a letter signed by lawmakers from nine UK political parties, came less than 24 hours after French President Emmanuel Macron said that his country would formally do so at a UN meeting in September. "Unless Keir Starmer stops blocking UK recognition of Palestine, the SNP will introduce a Palestine Recognition Bill when Parliament returns in September and force a vote if necessary," said Stephen Flynn, SNP's leader in the UK parliament. "Keir Starmer must stop defending the indefensible, finally find a backbone and demand that Israel ends its war now," he added. If France formally recognises a Palestinian state it would be the first G7 country - and the most powerful European nation to date - to make the move. Mr Starmer has come under rising domestic and international pressure over recognising Palestinian statehood, as opposition intensifies to the ongoing war in Gaza amid fears of mass starvation there. The UK leader yesterday spoke to his French and German counterparts and outlined UK plans to airdrop aid to people in Gaza and evacuate sick and injured children, his office said. The SNP holds nine seats in the 650-seat UK parliament.


RTÉ News
10 hours ago
- RTÉ News
Trump's Scottish getaway: Trade talks, golfing and protests
It was supposed to be a golfing trip with a bit of light business scattered throughout. Instead, US President Donald Trump's visit to Scotland has taken on a new significance, with the small village of Turnberry potentially the backdrop for a trade agreement between the EU and US. According to officials in the European Commission, this is being treated as a "president-to-president" negotiating session. It is not a signed, sealed, delivered photo-op. "There is optimism but no certainty that a deal will be reached," they explained. And so it seems that Turnberry is the place where both leaders will seek to overcome those final hurdles. Some may raise an eyebrow that the meeting takes place, not in the US or in an EU country, but rather in the UK which voted to leave the European bloc. But time is of the essence with a deadline approaching, and it gives both leaders a chance to meet and secure a deal that would avert increased tariffs on both sides of the Atlantic. Mr Trump has managed to focus much of the world's attention on Turnberry. As well as his meeting with Ursula von der Leyen, he is also holding bilateral sessions with British Prime Minister Keir Starmer and Scottish First Minister John Swinney. Trade, Gaza and Ukraine are all expected to be talking points when he meets both men. Much of the UK's attention will be on whether Mr Starmer can secure a commitment to reduce 25% tariffs on British steel, but also whether he can reduce 10% baseline tariffs. There will also be focus on what is said on Gaza, with growing outrage around the humanitarian crisis there. Over 200 MPs signed a cross-party letter on Friday, demanding that the British Prime Minister recognise the state of Palestine. Mr Trump's Turnberry visit will be remembered for many reasons. Turnberry welcome In the seaside village of Turnberry there is bemusement among locals that they have found themselves at the centre of much of the world's gaze. The reception President Trump has received is similar to the one he was greeted with in Doonbeg County Clare in 2019, where many welcomed a man who had brought job opportunities to the area. It is an investment not to be sniffed at according to people like councillor Alec Clark, the deputy leader of South Ayrshire Council. The independent councillor, who also holds the Tourism and Culture portfolio in the council, told us this week that Trump Turnberry employs around 400 people. Mr Trump bought the resort in 2014. His election as president in 2016 only served to boost the profile of the hotel and surrounding area. Opposition exists however. One elderly woman was clear that he was a man "totally at odds" with the people of Scotland. "I don't think we should entertain him at all. I don't think people like that are welcome in Scotland at all," she explained. Scottish Protests This weekend's visit has been described as semi-private. As a result the president's schedule during the visit is being decided and guarded by the White House. It has made the organising of protests somewhat difficult for those eager to showcase their opposition to his presence, as they cannot be sure where he will be each day. Nevertheless, people protesting under the banner "Stop Trump Coalition" made their voices heard yesterday during simultaneous demonstrations in Edinburgh and Aberdeen. Jack Nevin, organiser of the Edinburgh protest, explained that the gathering outside the US Consulate was not just to convey a message that Mr Trump is not welcome in Scotland, but also to showcase opposition to his policies, including in relation to Gaza. "It's a protest of Trumpism, and it's a rejection of the politics of hate, division and fear, which is propagating in the United States and throughout the world," he said. A "Festival of Opposition" has been promised for Aberdeen where Mr Trump's son Eric is expected to cut the ribbon on a second course at the family's golfing resort. It will be named after the US President's Gaelic speaking mother, Mary Anne MacLeod, who grew up in the outer Hebrides. Deal or no deal The main takeaway from this presidential visit is likely to be whether the European Commission President leaves with a deal or without one. Either outcome will have consequences for both the US and EU. Should a deal not be reached, tariffs will increase to 30% on EU goods. Europe has promised retaliatory measures on €93 billion of US goods too. Ms von der Leyen's decision to travel to Scotland is being taken as an indication that she is confident that it will be worth her while. She landed in Glasgow last night and will make her way to Turnberry today. European Trade Commissioner Maros Saefcovic is due to land today and will join her for the meeting. Senior officials in the European Commission this weekend said that there was a feeling that talks had advanced to a point where leaders could meet and make final concessions. And so all eyes will be on Turnberry, to see whether it is a deal or no deal.