Schmidt got it wrong and must ring changes
With the Wallabies overpowered in the contact zones in Brisbane, coach Joe Schmidt must surely reverse some selection errors by starting Angus Bell and Billy Pollard up front as hooker Matt Faessler was predictably underdone. Halfback Jake Gordon was in similar territory, although he might be paradoxically spared by the impact that Tate McDermott brings off the bench.
The best position for Joseph-Aukuso Suaalii is also still up for debate - his selection at No.13 has forced Len Ikitau into a battering ram role that is a waste of his footwork and distribution skills.
Lucky Lions dodged a yellow card
Referee Ben O'Keeffe must have looked very hard to find the arms in the Ben Earl tackle on Joseph-Aukuso Suaalii in the 59th minute as the No.13 tried to crash over from close range. It was a poor decision – Earl made little or no attempt to wrap – he turned his head away and threw a shoulder towards Suaalii's lower limbs. In fact, you could argue that Earl already had a knee on the ground when he hit Suaalii. It was a clear penalty and should have been a yellow card as the Lions had committed repeat infringements by that stage. Those types of tackles are a blight on the game – knee surgeons must wince every time they see them.
There was good and bad from Suaalii
There is a serious case for starting Hunter Paisami at No 12, moving Len Ikitau back into his right spot at No.13 and putting Suaalii to the wing, where the Lions looked relatively vulnerable on Saturday. Suaalii ran hard all night, with 10 carries, but there is no reason the Wallabies couldn't manufacture those opportunities for him in the No.11 or No.14 jersey. Defensively, there are still a few issues – he was caught a bit narrow for Huw Jones' disallowed try and his tendency to want to whack the man in possession, even after the pass is away, means he can take himself out of the play.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sydney Morning Herald
an hour ago
- Sydney Morning Herald
Why is Australia's toughest player not playing for the Wallabies?
The aggression and venom are a clear by-product of Salakaia-Loto being left out of the Wallabies squad for the Lions series, with Jeremy Williams, Nick Frost, Will Skelton and Reds teammate Josh Canham preferred. The 41-Test lock has duly played with a hive of bees in his bonnet, to overtly remind Joe Schmidt of a combative aggression that few, if any, can match in Australian rugby. Schmidt hasn't appeared to notice his door has been kicked down - even after the First Nations game, there was no call-up - but Leota says a Wallabies recall for Salakaia-Loto should be a no-brainer. 'Anyone who knows 'Khan' as a person knows that he is very proud, very humble, but, man, he will play the brother next to him and die for the jersey. I know that for sure, with Khan,' Leota said. Speaking after the game at Marvel Stadium, Salakaia-Loto spoke freely about his joy of playing for the FNP team, but weighed his words carefully when asked about trying to state his case to Schmidt. Asked if he'd had feedback, he said: 'Just that I needed more minutes. I've had three chances to do cracks at these guys. I don't have any more chances, I guess, to sort of try and push my case forward. 'I've got my flight details to go home, back to Brissy to see my two little girls and my partner, so that's what I'm focusing on.' Salakaia-Loto said the emotion in his performance in Melbourne was based on a spiritual week with the FNP squad, where he got a chance to reconnect with his Samoan roots and to represent his family, culture and ancestors. 'I was always going to be, I guess, heavy on the emotion, and I guess that's just what you saw,' he said. 'I just got up there and played. And, you know, you mix that with a bit of frustration, a bit of emotion, and I guess the passion that I've been playing, especially for this week, it's like you saw the way we played.' Salakaia-Loto wasn't the only one stating a case to Schmidt, with Charlie Gamble again outstanding, Swain putting in a strong shift, and the front row of Taniela Tupou, Brandon Paenga-Amosa and 20-year-old Brumby Lington Ieli dominating. 'I think it was a better week for someone like 'Nela'. The opportunity to sort of put culture first and really have an awesome weekend with the coaches, Toutai Kefu, Sekope Kepu, Glen Ella. The list goes on (Simon Raiwalui and Tana Umaga were also assistants). 'These guys know how we operate as people. They understand what makes us tick. I look at these coaches, and they look like me, they look like 'Nela', we all look like each other. We understand what makes us tick, we understand how we operate. Loading 'In terms of Nela, this week is an awesome week in terms of using it as a springboard for him to go back into the camp and really add value to the Wallabies.' Salakaia-Loto said he hoped the FNP showing had served as inspiration for young Pasifika and Indigenous kids. 'To look at the TV and see that there's players of First Nation descent, Pasifika descent. We come from small places, small islands, and there's not many indigenous players into rugby,' he said.
The Age
an hour ago
- The Age
Why is Australia's toughest player not playing for the Wallabies?
The aggression and venom are a clear by-product of Salakaia-Loto being left out of the Wallabies squad for the Lions series, with Jeremy Williams, Nick Frost, Will Skelton and Reds teammate Josh Canham preferred. The 41-Test lock has duly played with a hive of bees in his bonnet, to overtly remind Joe Schmidt of a combative aggression that few, if any, can match in Australian rugby. Schmidt hasn't appeared to notice his door has been kicked down - even after the First Nations game, there was no call-up - but Leota says a Wallabies recall for Salakaia-Loto should be a no-brainer. 'Anyone who knows 'Khan' as a person knows that he is very proud, very humble, but, man, he will play the brother next to him and die for the jersey. I know that for sure, with Khan,' Leota said. Speaking after the game at Marvel Stadium, Salakaia-Loto spoke freely about his joy of playing for the FNP team, but weighed his words carefully when asked about trying to state his case to Schmidt. Asked if he'd had feedback, he said: 'Just that I needed more minutes. I've had three chances to do cracks at these guys. I don't have any more chances, I guess, to sort of try and push my case forward. 'I've got my flight details to go home, back to Brissy to see my two little girls and my partner, so that's what I'm focusing on.' Salakaia-Loto said the emotion in his performance in Melbourne was based on a spiritual week with the FNP squad, where he got a chance to reconnect with his Samoan roots and to represent his family, culture and ancestors. 'I was always going to be, I guess, heavy on the emotion, and I guess that's just what you saw,' he said. 'I just got up there and played. And, you know, you mix that with a bit of frustration, a bit of emotion, and I guess the passion that I've been playing, especially for this week, it's like you saw the way we played.' Salakaia-Loto wasn't the only one stating a case to Schmidt, with Charlie Gamble again outstanding, Swain putting in a strong shift, and the front row of Taniela Tupou, Brandon Paenga-Amosa and 20-year-old Brumby Lington Ieli dominating. 'I think it was a better week for someone like 'Nela'. The opportunity to sort of put culture first and really have an awesome weekend with the coaches, Toutai Kefu, Sekope Kepu, Glen Ella. The list goes on (Simon Raiwalui and Tana Umaga were also assistants). 'These guys know how we operate as people. They understand what makes us tick. I look at these coaches, and they look like me, they look like 'Nela', we all look like each other. We understand what makes us tick, we understand how we operate. Loading 'In terms of Nela, this week is an awesome week in terms of using it as a springboard for him to go back into the camp and really add value to the Wallabies.' Salakaia-Loto said he hoped the FNP showing had served as inspiration for young Pasifika and Indigenous kids. 'To look at the TV and see that there's players of First Nation descent, Pasifika descent. We come from small places, small islands, and there's not many indigenous players into rugby,' he said.
Perth Now
2 hours ago
- Perth Now
Unwanted Wallabies forward makes case for selection
He has the support of Test greats Michael Hooper and Toutai Kefu, and Lukhan Salakaia-Loto hopes he has also won over Wallabies coach Joe Schmidt after another rousing audition against the British and Irish Lions. Salakaia-Loto was a stand-out as the First Nations and Pasifika XV almost caused a massive boilover at Marvel Stadium before falling to a 24-19 defeat. It was the lock/back-rower's third meeting with the Lions and he again proved he has the skills, physicality and aggressive mindset to unsettle the highly fancied tourists. His First Nations and Pasifika coach Kefu, an integral part of the Wallabies team that downed the Lions in 2001, said Salakaia-Loto had been "outstanding", while Test centurion and former captain Hooper said the 28-year-old should be in the starting side. But Salakaia-Loto wasn't convinced he would be recalled to the Wallabies squad ahead of their must-win match at the MCG on Saturday night, when they need a victory to keep the series alive after a loss in Brisbane. Told by Schmidt he needed more minutes after an injury-affected Super season, Salakaia-Loto said he'd done what he could. "I've had three chances, three cracks at these guys, so I don't have any more chances to sort of try and push my case forward," the Reds veteran said. "I've got my flight details to go home, back to Brissie to see my two girls and my partner, so that's all I'm worried about." Salakaia-Loto said his performance had been inspired by the emotion of representing his Samoan culture and family, as well as "a bit of frustration". He said he also took the attitude that he didn't care about the celebrated status of the Lions players. "I'll be honest, I just don't care," said the 30-cap forward. "I got a taste of them up against the Reds and I just knew that what they're about means nothing to me, I just go out there and play. "You mix that with a bit of frustration, a bit of emotion, and I guess the passion that I've been playing (with), especially for this week." While the Wallabies team for the second Test will be revealed on Thursday, the Lions appear set to rule out lock Joe McCarthy and winger Mack Hansen, with the star Irish pair both battling foot injuries. "Joe hasn't trained so far, but with the nature of the week, which is a bit different, we will see how he is for Thursday," said coach Andy Farrell. "Mack's progressing. Whether he's progressing quick enough, we'll see towards the end of the week." Owen Farrell captained the Lions for the first time and completed 80 minutes against the First Nations and Pasifika outfit to put his hand up for a midfield bench role. Farrell described the MCG clash, where more than 90,000 fans are expected, as the "biggest game of our lives" and said his team would need to improve to beat a desperate Wallabies side. "There will have to be plenty of improvement to get to the point where there's a win on the cards, because we know that Australia are going to be a lot better," Farrell said. "If you can't get up for what's coming, we're all in the wrong place. To me, this is the biggest game of our lives for every one of us who is part of our squad."
