Schmidt got it wrong and must ring changes
With the Wallabies overpowered in the contact zones in Brisbane, coach Joe Schmidt must surely reverse some selection errors by starting Angus Bell and Billy Pollard up front as hooker Matt Faessler was predictably underdone. Halfback Jake Gordon was in similar territory, although he might be paradoxically spared by the impact that Tate McDermott brings off the bench.
The best position for Joseph-Aukuso Suaalii is also still up for debate - his selection at No.13 has forced Len Ikitau into a battering ram role that is a waste of his footwork and distribution skills.
Lucky Lions dodged a yellow card
Referee Ben O'Keeffe must have looked very hard to find the arms in the Ben Earl tackle on Joseph-Aukuso Suaalii in the 59th minute as the No.13 tried to crash over from close range. It was a poor decision – Earl made little or no attempt to wrap – he turned his head away and threw a shoulder towards Suaalii's lower limbs. In fact, you could argue that Earl already had a knee on the ground when he hit Suaalii. It was a clear penalty and should have been a yellow card as the Lions had committed repeat infringements by that stage. Those types of tackles are a blight on the game – knee surgeons must wince every time they see them.
There was good and bad from Suaalii
There is a serious case for starting Hunter Paisami at No 12, moving Len Ikitau back into his right spot at No.13 and putting Suaalii to the wing, where the Lions looked relatively vulnerable on Saturday. Suaalii ran hard all night, with 10 carries, but there is no reason the Wallabies couldn't manufacture those opportunities for him in the No.11 or No.14 jersey. Defensively, there are still a few issues – he was caught a bit narrow for Huw Jones' disallowed try and his tendency to want to whack the man in possession, even after the pass is away, means he can take himself out of the play.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sydney Morning Herald
2 hours ago
- Sydney Morning Herald
NRL 2025 LIVE updates: Sandon Smith recalled as Roosters fight for top eight spot
Latest posts Latest posts 7.30pm King Ted for Dally M I declared it a while back, but who will deny Roosters fullback James Tedesco the Dally M? Early leader Luke Metcalf has gone down with a season-ending knee injury, while another contender, Melbourne fullback Ryan Papenhuyzen, continues to battle a calf injury. Can you think of anyone else in the race. That's right, I'll be waiting. In the press box. With no more food. Or water. 7.27pm No Victor Sydney Roosters enforcer Victor Radley told journalists at the Beer Footy and Food Festival launch at Henson Park he would be touch-and-go with his dodgy left shoulder – then he is not only not named, but ruled out the next month by coach Trent Robinson. If there is a silver lining with the extended time on the sidelines, it's the fact Radley can continue to work on his cognitive skills and 'work' his brai after a string of concussions. We asked the 'Enforcer' who had impressed him most this year at Easts, and he was quick to nominate Naufahu Whyte. Still on Henson Park, get down to the 'Ninth Wonder' on Saturday afternoon to watch the almighty Newtown Jets while enjoying good tucker and brew. 7.24pm Welcome to Allianz Howdy all. Welcome to the SMH blog. Who have we got tonight? The Roosters looked ready to steam over the top of Cronulla last week, then ran out of steam. They were out-muscled, and there were simply too many errors. The Storm lost at home against Manly, and now missing Nelson Asofa-Solomona (suspension), while Cameron Munster is in Queensland for his father's funeral on Friday. How many times do Melbourne drop two on the bounce? They need a win to keep their top-two hopes alive. The Chookies need a victory to keep their finals' dream alive.
The Age
2 hours ago
- The Age
NRL 2025 LIVE updates: Sandon Smith recalled as Roosters fight for top eight spot
Latest posts Latest posts 7.30pm King Ted for Dally M I declared it a while back, but who will deny Roosters fullback James Tedesco the Dally M? Early leader Luke Metcalf has gone down with a season-ending knee injury, while another contender, Melbourne fullback Ryan Papenhuyzen, continues to battle a calf injury. Can you think of anyone else in the race. That's right, I'll be waiting. In the press box. With no more food. Or water. 7.27pm No Victor Sydney Roosters enforcer Victor Radley told journalists at the Beer Footy and Food Festival launch at Henson Park he would be touch-and-go with his dodgy left shoulder – then he is not only not named, but ruled out the next month by coach Trent Robinson. If there is a silver lining with the extended time on the sidelines, it's the fact Radley can continue to work on his cognitive skills and 'work' his brai after a string of concussions. We asked the 'Enforcer' who had impressed him most this year at Easts, and he was quick to nominate Naufahu Whyte. Still on Henson Park, get down to the 'Ninth Wonder' on Saturday afternoon to watch the almighty Newtown Jets while enjoying good tucker and brew. 7.24pm Welcome to Allianz Howdy all. Welcome to the SMH blog. Who have we got tonight? The Roosters looked ready to steam over the top of Cronulla last week, then ran out of steam. They were out-muscled, and there were simply too many errors. The Storm lost at home against Manly, and now missing Nelson Asofa-Solomona (suspension), while Cameron Munster is in Queensland for his father's funeral on Friday. How many times do Melbourne drop two on the bounce? They need a win to keep their top-two hopes alive. The Chookies need a victory to keep their finals' dream alive.
Sydney Morning Herald
4 hours ago
- Sydney Morning Herald
No MCG fairytale for homegrown Lion as visitors brace for ‘talisman' Skelton
Andy Farrell revealed he had selected Garry Ringrose to start at outside centre but the Ireland centre had selflessly withdrawn from the Test debut after admitting following training on Thursday he was still experiencing symptoms from a concussion suffered against the Brumbies. Ringrose missed the first Test but played 70 minutes against the First Nations and Pasifika side on Tuesday, and had had no further knocks in the game or at training. 'But with these type of things, players are getting very good at telling the truth of how they feel, so it was a no-brainer to make the change straight away,' Farrell said. Huw Jones was recalled to the No.13 jersey. When asked to comment on the selflessness of Ringrose's admission, Farrell said: 'I thought exactly the same the minute that he mentioned it because it's tough to do that. 'It's very easy to keep it to yourself and lie and not be honest and open. It was very big of him and the right thing to do, 100 per cent. For the team as well, not just for Garry.' The Lions are bracing for a dramatic upgrade in physicality from the Wallabies at the MCG, after Joe Schmidt rubber-stamped the returns of Will Skelton and Rob Valetini, and with Langi Gleeson added to a bench with a split of six forwards and only two backs. 'It is what it says on the tin – it's obvious what they're going to bring and why they're selected,' Farrell said. 'I suppose they're delighted with [the returns of Valetini and Skelton], and the 6-2 bench just backs that up a little bit, doesn't it? So it's not unexpected.' Lions captain Maro Itoje played with Skelton at Saracens, and has played against him often after the Australian moved to La Rochell in France. 'I played a few good years with Will. Played against him a few times as well. He's a fantastic player. He's a talisman for La Rochelle and any side he plays in, he adds a sense of dynamism, size and power to the team. I'm delighted for him that he's able to play.' Loading The Lions can secure the series with victory at the MCG, and the 2025 squad are aiming to become the first Lions touring group to win back-to-back series in the same country, after winning in 2013. The turnout of MCG members will play a role, but attendance forecasts for the second Test at the MCG are tracking towards 90,000, which could see the game break two records for Lions' fixtures. The biggest Wallabies-Lions crowd is 84,188, set in Sydney in the third Test in 2001, and the biggest Lions crowd ever is 90,000, set in Johannesburg in 1955. 'When you spend time in Melbourne and speak to the locals, they hold the MCG in a really special regard,' Itoje said. 'If it reaches full capacity, it'll definitely be the biggest stadium I've played in. It's something we're looking to relish.'
