St James's Hospital apologises to trans woman over treatment at emergency department
In a public statement made to Paige Behan before the Workplace Relations Commission (WRC), the hospital acknowledged there is a 'lacuna in the care pathways' for people in her position.
Its management has apologised for the 'unsatisfactory and upsetting' experience she faced and undertook to meet with a trans advocacy group to discuss its concerns.
Ms Behan brought a statutory complaint against the hospital's board alleging that she was discriminated against in breach of the Equal Status Act 2000 when she came in seeking emergency treatment on August 16th, 2024. Her complaint has now been resolved by agreement.
READ MORE
The case opened before adjudication officer David James Murphy on Monday afternoon, following a short adjournment for talks between the parties.
Ms Behan's barrister, Michael Kinsley BL, appearing instructed by solicitor Seamus Hempenstall of Daly Hempenstall LLP said: 'The matter has been resolved and the only action required is that a public statement be read out by the hospital.'
The statement was then read out by counsel for the board of St James's Hospital, Mairead McKenna.
'St James's Hospital acknowledges there is a lacuna in the care pathways available for patients who have received gender-affirming surgery abroad,' Ms McKenna said.
'[The hospital] apologises to Paige Behan for the unsatisfactory and upsetting experience she had during her attendance at the emergency department on 16 August 2024. The hospital deeply regrets the upset caused to Ms Behan,' Ms McKenna said.
'St James's Hospital is committed to learning from Paige Behan's experience at the hospital and has agreed to meet with Transgender Equality Network Ireland (TENI) at Paige Behan's request to discuss the concerns regarding the care available to patients who are returning from abroad following gender-affirming surgery.'
The adjudicator, Mr Murphy noted the withdrawal of the equal status complaint pursuant to an agreement between the parties.
He praised the 'hard work' of the litigants in coming to the agreement, and commended their commitment to 'improving the service to everyone's benefit' before closing the hearing.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
FSAI recalls spinach and mixed leaves products over listeriosis fears
Spinach and mixed leaves products produced by McCormack Family Farms are being recalled due to the detection of the bacteria listeria monocytogenes, said the Food Safety Authority of Ireland (FSAI) . Recall notices will be displayed at point of sale in stores, with the below branded products being recalled: McCormack Family Farms Energise Super Mix, 100g McCormack Family Farms Irish Spinach Leaves, 100g McCormack Family Farms Irish Spinach Leaves, 200g McCormack Family Farms Irish Spinach Leaves, 250g McCormack Family Farms Mixed Leaves, 75g McCormack Family Farms Baby Leaves, 100g & 200g Tesco Mild Spinach, 350g Egan's Irish Baby Spinach, 250g Earlier this week, 141 ready-made meals produced by Ballymaguire Foods were recalled from several Irish supermarkets in connection with an 'extensive' outbreak of the rare bacterial infection listeriosis. The FSAI confirmed that one adult has died as a result of listeriosis, while nine cases of infection were identified. [ What is listeriosis and how serious is an infection? Opens in new window ] Symptoms of listeria monocytogenes infection can range from mild flu-like symptoms to gastrointestinal symptoms such as nausea, vomiting and diarrhoea. In rare cases, the infection can be more severe. READ MORE Some people are more vulnerable to listeriosis, including pregnant women, babies and people with weakened immune systems, including the elderly. Retailers are now requested to remove the implicated products from sale, and consumers are advised not to eat them. Further information on the recalled products, including their best-before dates, is available on the FSAI website here .
Irish Times
17 hours ago
- Irish Times
Like Katriona O'Sullivan, my childhood love of sport became a quest for weight-loss points
Katriona O'Sullivan, the Maynooth University academic and author of the bestselling memoir Poor , posted an emotional video to her Instagram recently in which she recalls a note from her second-year school report in which her PE teacher describes her as 'excellent at all sport', 'having a lot of talent' and 'capable of performing at a high level at any sport of her choosing'. She is sharing this reflection, she explains, in the context of writing about her body in her next book, Hungry. Within a year of that report card, she says, she was pregnant. After another year, she'd joined Weight Watchers, an experience which transformed her joyful experience of exercise into a commodified quest for weight-loss points, devoid of any of the pleasure – and sense of her own talent – that she used to derive from it. The specifics of O'Sullivan's personal story are her own but what she discusses here about the relationship between sport and adolescence will be recognisable to many women. The number of girls and young women who make it through puberty with their love of sports and exercise (for its own sake) intact is something that has been written about a lot recently . How many women who maintain an active participation in exercise share O'Sullivan's experience of having what was once a carefree, joyful, or even competitive endeavour become a functionalist understanding of movement as primarily for the sake of weight loss or body transformation? Whether it's the anxieties that accompany the onset of periods (worsened by the wacky obsession with compelling girls to wear white shorts and skorts on competitive teams), or the targeting of advertising and marketing that seems designed to instil in us the idea that our bodies are little but passive shells for garnering the approval or disapproval of the external world – engaging in sports and exercise in our teenage years starts to feel like a social risk. READ MORE O'Sullivan's words resonated especially for me after a week where I've had cause to reflect a lot on my relationship with sports. Last weekend, as a result of a very under-thought-out (and possibly slightly drunken) decision-making, I swam the longest distance (3.9km) on offer at the Gaelforce Great Lake swimming event on Lough Derg. Despite our creche's summer holidays and the baby-sleep-eviscerating heatwave conspiring to ensure I had almost no rest or good sleep in the days running up to the event, I put in a perfectly decent performance. There were various moments of thinking I was drowning, or believing a rescue kayak must be hovering behind me, and despite almost certainly swimming about two additional kilometres in zigzagging all over the place, I didn't get anywhere near the 1.45 time cut-off beyond which they suggested people might be removed from the water for their safety. Given the balmy conditions, this was probably an empty threat anyway. As I exited the water, a little boy put a medal over my cap-clad head, which my watching four-year-old daughter quickly snaffled for her neck. It's hard to explain the extent of the pride I felt. Having done no open water training for the swim, I am forced to conclude that this is something I might just be good at. I have passionately taken up pool swimming again since I saw Mona McSharry win her bronze in Paris last year. But when I reflect on why I left my swimming club the year I started secondary school, I remember it was about coping with being in togs at a time when I had come to regard my body as a site of big social embarrassment and shame. I know I was not alone in trading coaches to galas and goggles for long, lonely walks and compulsive bedroom sit-ups. Perhaps it is in part shared history that explains the surge of women rediscovering competitive physicality via Hyrox, the competitive fitness trend , triathlons and open-water swimming in their 30s and beyond. We are clawing back a sense of our bodies as powerful instruments with a lot left to give, in the face of a media landscape constantly telling us that our physical stock is plummeting – and that we should focus on saving ourselves with hormone health, expensive supplements and everything from naturopathy to invasive surgery. When I finished that race, I sent people post-race photographs of me and the medal thief. I cannot imagine a scenario in which I would willingly send someone photographs of myself in a swimsuit, except one in which my engagement with my body as something I do things with (instead of a thing that might look good or bad) had been swung back in the right direction. We are living through a deepening crisis about girls' exposure to online and offline messaging that is damaging to their sense of their bodies and what they are for. And so we need to make it as easy as possible for them to stay involved in activities that push back against this understanding of their bodies as objects of scrutiny they have to drag around with them. This involves giving much more space to highlighting women's achievements in sports and physical pursuits, so that young girls have some counterweight against a media landscape heaving with Kardashians, influencers and body-as-object messaging. It also involves making participation in sport varied, accessible and cheap. And it means ensuring that women's routes back into sport later in life aren't prohibitively expensive, or impossible to fit into professional or maternal lives.
Irish Times
17 hours ago
- Irish Times
Parents facilitating a 16-year-old's ‘prinks' is a sign of our weird relationship with alcohol
The drinks industry would have not opposed health warning labels on alcohol if they did not pose an existential threat to its profits. However, Big Alcohol lobbying so hard to get the Government to delay implementation until 2029 may have backfired. The unforeseen consequence is that more people now realise that alcohol is a class one carcinogen , in the same category as tobacco and asbestos. If your reaction to that statement was either to flinch or roll your eyes, welcome to Ireland, where our relationship with alcohol is as convoluted and as hard to uproot as bindweed. Our per capita intake may not be the worst in Europe and it is true that it is falling, but our addiction to binge drinking means that our health is still getting hammered. British travel writer and entrepreneur Dan Kieran once wrote a perceptive piece likening alcohol to a shared ritual , with an unspoken agreement that it is a good thing and part of who we are. He may as well have been taking about Ireland. READ MORE He described some people's tacit reaction to his decision to drink only on rare occasions, which amounted to, 'It's nice to see you and I'm in a good mood and there are lots of things worrying me at the moment [that] drinking allows me to forget briefly. Please don't suggest I have a dependency problem and ruin it for me.' Our relationship with alcohol starts early. A friend describes being astonished that parents she knows feel the need to facilitate their 16-year-olds' 'prinks' – pre-drinking, as in drinking alcohol at home before going out – as though access to alcopops is a human rights issue. Evidence from UK-based drinks market analyst IWSR suggests that even Gen Z, formerly seen as abstemious, are starting to consume more alcohol. IWSR sees it as positive that Gen Z are displaying 'a greater willingness to explore and maintain wider repertoires among multiple drink categories; above-average engagement with spirits; [and] a more relaxed stance on sustained moderation'. Tánaiste Simon Harris a former champion of health labels, now supports delaying introduction of health labelling for years. There may be concerns about unforeseen consequences, including pushing young people towards cocaine if alcohol use is reduced because of price increases. The cost of a gramme of cocaine is about €70, while a pint hovers somewhere between €6 and €7. [ Delay on health labelling on alcohol comes amid uncertain trading environment Opens in new window ] But it's often not one or the other. Very few people snort their first line of coke while stone cold sober. A 2019 Health Research Board study shows that alcohol was consumed in 85 per cent of first uses of cocaine. Alcohol is a gateway drug to cocaine, and taking cocaine enables people to drink more. We have such a weird relationship with alcohol that we would prefer to worry about cocaine use going up, rather than face the fact that most people's drug of choice is alcohol. Heavy-handed tactics by Big Alcohol backfired in Yukon, Canada, in 2017. Yukon, like Ireland, has high rates of binge-drinking and health-related harms like cancer. The Yukon government is directly involved in the sale of alcohol. Researchers saw tiny Yukon as an ideal location to conduct an eight-month real-world experiment on the impact of health warning labels. Bright yellow labels were affixed to alcohol in the government liquor store in Whitehorse, the capital. The experiment was axed within a month after ferocious industry pressure. Emails obtained under freedom of information showed that industry leaders claimed the assertion ''alcohol can cause cancer' is a false and misleading statement'; one called the cancer-warning label 'alarmist and misleading'. The relentless lobbying to drop the labels in Yukon only focused attention on the reasons behind the resistance. In 2018, when the legislation regarding labelling was being introduced in Ireland, some industry members compared the carcinogenic effect of alcohol to that of burnt toast. Drinkaware, which is funded by the alcohol industry, runs soulful ads featuring hip-hop artist Nealo, urging us to embrace mindful drinking. Meanwhile, the alcohol industry opposes all regulation that limits the availability, price and promotion of alcohol. [ Drinks Ireland warned Taoiseach that alcohol health labelling plans seen as 'trade barrier' by US Opens in new window ] Alcohol is responsible for four deaths every day in Ireland and causes more than 200 types of illnesses and injuries, including seven common deadly cancers, fatal liver disease, and foetal alcohol spectrum disorder. One in 13 cases of breast cancer is directly related to alcohol consumption. Worryingly, most people who are aware of the link think it is just heavy drinking that is problematic. Saving lives by challenging a culture reinforced daily by a powerful global lobby requires courage. There will never be a good time to introduce labelling. There will always be an economic crisis or a powerful lobby that will be displeased. We were on the verge of doing something as revolutionary as the smoking ban, and we chickened out. Have your say: What do you think of 16-year-olds drinking alcohol? Would you let your own teens drink at home? Tell us below
