Forestry: Rotorua consultant warns of tough times for NZ log exports to China
Since 2019, New Zealand's isolating export log prices have occasionally 'come back' to sub-$100 per cubic metre from an average of $132.
At the lower level, he said harvesting for most of the small forests' estate was not viable and, because there was little or no domestic demand, they shut their gates.
Tombleson said he had not witnessed such a 'negative outlook' for the industry in his 50-year forestry career.
A Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Trade report, released in December, said property investment in China fell 10.2% in the first seven months of 2024.
October data showed an improvement in housing sentiment.
However, the overall picture remained 'challenging' with both investment in real estate and the number of new builds dropping by their fastest rate in October year-on-year.
Weak market
The MFAT report said structural change in the property sector had weakened economic activity in related sectors of construction and furniture-making, both of which import New Zealand logs and wood products.
'This impacts demand and global prices for New Zealand logs.'
MFAT said China's total imports of logs had fallen 36% from 2021-2023 (NZ$16.4 billion to NZ$10.3 billion).
The current property slump has been a 'hard market demand correction', meaning that while demand for logs would eventually stabilise, it's likely to do so at a level lower than the heights of 2020-2021.
Tombleson said a bulk of New Zealand's log exports initially went to Japan and Korea which completed the same cycle of demand to build infrastructure.
'Then China came in overnight,' he said.
'They could do what no others could in terms of scale.'
Tombleson said predictions of a downturn in log exports to China in the next decade 'came forward'.
Increasing demand
On a brighter note, Tombleson said there was increasing demand from companies such as dairy giant Fonterra in its move away from fossil fuels to wood pellets and wood chips to power boilers.
He said regrettably, the increasing demand for biofuels would not be a substitute for the high prices paid by China required to make forestry profitable, particularly for more than 4000 smaller forest owners who were mainly farmers.
Fellow forestry consultant Dennis Neilson was similarly concerned about the log trade to China, which he helped initiate in 1985.
Following a 'building frenzy' which started in 2008-2009, he said the past four years had seen the sector 'crash quite quickly' in China.
This stemmed from factors including an oversupply of logs in relation to previous demand, closure of construction companies through financial issues, and the Covid pandemic.
A frequent visitor to China for his Rotorua-based business, Neilson said he did not predict the severity of the downturn in the log trade there.
'It's likely to be subdued for several years before it comes back.'
US tariffs
While China was not a huge market for sawn timber from New Zealand, the organisation representing sawmills and timber treatment companies was 'nervous' about that sector's biggest trading partner – the United States.
New Zealand Timber Industry Federation chief executive Jeff Ilott said proposed tariffs on exports of sawn timber from New Zealand to the US were not due to be introduced until later in the year.
'We will wait and see.'
Ilott said for the year to December, exports of sawn timber to China increased from 210,000 cubic metres to about 250,000 cubic metres (returning around $331 per cubic metre).
However, he said this did not represent a 'big return' for New Zealand's annual billion-dollar sawn timber export business.
NZ Forest Owners' Association board member Marcus Musson said overall, it's not all doom and gloom for the industry, with supply matching demand the key.
Fluctuations in the Chinese market were 'not unusual', he said, with some commentators predicting a rebound in construction next year.
Musson said the furniture market – NZ logs processed in China and exported to the US – has remained strong, but the proposed tariffs have created some uncertainty.
On the home front, he says more biofuel opportunities need to be pursued, as does 'mass timber building' in the residential, commercial and industrial sectors.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Otago Daily Times
40 minutes ago
- Otago Daily Times
Corner Store: Over 25 years where style and individuality intersect
People have known it as Base Clothing store, but the Wānaka retailer has changed its name to Corner Store. As it turns out, it is one of the longest-running clothing stores in town. Owner Chris Walsh got his first retail job when he was just 15, working across the Ditch in Newcastle, where he was brought up. That was where he got a taste of fashion and the fun that comes from working in the industry, he says. "There were these cool girls working with me and I was thinking 'Whoa, there's great girls, you can hang out with girls, this is perfect'," he jokes. He dreamed of coming to New Zealand to ski at Treble Cone. When he arrived, he fell in love with Wānaka and the rest is history. In 1999, he and two mates, Brent Harridge and Tim Hudson, brought into the Base clothing store business. At the time it cost them just $50,000 each for the lease in Helwick St. By comparison, sections in Meadowstone Dr at the time were going for about $30,000. "I came to New Zealand and realised there wasn't much in the way of clothing stores." There was little happening at the lakefront end of Helwick St and so they placed themselves on "Plods Patch" (the intersection of Helwick and Dunmore Sts), as it was affectionately named. He recalls PaperPlus was on the diagonal corner, where it still sits today. "More retail in upper Helwick St has helped. The pavements were no good at the start — it was just us and the pharmacy. You had to cross the road, [so] we were a bit of a destination." Over the course of a quarter of a century, he has seen the town change remarkably and plenty of retailers fail, or leave for other opportunities. "In Wānaka, a lot of shops come and go but there's still a lot of independent stores and we have a local vibe, which is pretty cool and special." While there were stores before his, and many have come since, the shops he recalls having done the long-haul are Kai Whakapai, the Dough Bin, PaperPlus, Racers Edge, Wānaka Pharmacy and the Westpac Bank. Mr Walsh puts down the longevity down to necessity and grit. After the 1999 Wānaka floods and the Global Financial Crisis in 2008, he had to borrow money from his parents and sell property to stay on that corner. "My accountants were saying shut the business down." He stayed because he loved the work and "knew it would come right". It did. Once the GFC passed, Wānaka township started to grow at a slow and steady pace; in the past five years it has boomed. The property market and domestic buyers had helped. Tourism been a huge part of his shop's survival. "The quality of international tourism — we are getting more European and Americans and Canadians and they love shopping," he says. "Covid was frightening when it happened. We started our online store more heavily during Covid and then after Covid we had a really awesome couple of years. "I find New Zealanders are my best customers, followed by Aussies. New Zealanders were travelling around and supporting New Zealanders. The last couple of years have been a little tough because the economy has been a little tough on people's spending, mortgages and interest rates." When he looks back on 1999 when the shop first opened, the store was quite "modern" compared with most others, which set it apart. "The store was unique. It was way out there; everything was old and our store was new school and modern." Initial brands stocked were Lee, Huffer, Wrangler and Rusty, all of which carry through today. Mr Walsh says Wānaka is great for shopping because it has more than just chain stores. It is a shopping destination because of its unique independent stores. "In Wānaka, the clothing assortment is fantastic. There are so many good clothing stores. I think we are one of the best places to go shopping. We have more options than anywhere. You go anywhere else and they are all chain stores but here we are all different and independent." He adds that Wānaka people are fashionable. "I think Wānaka people are fit and healthy and they like to wear cool clothes that are comfortable. And the older crew dress younger. It's down to earth." While his prices are mid level, he has enjoyed seeing higher-end fashion come to Wānaka and bring something for everyone. The business trio also started women's clothing store, Bella, as well as the Base ski shop. They have since sold both and they are still in operating. And as for the name change, it's obvious, he says. "I dreamed up all these funky names. Corner Store suits all the ages — we have teens and older customers, we cater for all women and all ages and Corner Store seems to suit that, a place that caters for all."
Otago Daily Times
43 minutes ago
- Otago Daily Times
Plan to bowl TV house for bougie boutique hotel
An artist's impression depicts a proposed four-suite boutique hotel on Man St. PHOTO: SUPPLIED A 'landmark' boutique hotel is planned for Queenstown. Cactus Kiwi Ltd Partnership wants to bowl a two-level 1960s character home at 10 Man St — which served as the police station for the first two series of locally shot TV crime thriller, One Lane Bridge — and replace it with a four-level hotel, accessed from the Brecon St stairs and Man St. The 339sqm site, sandwiched between Queenstown's established CBD and the emerging expansion towards Skyline's gondola, sold to a local buyer in 2021 for $3.1million + GST. Originally a residential home, it was, for many years, home to a language school, which has since ceased. It's directly beside the Man St carpark, above which a 173-room hotel was approved last year through the Covid-19 Recovery (Fast-track Consenting) Act 2020, and a stone's throw from the Sofitel Hotel. According to the application, the high-quality boutique hotel, designed by Monk McKenzie, will have just four guest rooms, with total capacity for eight people. At the basement level, accessed via lift or the Brecon St stairs, a small wine bar's proposed, open to guests and the public, from 8am to 4am daily. The lobby will be on the ground floor, accessed via Man St, with two suites each on the second and third floors, each with large living spaces, master bedrooms, and spa/shower facilities. From Man St, it'll look like a three-storey building; from the Brecon St steps it'll present as four. "While the hotel will be of a much higher elevation than the built form below on Brecon St, the height of the building will not be out of character, withthe adjoining level of built form, including Sofitel Hotel and the consented hotel on top of the Man Street carparking building," the application says. And, according to an urban design report from Williams & Co, it can be described as a "landmark corner site", with the hotel providing a "strong edge" to the Brecon St steps, and will signal the future extending line of built form along Man St towards Lakeview. Queenstown's council's currently vetting the application.
Otago Daily Times
43 minutes ago
- Otago Daily Times
Network Waitaki gives $121,476 to 52 groups
Network Waitaki chief executive officer Dylan Andrews was on deck to present more than $120,000 in donations to community groups in the district at their annual sponsorship awards night on Monday. PHOTO: NIC DUFF Network Waitaki has dished out more than $120,000 to community groups in the district. The Oamaru-based lines company held its annual sponsorship awards night at the Oamaru Opera House on Monday, giving away a total of $121,476 to 52 groups. Network Waitaki chief executive Dylan Andrews said the selection process was as difficult as ever due to "so many worthy initiatives". "More often than not, our sponsorship grant is a significant contribution towards the cost to buy new equipment, help pay for a tournament or improve the wellbeing of people in the community. "Every bit helps make Waitaki a better place to live and play." In addition to the sponsorship awards, Network Waitaki is also a continued sponsor of the Otago Southland Rescue Helicopter and the new Network Waitaki Events Centre. Applications for Network Waitaki's Individual Sporting Programme are open until September 30 and can be made through its website. Individuals can apply for financial support for personal participation, either locally or at representative level, or for skills development in a chosen field such as music, arts or sport. — APL
