Brain injuries hearing: ‘no safe number of times' a footballer can head the ball
There is 'no safe limit' for heading a football, the high court heard, as lawyers acting for former players who suffered permanent brain injuries sought to advance their case against the game's authorities.
Claimants in the case argue that the authorities should have made players aware of the risks they were taking by heading a ball as far back as the 60s, claiming that information on the danger of repeated blows to the head was in the public domain.
Speaking on behalf of the 23 former professional players, and the families of 10 deceased players who comprise the joint action, Susan Rodway KC told a pre-trial hearing in London on Thursday that 'it is the defendants' duty to outline what they did know' on the issue of injuries.
'The claimant position is that repeated heading and clashes and associated injuries have a cumulative effect,' she said. 'We are saying there is no safe number of times a player can head the ball. Do the defendants have experts that say there is a quantum under which safety is maintained?
'If that is the case, we say that the case continues but on the basis that the defendants will have exceeded even that safe level, unless they are going to say starkly that heading of the ball is safe, however much you do it.'
The Football Association, English Football League and FA of Wales are joint defendants in the case and Michael Kent KC, acting on behalf of the EFL, said this definition meant the court was now hearing a 'completely different' case from one looking at individuals who had experienced concussion on the pitch.
Analysing the risk of repeated heading meant that 'we are dealing with allegations related to something which would not at the time have produced any identifiable problem,' he said. 'It's a cumulative but invisible injury over a period, completely different from a case based on a huge number of references to concussions and their management.'
Rodway said that a further 90 individuals have agreed to join the legal action and that 'we remain of the view that this could go as high as 150'. The claimants include the family of former England midfielder and 1966 World Cup winner, Nobby Stiles, who had dementia and died in 2020. A postmortem found he was suffering from chronic traumatic encephalopathy, a progressive brain condition caused by repeated blows to the head.
Sign up to Football Daily
Kick off your evenings with the Guardian's take on the world of football
after newsletter promotion
Both sides also challenged each other over perceived delays in bringing the case to trial, with Rodway asking for deadlines to be moved forward and defendants demanding extra information. 'It has been five years since the case started, and three years since generic elements of claim were submitted,' Rodway told the court. 'I very much hope that the court can take on board that enough is enough and we need to progress.'
Martin Porter KC, representing the FA, said: 'I know her solicitor will tell anyone who listens that the FA is dragging its feet but we have had to go to strenuous efforts in order to discover what these cases are truly about.'
Judge Amanda Stevens ruled that the parties should reconvene for a further pre-trial hearing on 29 July.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
10 minutes ago
- BBC News
'It's not normal' - how Chelsea coped with the stoppage
"This is not football."The words of Chelsea manager Enzo Maresca when asked about how the one-hour-53-minute stoppage impacted their Club World Cup last-16 tie against defenders Marc Cucurella, Levi Colwill and Tosin Adarabioyo were furious when pulled off the pitch - as was Maresca - having been on course to win with only five minutes of normal time re-entering the operations and dressing room area, players took turns to cycle on exercise bikes to keep their muscles warm and did kick-ups to stay fresh at the Bank of America Stadium in explained the mood and why it impacted performance, adding: "So two hours inside - people speak with the family outside [to check] if they were good with the security. People eating, laughing, talking on their mobiles. It was two hours. That's why I said it's not football."Captain Reece James added: "It was quite disruptive when you're in the flow of the game. Lots of substitutions - trying to get warm and stay warm. It was difficult and the climate was very hot and humid."A senior Chelsea official admitted to confusion and relief around the senior staff after the match."You cannot be inside for two hours. It is something completely new," Maresca said."I can understand that for security reasons you suspend the game. But if you suspend six, seven games that means that probably is not the right place to do this competition."This is a fantastic competition. The Club World Cup is top; we are happy to be in the last eight."It's not normal to suspend a game. In a World Cup, how many games are suspended? Probably zero. In Europe, how many games? Zero."
The Sun
12 minutes ago
- The Sun
I spent weeks identifying 7/7 victims – the atrocity still haunts me 20 years on
HERO Scots cops who identified victims of the London 7/7 terror attacks last night revealed they are still haunted by the atrocity 20 years on. Paul Clements, 67, recalled his 'traumatic' five-week deployment in a mortuary holding commuters killed when terrorists detonated suicide bombs on three trains and a bus. 4 4 4 The retired Met Police officer revealed he still struggles to board the Underground due to painful memories of the rush-hour tragedy — when 52 people lost their lives and 784 others were wounded. He had grown used to dealing with the 'ugly side' of life in the force but nothing prepared him for his work helming a team of Disaster Victim Identification officers. Days from the 20th anniversary of the attack on July 7, 2005, dad-of-one Paul, from Stranraer, said: 'I spent five weeks in a mortuary with a team trying to identify victims. 'It was traumatic, of course it was. Each body part or each person is also a crime scene. 'Obviously we had to recover any forensic evidence. We had to look for SIM cards, or bits of circuit board, for evidential purposes, because we were trying to find out what type of detonators were used. 'You're dealing with an ugly side of life — and as a police officer you do deal with the ugly side of life — but this was on a fairly massive scale. 'It took most people by surprise. You do have to be professional.' Three bombs were detonated on board Underground trains within 50 seconds of each other as Londoners headed to work. An hour later a fourth explosive ripped through the top of a No30 double-decker bus. Recalling his struggles later to catch the tube, with the memory of the attacks fresh, Paul said: 'I remember later walking to the tube station. 7/7 survivor Dan Biddle and his rescuer Adrian interview 'I got to the entrance and I just couldn't walk in it. I got a mental flashback of everything I'd just dealt with. 'I thought, no, I cannot go on the tube. And strangely enough, I got a bus, and the bus took me probably three or four times the length of time. 'Although obviously a bus was bombed as well, it didn't have the same mental impact as the tube did. 'For about a year I just refused to go on the tube. Needs must and eventually I faced up to it and jumped on the tube. But even now it just brings back all those memories. 'I'll do it, but I never feel comfortable going on the tube — and that's 20 years later.' Three suicide bombers launched the deadliest terror atrocity on British soil — setting off from Leeds around 4am in a hired Nissan Micra then driving to Luton to meet their fourth accomplice. Scots Victim Tragedy ACCOUNTANT Helen Jones was the only Scot to die in the terror attack. Helen, 28, was killed in the Piccadilly line bombing just weeks after moving into a North London flat with her boyfriend. She grew up in Templand, near Lockerbie, Dumfries-shire, and went to Aberdeen University aged just 16. After leaving school, she also spent time working with prostitutes and drug addicts at Glasgow's city mission and volunteered at homeless hostels. She'd texted her partner just before the bomb was detonated. Three of the men, Mohammad Sidique Khan, 30, Shehzad Tanweer, 22, and Germaine Lindsay, 19, entered the Underground and boarded separate trains. Ringleader Khan got into the second carriage of a westbound Circle line train heading to Paddington and detonated his device near double doors at Edgware Road station. Tanweer boarded an eastbound Circle line train and set off his device at the rear of the second carriage between Liverpool Street and Aldgate at the same time. Meanwhile, Lindsay caused the most devastation when he exploded his bomb on a southbound Piccadilly Line service between King's Cross and Russell Square. An hour later Hasib Hussain, 18, launched a fourth attack on boarding a bus at Tavistock Square. Retired Detective Sergeant Callum Sutherland, 67, from Greenock, led units working with pathologists to identify the deceased in a makeshift mortuary. The crime scene manager and his officers had to search for bits of explosive devices — a job so grim that many opted to stay in a hotel for five weeks rather than return to their families and discuss the devastating details. Callum endured harrowing shifts with fellow officers within the temporary morgue in the gardens of the Honourable Artillery Company. Netflix Doc Details Horror Attack A NEW Netflix documentary will offer inside accounts of the horrific day. Attack on London: Hunting The 7/7 Bombers features exclusive interviews with witnesses, including survivors and police. Former Prime Minister Tony Blair, 72, also contributed to the programme. And relatives of Brazilian Jean Charles de Menezes, 27, pictured, who was shot dead after being wrongly suspected of being a terrorist, also have their say. The documentary will launch on the streaming service on Tuesday. He admitted: 'A girl was meant to be getting married there over the weekend. The police or the government paid for her wedding to be somewhere else so they could use this as a temporary mortuary. 'It's later it affects you. You'll hear police officers say, it doesn't bother me, it's just a job. 'Well, rubbish. It does. Not necessarily at the time, or the next day, or a few days later, but at some point it will.' Family man Callum has also worked with crime author and scriptwriter Lynda La Plante on TV shows Prime Suspect and Trial & Retribution. He added: 'You have the occasional nightmare. I've always felt if it doesn't bother you, then you're not the right person for the job. 'One of the things that was different as well is, generally, in a murder, you don't know who did it, or you don't know the exact cause of death until you have a post-mortem. But with the bombings, you knew how those people had died from the word go. 'It's tiring because you were doing 12-plus hour days, day in, day out, but we had an important job to do.' He and colleague Paul remain proud of how they handled the toughest days of their careers. Paul said: 'It doesn't feel like 20 years. It seems in some instances almost like a couple of years ago. We all felt very proud. I think we're all professional, and it was a multi-team sort of effort because it wasn't just Met officers and we worked exceptionally well.' Callum added: 'You should be thinking about people who've lost their loved ones, giving family comfort and finding out who did it.'
The Sun
12 minutes ago
- The Sun
Liverpool ready to offer winger to Crystal Palace in swap for £50m-rated Marc Guehi as transfer spree goes on
LIVERPOOL are ready to throw flying Scot Ben Doak into a swap deal for England star Marc Guehi. The Kop's transfer team are focusing on centre-half Guehi, 24, as their next target but Palace want around £50million for him. 3 3 Doak, 19, is fancied by Palace and rated in the £25m class despite his limited appearances outside a loan spell at Middlesbrough. He played 24 times in the Championship last term, scoring three times and assisting seven goals. Liverpool would offer the winger and cash to snap up Guehi but that will take a great deal of negotiating. Palace supremo Steve Parish is renowned for standing firm on valuations. Everton are keen on Doak but not at that price. Meanwhile, Guehi is letting his deal run down but has been relatively low-paid at Selhurst Park for some time — money is not his driving force. His deal is set to expire at the end of the 2025/26 campaign. Liverpool are not the only club interested in his services with Newcastle and Manchester United also keen. Arne Slot 's side are looking to add another centre-back to the squad with Jarell Quansah expected to leave. The Under-21 Euros winner with England is set to sign for Bundesliga giants Bayer Leverkusen. Quansah, 22, will have a medical with Erik ten Hag 's side on Monday ahead of a £30m switch, according to Fabrizio Romano. Liverpool have been active in the transfer market as they look to strengthen ahead of the Premier League title defence. The likes of Florian Wirtz, Jeremie Frimpong, Milos Kerkez and Freddie Woodman have been welcomed through the doors at Anfield. 3
