Price wars grip China as deflation deepens, $30 for a luxury Coach bag?
'I'm cutting down on large expenditures,' said 28-year-old Li, while browsing for items in Beijing's Super Zhuanzhuan second-hand luxury items store that opened in May.
'The economy is definitely in a downturn,' she said, adding: 'My family's wealth has shrunk by a lot' due to the property crisis China has been grappling with since 2021.
As deflationary pressures mount in the world's second-largest economy, consumer behaviour is changing in ways that could lead to further downward pressure on prices, raising concerns that deflation could become entrenched, posing more headaches for China's policymakers.
Data showed on Monday that consumer prices fell 0.1% in May from a year earlier, with price wars raging in a number of sectors, from autos to e-commerce to coffee amid concerns about oversupply and sluggish household demand.
New businesses are seeking success by targeting penny-pinchers, from restaurants selling 3 yuan ($0.40) breakfast menus to supermarkets offering flash sales four times a day. But this trend is worrying economists who see price wars as ultimately unsustainable as losing firms may have to close and people may lose their jobs, fuelling further deflation.
Consumer price sensitivities' have accelerated growth in the Chinese second-hand luxury market since the pandemic, with annual growth rates surpassing 20% in 2023, according to an industry report by Zhiyan Consulting from last year.
But that growth has also led to a spike in the volumes of such items available for sale - which is noticeable in the level of discounts on offer. U.S. stocks closed marginally higher on Monday, with the Dow ending flat, the S&P 500 posting a slight gain and the Nasdaq climbing three tenths of one percent.
Some new stores, including Super Zhuanzhuan, are offering items at discounts of up to 90% of their original price, compared with industry standards of 30-40% in recent years. Discounts of 70% or more are also now common on large second-hand platforms, such as Xianyu, Feiyu, Ponhu and Plum.
'In the current economic environment we are seeing more existing luxury consumers shifting to the second-hand market,' said Lisa Zhang, an expert with Daxue Consulting, a market research and strategy firm focusing on China.
But sellers 'have more discounts and it's due to more competition.' At Super Zhuanzhuan, a green, carryall Christie handbag model by Coach, which its first owner bought for 3,260 yuan ($454) can be re-purchased for 219 yuan ($30). A 2,200 yuan Givenchy G Cube necklace can be found for 187 yuan.
'Year-to-year, it's like 20% growth in the number of sellers, but the buyers' numbers are pretty much stable,' said the founder of another second-hand luxury business in China, asking for anonymity to speak candidly about the state of the industry.
'The middle class - their salary has really decreased. The economy is the number one reason we're seeing these trends.'
He said big cities such as Shanghai and Beijing have enough buyers to accommodate new market entrants, but elsewhere in China there isn't any room for more.
'I would expect the majority of the stores which have recently opened up will actually close,' he said.
University professor Riley Chang was browsing through Super Zhuanzhuan not because she wanted to buy anything new - she hasn't spent money on big brands since the pandemic - but because she wanted to see what the market was if she sold any of her own possessions.
She wasn't happy with what she saw.
'I've been to several major second-hand luxury stores in Beijing and Shanghai and they all try to push your price as low as possible,' said Chang.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
2 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Asia shares sideswiped by US economic jitters, oil slips
SYDNEY: Asian share markets followed Wall Street lower on Monday as fears for the U.S. economy returned with a vengeance, spurring investors to price in an almost certain rate cut for September and undermining the dollar. Some early resilience in U.S. stock futures and a continued retreat in oil prices did help limit the losses, but the bleak message from the July payrolls report was hard to ignore. Not only had revisions meant payrolls were 290,000 below where investors had thought they would be, but the three-month average slowed to just 35,000 from 231,000 at the start of the year. 'The report brings payroll growth closer in line with big data indicators of job gains and the broader growth dataset, both of which have slowed significantly in recent months,' noted analysts at Goldman Sachs. 'Taken together, the economic data confirm our view that the U.S. economy is growing at a below-potential pace.' Neither did the reaction of President Donald Trump instil confidence, as the firing of the head of Labor Statistics threatened to undermine confidence in U.S. economic data. Likewise, news that Trump would get to fill a governorship position at the Federal Reserve early added to worries about the politicisation of interest rate policy. Analysts assume the appointee will be loyal to Trump alone, though the president did grudgingly concede that Fed Chair Jerome Powell would likely see out his term. 'It opens the prospect of broader support on the Fed Board for lower rates sooner rather than later,' said Ray Attrill, head of FX research at NAB. 'Fed credibility, and the veracity of the statistics on which they base their policy decisions, are both now under the spotlight.' Markets moved quickly to price in a lot more easing with the probability of a September rate cut swinging to 90%, from 40% before the jobs report. Futures extended the rally on Monday to imply 65 basis points of easing by year-end, compared to 33 basis points pre-data. Markets have essentially already eased for the Fed with two-year Treasury yields down another 4 basis points at 3.661%. They tumbled almost 25 basis points on Friday in the biggest one-day drop since August last year. DOLLAR DENTED The prospect of lower borrowing costs offered some support for equities and S&P 500 futures inched up 0.1%, while Nasdaq futures rose 0.2%. Asian share markets, however, were still catching up with Friday's retreat and the Nikkei fell 2.1%, while South Korea dipped 0.2%. MSCI's broadest index of Asia-Pacific shares outside Japan broke the mould and firmed 0.3%. Wall Street has also taken comfort in an upbeat results season. Around two-thirds of the S&P 500 have reported and 63% have beaten forecasts. Earnings growth is estimated at 9.8%, up from 5.8% at the start of July. Companies reporting this week include Disney (DIS.N), opens new tab, McDonald's, Caterpillar and some of the large pharmaceutical groups. The dismal U.S. jobs data did put a dent in the dollar's crown of exceptionalism, snuffing out what had been a promising rally for the currency. The dollar dipped 0.1% to 147.24 yen , having shed an eye-watering 2.3% on Friday, while the euro stood at $1.1585 after bouncing 1.5% on Friday. The dollar index was pinned at 98.659 , having been toppled from last week's top of 100.250. Sterling was more restrained at $1.3287 as markets are 87% priced for the Bank of England to cut rates by a quarter point at a meeting on Thursday. The BoE board itself is expected to remain split on easing, while markets still favour two further cuts by the middle of next year. In commodity markets, gold was flat at $3,361 an ounce , having climbed more than 2% on Friday. Oil prices extended their latest slide as OPEC+ agreed to another large rise in output for September, which completely reverses last year's cuts of 2.2 million barrels per day. Brent dropped 0.6% to $69.24 a barrel, while U.S. crude also fell 0.6% to $66.93 per barrel.
Business Recorder
2 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Wall Street Week Ahead: AI gains and strong earnings support Wall Street as tariff woes linger
NEW YORK: With more than half of second quarter earnings reported and stocks near record highs, company results have reassured investors about the artificial intelligence trade that has energized Wall Street, even if tariff worries curtailed buying. With results in from 297 of the S&P 500 companies as of Thursday, year-on-year earnings growth for the second quarter is now estimated at 9.8%, up from 5.8% estimated growth on July 1, according to LSEG data. Next week investors will get a peek at earnings from Dow Jones Industrial Average constituents Disney, McDonald's and Caterpillar, for a look at the broader economy. Strong profit reports for these companies could propel the Dow, trading just shy of its December record high, to a fresh peak. Some 81% of the companies have beaten analyst expectations on earnings, above the 76% average for the past four quarters. 'The earnings season has been unambiguously better than expected,' Art Hogan, chief market strategist at B. Riley Wealth in Boston, said. The strength of corporate earnings is particularly reassuring for investors after the pummeling sentiment took in the prior quarter due to the twin threats of tariffs and worries over flagging economic growth. 'The first quarter was a bit more mixed and you had some questionable economic data ... which I think gave the market some pause,' said Tim Ghriskey, senior portfolio strategist at Ingalls & Snyder in New York. 'But the second quarter seems to have just been a turnaround,' Ghriskey said. The strength of results for names linked to the artificial intelligence trade - the investment thesis that AI will be a transformative force, driving a significant portion of future economic growth and company profits - is particularly heartening, investors and analysts said. 'Overall it has been mega caps, growth/technology/AI that is driving a lot of the results,' Ghriskey said. 'This is where we want to be exposed in terms of companies ... we're at maximum equity exposures and we're comfortable there.' Having boosted the market for several quarters, the trade ran into rough waters at the start of the year as the emergence of Chinese-founded artificial intelligence startup DeepSeek rattled investors, stoking concerns over heightened competition that could disrupt the dominance of established tech giants at the heart of the AI trade, including Nvidia. Strong results from Microsoft and Meta Platforms reassured investors that massive bets on AI are paying off. Worries over AI demand appear overblown, Macro Hive research analyst Viresh Kanabar said. The trade related tumult earlier this year prompted many investors to pare equity exposure, particularly to higher-risk growth stocks. Even after the market rebound - the S&P 500 is up about 6% for the year and near a record high - institutional investors have been slow to return to equities. Overall, investors' equity positioning is still only modestly overweight, according to Deutsche Bank estimates. Strength in earnings from AI and technology names could draw more investors and lift markets further in coming weeks, analysts said. 'If you are trying to beat your benchmark and you were underweight any of the AI names you have to chase them,' B. Riley Wealth's Hogan said. After S&P 500's 2.2% gain in July, the seasonally volatile months of August and September, markets might face some short-term turbulence, Hogan said. Historically, August has marked a pick-up in stock market gyrations that peaks in October. August kicked off with stocks selling off sharply on Friday as new US tariffs on dozens of trading partners and Amazon's unimpressive earnings weighed on sentiment, while a weaker payrolls report added to risk aversion. But any near-term market pullback should be seen as a buying opportunity, especially in some of the mega-cap, technology names, Hogan said. With big AI names, Alphabet, Microsoft, Nvidia, Meta Platforms and Amazon, commanding about a quarter of the weight in the S&P 500, the health of the AI trade bodes well for the market at an index level, analysts said.
Express Tribune
3 hours ago
- Express Tribune
China may have cracked 'carbon code'
Listen to article For the first time in its recent history, China has managed to increase energy use while reducing carbon emissions — a milestone seen as an early sign of "absolute decoupling" and potentially one of the most consequential shifts in global climate politics. By breaking the historic link between economic growth and rising emissions, China appears to be embarking on a high-stake transition towards a 'post-carbon industrial model', positioning itself as the world's first emerging electrostate. While many countries have reduced carbon intensity, few have grown economically and consumed more energy while cutting overall emissions. In the year leading to March 2024, China emitted an estimated 12 billion tonnes of carbon dioxide, which is more than all of Asia combined, and nearly double the emissions recorded in the United States. However, in a striking reversal, emissions during the following year showed a marginal but crucial decline, even as energy consumption continued to rise. Carbon dioxide emissions per kilowatt hour (kWh) of electricity averaged 492 grams during the opening half of 2025, according to data from energy portal This marked the first-ever reading below 500 grams per kWh, down from 514g/kWh during the same period in 2024 and 539g/kWh in the first half of 2023. The shift comes amid a seemingly contradictory backdrop. In 2023 alone, China approved or began construction of 94 gigawatts (GW) of coal-fired power plants - enough to power the entire UK grid twice over. However, at the same time, it began installing renewables at a pace that dwarfs the rest of the world. Over 500GW of wind and solar projects were under construction last year. The apparent contradiction — a coal station nearly every week, alongside continent-sized solar farms in Inner Mongolia — is part of a redundancy strategy for energy security. Experts note that the newly built coal capacity is not intended to run continuously, but rather to backstop an increasingly renewable-powered grid in times of shortfall. Despite the rising coal capacity, emissions intensity — the amount of CO2 per unit of GDP — continues to fall, signalling broader structural changes. China remains the world's largest carbon emitter, but its per capita emissions, while higher than the EU and UK, are still lower than the United States. The emissions data comes from research compiled by Lauri Myllyvirta at Finland's Centre for Research on Energy and Clean Air (CREA), using customs data and commodity flows, which experts say is difficult to falsify. While some scepticism remains regarding official Chinese statistics, independent analysts at the Carbon Tracker Initiative affirm the trend as credible. 'Industrial sovereignty' However, experts argue that this alone cannot explain the decoupling. The more transformative factor is China's state-driven electrification strategy: mass investment in electric vehicles, high-speed rail, electrified industrial processes and grid upgrades, all underwritten by its industrial planning apparatus. The shift is driven by China's tight control over key supply chains, with near-monopolies in solar-grade silicon, lithium batteries and EV production, cementing its role as the backbone of the post-carbon economy. Analysts have long pointed out that unlike the EU or US, China's climate response is not shaped by market instruments or carbon pricing alone, but through centralised industrial planning, state-owned enterprise reform, and a long-term view of energy sovereignty. The model allows for planned overcapacity, such as building both coal and renewables, as part of a transition phase, rather than as a sign of policy indecision. Global stakes Meanwhile, the implications are geopolitical as much as ecological. With Trump once again pulling out, China is stepping up as a leading force on climate action. On July 24, 2025, China and the European Union issued a joint statement, pledging to enhance and achieve their climate targets. Without naming the US directly, they referred to "the fluid and turbulent international situation today," stating that "major economies — must step up efforts to address climate change". Moreover, through its Belt and Road Initiative, China has expanded its renewable energy outreach, funding solar projects in Egypt and wind power development in Ethiopia. Despite remaining the world's largest coal consumer, China has made major strides in clean energy investment at home, particularly in solar, wind and electrification. In 2024, nearly half of all new renewable energy capacity added globally came from China. Meanwhile, it is expected that there may be more to come. President Xi Jinping previously pledged to begin emissions reductions before 2030 and achieve net zero by 2060. Some analysts now believe he may announce a new emissions target for 2035 at the upcoming UN General Assembly. The writer is a Lahore-based senior journalist
