How losing party posts led to Cabinet exits before — and what's different this time with PKR's Rafizi and Nik Nazmi
Their abrupt resignation comes after both Rafizi and Nik Nazmi failed to defend their PKR deputy presidency and vice-presidency respectively in the party's recent elections.
However, have there been other instances where Cabinet members have resigned or been replaced following changes in their respective party leadership?
The short answer is yes. This was hardly the first time, and here is a list of what happened following their losses:
Datuk Seri Ong Tee Keat (right) lost his MCA presidency to Datuk Seri Dr Chua Soi Lek (left) in 2010. — Picture by Saw Siow Feng
1. Ong Tee Keat dropped after losing MCA presidency
In October 2008, then MCA president Tan Sri Ong Tee Keat was elected to his post while Tan Sri Dr Chua Soi Lek was elected deputy president following party polls.
However, their appointments set forth a tumultuous partnership as both men could not see eye to eye and would eventually lead to a leadership crisis which took nearly 18 months to resolve, culminating in a re-election in early March 2010.
In the 2010 party polls, Dr Chua emerged victorious and Ong failed to defend his presidency.
Ong, who was transport minister at the time, was subsequently dropped from Datuk Seri Najib Razak's federal Cabinet in a reshuffle which took place in June the same year.
Unlike Rafizi and Nik Nazmi, Ong did not immediately tender his resignation as a Cabinet member after his defeat.
He was replaced by Tan Sri Kong Cho Ha — the MCA secretary-general then.
Datuk Seri Dr S.Subramaniam (left) and Datuk Seri G.Palanivel (sitting) sharing a light moment in 2013 before their rift in 2015. — Picture by Choo Choy May
2. G. Palanivel losing post following ouster from MIC presidency
In June 2015, MIC was plunged into a leadership struggle, with then party president Datuk Seri G Palanivel and his then deputy Tan Sri Dr S Subramaniam that saw both leaders claiming to be president.
The struggle stemmed from Palanivel disputing the Registrar of Societies order for MIC to conduct re-elections for the party.
The leadership crisis would culminate in Palanivel being ousted by Dr Subramaniam after the party's central working committee (CWC) ruled the former's party membership has been revoked for taking the party to court without a resolution from the CWC.
Palanivel, who was natural resources and environment minister, was subsequently dropped from Datuk Seri Najib Razak's federal Cabinet in a reshuffle which took place in July the same year.
Palanivel did not immediately tender his resignation as a Cabinet member after losing his party membership and presidency.
He was replaced by Tun Wan Junaidi Tuanku Jaafar from Parti Pesaka Bumiputera Bersatu.
PKR president Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim (centre), flanked by former deputy president Datuk Seri Rafizi Ramli (sitting left) and former vice-president Nik Nazmi Nik Ahmad (right). — Picture by Shafwan Zaidon
What's next for Rafizi and Nik Nazmi — but also Anwar?
The obvious difference with the abovementioned cases was that Rafizi and Nik Nazmi both had resigned.
With the PKR party polls now concluded and vacancies in the Cabinet to be filled, a Cabinet reshuffle is the most likely outcome.
A day before party polls, Anwar reassured the public that his party's poll was an internal process and had nothing to do with the issue of reshuffling the Cabinet.
He said he was powerless to stop other people's ambitions should they wish to resign but affirmed that he has no plans of making changes to his Cabinet line-up just yet.
The Prime Minister's Office (PMO) later confirmed it has received letters from both Rafizi and Nik Nazmi requesting leave and resignations from their Cabinet posts.
The PMO said Anwar has approved the leave requests from both ministers following a review of their submissions but any further developments regarding the matter of their resignation will be communicated in due course.
Anwar also said that there will be no Cabinet reshuffle with the duo are on gardening leave.
Meanwhile, Umno president and Barisan Nasional (BN) chairman Datuk Seri Ahmad Zahid Hamidi said Umno is willing to accept the vacated Cabinet posts but won't demand them as they 'know the limits to their requests'.
Zahid also called the duo's decision 'principled', while praising their contributions to the government.
BN is a coalition partner to Anwar's Pakatan Harapan. Its component party Umno, who holds the most seats in BN at 26 out of 30, currently has seven ministers in its line up.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Washington Post
an hour ago
- Washington Post
China-linked scam centers target U.S., congressional commission warns
A bipartisan commission that advises Congress on China warned Friday that 'fragmented and under-resourced' U.S. efforts to counter a multibillion-dollar scam industry, backed by Chinese criminal organizations, could see it increasingly aimed at Americans and escalate rapidly with new technologies. The U.S.-China Economic and Security Review Commission (USCC) said in a report released Friday that U.S. losses from China-linked fraud probably far exceeded $5 billion in 2024 — up 40 percent from the previous year — with Americans emerging as the top targets for Chinese criminal organizations since the covid pandemic. The scams — often linked to transnational crime syndicates involved in drug and money laundering operations — target Americans through text messages, social media, dating apps and jobsites. Beijing, meanwhile is using its own crackdown on the scam centers to expand its law enforcement presence in Southeast Asia, which could bolster China's leverage over regional governments and facilitate intelligence operations, the report said. 'These things are industrial-scale fraud factories that are using some of the most modern technology available, and their use of that technology is allowing them to scale these things very quickly. … I don't even think American law enforcement has figured out how to get their heads around this yet,' said Mike Kuiken, a USCC commissioner. The commission raised concerns that Chinese criminal organizations are giving Beijing unfettered access to U.S. personal data. It pointed to recent wide-scale raids by Chinese authorities on scam centers carried out in countries including Laos and Myanmar, where they seized computers and phones that, according to the report, probably grant Beijing access to data harvested on American targets. 'They're collecting computers, communication devices and they're collecting a lot of data on Americans, which should concern us as well,' said Randall Schriver, vice chair of the commission and the former assistant secretary of defense for Indo-Pacific Security Affairs under the first Trump administration. The report also highlighted cases where scam operators and criminal syndicates have built 'mutually beneficial' relationships with the Chinese government and its Belt and Road infrastructure program, creating special economic zones where scam centers targeting Americans have flourished. It pointed to the ongoing expansion of a criminal network led by U.S.-designated triad boss Wan Kuok Koi, which a Washington Post investigation last month showed has ties to the Chinese Communist Party and is under investigation by Southeast Asian authorities for operating scam centers. The Chinese embassy in Washington did not comment on specifics raised in Friday's report. 'The Chinese government stands firm in combating crimes of telecom and online fraud, fighting cross-border illegal and criminal activities and protecting the lawful rights and interests of Chinese citizens,' said Chinese embassy spokesman Liu Pengyu. The USCC report comes amid a sweeping State Department reorganization — one that began last week and has seen about 1,300 employees dismissed, including key personnel overseeing coordination of counter-scam operations in Southeast Asia. Gone as part of the shake-up is the Office of Multilateral Affairs within the East Asian and Pacific Bureau, which coordinated with countries on U.S. policy countering scam centers targeting Americans, according to two former department officials who spoke on the condition of anonymity to avoid reprisals. The State Department has said that 'mission-critical functions and personnel' will be reintegrated within the department. Commissioners behind Friday's report said they hoped those scam-fighting staff would remain in place. 'If the State Department is about making America safer, more secure, more prosperous, this needs to be on the agenda,' said Schriver. The Trump administration has gutted the U.S. Institute of Peace, which laid off nearly all of its U.S.-based staff in March. The organization had played a key role in monitoring the scale of the threat posed by Chinese-backed criminal networks operating scam centers across Southeast Asia. In its recommendations to Congress, the USCC report said that cementing cooperation with Southeast Asian allies is critical to avoid 'further entrenching Beijing's presence and influence' in the region. 'There's a law enforcement piece and there is a diplomacy piece,' said Kuiken, who said scam centers should rank higher on the U.S. agenda in future engagements with Beijing, alongside ongoing efforts to crack down on the global fentanyl trade. 'It is a complex challenge involving multiple elements of our government, but it's a very serious problem,' he said. Research by USIP found that Chinese criminal organizations are expanding their global reach, using international money laundering networks — including operations inside the United States — to facilitate large-scale scams and mass human trafficking. These networks are used to staff scam centers, which have proliferated into the hundreds, particularly in a lawless region known as the Golden Triangle, where China's border meets Myanmar and Laos near Thailand. Key U.S. allies like Thailand are facing growing pressure from Beijing to grant senior Chinese police officials access to the scam compounds, according to the USIP report. 'The Chinese government has worked closely with mainland Southeast Asian governments to combat transnational criminal activities in those areas, arguably providing a pretext for China to gradually assert more political influence over the region,' it said. In a large-scale operation earlier this year, Thai authorities — acting at Beijing's urging — cut electricity to scam centers along the Myanmar border after a Chinese actor was kidnapped and held for several days in one such scam center. The USCC warned Congress that the crackdowns target groups scamming Chinese citizens, an action the USCC says is incentivizing them to shift focus to Americans. 'If the United States does not strengthen its relationships with Southeast Asian countries and help them build the capacity to tackle scam centers, these countries will likely grow more reliant on China to address transnational crime, further entrenching Beijing's presence,' said the report. The commission said that Beijing has little incentive to crack down on operations targeting U.S. users, noting that criminal networks have pivoted toward Americans. The scams not only drain financial resources but have also had more tragic consequences, including reported suicides tied to victims' losses, the report said. These scam operations, historically run by Chinese criminal organizations, initially targeted Chinese nationals through so-called 'pig butchering' schemes — a term describing romance scams in which fraudsters build trust over social media or messaging apps before persuading victims to send money. Buoyed by new tools including artificial intelligence and social media, as well as better connectivity in regions where they operate, scam operators have sought more Western victims. That pivot has also fueled a growing network of money laundering on U.S. soil. Federal indictments show how hundreds of millions of dollars swindled from Americans have been funneled through sophisticated webs of bank accounts, shell companies and cryptocurrency exchanges — ultimately routing stolen funds back to criminal syndicates in Asia. In February 2025, federal prosecutors in California charged two Chinese nationals and a U.S. accomplice with laundering more than $13 million in proceeds from pig-butchering scams through U.S.-based shell companies. Last month, the Justice Department announced a record $225 million cryptocurrency seizure tied to a sophisticated money-laundering scheme that lured U.S. victims into sending funds through fraudulent investment platforms. 'The Chinese are also clearly extending their money laundering operations into the United States, so this digital money laundering is being assisted by Chinese criminal elements within our borders,' said Shriver. Hannah Natanson contributed to this report.
Yahoo
4 hours ago
- Yahoo
Trump's tariffs threaten to take the fizz out of Champagne's crucial US market
VERZENAY(Reuters) -Champagne producers in northeastern France need to find new markets after U.S. President Donald Trump threatened 30% tariffs on EU exports, the chairman of a French industry group said, suggesting Brazil, Southeast Asia and South Africa as options. The U.S. is the biggest market for champagne with 10% of champagne exports by volume and 15% by value and producers say the tariffs will push up prices for consumers and threaten jobs all along the supply chain, including in the United States. "The repercussions for all family champagne exports will be severe because it will mean lost income from bottle sales, which will also affect the grape harvest quotas we will be allowed to collect," said Stephane Vignon, whose family has been producing Champagne in Verzenay since 1946. With 70% of champagne sales currently concentrated in just five countries, tariffs should push producers to seek new markets, said Maxime Toubart, chairman of industry group Comite Champagne (Champagne Committee). He said France's cognac industry, which is mainly reliant on exports to China and the U.S. where it could also face duties, provides a cautionary tale for champagne producers on the need to diversify. But replacing U.S. sales is not easy, he said. "We can't just say we'll sell three million fewer bottles in the U.S. and put them in Japan instead. So actually, there is no alternative today to this fall in volume," he said. Total champagne exports fell more than 10% last year but rose slightly in the first four months of 2025 ahead of a 10% tariff in April, farm office FranceAgriMer said. "If tomorrow the 30% tariff is implemented, I think it will definitely impact the relationship," said Hugo Drappier of the Drappier Champagne house. "We've always managed to build a relationship of trust with our clients through the quality of our wines ... Let's hope that relationship isn't broken." (Writing and additional reporting by Sybille de La Hamaide and Michaela CabreraEditing by Gabriel Stargardter and Sharon Singleton) Sign in to access your portfolio
Yahoo
5 hours ago
- Yahoo
Trump's tariffs threaten to take the fizz out of Champagne's crucial US market
VERZENAY(Reuters) -Champagne producers in northeastern France need to find new markets after U.S. President Donald Trump threatened 30% tariffs on EU exports, the chairman of a French industry group said, suggesting Brazil, Southeast Asia and South Africa as options. The U.S. is the biggest market for champagne with 10% of champagne exports by volume and 15% by value and producers say the tariffs will push up prices for consumers and threaten jobs all along the supply chain, including in the United States. "The repercussions for all family champagne exports will be severe because it will mean lost income from bottle sales, which will also affect the grape harvest quotas we will be allowed to collect," said Stephane Vignon, whose family has been producing Champagne in Verzenay since 1946. With 70% of champagne sales currently concentrated in just five countries, tariffs should push producers to seek new markets, said Maxime Toubart, chairman of industry group Comite Champagne (Champagne Committee). He said France's cognac industry, which is mainly reliant on exports to China and the U.S. where it could also face duties, provides a cautionary tale for champagne producers on the need to diversify. But replacing U.S. sales is not easy, he said. "We can't just say we'll sell three million fewer bottles in the U.S. and put them in Japan instead. So actually, there is no alternative today to this fall in volume," he said. Total champagne exports fell more than 10% last year but rose slightly in the first four months of 2025 ahead of a 10% tariff in April, farm office FranceAgriMer said. "If tomorrow the 30% tariff is implemented, I think it will definitely impact the relationship," said Hugo Drappier of the Drappier Champagne house. "We've always managed to build a relationship of trust with our clients through the quality of our wines ... Let's hope that relationship isn't broken." (Writing and additional reporting by Sybille de La Hamaide and Michaela CabreraEditing by Gabriel Stargardter and Sharon Singleton) Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data
