Premier powerless to axe misfiring KZN MECs
Image: Supplied
DESPITE calls for Premier Thamsanqa Ntuli to sack the under performing MECs for Health and Education in KwaZulu-Natal, his hands were said to be tied as any cabinet reshuffle would likely collapse the provincial power pact of the Government of Provincial Unity (GPU).
At the centre of the storm were Sipho Hlomuka, the MEC for Education, and Nomagugu Simelane-Mngadi, the MEC for Health, both senior ANC figures in KZN politics. Their departments account for the lion's share of the provincial budget, yet both have been rocked by controversy and dysfunction claims.
Hlomuka has been under fire from teacher unions amid the crisis besetting his department, including the delayed payment of Grade R teachers and non-payment of service providers. This has sparked widespread condemnation of the Education MEC.
UMphathiswa wezeMpilo KwaZulu-Natal uNksz Nomagugu Simelane, umnyango wakhe okweleta osomabhizinisi uR1.7 billion
Image: SIGCINIWE
Simelane-Mngadi who is at the helm of the ailing health department, has also been on receiving end of criticism from disgruntled service providers who were not paid. She revealed last week that her department owed them R1.7 billion.
Hlomuka was the deputy provincial secretary while Simelane-Mngadi was deputy provincial chairperson for thw ANC in KZN, before the provincial structure was reconfigured in February following poor showing during the last year's national elections.
MEC for Education in KwaZulu-Natal Sipho Hlomuka.
Image: Tumi Pakkies Independent Newspapers
Ntuli, in his capacity as premier, has the powers to appoint and remove members of the provincial executive council.
He is also the IFP provincial chairperson, and assembled his cabinet in June last year, following his election as premier of the province.
Despite the pressure, insiders said Ntuli cannot act unilaterally.
The GPU, an alliance between the Inkatha Freedom Party (IFP), African National Congress (ANC), Democratic Alliance (DA), and the National Freedom Party (NFP), was formed to govern the province after no party secured an outright majority in the last election. Any reshuffle would require consensus from all coalition partners.
This was part of the power-sharing deal agreed to by the said parties.
National Education, Health and Allied Workers' Union's (Nehawu) provincial secretary Ayanda Zulu said: "We are not happy with a lot of things that are happening in the department of health as Nehawu. We had a meeting with the MEC and raised the matters that concern us as the union."
Zulu said some of their concerns included the plight of workers amid the ongoing crisis in the department of health.
"Our biggest concern is the workers and people of the province who continue to receive bad service from the department of health," said Zulu.
A source in the provincial government said Ntuli's hands were tied and argued that any reshuffle without the agreement with GPU partners would" backfire spectacularly".
"The reality is that the premier is not happy with the performance of some of his MECs. But if he just replaced them. That would backfire spectacularly for him and this could even collapse the provincial government," said the source.
The provincial secretary for the South African Democratic Teachers Union (SADTU) said:" The problems in the education department in KZN are as a result of austerity measures (budget cuts ) and the cost cutting measures imposed by the Provincial Treasury and the Office of the Premier."
A Grade R teacher in KZN, who spoke on condition of anonymity, said:" The MEC is clearly failing. I think it's time the province gets a new MEC, maybe they will deliver. But again, the turnaround of the provincial department will not be an overnight thing because of the many crises the department is facing," said the teacher.
Another teachers' union, the National Teachers Union (NATU) have also previously called for accountability, and demanded Premier Ntuli to wield the axe over Hlomuka.
Attempts by Daily News to obtain responses from the offices of Premier Ntuli, MEC Hlomuka, and MEC Simelane-Mngadi were unsuccessful, as their spokespersons failed to respond to inquiries.
DAILY NEWS
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
eNCA
8 hours ago
- eNCA
'Resilient, strategic and clever' - politicians describe late David Mabuza
JOHANNESBURG - Very resilient. That's how ANC spokesperson Mahlengi Bhengu-Motsiri, describes former deputy president David Mabuza, who has died in a Mpumalanga hospital aged 64. Minister in the Presidency Khumbuzo Ntshaveni has also paid tribute Mabuza. Ntshaveni described the late ANC leader as a warm, supportive and down-to-earth leader. Mabuza played a key role, during a turning point in ANC internal politics, particularly at the 2017 Nasrec conference. It was a critical time the party and South Africa, as the country tried to move away, from the damage of state capture. International Relations Minister Ronald Lamola also remembered Mabuza as a special educator. Opposition parties are joining the ANC, in paying tribute to the 64-year-old. ANC NEC member Dr Zweli Mkhize has praised the late deputy president, as a humble, respectful servant of the people. He says Mabuza always took time to resolve problems of those around him. The former deputy president has died in hospital aged 64. Members of Parliament are reflecting on his role. One of his crucial responsibilities was in bridging the gap, between the legislature and the executive. National Assembly speaker, Thoko Didiza says he executed his role in parliament very well.
Daily Maverick
10 hours ago
- Daily Maverick
How South Africa fell into the dull political loop of becoming boring
The death of meaningful political advancement means that South Africa has become stuck in a rut of its own carving. Is there a way forward? Remember when South Africa used to be fun? Remember when the memes slammed into each other like neutrons and electrons, causing small explosions every 15 seconds or so? Remember when there was a fancy term for corruption? Remember when optimism and pessimism cycled around each other in an endless loop, and didn't always land on 'this sucks'? Yeah, me neither. South Africa has become boring. I'm not talking about a lack of political spectacle — there is still Floyd Shivambu scurrying around the kleptocratic wilds looking for a political party to hide behind, and the general idiocy at MK, which is eating itself, like faecal parasites. There is still President Cyril Ramaphosa trying to assert himself on the local stage while playing a pliant mouse in the White House. There's still the alleged drama within the alleged GNU, really just a coalition government and horse-trading forum where the Ramaphosa wing of the ANC and the house-trained wing of the DA bargain on behalf of their backers. Nor am I using 'boring' as a simile for 'blandly functional' — a sort of Scandinavian or Botswana-ish plodding along that results in something akin to stability. What I mean is boring in the true sense of the term — an endless drilling down into the depths of utter nothingness. Is anything happening in South Africa that could be meaningfully termed progress? If you're a capitalist, is the economy growing? If you're a socialist, is the economy becoming fairer? If you're a communist, is anyone at all being sent to the gulag? I'd wager no. Apologists for the coalition government point out several areas where something seems to be moving. The Hawks, South Africa's crack cops, appear to have pulled the proverbial thumb out, and have made some big arrests. The National Prosecuting Authority sort of/kind of won a case. The Transnet baddies have finally been arrested, even though most South Africans (outside of Cape Town) have forgotten what a train looks like. But even with these dogged, incremental improvements, crime and corruption are so embedded in the South African political, economic, social and cultural space that it hardly touches sides. Always accomplished sports-washers, South Africans can point to the excellent performance of our major teams in international competitions, but it's worth remembering that tiny East Germany cleaned up at the Olympic Games during the Cold War, and no one in West Germany was risking their life to hop the wall into the German Democratic Republic (GDR). Culturally, the music and movie booms teased during the 90s and noughties have stalled out. There is no meaningful support of artists in this country, which means talent gets strangled at birth. The Sports and Culture minister can't do sport and wouldn't know culture if JM Coetzee's entire bibliography was tattooed on his butt cheeks. The DTIC under Parks Tau has become exclusively focused on ensuring that American preferential trade deals remain in place, despite the fact that America thinks it's being screwed by Lesotho. The department no longer assesses applications for film industry tax rebates, a standard industry stimulus that pertains in any market that hopes to draw filmmaking talent. Tau has single-handedly killed the industry, through sheer ignorance and lassitude. (There are also those sweet sweet Lotto tenders, which may or may not have cost deputy minister Andrew Whitfield his gig.) Sure, there are individual politicians who are truly gifted—I'm thinking Geordin Hill-Lewis in Cape Town, and perhaps a handful of other players here and there. But Helen 'Supreme Karen' Zille has auditioned for the role of Johannesburg Executive Mayor, a role that has not been blessed with talent of late. Zille, a vet of State Capture and Ramaphosa's first-term Race Grift Wars, feels like an absurd anachronism at this point. And the only people keeping Julius Malema alive are her allied American race warriors, who don't seem to understand — because they don't understand anything — that Malema has no constituency, and no power base. So what's next? Zuma for president? Sort of. Deputy President Paul Mashitile, at this point a shoe-in for the ANC's next leader, did state capture before there was State Capture. As a ranking member of the Gauteng ANC mafia, he is adept at taking a piece of the action, and will only entrench and deepen South Africa's kleptocratic tendencies. It's all so boring. So where is the pushback? Part of the problem is that most people seem to be waiting for the coalition to click, and have deferred the responsibilities of citizenship to their proxies inside government. (See: the VAT fight.) But the coalition won't click, as should be perfectly plain now. As this suggests, the bigger problem is an existential exhaustion. First, there was the fight against apartheid. Then, there was the fight against State Capture. Now, there is the fight against reverse anti-white apartheid. (I'm kidding, I'm kidding.) The population of this country has been stirred up into a big mound of lukewarm mieliemeal — cheap carbs, hold the gravy. So much of it comes down to the fact that the dispensation just hasn't served the majority, not even close. I'm going to quote Peter Thiel here. Yup, Peter 'I Pull The Heads Off Babies' Thiel: 'When one has too much student debt or if housing is too unaffordable, then one will have negative capital for a long time … and if one has no stake in the capitalist system, then one may well turn against it.' No shit, homie. Most South Africans have tacitly turned against the system. The MK party's surge at the polls was a protest vote that functioned as a large raised middle finger at the establishment. And so downward we bore, deeper into the Earth's core than our defunct gold mines. It is perhaps ironic that South Africa's most interesting politician just won the Democratic primary for mayor in New York City. I know, calling Zohran Mamdani South African is a stretch, but he was educated here, and one imagines part of his world-view was formed here. Maybe that's why he can so clearly see through the guff, and understand that a politics of fairness, driven for and by the majority, is the only way forward. It's telling that both Republicans and Democrats are flipping out over the guy, as of course would any South African politician. Mamdani's platform leaves no room for grift, for the double-dealing and self-enrichment that has become the hallmark of postmodern politics. That's why we're boring, and why we'll keep digging our own deep graves. And why Mamdani presents a way forward that South Africans would do well to consider. DM
Daily Maverick
10 hours ago
- Daily Maverick
Nkabane defends R142bn education budget amid corruption allegations and opposition rejection
Minister of Higher Education and Training Nobuhle Nkabane says her budget is a step towards improving the post-school education and training sector. In a robust parliamentary debate, opposition parties, including the ANC's main Government of National Unity partner, the Democratic Alliance, were vocal in rejecting the Higher Education and Training budget on Thursday, 3 June 2025. Minister of Higher Education and Training Dr Nobuhle Nkabane's budget proposals for 2025/26 came under fire over a lack of trust in her and her department. This was mainly due to controversial appointments in the Sector Education and Training Authorities (Setas) and issues with the National Student Financial Aid Scheme, NSFAS. Nkabane has been under fire over her controversial Seta board appointments, along with a panel she established that raised concerns after Nkabane called it 'independent', while it consisted of people who worked in her department. She also named advocate Terry Motau as chairperson of the panel, which Motau slammed as false, leading to Nkabane issuing an apology. Budget tabled Nkabane said she had dedicated the budget to those within education who had recently been killed, such as Sisonke Mbalekwa and Sinethemba Mpambane, both from Walter Sisulu University (WSU). The budget allocation for the current financial year is R142.4-billion, of which Technical and Vocational Education and Training (TVET) colleges are to receive R14-billion. The combined allocation for the Setas and the National Skills Fund is R26-billion. NSFAS funding rises to R48.7-billion this year. Universities will receive R96-billion this year, while Nkabane acknowledged a R1.4-billion deficit in the universities' budget as a result of US funding cuts. She said that the NSFAS budget would 'not [be] sufficient to meet the growing demand for access to higher education'. Nkabane said the budget was a step towards improving the efficiency and performance of the post-school education and training (PSET) system. She said NSFAS was in the process of cancelling the more than R2-million rental contract for its Cape Town office. In addition, 'NSFAS conducted a comprehensive legal review on the contracts of student accommodation intermediaries who are charging 5% fees. We are waiting for a final report for us to decide in this regard. This is our commitment to clean governance, accountability and transparency, and to root out any potential corruption and maladministration in PSET,' said Nkabane. Chairperson of the parliamentary committee on higher education, Tebogo Letsie (ANC), supported Nkabane's budget. Letsie said the budget was a political commitment rooted in the Freedom Charter and shaped by the developmental vision of the National Development Plan. Those who did not support the budget 'will be saying to you that your poor child must not go to school, must not go to university because they are not programming their future… They must be saying that all the owners of properties must lose their properties. They will be saying all workers in our universities, our colleges and everywhere else must go home because those universities and student colleges must close down.' Rejection The Democratic Alliance rejected the budget. The party's Karabo Khakhau said 'the ANC wants the people of this republic to believe that a fight against corruption is a fight against the future of this country… The real enemy of progress against young people here is Minister Nkabane. It is the ANC that is protecting her and corruption. It is President Ramaphosa for refusing to fire her… I dare you: do the right thing in honour of these people (Mbalekwa and Mpambane) — resign.' Sihle Lonzi (EFF) also rejected Nkabane's budget, but said that the DA and the ANC were in a 'fake fight'. According to Lonzi, the DA's narrative was a deliberate distortion at best or sheer ignorance at worst. 'The state of student accommodation in South Africa is not only inhumane; it's gross negligence… Why can you not develop an efficient payment system that will pay students, institutions, and accommodations directly… You must blacklist corrupt board members, Minister. You must blacklist corrupt CEOs,' demanded Lonzi. Sihle Ngubane (MK party) rejected the budget and called out the minister for saying it was dedicated to those who had died, because 'the department, under the minister, and its negligence, caused the death of this student (Mbolekwa),' said Ngubane. 'When you (Nkabane) say drive inclusive growth and job creation, there is no inclusive growth in this government, there is no economy, and there is nothing,' said Ngubane. Other parties such as Al Jama-ah, the Inkatha Freedom Party, the Patriotic Alliance, Build One South Africa and Rise Mzansi supported the budget. When Deputy Minister of Higher Education and Training and DA member, Mimmy Gondwe, took the stand, she was immediately asked by the EFF's Lonzi whether she supported the budget. Gondwe did not reply directly, but instead highlighted numerous interventions, oversight visits, partnerships, and student-centred initiatives undertaken under her leadership since July 2024. She emphasised that the budget had to reflect a determination to build an ethical and inclusive education system. DM
