India keen to strike trade deal with US, but wary about crossing red lines on agriculture, dairy
Around 60 per cent of India's 1.4 billion people are engaged directly or indirectly in agriculture.
– In the central Indian state of Madhya Pradesh, soya bean farmer Harnam Singh Lodhi lamented that he has enough difficulties without having to worry about competition from American farmers.
'This year, non-stop rains after sowing have hurt the crop,' said Mr Lodhi, who fears 70 per cent of his soya bean crop was washed out and ruined.
'I am also worried about getting good rates when the crop is harvested in October,' added the farmer, who has an 8.1ha farm in the biggest soya bean producing state in India, on which he also cultivates wheat.
'So how can I, on top of all that, compete with American soya bean farmers?'
Soy farmers like Mr Lodhi are contending with a market glut due to a good November harvest, which has pushed average prices down by about 10 per cent since 2024 to around 4,000 rupees (S$59.60) for 100kg.
Prices could fall further if the United States gets its way.
Soy – along with dairy, wheat, rice and apples – is among the American produce Washington wants India to ease import restrictions on. The US is the world's second-largest producer of soya beans, while India is ranked the fifth.
Top stories
Swipe. Select. Stay informed.
Singapore 2 workers stranded on gondola dangling outside Raffles City Tower rescued by SCDF
Asia Japan PM Ishiba apologises to his party for election loss, vows to stay in office to deal with US tariff talks
Business $1.1 billion allocated to three fund managers to boost Singapore stock market: MAS
Singapore Proof & Company Spirits closes Singapore distribution business
Life Travel Journal: Safari tourism with a side of moral crisis
Singapore Mandai Wildlife Group group CEO Mike Barclay to retire; Bennett Neo named as successor
Singapore Jail, caning for man who held metal rod to cashier's neck in failed robbery attempt
Singapore Fresh charge for woman who harassed nurse during pandemic, created ruckus at lion dance competition
The South Asian country is looking to reduce a
26 per cent 'reciprocal' tariff imposed by the Trump administration.
But resistance from Indian farmers to the US push for greater market access in agriculture and dairy has been a major sticking point in the government's tariff negotiations.
India's Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman said in a July 1 interview with The Financial Express that these sectors 'have been among the very big red lines, where a high degree of caution has been exercised'.
Around 60 per cent of India's 1.4 billion people are engaged directly or indirectly in agriculture, a sector that accounts for about 18 per cent of the annual economic output of the world's fourth-largest economy by nominal GDP.
Collectively, farmers wield enormous political clout.
Pressure from farmer groups was one key reason behind India's 2019 decision not to join the Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership, a free trade agreement involving 15 Asia-Pacific countries.
In 2021, following 11 months of
massive farmer protests, the government was forced to repeal three farm laws which farmers believed to favour large companies.
More on this topic India proposes retaliatory duties at WTO against US tariffs on vehicles
Pushback to pressure
Currently, US agricultural exports to India include nuts such as almonds and pistachios, pulses such as chick peas, and some fresh fruit.
US President Donald Trump has said that 'India basically is working along that same line' of the deal struck with Indonesia, which has agreed to buy US$4.5 billion in US produce, among other measures, in exchange for a tariff rate of 19 per cent, down from the original 32 per cent.
Agriculture accounts for about 18 per cent of the annual economic output of the world's fourth-largest economy by nominal GDP.
PHOTO: AFP
Indian Commerce and Industry Minister Piyush Goyal said on July 15 that the two countries are moving quickly to reach a 'win-win' agreement.
But farmers' associations in India are against any tariff reduction deal giving American agricultural products unfettered access to the Indian market.
They are also against the entry of genetically modified crops, such as corn from the US, which is among the key sticking points in the negotiations. India allows cultivation of genetically modified cotton but does not allow cultivation of any other genetically modified crops domestically.
The Indian Coordination Committee of Farmers Movements (ICCFM), a network of farmers' organisations, has urged the government 'to protect the interests of Indian farmers, ensuring our food sovereignty and security' in the India-US trade deal.
The Bharatiya Kisan Sangh (BKS) – a farmers' organisation affiliated with the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh, the ideological parent of the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party – has made a similar call.
'We are not on a level playing field when it comes to American farmers. The landholding is smaller in India. How will we compete?' asked Mr Mohini Mohan Mishra, BKS All-India general secretary.
'It will be better to keep discussions on agriculture and dairy out of this deal,' he added.
Small Indian farms cannot match the scale and efficiency of US farms, which average 188.5ha and often benefit from large-scale operations, advanced mechanisation, subsidies and better infrastructure.
In comparison, India's farms are small, fragmented and hardly mechanised. Some 86 per cent of farmers operate from less than 2ha of land.
The agriculture sector also struggles with low productivity, rising costs of items like fertilisers and seeds, poor irrigation infrastructure and an over-dependence on rain for water.
While the government supports farmers with guarantees that it will buy certain agricultural products at pre-determined rates, farmers continue to struggle to make ends meet.
A single crop failure or a drop in prices for produce could send Indian farmers, who are typically already weighed down by loans, spiralling into financial crisis.
Cereals such as rice, wheat, maize and millet account for more than half of India's total agricultural production and two-thirds of agricultural crop area.
Indian farmers fear that an influx of these cheaper produce from the US will further erode their earnings amid already difficult circumstances.
'There is no way, because of food security and livelihood issues, that we can expose our farmers to face competition from large agri businesses,' said Dr Biswajit Dhar, a trade expert at the Council for Social Development, a think-tank focusing on justice and equality in development.
Dairy sensitivities
India is the world's largest producer of milk, but it only has a 0.25 per cent share of global dairy trade due to high domestic consumption.
This makes India an attractive market for US dairy.
But if US milk were allowed into India, prices are likely to fall by about 15 per cent – spelling a potential annual loss of 103 billion rupees to dairy farmers, a State Bank of India report forecasts.
There is also cultural and religious resistance to importing US dairy, due to the American practice of feeding cattle with animal by-products.
Recent trade agreements that India inked with Australia and the United Kingdom could offer some ideas on resolving the impasse with the US.
The India-Australia Economic Cooperation and Trade Agreement signed in 2022 exempted duties on Australian barley, oats and lobsters – but dairy and chickpeas were excluded.
In the free-trade agreement with UK, India refused tariff reductions on UK dairy, apples, poultry and sugar to protect farmers.
'What could be done is that India could increase market access for the US in some areas like nuts and processed foods,' Dr Dhar said.
'The government will be worried about facing farmers' wrath. I don't think the government will test them.'
BKS' Mr Mishra warned that if the government goes ahead with agriculture and dairy in the deal, 'we will also decide how to go ahead'.
'The government will have to think – there are so many elections coming one after the other,' he said, referring to state-level elections.
He added: 'If they don't work for the welfare of farmers, farmers will also not cooperate.'
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles

Straits Times
27 minutes ago
- Straits Times
Singapore, Vietnam agree to step up defence ties, dialogue among leaders
Find out what's new on ST website and app. Vietnam's Minister of National Defence, General Phan Van Giang (on the red carpet, left), welcomes Defence Minister Chan Chun Sing in Hanoi on July 22. SINGAPORE - Singapore and Vietnam will strengthen their defence relationship and seek more regular dialogue between their leaders, Defence Minister Chan Chun Sing said on July 22. This is as both countries aim to achieve concrete outcomes from the upgrade of bilateral ties to a Comprehensive Strategic Partnership (CSP) earlier in 2025, Mr Chan said at the conclusion of a visit to Hanoi. During his visit, Mr Chan had called on Vietnam's Prime Minister Pham Minh Chinh. The two leaders reaffirmed the warm and friendly bilateral relationship between Singapore and Vietnam, and discussed various initiatives under the CSP, said Mindef in a statement. Mr Chan, who is also Coordinating Minister for Public Services, said he and Mr Pham discussed several areas of potential cooperation, such as in renewable energy, data and finance, and leadership development. At the strategic level, more dialogue between leaders of both sides is important, given the turbulent global economic and security situation, he added. 'We talked about setting up more regular dialogues between the public services of both sides, and how we can use such occasions to talk about the emerging challenges that both of us face,' he said. In March 2025, Prime Minister Lawrence Wong and Communist Party of Vietnam General Secretary To Lam announced that Singapore and Vietnam had elevated bilateral ties to a wide-ranging CSP, with both sides committing to deepen cooperation in areas such as security, sustainability and the digital economy. Top stories Swipe. Select. Stay informed. Singapore Singaporeans aged 21 to 59 can claim $600 SG60 vouchers from July 22 Singapore Singaporeans continue to hold world's most powerful passport in latest ranking Singapore Woman evacuated from lift in Supreme Court building after falling glass triggers emergency halt Asia Malaysian aide's unresolved 2009 death tests govt's reform pledge despite DAP chief's apology Singapore Prosecution says judge who acquitted duo of bribing ex-LTA official had copied defence arguments Singapore Singapore not affected by haze despite smoke plumes in Sumatra: NEA Singapore Miscalculation of MOH subsidies and grants led to $7m in overpayments, $2m in shortfalls Singapore Ports and planes: The 2 Singapore firms helping to keep the world moving The CSP with Vietnam is Singapore's first with an Asean member state, reflecting both countries' shared commitment to expanding cooperation in areas of mutual benefit and which can create growth opportunities, said Mindef. Singapore's cooperation with Vietnam also supports regional initiatives like the Asean Digital Economy Framework Agreement and the Asean Power Grid, which will strengthen the economy and resilience of Singapore, Vietnam and Asean, the ministry added. On his trip, Mr Chan also met his counterpart, Minister of National Defence Phan Van Giang, and they exchanged views on geopolitical developments. Given that security challenges will increasingly be networked, Mr Chan said he and General Phan discussed ways for the two armed forces to work together to counter such threats. The two defence ministers also agreed to step up military-to-military interactions through high-level visits, bilateral dialogues, cross-attendance of courses, and professional exchanges. 'We will also continue to work together at the Asean Defence Ministers' Meeting (ADMM) and ADMM-Plus to uphold an open and inclusive regional security architecture,' said Mr Chan. Mr Chan was joined at the meetings by Minister of State for Defence Desmond Choo.

Straits Times
an hour ago
- Straits Times
Syrian committee reports 1,426 killed in March violence
Find out what's new on ST website and app. FILE PHOTO: Alawite Syrians, who fled the violence in western Syria, walk in Nahr El Kabir River, after the reported mass killings of Alawite minority members, in Akkar, Lebanon March 11, 2025. REUTERS/Mohamed Azakir/File Photo BEIRUT - A Syrian fact-finding committee said on Tuesday that 1,426 people, including 90 women, had been killed during the March 6-9 violence in the country's coastal regions that witnessed attacks on security forces followed by killings of Alawite Syrians. The incidents were the worst violence to hit Syria since the downfall of President Bashar al-Assad last year, and the fact-finding committee's work is seen as an important test of the new leadership, made up mainly of former anti-Assad rebel fighters. In a key finding, the committee concluded that Syrian commanders did not give orders to commit violations and in fact gave orders to halt them. The committee came up with a list of 298 suspects involved in violations against Alawites and 265 involved in the initial attack on security forces, committee head Jumaa Al-Anzi said. The names are not being released publicly for now and have been referred to courts for further investigations, while 31 people have been arrested, spokesperson Yasser Farhan said. The violence began on March 6 with attacks on Syrian security forces stationed in the region that put hospitals and other state institutions out of operation and caused wide areas to fall out of government control, Farhan said. The committee found that 238 members of the security forces were killed in these attacks, perpetrated by forces aligned with the former Assad government, Farhan said. Top stories Swipe. Select. Stay informed. Singapore Singaporeans aged 21 to 59 can claim $600 SG60 vouchers from July 22 Singapore Singaporeans continue to hold world's most powerful passport in latest ranking Singapore Woman evacuated from lift in Supreme Court building after falling glass triggers emergency halt Asia Malaysian aide's unresolved 2009 death tests govt's reform pledge despite DAP chief's apology Singapore Prosecution says judge who acquitted duo of bribing ex-LTA official had copied defence arguments Singapore Singapore not affected by haze despite smoke plumes in Sumatra: NEA Singapore Miscalculation of MOH subsidies and grants led to $7m in overpayments, $2m in shortfalls Singapore Ports and planes: The 2 Singapore firms helping to keep the world moving In response to the attacks, around 200,000 armed men mobilized from across Syria, pouring into the coastal region, he said. This led to violations including killings, theft and sectarian incitement that the committee found were "widespread but not organised," Farhan said. Farhan said the committee members had full cooperation from government forces as they undertook their months of work. REUTERS

Straits Times
an hour ago
- Straits Times
‘Extremely high' risk of serious abuses amid expanded Israel Gaza operation: UN
Find out what's new on ST website and app. UN rights chief Volker Turk said Israeli airstrikes and ground operations will invariably lead to further civilian deaths and destruction of civilian infrastructure. GENEVA - The United Nations warned on July 22 that Israel's expanded operations in central Gaza created an 'extremely high' risk of serious international law violations. It also cautioned that permanently displacing Gaza's population would be a war crime and possibly a crime against humanity. 'These Israeli airstrikes and ground operations will invariably lead to further civilian deaths and destruction of civilian infrastructure,' UN rights chief Volker Turk said in a statement. 'Given the concentration of civilians in the area, and the means and methods of warfare employed by Israel until now, the risks of unlawful killings and other serious violations of international humanitarian law are extremely high.' Deir el-Balah came under intense shelling on July 21, a day after Israel's military ordered residents to leave , warning of imminent action in an area where it had not previously operated. Between 50,000 and 80,000 people were in the area when the evacuation order was issued, according to initial estimates from the UN's humanitarian agency OCHA. 'The latest Israeli displacement orders, followed by intensive attacks on southwestern Deir el-Balah... have added more misery to the suffering of hungry Palestinians,' Mr Turk said. 'It seemed the nightmare couldn't possibly get worse. And yet it does.' The UN high commissioner for human rights highlighted that the area targeted by the latest attacks was 'also home to several humanitarian organisations, including clinics, other medical facilities, shelters, a community kitchen, guesthouses, warehouses and other critical infrastructure'. At the same time, he pointed out that 'homes have already been destroyed, and thousands have been forced to flee the area again'. 'Their only choice is to go to the ever-shrinking areas of Gaza where hundreds of thousands are being forced to gather, rendering difficult any attempt to deliver humanitarian assistance,' he said, stressing that 'even these areas are not safe'. 'I remind Israel that permanently displacing people living under its occupation would amount to unlawful transfer, which is a war crime, and in certain circumstances, may also amount to a crime against humanity.' Mr Turk stressed that 'Israel, as the occupying power, must ensure food, medical and other supplies are provided for the population'. 'And instead of launching round upon round of new military attacks, there must be an immediate end to the killings, destruction and the wide scale violations of international law,' he insisted. 'More and more countries are joining the calls to shake us out of this nightmare.' AFP