SCOTUS upholds Obamacare free preventive care coverage
The Supreme Court on Friday rejected a challenge to a section of the Affordable Care Act that designates a federal task force to recommend which preventive services insurers must cover at no cost to patients.
Why it matters: The 6-3 decision will ensure continued access to free cancer screenings, vaccines, HIV drugs and counseling for the roughly 150 million Americans with private health insurance.
The court said that the Health and Human Services secretary can still remove members of the task force.
Justice Brett Kavanaugh wrote the opinion, with Chief Justice John Roberts and Justices Sonia Sotomayor, Elena Kagan, Amy Coney Barrett and Ketanji Brown Jackson concurring.
"This is a critical win for prevention," Michael Ruppal, executive director of The AIDS Institute, said in a statement.
Context: The case stems from a 2020 lawsuit against the federal government filed by two Christian-owned companies.
They argued that the task force recommendation requiring them to cover free HIV prevention drugs in their employer-sponsored health plans was unconstitutional because task force members are not confirmed by the Senate.
The Trump administration defended the structure of the task force, echoing the Biden administration arguments that it's constitutionally sound because the health secretary can remove members at will and decide when insurers have to cover recommendations.
Justices agreed that task force members are accountable to the HHS secretary.
"In short, through the power to remove and replace Task Force members at will, the Secretary can exert significant control over the Task Force—including by blocking recommendations he does not agree with," Kavanaugh wrote in the opinion.
The other side: Justices Clarence Thomas, Samuel Alito and Neil Gorsuch — the court's most conservative members — maintained that the task force members were not appointed in accordance with the Constitution.
What to watch: The decision gives HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. the opportunity to make big changes to the preventive service task force's membership and the services it endorses.
He's already done something similar with the panel that advises CDC on immunization recommendations, removing all 17 of its members and replacing them with handpicked successors.
"The potential for politicization and the rejection of scientific consensus under this administration pose an ongoing threat to the very services this ruling just preserved," Elizabeth Taylor, executive director of the National Health Law Program, said in a statement.
Congress is also debating cuts to Medicaid, which could erode access to preventive care for millions of Americans.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
35 minutes ago
Brazil ex-leader Jair Bolsonaro rallies supporters in Sao Paulo to protest his Supreme Court trial
SAO PAULO -- Former Brazilian President Jair Bolsonaro on Sunday attended a public demonstration in Sao Paulo to protest against his ongoing Supreme Court trial in the South American country. A couple of thousand people gathered on Paulista Avenue, one of the city's main locations, in a demonstration that Bolsonaro, before the event, called 'an act for freedom, for justice.' Bolsonaro and 33 allies are facing trial over an alleged plot to overturn the 2022 presidential election results and remain in power. They were charged with five counts related to the plan. The former president has denied the allegations and claims that he's the target of political persecution. He could face up to 12 years in prison if convicted. 'Bolsonaro, come back!' protesters chanted, but the former president is barred from running for office until 2030. Brazil's Superior Electoral Court ruled last year that he abused his political power and made baseless claims about the country's electronic voting system.
Buzz Feed
3 hours ago
- Buzz Feed
20 'Healthy' Habits That Are Actually Harmful
If you've ever picked up a habit that you thought was healthy only to find out later that it wasn't doing you any favors, welcome to the club. Recently, people on Reddit shared some common behaviors that people think are healthy that can actually backfire, and I'm definitely guilty of a few of these. Here's what they had to say: "Overtraining without rest. Fitness obsession can backfire fast if you ignore recovery." —Appropriate_Rip_104"Found this out recently. Terrible headache, two days of depression, and weakness. My body just said, 'no more.'I'm on a better routine now, not as intense, and learning to rest without guilt."—budda_belly "Carnivore diets. You're telling me you've eliminated fruits and vegetables in favor of eating absurd amounts of fat and/or protein in the name of health? Stop and listen to how ridiculous that sounds. Anything taken to the extreme is bad, and carbs do not make you fat just because they're carbs. Keto isn't much better either." "The idea that because you don't have a diagnosis, you don't have a problem. I spent 23 years of my life with undiagnosed ASD/ADHD, which was unpleasant and led to some hellish self-doubt and low self-esteem. I had problems that made me feel awful, and I'd just rationalize it as everyone else had those problems, but then I realized that this wasn't the case, and that I was an oddball. Spent many nights sleepless, going, 'Why can't I be normal?'" "Consuming tons of protein! Studies show that Americans tend to overestimate protein needs. My protein needs as a grown adult, per evidence-based calculators, are about 46g of protein per day. I've been told time and time again on Reddit this isn't enough, and even been told it's not enough PER meal! Insane. Your body makes the proteins it needs as long as all of the necessary amino acids are present!" "I think a lot of American men are interested in growing the size of their muscles and hear about protein left and right, so their viewpoint of what protein needs look like may be skewed toward what's needed for bulking. And I believe this influences how many people think about protein needs online, even for people who aren't bulking whatsoever. 46g per day is easily achieved with three meals, including vegetarian meals."—Ok_Nothing_9733 "'Positive vibes only' attitude." "Detox teas/diets. People, you do not need to detox. Your body removes toxins through its normal processes, and unless something is very wrong, you don't have random toxins hanging out in your body and poisoning you. And a lot of these really expensive teas have questionable herbs or other ingredients in them that could harm you." "Working 80 hours a week because 'hustle culture' told you it's the path to success. Congrats, now you're rich and exhausted." —patilpradipj"The weird thing about this is, I'm now in C-suite management after working my way up from being an electrician, did the whole thing, big hours, night school for an MBA, I work less now than when I was a teenager! Get to a level you're happy with, then look for other things that make you happy. I put my body and mind through hell to climb the ladder, now I try to relax as much as I can!!"—Oncemor-intothebeach "Going vegan without proper preparation and understanding of nutrients, out here hella deficient in lots of stuff, and it's unhealthy!" "Independence. Obviously, a certain amount is healthy, but some people/cultures glorify hyper-independence, associating it with strength. Social support and connection are so important for healing, health, and quality of life." "Most diets. I think I did the cabbage soup diet for the first time at 12. I found it as an adult, and that is just... What?! What was I thinking?!?!" —Syndromia"Same! The magazines were saying Victoria Beckham was doing it, so I did it. I was just farting and hungry all the time."—AdRevolutionary6650 "Apple cider vinegar shots in the morning to boost metabolism. It's never been scientifically proven to burn fat or increase metabolism. You are also essentially rinsing your teeth in acid first thing in the morning." "One that always comes to mind is those 'healthy' fruit juices. Like, we think we're doing our bodies a favor by sipping on a juice, but a lot of store-bought ones are loaded with sugar. Even if it's 100% fruit juice, it can still spike your blood sugar and mess with your metabolism. Over time, it's actually not as healthy as we think!" "Pushing yourself through pain. It's one thing to push yourself in a workout a little more than last week to see results, but I've seen so many people brag about 'playing through an injury,' and all I can think is, 'Congrats? I guess?' No joke, I met a dude who claimed he finished a rugby game at school with a torn ACL and called me a pussy for getting surgery as soon as I could." —Sufficient-Ad-3586 "Obsessive diet limitation. You want to give up sugar for a short period of time or try a diet elimination to find out what's making you bloat go for it but chances are if you continue this on a hardcore bias and cut out things completely if it's not allergy related it's not sustainable and you are just going to binge later. Sugar is okay in moderation. Carbs are okay in moderation." "Comparing your real life to Instagram fitness models' highlight reels. Mental health matters more than visible abs." "Pretty much every unregulated dietary supplement out there. There are people who say that they don't trust Big Oil, Big Pharma, but take like 10 or more supplements, despite the fact that prescription drugs are much better regulated than any supplement." —WhaleSharkLove "Following whatever viral podcast seems like it has 'good' health information." "Talking about your feelings. Obviously, don't bottle stuff up to the point of some kind of implosive episode. But it's not healthy to 'vent' all the time or analyze every emotion you have. It shrinks your worldview down to 'how you feel about it' and removes your ability to think critically or objectively about things. It also breeds a sort of narcissistic state of being where everything is filtered through the lens of how YOU feel about it." "Sun exposure. Like, yes, of course, go outside and get fresh air and open your curtains, but over time, long-term sun exposure is what leads to signs of aging, but worse, of course, can lead to skin cancer and other skin issues. Wear sunscreen, stay in the shade as much as you can when you're outside, take care of yourself, etc, etc." "I felt so silly learning this as an adult. If excessive tanning makes people look like leathery reptiles and if the sun burns you, why would you only wear sunscreen only in the summer only on certain parts of your body? The sun's rays are always hitting you. Why else did people who didn't go out have such pale and even skin? Duh. It's so obvious to me now."—snickerssnacks And finally, "Honestly, too much of everything will make you sick, no matter if it's healthy or not." Is there anything else you would add? Tell us about it in the comments or via the anonymous form below:
Axios
3 hours ago
- Axios
Retiring GOP senator savages Medicaid cuts in Trump's "big, beautiful bill"
Fresh off announcing he'll retire next year, Sen. Thom Tillis gave a lengthy floor speech Sunday night attacking cuts to Medicaid in the " big, beautiful bill." Why it matters: The North Carolina Republican is accusing the GOP of breaking President Trump's campaign promises to protect Medicaid. Tillis voted Saturday against starting debate on the bill, and has declared he'll vote "no" on the final version. Zoom in: "I'm telling the president, you have been misinformed," Tillis said on Sunday night. "What do I tell 663,000 people in two years, three years, when President Trump breaks his promise by pushing them off of Medicaid because the funding's not there anymore," Tillis asked. He compared Trump's promise on Medicaid to former President Obama's "if you like your health care plan, you can keep it" quote on the Affordable Care Act. The Senate's version of the "big, beautiful bill" would result in 12 million more people without health insurance in 2034 than today, the Congressional Budget Office projects. Between the lines: The Senate is expected to vote on Monday on an amendment by Sen. Rick Scott (R-Fla.) that would lower the federal matching share (FMAP) for states that have expanded their Medicaid programs.
