Permits allowing guns, ATVs in backcountry are unfair as the public stays barred: Whiteshell cottager
As all backcountry trails and waterways remain in Manitoba's provincial parks remain closed to the public, some cottagers say it's unfair that outfitters are allowed to hunt in the backcountry with government-approved permits during a provincewide state of emergency.
Barb Robson, who lives in Winnipeg and has a cottage on the south shore of Big Whiteshell Lake in Whiteshell Provincial Park, told CBC News on Tuesday that her husband was not allowed to return to the cottage to collect their boat and family heirlooms that have been passed down for generations.
She said it's not fair that some outfitters can go in the backcountry while trails remain closed and some cottagers are still being kept out of the park.
"If you're going to give permits to outfitters, you should give permits to cottage owners and seasonal people who are just going in there, and out to retrieve their stuff," she said.
Environment Minister Mike Moyes, who oversees provincial parks, said backcountry permits are issued to outfitters on a case-by case basis, and can be rescinded if fire conditions change.
He said most of the human-caused fires currently burning across Manitoba were not intentionally set. He said he understands the frustration, but stressed that keeping the public out of certain areas helps to limit further spread and keep firefighting resources where they're needed most.
"We really sympathize with those folks. We recognize just how important some of those places are, as well as some of those belongings. But we have to make sure that safety comes first," Moyes said, asking for patience.
Robson questioned whether allowing outfitters to bring possible fire hazards like guns and all-terrain vehicles in the backcountry during the spring bear hunt is safe.
She said it doesn't make sense to approve these permits at the same time provincial officials are urging people to reconsider non-essential travel in Manitoba to free up hotel rooms for wildfire evacuees.
"They're telling people not to come to Manitoba and yet they're allowing them to go out and do their hunting. That's very frustrating. Where is the fairness in all of this?" she wondered.
"Just take the permits away and then you're not going to have an issue with anyone, including me. Because they can't go to the backcountry and I can't," Robson said.
Outfitters not operating in evacuated areas, association says
The Manitoba Lodges and Outfitters Association says its members who hold approved permits are not operating in areas that have a mandatory evacuation order in place.
Melanie MacCarthy, president of the association, said the permits issued by the provincial government come with safety restrictions, like ensuring ATV riders have fire extinguishers with them or limiting operations between 7 p.m. and 11 a.m.
MacCarthy said backcountry access is "critical" for outfitters during bear season.
"Bear hunting happens deep in the woods … Without that backcountry access, they essentially can't operate," she said.
"It's a short window for our operators to make a living and they're only doing so when it's deemed safe by conservation and given an approved permit to do so," MacCarthy said.
Robson said it's unfair for the province to approve any permits when members of the public have been barred from the backcountry.
"If you're not going to let us in — point blank, if there's no backcountry travel — take the permits away. Take them away," she said.
On Wednesday at 8 a.m., Robson will be able to return to her cottage on Big Whiteshell Lake, as that area of the provincial park reopens to permanent residents, cottagers and commercial operators, the province said in its Tuesday fire bulletin. Crowduck Lake will also reopen Wednesday morning.
At 4 p.m. on Wednesday, permanent residents, cottagers and commercial operators can head back to Florence Lake, Nora Lake and Ophir Siding.
On Friday, seasonal campers can return to campgrounds at Big Whiteshell Lake.
Backcountry travel rules frustrate some Manitobans
11 hours ago
Duration 1:54
Backcountry travel in Manitoba is only allowed right now with a permit, as a provincewide state of emergency because of wildfires continues. However, some Manitobans aren't happy with those rules.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CTV News
31 minutes ago
- CTV News
Flight cancelled or delayed? These are your rights
You've packed your bags, planned your itinerary and booked your taxi to the to find out that your flight has been cancelled. So, what do you do now? The Canadian Transportation Agency (CTA), an independent, quasi-judicial tribunal of the Government of Canada, points out that it is up to the airline to accommodate you as soon as possible. 'In all situations, the airline must provide you with a new reservation on another flight if your original flight has been delayed for three hours or more, or if it has been cancelled,' states the organization's website. The CTA's mandate is to ensure that passenger rights across all modes of transportation are respected and protected. The terms and conditions of the replacement flight, according to Noovo Info, can differ depending on the reason behind the cancellation, and whether or not they are due to a complication caused by the airline. Can I get compensation? You may be entitled to compensation if your flight is delayed or cancelled and the situation is within the airline's control, such as a commercial decision or an avoidable technical problem. Events outside the company's control, such as adverse weather conditions, do not count. In addition, you can only get compensation if you find out about the cancellation or delay less than 14 days before your scheduled departure and you arrive at your destination more than three hours later than expected. Here is the compensation scale, according to the CTA, for major airlines: $400 if you arrive at your destination with a delay between three and six hours; $700 if you arrive at your destination with a delay between six and nine hours; $1,000 if you arrive at your destination with a delay of nine hours or more. If you choose a refund instead of rerouting, you are still eligible to receive $400. Examples of large airlines include Air Canada (including Jazz and Rouge), Air Transat, Flair Airlines and Porter Airlines. For smaller airlines: $125 if you arrive at your destination with a delay between three and six hours; $250 if you arrive at your destination with a delay between six and nine hours; $500 if you arrive at your destination with a delay of nine hours or more. If you choose a refund instead of rerouting, you are still eligible to receive $125. The size of your airline is indicated in the conditions of your ticket. You have one year to submit a claim for compensation due to a delay or cancellation, and the airline has 30 days to respond, either by making a payment or explaining its reason for refusal. Beyond compensation In addition to compensation, the Flight Claim platform points out that people can also be entitled to short-term assistance. This includes requesting refreshments and sufficient food depending on the wait time, two free telephone calls, telexes, faxes or e-mails, and hotel accommodation for one or more nights. Flight Claim adds that it is possible to ask for reimbursement for part of a journey not made, no longer required, or other such modifications to the original travel itinerary. What if I used a travel agent? Customers who employed travel agents licensed in Quebec can 'benefit from one of the best protections available' via the Compensation fund for customers of travel agents. Regulated by the Office of Customer Protection, the fund can reimburse travellers who are disappointed with the services they paid for. There are many scenarios covered under the fund, including severe bad weather, overbooking, natural disasters and political instability. Any tourist services purchased with a licenced travel agent are protected by the fund, including air tickets, bus transportation, hotel stays, cruises and excursions. This applies both to online purchases and those made directly with an agency. 'This is not the case when you book directly with the supplier, or when you buy from a travel agent outside Quebec,' the OPC stresses.
CTV News
2 hours ago
- CTV News
OC Transpo touts strong O-Train ridership during Ottawa Bluesfest
OC Transpo is reporting strong ridership on all O-Train lines during Ottawa Bluesfest this summer. This year's edition of the popular music festival marks the first time that the north-south Line 2 and the Line 4 airport spur have been in operation alongside the east-west Line 1, which stops right outside the festival grounds at LeBreton Flats. 'Strong ridership was observed throughout the festival with an estimated 650,000 customer trips on Line 1 and 87,000 customer trips on Line 2,' said acting general manager of Transit Services Troy Charter in a media release Tuesday. Charter says the busiest day was July 18, when Green Day was the headliner, which had a combined 112,000 customers trips on Lines 1 and 2. 'Strong usage of the new Park & Rides connecting customers with Line 2 was also observed,' Charter wrote, though no specific numbers were included in the release. Festivalgoers could board an OC Transpo bus, an O-Train, or take Para Transpo using their Bluefest tickets during the festival. 'Transit service performed as planned. Signage was placed at various locations to help customers during the festival. Staff were at key locations to support customers throughout the festival, and announcements were made in and around stations,' Charter said. There was one hiccup with signage, when some people spotted mistranslated signs for eastbound travellers that said 'vers l'ouest' in French, which means 'westbound.' OC Transpo said the signs were quickly replaced. Charter said OC Transpo will continue to review operations to capture lessons learned and improve the customer experience at future major events. More than 250,000 people attended Ottawa Bluesfest this year.
CTV News
2 hours ago
- CTV News
Heading to the beach in Barrie? Here's what you need to know before you go
A lifeguard stand is pictured as people keep cool at Centennial Beach in Barrie, Ont. (Rob Cooper/CTV News). The City of Barrie reminds beachgoers to brush up on the rules before heading to the waterfront this summer. Whether you're soaking up the sun at Centennial Beach or dipping your toes in the water at Minet's Point, there are a few key guidelines in place to help keep everyone safe and the area clean, according to the City of Barrie. One of the main rules beach visitors should be aware of is that tents and sunshades are not permitted at Barrie's beaches or waterfront parks. The restriction is in place to preserve clear sightlines for lifeguards and visitors alike. However, standard umbrellas supported by a single pole are allowed. The city is also asking residents to check water quality reports before visiting the beach. The Simcoe Muskoka District Health Unit regularly tests water at public beaches for safety, and results are posted online throughout the summer months. Other important reminders for a safe and enjoyable visit include: Leave no trace: If garbage bins are full, beachgoers are expected to take their waste home with them. No pets allowed: Dogs are not permitted on City beaches. Smoke-free zones: Smoking is strictly prohibited on all City beaches. No private cooking equipment: Personal barbeques, stoves, or any cooking appliances are not permitted on waterfront property — even if they're not in use. Designated community-use barbeques are available at Tyndale Park and Centennial Park, and are open daily. Users are asked to follow posted rules and dispose of used coals only in designated containers — not in regular trash bins.
