Huge blood test myth has finally been busted
QUESTION: Dear Dr Zac, I saw a doctor on Instagram saying that getting blood tests can make you more sick, because the more blood you have drawn, it's taking away your immune system? Is that true or just social media pseudoscience? – Amanda, 27, Gold Coast
ANSWER: If I had a dollar for every time an 'Instagram doctor' spread weird health advice, I'd be rich enough to launch my own line of overpriced supplements and film it shirtless in a rainforest.
Let's get straight to it: The claim that drawing blood somehow removes your immune system is complete nonsense. According to this so-called 'Medical Medium' (who, by the way, says his info comes from a spirit – yes, really), taking blood for tests will make you sicker because it weakens your immune system. That's not just wrong, it's dangerously misleading.
Here's why you shouldn't panic if your GP orders a blood test – and why listening to ghost-guided wellness influencers could do more harm than a few millilitres of blood ever could.
Blood tests don't drain your immune system – just your TikTok feed.
Let's bust the myth first: Your immune system doesn't live in your blood like it's floating around in a tiny lifeboat. Yes, some immune cells are in your bloodstream, but they're constantly being produced by your bone marrow and lymphatic system. Drawing a small amount of blood doesn't cripple your defences, it gives your doctor valuable clues to help strengthen them.
Standard blood tests typically take about 5–10ml of blood. That's around two teaspoons. The average adult has five litres of blood. You've probably lost more than squeezing a pimple or stubbing your toe in the dark.
Even if you get extensive testing done, say 50ml worth, it's still less than 2 per cent of your total blood volume. Your body replenishes that quickly, usually within 24–48 hours. Unless you're a lizard person (or actively haemorrhaging), you'll be just fine.
But what about people who feel worse after blood tests?
This is where things get a bit nuanced. Some people do feel faint, dizzy or tired after having blood drawn. But that's more to do with how the blood was taken (and whether you had breakfast) than the blood itself.
Feeling queasy is often linked to: Vasovagal response (a fancy way of saying your body freaks out at needles), Low blood sugar, or anxiety.
These are temporary reactions, not signs your immune system is crumbling.
Where did this bizarre idea come from?
The quote in question comes from Anthony William, aka the 'Medical Medium'. He claims to hear health advice from a spirit (who apparently skipped immunology class).
He's not a licensed doctor, has no formal medical training, and has previously claimed celery juice can cure everything from anxiety to shingles. He's also built a multimillion-dollar wellness empire promoting unproven health advice, often to people who are desperate and vulnerable. That, in my opinion, is the real sickness.
Sure, he throws in the odd disclaimer like 'work with your doctor,' but that's like a car salesman saying 'test the brakes' while handing you a steering wheel held on with duct tape.
Here's what you actually should do around blood tests
If you're sick or dealing with chronic illness, your doctor might want to order blood work to understand what's going on. That's a good thing. The faster you get the right diagnosis, the faster you can get the right treatment.
Some basic tips for a smooth blood test experience:
• Drink plenty of water beforehand (it makes veins easier to find)
• Don't skip meals unless told to fast
• If you get dizzy, let the phlebotomist know, they can take extra care
• Rest afterwards if needed, and have a snack
That's it. No sage burning or spirit communication required.
The only thing scary about blood tests is the fact that some influencers think they're dangerous. Removing 5ml of blood won't wreck your immune system – but believing Instagram pseudoscience just might.
Blood tests are safe, essential, and can literally save your life. And if someone tells you otherwise while claiming to get their health info from ghosts, maybe it's time to unfollow.
You've got this.
Dr Zac
Dr Zac Turner is a medical practitioner specialising in preventative health and wellness. He has four health/medical degrees – Bachelor of Medicine/Bachelor of Surgery at the University of Sydney, Bachelor of Nursing at Central Queensland University, and Bachelor of Biomedical Science at the University of the Sunshine Coast. He is a registrar for the Australian College of Rural and Remote Medicine, and is completing a PhD in Biomedical Engineering (UNSW). Dr Zac is the medical director for his own holistic wellness medical clinics throughout Australia, Concierge Doctors.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
SBS Australia
an hour ago
- SBS Australia
Vibha wanted to honour her mother's wish to die voluntarily at home. She found help online
Disclaimer: The opinions in this podcast are general and non-binding. For specific advice, please consult your General Practitioner or health expert. LISTEN TO SBS Hindi 17/07/2025 19:51 Hindi LISTEN TO SBS Hindi 14/07/2025 19:09 Hindi
ABC News
3 hours ago
- ABC News
Disability advocates say NDIS changes disregard alternative therapy benefits
On the red dirt in the outskirts of Kalgoorlie in Western Australia, a large, dark bay horse gently nuzzles Cooper in the chest. The 16-year-old in a wide-brim cowboy hat smiles. It is a sweet moment between the two friends. Cooper remembers being sceptical when his parents first suggested equine therapy as a way to build confidence and better manage his emotions during a difficult period. But he gave it a go. And the results, he says, have been life-changing. "It helps regulate my emotions. "When you're in control of such a big animal, it makes the other big things in life seem less scary." In his first equine therapy session, Cooper bonded with a horse named Rio. "Rio's the biggest and scariest," he said. "He weighs over half a ton. "They say he has ADHD (attention deficit hyperactivity disorder), which is OK because I do too." Now, as Cooper gently brushes Rio under the dappled shade of a gum tree, both seem very serene. Cooper, who also has autism, accessed equine therapy through the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS). However, that stopped in October when the federal government introduced significant changes to the NDIS to reduce costs, including no longer funding equine therapy. Peak disability advocacy bodies have told the government some of the new rules are too "medicalised" and don't consider the benefits of some alternative therapies. The feedback was part of a consultation period on the new NDIS Support rules, open for public submissions until July 27. The NDIS Support rules list what is and is not funded. You can read it here. One of the major changes is that the NDIS will no longer fund supports that are not "evidence-based" or directly linked to someone's disability. Equine therapy falls under the umbrella of animal therapies, which are activities designed for people to have a positive experience with animals. It can include things like rabbit petting, playing with puppies or horse riding. Often, the goal is to help people cope with or recover from mental and physical health conditions, but it can vary. Under the changes, animal therapy has been deemed an "alternative" or "complementary therapy" and now falls in the same excluded category as tarot card reading, aromatherapy and crystal therapy. Assistance animals, like guide dogs, that are specially trained to help someone manage a disability, remain funded. As does animal-assisted therapy, which is where an accredited therapist uses an animal to help clients engage in therapy and get the most out of their sessions. Music and art therapy also remain funded by the NDIS, as long as the therapists are registered with the relevant peak bodies, which require them to have undergone recognised training and accreditation. In May, the government held online consultation sessions with disability peak bodies around the NDIS Support rules. A summary document of the feedback says there is evidence some supports no longer funded by the NDIS, like (alternative) therapies, work well for people with disability, where it meets their needs. "Participants particularly spoke about therapies. They said the lists are 'medicalised' and do not consider the benefit of some alternative therapies to participants." Other feedback included that remote communities need to be considered separately from metropolitan areas. "There are gaps in services in rural and remote communities that means more flexibility is needed." The Department of Social Services (DSS), which is running the consultations, says the feedback will help make decisions about what supports will and won't be funded in the future. People with Disability Australia was one of the peak advocacy organisations to contribute to the May round of consultation. Acting chief executive Megan Spindler-Smith said there were concerns the lists were too medicalised and too focused on being evidence-based. "This drive to be evidence-based is important, but what it means is that a lot of things like alternative therapies we know work in specific cases, or for some groups of people with disability, are not able to be considered," they said. Mx Spindler-Smith said the term "evidence-based" was also problematic because people with disability had historically not been allowed to take part in research, particularly clinical research. "So then that evidence doesn't necessarily link exactly to our direct lived experience." Another concern, Mx Spindler-Smith said, was the lack of consideration and flexibility for those living in non-metropolitan areas to access funded support services. "Registered therapists don't necessarily have a home base in many regional and remote areas," they said. "Which means that there are cohorts that are never going to be able to access it in the same way and therefore have been using non-registered therapists or people who can provide a similar level under supervision but cannot be seen as part of the list." Mx Spindler-Smith said it was important those in the disability community shared their views and experiences. "Right now, there is an opportunity until July 27 for you to have your say," they said. Lynette Keleher is the owner and operator of Breakthrough Equine Therapy, where Cooper does his lessons. Ms Keleher said Cooper was just one of hundreds of young people on the NDIS she had seen benefit from equine therapy over the years. She likened it to learning a new language or musical instrument in terms of how it engaged the body, brain and emotions. "We have a retainment rate of 90 per cent. Week after week, our clients return eager to see their favourite horse and reconnect. "You can see their troubles, negative thoughts and self-doubts disappear." Ms Keleher said previously, the business had about 50 per cent NDIS clients but had to pivot to offering other services when the changes came into effect. She said the financial impact meant a reduction in the number of staff — many of whom were NDIS participants employed through Breakthrough. Kalgoorlie-Boulder resident Jo Russell said her 21-year-old daughter Megan, regularly attended the equine therapy sessions at Breakthrough. "The gains she had made — it matched up with her NDIS goals. It aligned with what we were trying to develop and create for her and with that little stroke of the pen … it's all gone." Megan Russell requires full-time care. She is non-verbal, has autism, an intellectual disability and hip dysplasia. Her mother, Jo Russell, said the equine therapy sessions had both psychosocial and physical benefits. The physical benefits came from sitting up straight in the saddle and riding, which improved her daughter's mobility, posture and flexibility. And the psychosocial benefits, Ms Russell said, came from feeding and grooming horses, and interacting with staff, which helped break down the interpersonal gaps that came from her autism and avoiding contact. Ms Russell said continuing with the sessions, without the support of the NDIS, was not financially feasible. "[My daughter] is on a disability support pension. I'm on a disability support pension. I couldn't afford it for her, she couldn't afford it for herself," Ms Russell said. Ms Russell said she had heard similar stories from other members of the Goldfield region's disability community. "They're all very distressed because some of them can see their children regressing," she said. "The gains that have been made [through equine therapy], have now been lost." Ms Russell said the changes disproportionately affected regional and remote communities, like Kalgoorlie-Boulder, which struggled to attract and retain experienced specialists and health professionals. Psychologist and animal-assisted therapy expert, Professor Pauleen Bennett, said while there could be benefits to activities like equine therapy — the term "therapy" was misleading and the lack of regulation and oversight had the potential to cause harm. Professor Bennett said the alternative could be damaging and meant people might be missing out on real therapy with a qualified therapist. "For me, the critical difference is whether it's therapy or whether it's something else," she said. "That doesn't mean we shouldn't be doing it, and maybe the NDIS needs to be looking as some sort of way of accrediting people or organisations who do animal-assisted activities, but without calling it therapy," she said. Without the proper checks and balances that existed for other allied health services, Professor Bennett said anyone could claim to provide animal therapy — and there was no way for people to know whether it was fantastic or terrible. "We need some way of ensuring that the activities that they're doing are having a positive benefit," she said. "For some people, they definitely are. But without some sort of quality control … it's difficult to know." Meanwhile, Cooper and his family will be watching the outcome of the NDIS Support rules review closely. The Kalgoorlie teenager has not stopped equine therapy sessions entirely, but without the support of NDIS funding, they say visits will be fewer and far between.
ABC News
3 hours ago
- ABC News
Prescriptions to be issued by WA pharmacists for asthma, ear infections under training program expansion
Pharmacists in Western Australia now have the opportunity to expand what they can prescribe in a bid to ease pressure on the state's health system. The WA government has announced the expansion of a pilot program offering further training for pharmacists, allowing them to diagnose and treat health conditions that would normally require people to visit a GP. The expanded pilot program will allow pharmacists to treat certain skin conditions, ear infections and asthma. Currently pharmacists can treat urinary tract infections, re-supply oral contraceptives and administer certain vaccines. WA Health Minister Meredith Hammat announced the program's expansion on Monday, saying it would provide people with more options to access health care. "By enhancing the skills of community pharmacists, we are reducing pressure on hospitals and GPs while giving patients safe, effective care options closer to home," Ms Hammat said in a statement. "GPs will continue to play a really important role in the healthcare system," she later told reporters on Monday. Ms Hammat said during consultation, the Australian Medical Association and the College of Royal General Practitioners had raised concerns about the program. "Our focus is on making sure the program is safe and effective," she said. The qualification will be issued by universities and is expected to take 12 months to complete, with graduates receiving a certificate in pharmaceutical prescribing.
