logo
Perception trumps reality: Did the US really destroy Iran's nuclear programme?

Perception trumps reality: Did the US really destroy Iran's nuclear programme?

Irish Examiner11 hours ago
Rafael Grossi, the director general of the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) has contradicted US president Donald Trump's contention that the Iranian nuclear programme was destroyed by the US air attack on Iran on the night of June 22-23.
Grossi has also assessed that Iran still has the technical knowhow to produce enriched uranium within months. In an Irish Examiner article last week, Iranian response in Doha was only a carefully choreographed demonstration it was pointed out that the Iranians will recover quickly and would have backup teams of nuclear scientists to continue their work.
In the world of geopolitics, perception is often more important than reality.
Seeking the truth
Seeking the truth can be a frustrating experience in a time of mass communication, when conflicting messages are flashing by in sound bites. Logic teaches us some coping mechanisms.
Let us start with the concept of perspectivism, which, to summarise, means that no one statement holds absolute truth. Truth, instead, is the sum total of many statements.
For example, you are sitting in a Cork cafe. It's a beautiful morning and you are in good company. The waft of freshly-brewed coffee completes a precious moment of bliss. You open the Irish Examiner. You see the front page, but your companion sees only the back page, which somehow always manages to have a really interesting story. You both have different perspectives, but neither of you has the overall truth. The truth slowly reveals itself, page by page.
The aftermath of the US bombing of Iran's nuclear facilities presents a similar dilemma. Did the Americans destroy Iran's programme to produce nuclear weapons or not? Before you even ask yourself the question, let's be honest, what is the answer you want to hear? Essentially, which side are you on? Most probably, your basic platform of information is what you have read or watched on TV and cinema over your lifetime.
Taking sides
My generation was keenly aware of the Holocaust. It was captivated by the film Exodus and identified Israel's struggle to survive with Ireland's fight for freedom. We abhorred the PLO aircraft hijackings and the murder of Israeli athletes in Munich in 1972. It took two generations to change that view and see the present leadership in Israel as the bad guys that turned Gaza into a human slaughterhouse.
Whatever side you are on, let's consider the US intervention in Iran as objectively as possible. Within hours of the US bombing, selected leaking from a preliminary US intelligence report, to CNN, sensationally contradicted Trump's claim that the Iranian nuclear complexes were obliterated. The main contentious point of the leaked report was that Iran's nuclear programme was only set back for a few months.
The Trump administration's overreaction to this report actually heightened the public perception that the US air attacks were not successful. Moreover, that caused more problems for the Israelis, whose stated war objective was the removal of the Iranian nuclear threat, not just its delay.
The Israelis continued attacking targets in Iran even though Trump and defence secretary Pete Hegseth were claiming that the Iranian nuclear facilities were obliterated.
The joint press conference held by Hegseth and the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, General Dan Caine, was unprecedented. Hegseth went ballistic in his criticism of the media, blaming them for being unpatriotic. Caine gave a calm, measured presentation on the operation and explained why it would be several weeks before the full extent of damage to the facilities was known.
We must remember that this mission had been planned in detail for the past 15 years at least. Over that period of time, both US and Israeli intelligence assets in Iran would have been compiling a mass of data. The bombs used in the attack, the massive ordnance penetrators, were designed with these specific targets in mind.
The great Arthur C Clarke, engineer and science fiction writer, stated:"If an eminent scientist tells you something is possible, believe him. If he tells you something is impossible, don't believe him.
The US Army Corps of Engineers has a simple motto, which explains its outlook on taking on tough tasks. It says: 'The very difficult we do immediately; the impossible takes a little longer.'
Bearing in mind both comments, we must also not forget that it was the Americans that pulled off the greatest engineering feat of all time, landing men on the Moon and bringing them back alive.
In early 1972, I remember being in Cape Kennedy watching astronauts in training for a Moon flight. On one wall the planning and preparation sequence for the Apollo Project was laid out using a concept called systems engineering.
The air operation in Iran had the benefit of the most advanced technology available in the world today. Conducted in one non-stop 36-hour round trip from the US to Iran, involving air refuelling, the final run to the targets was carried out in complete darkness.
In the Irish Military College, cadets and officers are always advised to keep their plans as simple as possible, to consider and anticipate every contingency, to rehearse as much as possible and allow for backup personnel and equipment. The more complicated the plan, the more likely something will go wrong. Disasters can happen. The US learned a lot from the 1980 failed rescue operation in Iran, during which eight US servicemen were killed in a helicopter crash, when Delta Force tried to free the captured US Embassy staff.
The big question now is if the 400kg of enriched uranium stockpiled by the Iranians was in the Fordow facility. The Iranians say they had removed it to a safe location. US observers think it would have been too difficult to move in time, but the Iranians must have known that Fordow was a prime target.
A satellite picture of Iran's underground nuclear enrichment site at Fordow in March. Picture: Planet Labs PBC/AP
Iran foresees the day when its oil runs out and it will require a reliable energy source. Nuclear energy is a viable alternative and Iran should be allowed to develop a peaceful nuclear energy programme. However, it should accept international control over any enriched uranium.
Trump was asked at the recent Nato meeting in the Hague about US-Iran talks. His immediate reaction was that he saw no reason for talks. Since then he has changed his mind and behind the scenes, efforts are being made to get the Iranians back to the negotiating table.
Latest reports are that the US and Iran are set to resume nuclear talks in Oslo. Iran is reported to want a US guarantee before talks begin that it will not be attacked. To use an Americanism, the 'game' is not over until the fat lady sings.
Dorcha Lee is a retired army colonel and defence analyst.
Read More
Unreliability of Donald Trump's US means a cascade of nuclear armament is on the way
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Trump to host Netanyahu at White House as Gaza ceasefire talks begin in Doha
Trump to host Netanyahu at White House as Gaza ceasefire talks begin in Doha

The Journal

time2 hours ago

  • The Journal

Trump to host Netanyahu at White House as Gaza ceasefire talks begin in Doha

ISRAELI PRIME MINISTER Benjamin Netanyahu will meet US President Donald Trump in Washington today amid indirect negotiations between Israel and Hamas aimed at brokering a ceasefire in Gaza. The talks, which began in Doha on Sunday evening, are also seeking to reach an agreement on the release of hostages in exchange for Palestinian prisoners. Speaking on Sunday, Trump said there was a 'good chance' of reaching an agreement. 'We've gotten a lot of the hostages out, but pertaining to the remaining hostages, quite a few of them will be coming out,' he told journalists. Netanyahu, speaking before boarding his flight to Washington on Sunday, said his meeting with Trump could 'definitely help advance this' deal. He said he had dispatched the team to Doha with 'clear instructions' to reach an agreement 'under the conditions that we have agreed to.' He previously said Hamas's response to a draft US-backed ceasefire proposal, conveyed through Qatari and Egyptian mediators, contained 'unacceptable' demands. 'Important mission' Two Palestinian sources close to the discussions told AFP the proposal included a 60-day truce, during which Hamas would release 10 living hostages and several bodies in exchange for Palestinians detained by Israel. However, they said, the group was also demanding certain conditions for Israel's withdrawal, guarantees against a resumption of fighting during negotiations, and the return of the UN-led aid distribution system. Advertisement Israeli army vehicles moves in the Gaza Strip as seen from southern Israel. Alamy Stock Photo Alamy Stock Photo Netanyahu has an 'important mission' in Washington, 'advancing a deal to bring all our hostages home,' said Israeli President Isaac Herzog after meeting him Sunday. Trump is not scheduled to meet the Israeli premier until 6.30pm (11.30pm Irish time), the White House said, without the usual presence of journalists. Of the 251 hostages taken by Palestinian militants during the 2023 attack, 49 are still being held in Gaza, including 27 the Israeli military says are dead. Since Hamas's October 2023 attack sparked the current Israeli offensive in Gaza, mediators have brokered two temporary halts in the fighting. They have seen hostages freed in exchange for some of the thousands of Palestinian prisoners in Israeli custody. Israel broke the last ceasefire agreement and resumed its offensive on 18 March. Recent efforts to broker a new truce have repeatedly failed, with the primary point of contention being Israel's rejection of Hamas's demand for a lasting ceasefire. 'Enough blood' In Gaza, the territory's civil defense agency reported 26 people killed by Israeli forces on Sunday, 10 of them in a strike in Gaza City's Sheikh Radwan neighbourhood. 'We are losing young people, families and children every day, and this must stop now,' Sheikh Radwan resident Osama al-Hanawi told AFP. 'Enough blood has been shed.' Palestinians crowd to receive a hot meal at a food distribution point in Khan Younis. Alamy Stock Photo Alamy Stock Photo Media restrictions in Gaza and difficulties in accessing many areas mean AFP is unable to independently verify the tolls and details provided by the civil defense agency. Contacted by AFP, the Israeli military said it could not comment on specific strikes without precise coordinates. Hundreds killed seeking aid The war has created dire humanitarian conditions for the more than two million people in the Gaza Strip. Related Reads Israeli air strikes kill 38 Palestinians in Gaza as Netanyahu prepares to fly to Washington Hamas ready to start Gaza ceasefire talks 'immediately' as Israel continues strikes on Gaza A US and Israel-backed group, the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF), took the lead in food distribution in the territory in late May, when Israel partially lifted a more than two-month blockade on aid deliveries. But its operations have had a chaotic rollout, with Palestinians seeking aid being killed near its facilities while awaiting rations on a near daily basis. UN agencies and major aid groups have refused to cooperate with the GHF over concerns it was designed to cater to Israeli military objectives. The UN human rights office said last week that more than 500 people have been killed waiting to access food from GHF distribution points. The Gaza health ministry on Sunday placed that toll even higher, at 751 killed. Hamas's October 2023 attack resulted in the deaths of 1,219 people, mostly civilians, according to an AFP tally based on Israeli official figures. Israel's retaliatory offensive has killed at least 57,418 people in Gaza, also mostly civilians, according to the Palestinian health ministry. The United Nations considers the figures reliable. With reporting from © AFP 2025 Need more information on what is happening in Israel and Gaza? Check out our new FactCheck Knowledge Bank for essential reads and guides to navigating the news online. Visit Knowledge Bank Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal

Donald Trump to send 'tariff letters' to countries from today
Donald Trump to send 'tariff letters' to countries from today

The Journal

time2 hours ago

  • The Journal

Donald Trump to send 'tariff letters' to countries from today

THE US WILL begin to send letters to countries it intends to place blanket tariffs on before President Donald Trump's 9 July deal deadline. In a post to his social media platform, Trump said that letters and the conditions of any deals that have been reached will be sent to countries from 5pm (Irish Time) today. 'I am please to announced that the United States tariff letters, and/or deals, with various countries from around the world, will be delivered starting 12pm (Eastern), Monday, July 7th,' Trump wrote. Most countries have been slapped with a 10% tariff on exported goods by the US under Trump's levy programme. He told reporters yesterday that up to 15 countries may receive letters from today. US Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick has said, however, that higher tariffs would kick in on 1 August but denied that it was a way of delaying the deadline. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent also denied that the White House was backing down. It comes as the EU is racing to reach a deal with the US ahead of Wednesday, as the threat of potentially a 50% tariff on European goods looms over negotiators . Advertisement So far, the Trump administration has only reached deals with the UK and Vietnam, while Washington and China agreed to temporarily lower high levies on each other's products. Should a mutual agreement not be reached, the EU has said it will impose its countermeasures on the US on 14 July. Trade commissioner Maroš Šefčovič returned to Brussels on Friday and confirmed that the EU has yet to reach a deal . The EU has sought to maintain a 0% tariff rate between its member states and the US. While this stance is supported by the Irish government, trade minister and Tánaiste Simon Harris has said that businesses should operate under the assumption that a 10% tariff is the 'new norm'. Harris today is set to be briefed by officials and speak with Šefčovič before briefing ministers on the latest trade developments at a cabinet meeting tomorrow, in 'final push' efforts to reach a deal. 'Tariffs are bad for consumers, jobs, economic growth and investment. As I have been saying for some time, the uncertainty is also bad for economic confidence and Irish businesses seeking clarity on the trading environment in which they operate,' he said. It is unclear if the EU will be successful in reaching its demands. There are serious concerns that the US's response to the European countermeasures could impact Ireland's lucrative aviation, pharma, drinks and agri-food industries Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal

Bloodthirsty Putin pounding Ukraine with close to 1,000 missiles and kamikaze drones a DAY in brazen defiance of Trump
Bloodthirsty Putin pounding Ukraine with close to 1,000 missiles and kamikaze drones a DAY in brazen defiance of Trump

The Irish Sun

time2 hours ago

  • The Irish Sun

Bloodthirsty Putin pounding Ukraine with close to 1,000 missiles and kamikaze drones a DAY in brazen defiance of Trump

RUSSIA could soon hammer Ukraine with 1,000 drones and missiles every day - as another deadly blitz landed overnight. It was the second 7 A fire rages following a strike on Odesa, where at least one person was killed Credit: East2West 7 A Russian Kamikaze drone hurtles down towards a built-up area Credit: East2West 7 Putin is cranking up the size of his assaults on Ukraine - in clear defiance against Trump's continued peace efforts Credit: AFP On June 1, a 479-strong wave of drones and missiles became June 9 saw that broken with 499, then again on June 29 with 537. And finally, just last Friday, Putin terrorised Kyiv with a firestorm of 550 drones and missiles - just as he and Trump finished a phone call. read more in world news Russia's defence industry is ballooning as projects come to fruition - such as an expanded missile plant in Votkinsk and rapidly expanding supply chains. With an expanding arsenal , the size of Russia's regular salvos look set only to increase - meaning they could soon nudge 1000 weapons per day. It's a bleak prospect for Ukraine, where each wave brings pain and death. Dozens of kamikaze drones and missiles landed this morning , killing at least three people - two in the weary Sumy region and on in Odessa. Most read in The US Sun There were also dozens of casualties in Ukraine 's second city Kharkiv. At least 27 were wounded, including children aged three, seven and 11, by the onslaught of Iranian-designed Shaded drones. US President Donald Trump said Russia just wanted to -keep killing people- and hinted at sanctions after Moscow launched its largest ever drone and missile attack on Ukraine in the three-year-old war- Two residential blocks were hit in Kharkiv, according to the regional administration, Oleh Syniehubov - with the top floors of one engulfed in flames. Psychologists were dispatched to treat people traumatised by Putin's latest strikes - which appeared to prioritise sowing terror among civilians Kyiv was also hit, as was Dnipropetrovsk region, where the weapons injured two pensioners, a man aged 73 and a woman, 66. In Donetsk, footage shows a Russian Gerber decoy drone was used as a strike weapon to slam into a residential building - triggering a giant explosion. As Ukraine turned to Europe - especially Germany - for urgent new help with its air defences, Donald Trump insisted he has not abandoned Kyiv. He said: 'I am helping Ukraine. I help a lot." 7 An explosion at a residential building from a Gerber decoy drone used as a strike weapon Credit: East2West 7 Trump also acknowledged the pounding that Ukraine is taking, despite his recent conversation with Putin. The President said: 'He [Zelensky] is being hit very hard - and I was very disappointed with my call with President Putin, I was very disappointed." Over the weekend, Trump said: "[Putin] wants to go all the way, just keep killing people, it's no good." US special envoy Keith Kellogg will fly to Europe to meet Zelensky this week. For its part, Ukraine hit warehouses at a chemical plant which produces ammunition and military-grade explosives for the Russian military machine. Repeated explosions were heard at the Krasnozavodsk site, some 55 miles northeast of the Kremlin. 7 Trump said he was 'very unhappy' with Putin 7 A fireman battles a blaze that has engulfed cars and buildings Credit: East2West The attack was carried out by Ukraine's new FP-1 one‑way kamikaze loitering strike drones, which support warheads of up to 120kg. Footage shows strikes at the strategic plant - the latest of dozens of Russian military factories to be hit by Ukraine. Ukraine is also believed to be behind major airport disruption in European Russia over the weekend and early today. Hundreds of flights were delayed or cancelled amid concerns over drones. Problems continued at Pulkovo airport in St Petersburg today, after major Moscow hub Sheremetyevo was badly hit on Sunday.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store