Smith & Caughey's closure a body-blow to Queen St retail
But Smith & Caughey's, a prudently managed family business, carried on. Its stately Victorian building with its art-deco frontage has housed a grand emporium of goods from around the world, and its Christmas window displays have been the delight of children to this day. It's been a survivor of Auckland's golden age, when Auckland was envied across the country, and Aucklanders used to actually boast about their city.
Last year, Smith and Caughey's narrowly survived a near-death experience only by closing its Newmarket store and retrenching the Queen St operation. Some of the reasons were outlined by its chairman, Tony Caughey: a major decline in foot traffic on Queen St meaning a 40% decline in revenue; the after-effects of Covid, crime and safety issues; national economic downturn; online shopping, designer brands like Gucci choosing to open their own stores; and competition from malls like Westfield Newmarket with their lavish free parking.
But many of these factors are in play in Australian cities too, where department stores like David Jones and Myer are still very much in business. So what's different about Auckland? Here, city centre foot traffic continues to decline, down 3.8% from last year, with shop vacancies nearly 10%.
Heart of the City's Viv Beck points to the compounding damage done to retail by Auckland Transport's removal of parking and loading zones, and increased parking charges, extended to 24 hours.
It's an inconvenient truth for some, but Smith & Caughey's closure announcement puts it bluntly: 'The city centre has also faced significant disruption and change in the form of ongoing roadworks and the slow progress of CRL, causing traffic congestion. Similarly, perceived safety issues, a large decline in foot traffic on Queen St, and an increase in parking costs have all continued to impact the economic position of the business.'
In recent years, at enormous expense and disruption, for reasons vaguely related to 'climate', the council reduced Queen St to two narrow lanes now dominated by mainly empty buses and a cycleway, the enlarged footpaths the home of beggars and rough sleepers.
Now, even driving to and on Queen St is a mission. Indeed, from Wakefield St to the Civic Theatre, where two years or so ago, Auckland Transport set up what critics call a 'revenue trap', $20 million of fines have been issued to unwitting drivers.
Though the council's 'City Centre Master Plan' promises an 'accessible, inclusive and prosperous city centre', its 'transformational moves' do the opposite; blockading and progressively hollowing out the city's retail heart. The Wellesley St West 'bus improvements' project, immediately adjacent to Smith & Caughey's, has been dug up for a year now, with no end in sight.
Even more depressing, its objective is to permanently block access to Queen St for private vehicles. 'Master Plan' zealots, seemingly indifferent to the damage caused, are now intent on extending this blockade, what they call the Queen St 'AVO' (authorised vehicle only) from Mayoral Drive to Victoria St.
This is part of an Orwellian 'A4E' (Access for Everyone) plan, intended to turn Queen St into a 'ZEA' (Zero Emissions Area), 'low-traffic neighbourhood'.
The City Rail Link, originally meant to enhance the quality of life in Auckland, is now seen almost desperately as a lifesaver. Unfortunately, its disruptive construction has taken more than double the time originally planned, costing at least three times what was stated in its business case. But the official assumption, almost an article of faith, is that once the CRL is opened, thousands of people will come flooding into the city.
That might well have been the case when construction began in 2016, but now why would they? Moreover, public transport is chronically failing in Auckland, with overall patronage since the 2019 peak down 11%, with rail patronage down 35%. Given challenging economic conditions, the council and AT should have done everything possible to keep Queen St retail.
Instead, it did the opposite. Sadly, Smith & Caughey's, finally overcome by the odds, is in many ways the victim of the city for which it was for 145 years a stylish icon.
Things have to change.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NZ Herald
2 hours ago
- NZ Herald
Mortgage rates drop, but further relief unlikely as OCR stabilises
At 5.1%, unemployment is the highest since 2016 (excluding the Covid-era) and it's expected to increase a little further before stabilising. This level of labour market slack usually keeps a lid on domestic inflation pressures. The RBNZ isn't done with cutting rates just yet, but an important insight borrowers should take from last week's decision is that we are nearing the end of the easing cycle. Of the big four Australian banks and Kiwibank, forecasts for where the OCR troughs range from 2.50% to 3%. The most recent RBNZ projections imply a floor of either 3% or 2.75%, with the odds slightly tilted towards the latter. Whoever you choose to believe, it's clear the bottom is getting closer. For most of us, this matters because of what it means for borrowing costs and the household budget. Mortgage rates have already fallen a long way. The two-year rate is 5% right now, down from 7% at the end of 2023. It's important to understand that your mortgage rate isn't driven solely by moves in the OCR. Global economic conditions, wholesale interest rates, bank funding costs and competition among lenders can also have a big influence. There's still a strong relationship though, especially for the shorter mortgage terms. In the past six months the gap between the OCR and the two-year rate has been about 1.5%, well below the average since 2017 of 2.2%. That tight spread could mean there's less room for mortgage rates to fall, even if we do see another OCR cut or three. The outlook could change if we experienced a global economic shock, or if inflation proved more persistent than expected. However, right now, the base case points to limited further relief. As our biggest lender, ANZ likely has some useful insights about the mortgage market. Its latest monthly property report suggests the two-year mortgage rate will bottom at 4.9% later this year, only marginally below current levels. It has the one-year slightly lower at 4.7%, while the three- and five-year rates don't dip below 5% in its projections. This conservative outlook is notable, given ANZ (with Kiwibank) sees the OCR falling to 2.50%. The upshot here is that most of the downward move in mortgage rates is behind us. I wouldn't say this is 'as good as it gets' for borrowers, but we're much closer to that point than many think. The next OCR decision is due in late August and importantly, this one will also see the release of a new forecast set. This is the natural opportunity for the next cut, but there are a few things to monitor between now and then. Next week's June quarter consumer price index (CPI) report is one, while the labour force report on August 7 will also be crucial. Assuming those are close to RBNZ projections, there's a decent chance we see a 0.25% cut at that time. That would take the OCR to 3%, close to neutral and where it sat comfortably for six years from 2010 to 2015. The focus will then shift to whether that's as low as it goes this cycle. With mortgage spreads already compressed relative to recent years and the OCR within neutral territory, borrowers hoping for much lower rates will be left disappointed. Mark Lister is Investment Director at Craigs Investment Partners. The information in this article is provided for information only, is intended to be general in nature, and does not take into account your financial situation, objectives, goals, or risk tolerance. Before making any investment decision Craigs Investment Partners recommends you contact an investment adviser.
Otago Daily Times
a day ago
- Otago Daily Times
‘It is my life's work': National Transport and Toy Museum on show for 30 years
When Gerald and Jason Rhodes bought 16 acres of land beside the Wānaka Airport 32 years ago, they had a vision much more imaginative than what could be seen of the barren block. While the father and son had large imaginations, they could not foresee the hangar full of aircraft, the cases full of Barbie dolls, the classic car collection of over 600, and a train set that could rival Sir Rod Stewart's. "Everything evolves and it starts somewhere but nothing ever stays still. Our idea was that it had to be able to evolve. We had an assortment of trucks, cars, aircraft and the toys grew very rapidly on the side," Jason Rhodes said. The National Transport and Toy Museum turns over the amount of customers in a few days what it did in a year when it first began. Mr Rhodes said they averaged about 45,000 people through their doors a year, but this needed to keep growing to cover costs. Gerald died over a decade ago, and Jason and daughter, Debbie Rhodes, continue the legacy and what has become the southern hemisphere's largest private collection open to the public. The museum started with 100 vehicles sourced from auctions, flea markets and private collections. They now have over 600. Add in a Chatham Islands plane, cars used on movies sets such as The World's Fastest Indian, bulldozers, and car brands dating back through the years. Gerald started his career with International Harvester and then went on to establish a car and truck wrecking business in Christchurch, meaning he was always in the right place to pick up new items for his collection. Wānaka was chosen as the home for the collection for the dry climate, which helps preserve the machinery. "He always wanted to do something and was involved in the airshow in the very first stages so he supplied a lot of the ground support and that sort of thing, so we based a section down here," Jason said. The museum has had its challenges; the global financial crisis and Covid-19 both sent it into dormant periods. The Wānaka Airport, owned by the Queenstown Lakes District Council, had not made the friendliest of neighbours at times, at least the bureaucratic strand of it, he said. "They have tried their hardest to move us on. We have become big enough and ugly enough that we are in the too hard basket nowadays. Moving a place like this, the building is the easy part, then you've got the objects. "The aircraft are large and machinery can be over 100 tonne a piece and then there are the hundreds and thousands of small pieces, that you have to package up, and rehouse — that wouldn't be a fun exercise." The museum opened to the public on December 26, 1995, and will officially turn 30 at the end of the year, although it has been under way for 32 years if you include preparing it for public. At that time, it was just the main building and Hangar 1, which was built to look like the aviation hangars used in the 1940s with authentic doors from Christchurch Airport. In April 2004, the Fire Station was added, followed in December 2005 by Hangar 2, to house military collectables, planes and motorbikes. Jason said the cabinetry and displays were often more expensive than the objects themselves, but you could not put a price on fun. "We have tried to source something for everyone, no matter where you come from, from what world and what age, genders. There is generally something that you will latch on to." He believed his father would be proud of the place it had become today, and the feedback it got. "His passion was enjoying seeing people enjoy things. "Talking to the people as they go out, a lot of people aren't sure what they are in for, but it is on the way out you get those conversations and that's the best part." Sister Debbie said her brother had inherited some of their father's tendencies. "He's got a love of hoarding; he's got dad's bug." Jason said he did not believe museums were a dying breed as the proof was the amount of money local and central government were willing to put into them. "It doesn't matter where you go around the world, museums are part of society, they show us where we are going and where we have come from." "It is my life's work. There is not a hell of a lot out there that would be this old in Wānaka."
Otago Daily Times
2 days ago
- Otago Daily Times
Looking sharp: That cool house on the corner
A Dunedin couple tell Kim Dungey how they overcame the odds to create one of the city's most unique homes. Covid lockdowns, a tricky triangular site and an old building with lots of unknowns - the road to this dream home was anything but smooth. But the ambitious project has resulted in a former corner store on one of Dunedin's busiest feeder routes being given a new lease of life. During World War 2, the single-storey shop - built to the boundary on both its street frontages - was operated by a Miss E.A. Sector. Later, it became a quirky flat with a bedroom right next to the footpath at the intersection of Royal Tce and Heriot Row. When they first saw the building advertised in 2013, the current owners fell in love with its angular shape and clinker brick cladding. Caroline Terpstra says she and husband Geoff were living in Maori Hill but were ready for a new challenge and a property that required less maintenance. Adding to the appeal: they had just returned from Europe, where they enjoyed staying in central city apartments and "being part of the action". When the building went on the market, the pair requested information but heard nothing back. Later, they sent a letter to the new owner and in 2017, they got a call "out of the blue" in which he explained his circumstances had changed and he was selling up. To make the project work financially, the couple needed to keep the ground floor as a rental. The initial plan was to add two levels above the shop but this proved too expensive so instead, they bought the neighbouring property in Heriot Row. This allowed them to build across the existing garage at the back of the former shop, limiting the development to one additional level and making the project affordable. It also gave them valuable set-down space for materials during construction. Their offer on the neighbouring property was accepted just as New Zealand entered its first Covid lockdown - a "stressful" time because they didn't know if the University of Otago would remain open and if the flat's existing student tenants would stay. Problems finding a builder delayed the start of the project, which meant that after selling their house, they had to spend two and-a-half years renting. Add in several other curve balls - including escalating building costs and material shortages - and it was the "perfect negative storm". Mr Terpstra, an architectural designer who drew up plans for the project, says the aim was to respect the heritage architecture while clearly demarcating between old and new so the history of the site could be easily read. At ground level, they kept all but one of the shop's window and door openings. Above this, the materials are clearly different but the dark metal cladding was designed to tie into the iron oxide colouring of the original bricks, and the roof shape references the gable roofs of the neighbourhood. Although the area was zoned residential 1, the Dunedin City Council recognised there had long been a building on the boundary and did not enforce the usual 4.5m setbacks from each road frontage, which would have halved the buildable area. The biggest challenge was working with the building's triangular shape, which made the placement of interior walls, and the design and build of the roof, especially tricky. "The 'sides' of the triangle are dictated by the roads and are at different angles in relation to the back of the triangle," Mr Terpstra says. "Internal partitions were built either parallel or at 90deg to the [back wall] as the most efficient way to divide the spaces ... However, all areas with exterior walls, except for our bedroom and bathroom, have an angled wall following the line of one of the road frontages, making for quirky and interesting spaces." The ground floor flat, not including a small outdoor amenity space, is just 49sq m while the interior of the apartment, excluding the garage and entry, is only 105sq m. But both believe challenges like this lead to better design outcomes. In his professional life, Mr Terpstra particularly enjoys renovation work and finding "hidden" space that homeowners don't necessarily see. "I quite like having constraints. You have to think about things a lot harder and, generally speaking, the solutions you come up with are much better." To make his own two-bedroom apartment feel spacious, he drew an open-plan kitchen, dining and living area, with a pitched, 4.8m ceiling. Circulation space is minimal, materials were kept consistent and every inch of space was used efficiently. For example, the kitchen runs along one wall and the end of the hall serves as an office. The keen gardeners were even able to include a west-facing terrace and a small garden. Working on the existing building was a "mission" because it was so well constructed, with two courses of bricks separated by a cavity, Mr Terpstra says. The triangle was tied together at the top by a concrete bond beam, on which the parapet sat. Before remodelling the ground floor flat, the director of Lowrise Design stripped the interior himself so he could recover the rimu rafters and beams. He then used them to build a slatted dividing screen and some of the stairs. Mrs Terpstra, formerly head of design at Otago Polytechnic and now its director of academic excellence, says a green, "end-of-run" carpet became the starting point for the interior scheme and a nod to the mid-century style they like. Six glass and rimu light shades they had been storing in sheds for 25 years, waiting to be used somewhere, hang from the living room's plywood veneer ceiling. Although it has taken them time to get used to the traffic noise in the area, the couple like that they rarely have to use a car themselves and that they live in a diverse neighbourhood with residents of varying ages. Many of them have been positive about the building's transformation. "Part of our reason for keeping it was that even though it was built in 1944, that's 80 years ago and it's quite an old building now," Mr Terpstra says. "But it's also one of those ordinary little shops that everyone had on their corner, a reminder of what neighbourhoods used to be like, and we thought that was worth saving. "It's a house we enjoy living in because it's not rectilinear and it's not straight-forward. It's given us an appreciation of quirky sites and spaces and what you can do with them. And there's a lot of undiscovered spaces like that in a city."
